Posted: May 27, 2008, 8:07 AM CST
[quote=Claayer]To be fair to be fair to Daisy .. she is pretty new and probably doesn't know Leo anyway..
Really?
You dont think it was "disparaging, or in any way insulting and was meant as motivation? In fact it is just that type of comments that leads people to say sod it and go on a bing! I have seen a man talk about precisely this less than 10 feet away from me and she managed to put herself in hospital"
Then there's my friend from the site who has an alcoholic friend, it taes so little snide comments from people who are completely unaware of the factors that this lady drank all the nail polish in her parents home in an attempt to kill herself after a simular innocent mistimed remark, couple with not getting her her passport if i remember.
My friend watched over her this xmas and cancelled her travel plans if i remember rightly she was going to die in hospital.The next time she takes alcohol it will kill her.
It's a bloody funny way of motivating people with respect, and you wont get anyone down at a drugs or alcohol addiction centre talking to their patients like that.They would walk out!Walk into one and watched family and friend support network and ask them what made people fall off the wagon/path to recovery....you'll be in for a shock.Then maybe you can come in and do the advice and motivational speaking when you have heard it.
Now bearing this in mind do you not see how some people are are aware of how bad these things can get can see the danger of just saying to someone pull your finger out, or shape up, or call them a loser.
This type of comment is a hairs breath away from what i read, and i think people should think twice before they make glib simple comments and dismiss them without realising what damage they can do to a persons will and self esteem and knock back a recovery.
I'll go even further, it may even trigger someone reading this to go on a bender if they thing everyone who has a drugs or alcohol dependancy should just pull their socks up!
Phone Vale House in Herford and ask them if they would suggest their professional counsellors take this approach! Counsellers dont do years of training for no good reason you know.
After all if they had the glib soundbite handbook ready they would just be able to dispense with places like Vale house and just have half day coffee mornings saying what can i do for you......."pull Your Sock up" next.....and carry on, wouldnt they, of course saving missions for the public purse.Maybe David Cammeron would approve of your idea, or Maggie Thatcher but someone who was to keep people dry and clean cant talk to people in such a way or funnily enough the feel insulted ,patronised, alienated and feel their councellor has no empathy with their feelings or what they are going through.Thats what makes people fall off, no support, nobody appearing to give a shit and then worse of all, those of all even when its explained by an alcoholic or heroine addict would just say "Pull your socks up, pull yourself together".
What a total utter numbskull attitude/policy that would be to endorse.........
Then again thats just plain Childish and petty, what a joke.A cheap shot, but it wont cut the fact that i am right and your completely wrong.
Ask any councellor in the field.I hope that spells out my position so it cant be twisted, or represented in any way.
It is basically total crap but then you go right ahead and think what you like, i was only interesting in Leo's welfare, or any other person who is unlucky enough to be in this position.frustrated:
Hell even ask leo privately if you like if i have offered him any support in the past.This attitute of complacency and shrugging shoulders makes me sick, and really aint going to help anyone