Ambrose2007: If you doubt that's possible, try the following thought-experiment: you're deeply in love with your present spouse, he or she takes a trip and is reported killed in a plane crash. A couple of years pass, and you meet a very special someone, and fall deeply in love. You are together for a few years - when suddenly your previous spouse returns!
Now you're deeply in love with two people, no?
Ambrose, my friend, I saw that movie, too...and that would be so hard on a person. My thoughts on this, though, are that you have grieved and moved on, and found another to love who matches who you are now in life. Your love for that other person would never be the same that it was before.
Yes, I still love my late husband. I always will. But if he returned today, I wouldn't be able to love him the way I did before. I have changed through the experiences I had with his death...and I can't go backward. That is true for others I have loved strongly in this life. I believe that once you truly love someone, you always love them in some way...love doesn't die if it truly existed in the first place.
There is another that I love strongly as well, and I always will...but he is not the man that can walk beside me for the rest of my life, and I am no longer the woman I was before, that it could have worked with had he given it a chance years ago. So...I'll love him 'til the day I die, but we will only ever be friends. That love is not the healthy, full, and deep love I share now with Buzzy. It doesn't even hold a candle to it.
Do I believe one can love two people equally in a romantic way? No...and a choice must be made. Your heart will guide you the right one, Soulmate. Listen to it.