Tater: I love these threads too.....just read this by you... I dis-agree with you again....
You can disagree with me Tater, until you're blue in the face, it does not mean that I have any less respect for you, nor does it mean that I think you are a child abuser, a bad person for raising your children in the way that you do, that is your business and your business alone.
I have not hit, spanked or whipped my children, I have never had the emotional feeling where I have wanted to, they are all young adults now, and are respectful, fine young people that are great fun and work hard.
You cannot hit discipline into a person, but you do knock out confidence, and instill fear, I have seen it.
Look at how many people are victims of domestic violence? I said this back in September, when this thread was raised and I will say it again.
How many times have we read, from women, 'that if he ever raised his hand to me, I would leave'
How is a child to leave?
As I said back then, I have tapped a hand, as toddlers, I have grabbed them to stop them stepping into the road.
I have children in my care all day long, not just my own, I teach them morals, languages, how to be treated, hitting children was outlawed at schools.
However, I do agree with you, when you say sending them to their rooms is wrong, I see their rooms as a place for reflection, learning, not as a punishment.
No, quick, short, sharp fast punishment was the trick with my children, round to the local soup kitchen and in touch with the local volunteer centre and doing some wotk there, to remind them how lucky they are.
Never failed with mine.
I was leathered as a child, and whilst I hold no anger to my father about it, I do remember the fear, that if I did something wrong, I would lie because of fear of being found out and being hurt. It made me a devious, sneaky child because of fear and that resulted in more bad behaviour. I never wanted my children to feel like that and I once told my dad that, as an adult, when we were having dinner at my house with my children.
My dad was and is not a bad man, but that was how it was done back then, 'wait till your father gets home'
So for me, hitting my children was never an option, when they were little, as adults now, if I want to swipe on the behind for being cheeky, they are able to do it back.
But a looming adult over a little child, with a raised hand?
I remember that feeling, it is terrifying.
And my children did not deserve to be terrified.