Ground Beef Gone Bad

Forums Home » Health, Fitness, Diet, Beauty » Ground Beef Gone Bad
THREAD AUTHOR
HealthyLiving Sulphur, Oklahoma USA
Mark Twain said that truth is stranger than fiction; after reading a bone-chilling story in the The New York Times this weekend I’m inclined to add that truth can also be far creepier than fiction. Creepier even than a gory horror film or twisted Steven King novel!

The title of the story sounds pretty mundane: E. Coli Path Shows Flaws in Beef Inspection. What’s new, right? It’s no secret that food inspection in the United States has proven less than perfect. But the reporter for this story dug deep to follow the events leading up to an E. coli outbreak in 2007 that left 940 people sick, and in particular, a young dancer who was left paralyzed.

I had always assumed that there was rigid testing at every step of the process for meat processing, and that the various outbreaks were rogue occurrences that had slipped through a large and under-managed system. Silly me. The truth is that there is no federal requirement for meat grinding facilities (grinders) to test their ingredients for the E. coli pathogen. According to the story, Cargill (from where the tainted meat in question came from) is “like most meat companies,” it relies on its suppliers to check for the bacteria and does its own testing only after the ingredients are ground together. The United States Department of Agriculture allows grinders to devise their own safety plans.

I find this hard to swallow: Meat companies get meat from a number of sources, grind it all together, then test it, which makes it extremely difficult to trace the source of tainted meat. Why? Because of handshake agreements between companies–tacit pacts that stand in the way of ingredient testing. Many big slaughterhouses use their muscle and only sell to grinders who agree NOT to test their shipments for E. coli. Slaughterhouses fear that one grinder’s discovery of E. coli will set off a recall of ingredients already sold to others. (And heaven forbid that contaminated meat should be recalled!) The story pointed out that Costco is one of the few big producers that tests trimmings for E. coli before grinding–and because of their policy, even with their huge buying power, they meet resistance from some big slaughterhouses (like Tyson).

So most people might think, well, OK, but if I practice great kitchen hygiene and cook the meat thoroughly it will be safe. Nope. A test by The Times found that the safe handling instructions are not enough to prevent the bacteria from spreading in the kitchen. The Times prepared three pounds of ground beef dosed with a strain of E. coli. Although the safety instructions on the package were followed, E. coli remained on the cutting board even after it was washed with soap and a towel picked up large amounts of bacteria from the meat.

That’s very scary to me (and I don’t even eat meat!), but it doesn’t stop there. There are descriptions of the slaughterhouse and meat processing facilities that will make your skin crawl–and then there’s the analysis of what ground beef is really comprised of. You’d think that ground beef is a chunk of meat sent through a grinder–not necessarily true. Commonly, ground beef is made from slaughterhouse trimmings and a “mash-like product” derived from scraps that are ground together, “an amalgam of various grades of meat from different parts of cows and even from different slaughterhouses.” These cuts of meat are particularly vulnerable to E. coli contamination, say food experts and officials.

Ground beef has been blamed for 16 outbreaks in the last three years alone–this summer, contamination led to the recall of beef from nearly 3,000 grocers in 41 states. As The Times succinctly notes, “Neither the system meant to make the meat safe, nor the meat itself, is what consumers have been led to believe.”
HealthyLiving Sulphur, Oklahoma USA
What do you think about this?

Should all meat packing plants be required to pre-test before packaging?

Prior to reading this article, did you believe it was being done?

Have you ever gotten sick from eating tainted meat products?
How long were you sick?


I have hauled lots and lots of meat and been in many meat packing facilities. Overseas shipments always had to be approved by the inspectors and supply the appropriate paperwork with the shipment.
Many times, I have witnessed the inspections on the receiving end by USDA when making my delivery to the customer.

Wouldn't money be saved by testing before the product is shipped? It makes sense to me.

Why does the industry take this risk which could endanger lives?

I think testing should be done at both ends, to be sure that meats are not contaminated during shipment by faulty refrigeration units on trailers and containers.
wildkitty mt.view, Oklahoma USA
no but my ex husband worked in a meat packing plant in nebraska, i remember one day he came home and said they had to shut the plant down cause someone got their finger cut off and they didn't know where it was , so they had to throw all the hamburger meat away. doh
RayfromUSA vienne, Rhone-Alpes France
The FDA is a whore serving US companies.

They are extremely strict on foreign companies shipping to the US (except China). But they are extremely lenient toward American companies.

They are totally corrupt when it comes to American drug companies.

Their role seems to be more "protectionist" than protection.
HealthyLiving Sulphur, Oklahoma USA
I saw on last nights News, that another outbreak of e-coli has occurred in the North Eastern States of the U.S.

They are recalling a specific lot # stamped on Ground Beef packages.

