Is it possible...

Forums Home » Dating & Relating » Is it possible...
THREAD AUTHOR
soulmateTWS Happy in, Alabama USA
Do you believe it's possible to actually love two different people...I'm not referring to lust or infatuation, but actual love...Very strong, deep, and in depth feelings that has lasted several years...torn between both...

Personally, up until recently, I'm not sure if I could have said "yes"...but after certain recent events...I think it can happen...((JMO)), but what a conundrum...how does one resolve something like this...sad flower
Ambrose2007 Badger, South Dakota USA
soulmateTWS: Do you believe it's possible to actually love two different people...I'm not referring to lust or infatuation, but actual love...Very strong, deep, and in depth feelings that has lasted several years...torn between both...

Personally, up until recently, I'm not sure if I could have said "yes"...but after certain recent events...I think it can happen...((JMO)), but what a conundrum...how does one resolve something like this...


You clone yourself? confused laugh wave



pretzelman Las Vegas, Nevada USA
yes...I believe it is very possible. Love isn't meted out in portions. Love know no directions. In carpentry we use waht is called a water level. Water will always find it's own level...and so will love




Stop...JMO



kissmedeeply Petitcodiac, New Brunswick Canada
soulmateTWS: Do you believe it's possible to actually love two different people...I'm not referring to lust or infatuation, but actual love...Very strong, deep, and in depth feelings that has lasted several years...torn between both...

Personally, up until recently, I'm not sure if I could have said "yes"...but after certain recent events...I think it can happen...((JMO)), but what a conundrum...how does one resolve something like this...

Nope i dont beleive you can actually love 2 people at one time..

I wouldnt even put myself out there to begin with..

Loving one person is alot to handlegrin



gypsykisses Port Huron, Michigan USA
pretzelman: yes...I believe it is very possible. Love isn't meted out in portions. Love know no directions. In carpentry we use waht is called a water level. Water will always find it's own level...and so will love

Stop...JMO



Of course it's possible. It's another way to mess up your life too. doh
mike69spain Almuñécar, Andalucia Spain
Someone wrote last year in here that each love is its own and hence does not stop you from loving twice.

I think that was in regards to "ever love again" but if that is possible, what say you can not do it at the same time?

wine

[Genderising mode ON] At least women with their multi-tasking ability - us guys better stay on target [Genderising mode OFF] laugh
Ambrose2007 Badger, South Dakota USA
kissmedeeply: Nope i dont beleive you can actually love 2 people at one time..

I wouldnt even put myself out there to begin with..

Loving one person is alot to handle


Of course we can love more than one person at once - we all do that every day of our lives! The argument, however, is that romantic love is sui generis - that is, completely unique - and therefore not susceptible to such division.

I don't think it's *practically* divisible. Romantic love simply consumes too much energy and time. However, many people have had multiple loves in their lives, and claim to love them all, though in different ways. We've all read about men or women who've maintained spouses with families in different locations, but very few of us would be psychologically capable of doing that.laugh hug
Ambrose2007 Badger, South Dakota USA
If you doubt that's possible, try the following thought-experiment: you're deeply in love with your present spouse, he or she takes a trip and is reported killed in a plane crash. A couple of years pass, and you meet a very special someone, and fall deeply in love. You are together for a few years - when suddenly your previous spouse returns!

Now you're deeply in love with two people, no?blushing heart wings wow
mike69spain Almuñécar, Andalucia Spain
Ambrose2007: If you doubt that's possible, try the following thought-experiment:


I did see that movie too conversing
mike69spain Almuñécar, Andalucia Spain
Sorry, tripped, there was a laugh involved in the above.

wine



Tater springfield, Illinois USA
Sure you can love more than one person at a time, I don't feel it's right, to have a relationship with more then one at a time though...JMO



SexyAttorney Clearwater, Florida USA
mike69spain: I did see that movie too



Yes, and you forget he was also in love with Wilson. Personally, I think Wilson used him and was in love with Spaulding!
Ambrose2007 Badger, South Dakota USA
SexyAttorney: Yes, and you forget he was also in love with Wilson. Personally, I think Wilson used him and was in love with Spaulding!


scold

rolling on the floor laughing heart1



Tamarin somewhere, Lothian, Scotland UK
Are you intimate with both?

Just one or neither?

Well someone was bound to ask....uh oh
druidess6308 Reverse, Pennsylvania USA
Ambrose2007: If you doubt that's possible, try the following thought-experiment: you're deeply in love with your present spouse, he or she takes a trip and is reported killed in a plane crash. A couple of years pass, and you meet a very special someone, and fall deeply in love. You are together for a few years - when suddenly your previous spouse returns!

Now you're deeply in love with two people, no?


Ambrose, my friend, I saw that movie, too...and that would be so hard on a person. My thoughts on this, though, are that you have grieved and moved on, and found another to love who matches who you are now in life. Your love for that other person would never be the same that it was before.

Yes, I still love my late husband. I always will. But if he returned today, I wouldn't be able to love him the way I did before. I have changed through the experiences I had with his death...and I can't go backward. That is true for others I have loved strongly in this life. I believe that once you truly love someone, you always love them in some way...love doesn't die if it truly existed in the first place.

There is another that I love strongly as well, and I always will...but he is not the man that can walk beside me for the rest of my life, and I am no longer the woman I was before, that it could have worked with had he given it a chance years ago. So...I'll love him 'til the day I die, but we will only ever be friends. That love is not the healthy, full, and deep love I share now with Buzzy. It doesn't even hold a candle to it.

