RicoWest: I can tell you why. I never learned how to flirt or make small talk, i.e., "to play the game". For example if a woman played hard to get, I took it to mean she wasn't interested, and it would just be her loss. Besides, most women aren't my type (I know what I like, and it isn't just any woman). There WAS one exception I can recall... at one speed dating party a couple of years ago, I talked to one woman who told it like it is, and believe me, if she would have been my type, I probably would have proposed to her right then and there!
But, it all comes down to whether you're on the market for a game player or a keeper, and whether you're a game player or a keeper yourself. I am very much a keeper, and I never get the hots for ANY woman who I think is a game player... it would be a big mistake if I ever married one.
I hope you find what you seek and need, then. I'm with you on one thing...I only date those who seem to be keepers. I'm not a game-player, and I don't want one. Just sometimes you've got to date them to find out that's what they are, and then you say "adios" and move on. I'm a keeper, and I hope I've found one who wants to keep me, and me him this time. So far, so good...and I hope it just gets better.