When will enough be enough???very mad

Simple testing of meats done at plants before grinding
would eliminate contamination and save LOTS of $$$ and possibly lower meat prices!
HealthyLiving Sulphur, Oklahoma USA
Several state health departments, the CDC, and the United States Department of Agriculture’s Food Safety and Inspection Service are investigating this multi-state outbreak, for which a notice of recall was issued on October 31, 2009. The cluster of illnesses reported includes twenty-eight persons from 12 states infected with matching strains of E. coli O157:H7. The number of ill persons identified in each state is as follows: California (1), Connecticut (4), Massachusetts (8), Maryland (1), Maine (2), Minnesota (1), New Hampshire (4), New Jersey (1), New York (1), Pennsylvania (2), South Dakota (2), and Vermont (1).

So let’s get to the meat of the matter–where has this tainted beef been sold?

Some of the ground beef was sold at Trader Joe’s, Price Chopper, Lancaster, Wild Harvest, Shaw’s, BJ’s, Ford Brothers and Giant stores in packages that carried the number “EST. 492? on the label. Most of the beef packages in the recall bear the establishment number “Est. 492? inside the USDA mark of inspection and have identifying package dates of “091509? or “091609.” Consumers are urged to check their refrigerators and freezers for beef products produced by this firm and purchased on or after September 15, 2009 and discard or return the recalled beef products to the place of purchase for a refund. Customers with questions about the source of a package of beef should contact the place where they purchased it.
Abram Goshen, Ohio USA
While I believe there should be regulations insuring the safety of meat sold to consumers, it is also the consumers responsibility to be aware of hazards. I don't order meat rare, I don't cook, and consume meat half cooked. Just about the same way you will find any meat cooked in third world nations, without refigeration, or inspections. While their bodies still have organs that operate and fight small amounts of contamination, the American way of life has those same organs removed of there just being in the way, not working of thier purpose. Ya gotta use steps to protect yourself, and quite relying on a stranger somewhere who is only going to the least amount possible to earn their pay.
toranoga Decorah, Iowa USA
A recall does a lot of good if you have eaten the meat 3 or 4 weeks before the recall is issued. Over the last decade, the recommended cooking temp for pork has been raised from 135 degrees internal to 165 degrees internal in order to kill whatever is floating around in it. Beef has gone from 135 to 150.
Packing plants owner by the same company but with different corrporate entities will sell to each other and be able to legally avoid testing. That is why they slaughter at one plant and process and package at another plant. Cargill can slaughter under Swift and process and package under Cargill and Cargill owns both. Tyson and Smithfield also operate different facilities under different names each has purchased over the years.
Under claims of under funding and under staffing, the USDA does no more than periodic spot checks at many large facilities. However, if you have a small local meat locker, they watch you butcher every single animal and check body parts on every single animal. Inspection fees(costs) are also much higher on a per animal basis at the local locker, but they are checked closely.
With drug residues in animals, at a large processing plant, you have about a 1 in 1000 chance of getting caught even if you do use a drug that has not been withdrawn as per the label. At the local locker, it is almost certain that you will get caught.
serene56 bateau bay, New South Wales Australia
doh More reason to be glad I'm a vegetarian laugh
Abram Goshen, Ohio USA
serene56: More reason to be glad I'm a vegetarian
Ya think, "Food poisoning from Salmonella and E. coli is commonly associated with eating contaminated bovine or chicken products, as the pathogens live in the guts of cows and the guts and egg-ducts of chickens, and contamination of meat can occur during the slaughtering process.

However, some recent outbreaks of food poisoning have been associated with contaminated salad or vegetable products, and more specifically, pre-bagged salads. For example, in 2007 a Salmonella outbreak in the UK was traced back to imported basil, and an E. coli outbreak in the USA in 2006 was traced to contaminated pre-packed baby spinach."
http://www.scientificblogging.com/news_releases/how_does_salmonella_contaminate_produce
serene56 bateau bay, New South Wales Australia
Abram: Ya think, "Food poisoning from Salmonella and E. coli is commonly associated with eating contaminated bovine or chicken products, as the pathogens live in the guts of cows and the guts and egg-ducts of chickens, and contamination of meat can occur during the slaughtering process.

However, some recent outbreaks of food poisoning have been associated with contaminated salad or vegetable products, and more specifically, pre-bagged salads. For example, in 2007 a Salmonella outbreak in the UK was traced back to imported basil, and an E. coli outbreak in the USA in 2006 was traced to contaminated pre-packed baby spinach."
http://www.scientificblogging.com/news_releases/how_does_salmonella_contaminate_produce


wave thanks for that info .. I dont eat chicken, eggs, products containing eggs - in fact I rarely purchase packaged goods. And I'm lucky that I can buy fresh vegetables from the market which, of course, I wash thoroughly before use. I eat a little cheese, but always check that it contains synthetic rennet only, not rennet derived from animal sources
catsreiki Craig, Colorado USA
If you think that is scary, please read "FOOD,INC." edited by Karl Weber. There is also a documentary of the same name. Here is an excerpt on E Coli
"Cattle and other ruminants are uniquely suited to eat grass. However in factory farm feedlots, they eat mostly corn and soybeans for the last few months of their lives. These starchy grains increase their growth rate and make their meat more tender, a process called "finishing." However scientists point to human health risks associated with a grain based diet of "modern" cattle.
A researcher from Cornell University found that cattle fed hay for the 5 days before slaughter had dramatically lower levels of acid-resistant E coli bacteria in their feces than cattle fed corn or soybeans. E coli live in cattle's intestinal tract, so feces that escape during slaughter can lead to the bacteria contaminating the meat."