Do I believe one can love two people equally in a romantic way? No...and a choice must be made. Your heart will guide you the right one, Soulmate. Listen to it. hug
mike69spain Almuñécar, Andalucia Spain
SexyAttorney: Yes, and you forget he was also in love with Wilson. Personally, I think Wilson used him and was in love with Spaulding!


Blimey... there WAS a movie? I just felt it was the perfect set-up for a script, possibly a soap-script as it would allow for a...

hang on a second... DALLAS! conversing

laugh
Ambrose2007 Badger, South Dakota USA
druidess6308: Ambrose, my friend, I saw that movie, too...and that would be so hard on a person. My thoughts on this, though, are that you have grieved and moved on, and found another to love who matches who you are now in life. Your love for that other person would never be the same that it was before.

Yes, I still love my late husband. I always will. But if he returned today, I wouldn't be able to love him the way I did before. I have changed through the experiences I had with his death...and I can't go backward. That is true for others I have loved strongly in this life. I believe that once you truly love someone, you always love them in some way...love doesn't die if it truly existed in the first place.

There is another that I love strongly as well, and I always will...but he is not the man that can walk beside me for the rest of my life, and I am no longer the woman I was before, that it could have worked with had he given it a chance years ago. So...I'll love him 'til the day I die, but we will only ever be friends. That love is not the healthy, full, and deep love I share now with Buzzy. It doesn't even hold a candle to it.

Do I believe one can love two people equally in a romantic way? No...and a choice must be made. Your heart will guide you the right one, Soulmate. Listen to it.


I'm not sure about that at all, Dru. To tell the truth, I always rooted for the guy who came back from death, and dislike the idea that one should automatically assume that the current love is superior to the previous one (due to life-circumstances or whatever). It could very well be that the soul connection was deeper with the former love. There aren't any guarantees that one can find it again in such a powerful form, I think.

A very interesting and troubling thought-experiment involves imagining BOTH your loves starting out at the same time on a roughly equal playing field. I often have wondered how I'd do against GG's former love/husband if we were both trying to win her heart at the same time. Of course, I'd win hands-down, I think, because we're more compatible...uh, right, GG? :uoh:uh oh sad flower dunno conversing sad flower blushing



kissmedeeply Petitcodiac, New Brunswick Canada
Ambrose2007: Of course we can love more than one person at once - we all do that every day of our lives! The argument, however, is that romantic love is sui generis - that is, completely unique - and therefore not susceptible to such division.

I don't think it's *practically* divisible. Romantic love simply consumes too much energy and time. However, many people have had multiple loves in their lives, and claim to love them all, though in different ways. We've all read about men or women who've maintained spouses with families in different locations, but very few of us would be psychologically capable of doing that.


I know what you mean about loving many.

but i am talking about loving someone deeply..as in a spouse..

No i cannot love another like i love my husband..

if i did that means i didnt love him like i thought..

I would never/ever put myself there in the first place..

And a good morning to you ambrose
Ambrose2007 Badger, South Dakota USA
druidess6308: Ambrose, my friend, I saw that movie, too...and that would be so hard on a person. My thoughts on this, though, are that you have grieved and moved on, and found another to love who matches who you are now in life. Your love for that other person would never be the same that it was before.

Yes, I still love my late husband. I always will. But if he returned today, I wouldn't be able to love him the way I did before. I have changed through the experiences I had with his death...and I can't go backward. That is true for others I have loved strongly in this life. I believe that once you truly love someone, you always love them in some way...love doesn't die if it truly existed in the first place.

There is another that I love strongly as well, and I always will...but he is not the man that can walk beside me for the rest of my life, and I am no longer the woman I was before, that it could have worked with had he given it a chance years ago. So...I'll love him 'til the day I die, but we will only ever be friends. That love is not the healthy, full, and deep love I share now with Buzzy. It doesn't even hold a candle to it.

Do I believe one can love two people equally in a romantic way? No...and a choice must be made. Your heart will guide you the right one, Soulmate. Listen to it.


Well, I do tend to agree with my son: Why trade down? I believe our current love OUGHT TO BE our best love. It's part of life's learning curve, I'm thinking.

If I'm right, then Buzzy is more compatible and more deeply connected to you - at least potentially - than your former husband(s), D. That is, if I were in your situation, I'd like to believe that he'd win my heart if he were vying with you along with the others...?

Are you going to accuse me of thinking too much again, D??blushing uh oh smitten sad flower
Ambrose2007 Badger, South Dakota USA
kissmedeeply: I know what you mean about loving many.

but i am talking about loving someone deeply..as in a spouse..

No i cannot love another like i love my husband..

if i did that means i didnt love him like i thought..

I would never/ever put myself there in the first place..

And a good morning to you ambrose


Morning, Joanne. wave hug

But what do you think of the "return from death" thought-experiment? What if something - Zeus forbid - happened to Eric, and you believe he was dead? Then, a few years down the line, you meet someone else and fell deeply in love (possible, no?).

THEN - Eric returns!

You now love two people romantically and deeply, am I right? dunno
waveconfused




Report this thread if it breaks rules, is offensive, or contains fighting. Staff may not be aware of the forum abuse, and cannot do anything about it unless you tell us about it. If this thread is offensive, please click here to report it »



If site dates and times do not show correctly, you can fix this by editing your timezone
Click here to edit your timezone »