Ralf74: Definately, but you also need to consider the stigma you can leave on a person should you be wrong. Unfortunately, allegations like these do not just disappear after the fact.
Don't get me wrong, I say hang the bastards, but I also think you need to proceed with caution if you aren't armed with all the facts.
Sadly in the course of my professional career I have seen some of the worst of both sides of this argument. From the double rape of a 3 year old and an 8 year old mentally handicapped. The pure physical damage done to these two girls was horrific but the emotional scarring must have been horrendous.
Having worked in the remote areas of W.A. I have also seen the abuse that sometimes goes on in the Aboriginal communities and while I applauded the government's desire to deal with it I'm not sure I support their methods.
When it comes to people not reporting I think of a case of a young man who was sexually molested by his mother from about the age of eight or ten until he was able to leave home. He did all the things we tell our children to do, he reported it to his teachers, his doctor the police etc. Unfortunately it wasn't until after his 3rd suicide attempt that someone actually listened to what he was saying.
I have also seen what happens when someone is wrongly accused of molesting children. The end result was he lost his marriage, his family, his job and even though it was proved that the complaint was malicious and unfounded he never got any of those things back and had to leave town because "where there's smoke, there's fire" "He just got away with it this time, didn't He?"
False accusation is also an increasing tactic used in custody battles to deny access to one or other of the parent's.
I'm not sure what the law is in the eastern states but here we do not have mandatory reporting by the public which I tend to think is good.
As a health care professional, however, I am subject to mandatory reporting of all forms of child abuse. But you can be damned sure I have it straight before I do because our system does not handle these cases well and getting it wrong will destroy lives almost as much as the abuse will. You try explaining to a five year old why they aren't allowed to see their mummy and daddy.
Don't get me wrong I do not support a soft approach to any type of abuse, especially abuse to children be it sexual, physical or emotional but sometimes it's not that easy to spot and we tend to want to think the best of others. Hell, I'm trained to know what to look for and it is not easy to spot.
The other side of the coin is also that most (not all) abusers were abused themselves. That being said I also believe repeat offenders should get the key. If they don't learn the lesson the first time why should they be allowed back into the community to offend again.
Sorry, long triabe, emotive issue.