HL Bless you for being a light of truth. People really need to open their eyes to what is going on around them!
catsreiki
drbombay virginia beach, Virginia USA
So what's your beef?laugh
HealthyLiving Sulphur, Oklahoma USA
catsreiki: If you think that is scary, please read "FOOD,INC." edited by Karl Weber. There is also a documentary of the same name. Here is an excerpt on E Coli
"Cattle and other ruminants are uniquely suited to eat grass. However in factory farm feedlots, they eat mostly corn and soybeans for the last few months of their lives. These starchy grains increase their growth rate and make their meat more tender, a process called "finishing." However scientists point to human health risks associated with a grain based diet of "modern" cattle.
A researcher from Cornell University found that cattle fed hay for the 5 days before slaughter had dramatically lower levels of acid-resistant E coli bacteria in their feces than cattle fed corn or soybeans. E coli live in cattle's intestinal tract, so feces that escape during slaughter can lead to the bacteria contaminating the meat."

HL Bless you for being a light of truth. People really need to open their eyes to what is going on around them!
catsreiki



Thank you so much for sharing this film with us. I found it online and am waiting for it to buffer now. Anyone who would like to watch it...
http://www.divxden.com/2zw3vi802s22/qfn-finc.avi.html#

Also, here is an interview done on CBS News with the makers of the film...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=wXmF_erEv1o&feature=related

Good to meet you cats!hug

HLbouquet
Witchaywoman Carpentersville, Illinois USA
See! That's why everybody should go vegetarian!!!!! Then you could all be perfect like me! Haha! Just kidding. I was talking to a guy last night. He brought up 'The Jungle' by upton sinclair. i read it a long time ago. That was a story that had a famous gross out part about the meat packing industry that caused a huge public outcry and caused people to demand better health laws regarding meat handling in the old days. Without that book, who knows what health standards would be today?
HealthyLiving Sulphur, Oklahoma USA
Witchaywoman: See! That's why everybody should go vegetarian!!!!! Then you could all be perfect like me! Haha! Just kidding. I was talking to a guy last night. He brought up 'The Jungle' by upton sinclair. i read it a long time ago. That was a story that had a famous gross out part about the meat packing industry that caused a huge public outcry and caused people to demand better health laws regarding meat handling in the old days. Without that book, who knows what health standards would be today?



Veg is better but today, even they are not safe from the industries contamination.

I am glad you brought up 'The Jungle', I will have to give it a read.

I watched that movie, "Food Inc." today. Lots of good info!
I really feel for the farmers, being bullied by Monsanto!very mad It made me feel so sad for those who are trying to "seed" when Monsanto has "black listed" them. The lawsuits are unbelievable and Monsanto always wins.

Another woman lost her 2 yr. old son to E.coli, 12 days after he had eaten a hamburger! She has been fighting in D.C. with "Kevin's Law", but it has not yet passed. It's been 7 yrs. since his death.

I would encourage ALL to watch it. I am downloading it now so I will have it in my files.grin

I have been to all of the meat packing plants and done business with all of them, both in the U.S. and Canada. Swift, National Beef, BPI, Monfort, Smithfield, Con-Agra, and Tyson, just to name a few.

We import beef from Australia from "cloned" cows. When you purchase it at the grocer, you have no idea what you just bought.barf

There is Hope though, YOUR purchases cast your vote. Shop at Farmers Markets, Buy Local, plant your own gardens, Buy Organic and refuse to buy the junk they've put on the shelves!! Learn to read labels. Most communities have people willing to educate you.
I know that many of the Seventh Day Adventist churches have free cooking and nutrition classes, and are very glad to assist you in making the transformation. They are world-wide!

HLbouquet
Goldenlady London, Surrey, England UK
I'm vegetarian, bordering on vegan confused

But, I think people should be eating a hell of a lot less meat anyway. People just gorge on it.

The meat industry is DISGUSTING - they way those animals are treated is disgusting, and so you can't be surprised when the end product is pretty disgusting too.

My family eat meat, and I try as much as possible to buy free range, grass fed etc, organic for them.

From what I've seen on TV about farming, animal husbandry, and the supply chain, I'm glad I live in England. I wouldn't particularly trust products from the USA or other European countries. I also avoid any cut price deals.

However, I don't waste time washing anything either - not fruit, veg or meat. I pick off the 'mucky' leaves, and overcook the meat anyway. Not totally careful, but just fussy what I buy and feed my family. 'Touch wood' we've been ok so far!




Report this thread if it breaks rules, is offensive, or contains fighting. Staff may not be aware of the forum abuse, and cannot do anything about it unless you tell us about it. If this thread is offensive, please click here to report it »



If site dates and times do not show correctly, you can fix this by editing your timezone
Click here to edit your timezone »