Extra terrestrial communication.

We've been listening for signs of, and signals from extra terrestrial life for over half a century and not heard a dickie bird.

Should we sending our own signals in a bid to make contact with others, rather than just listening?

If you had the opportunity, what signal would you send into outer space to represent the human race and our planet?
Post Comment

Comments (72)

I'd send them a red flag to begin with laugh

If they heed it, no need to worry about who or what to represent us or our planet.
I'd point the dish at the blogs and forums first.
I would tell them STOP predicting my words laugh

These messages have been going for years forward and receiving, one day we will meet up wow wow
Hey. It's a cool channel. [ WF

Legions of fans think it may be the best channel
Out there. ..[ .me, nah.
It started long before that, but not intentionally. laugh
Deep Purple: Smoke On The Water - on some self powered self-playing device. Spontaneous random thought.

meant to include this in the comment of course
We have been sending radio signals into space since radio was invented. Not possible to prevent it, without putting a faraday cage around the entire Earth. And some have sent out specific signals, as well. (Lookup Amateur Radio....)

Shalom,
Iyyov
Beware of time travel

Embedded image from another site
We are already sending signals they read. We are all amused that because it is not announced you decide we have not received return messages. Need to know, decided by others is the operative phrase. Most humans have zero need to know.
I've just watched a 1970's version to see if a different image of human kind might be projected, but what I found most notable were cuts to the audience that were less well synchronised with the rhythm.

Extra terrestrial's with no concept of human culture might assume the etiquette for the audience is to clap and dance offbeat. Imagine trying to practice in readiness for contact. laugh
scold no just letting them know other beings are around same as their messages to us. grin

I was trying to leave room for a discussion on whether we should send signals, or not, but yeah, shutting the stable door after the horse has bolted. laugh

That's a really interesting ethical point.

The thought of other life out there is likely pretty mind-blowing for most people. If other life is discovered, or even more so if contact is made, I'd be pretty miffed if I were deprived of that profundity during my lifetime.
That's a good point. Perhaps we too often ignore the impact(s) of acknowledging other's existence on our own planet.

Does thinking about our existence within the universe tell us more about ourselves than the universe?
jac the universe is soooo large we could not imagine it in our head, so in my book there was bound to be other forms but maybe too far away for us in our lifetime to see teddybear
I like the argument that it's both highly probable and highly improbable that other life forms exist in the universe.
My dad was conscripted into the Royal Signals in the 50's and is a radio amateur. From my earliest memories of him he's been sending nerdy messages into space as a biproduct of that.
I think the Fermi Paradox is a false dilemma. There is a Godilocks Zone for solar systems, there may be one for the galaxy. In which case it's not billions of planets spawning intelligence in all directions, but only right and left along our orbit of the galaxy at our distance. And civilizations rise and fall. The more advanced the fewer traces they leave (the Roman roads are still there, the ones in New York won't be in 100 years). A solar flare like the one in 1859 could remove this satellite and computer based culture in the time it takes people to starve. How may times could that be happening out there?
I don't think they would respond, they know we are here and looking for them but with the current state of the world, we are too volatile to contact yet. They know that they would likely be met with a missile rather than a welcoming hand shake so they don't contact us directly, just study us the same way we study monkeys in the jungle.
Or maybe like monkeys in a cage.

Maybe they put us here and we've forgotten our natural habitat. laugh
Very possible. The things you read about in the bible would all be explained by aliens and alien tech.
Or the Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy.

There is more to it Jac especially that the aliens don't use "time" the way earth people do. My post was focusing on what Track said about the hand shake.

I think I also might watch it again to understand better what they mean when Amy Adams, the scientist, can dream of what will happen because it's non-binary. I don't git dat dunno
I really can't remember it that well. dunno
I read a book that was about ETs life before he was left here..it was very sweet but I've forgotten the title.
( I read kids books sometimes before I gift them).
gift
I read kids books, too. It's sometimes to preview them, sometimes out loud for kids, or sometimes I just read what the kids are reading because they're good books.

I've not read the ET ones, but a little ... typing ...aaand...E.T. the Extra-Terrestrial, or E.T.: The Book of the Green Planet?
sos would be all i would send
That's the first time I've seen you selflessly thinking of others, Lee. thumbs up
[quote=jac_the_gripper
The thought of other life out there is likely pretty mind-blowing for most people. If other life is discovered, or even more so if contact is made, I'd be pretty miffed if I were deprived of that profundity during my lifetime.An Exoplanet is a planet orbiting a star other than our own. As of 1 March 2023, there are 5,332 confirmed exoplanets. They orbit 3,931 other stars.
There were some studies done in the 1970s regarding chemistry based life (like ours). It was determined there were really only 2 elements that could combine with Oxygen and and perform the full range of biological functions needed to form cells and higher organisms. One is Carbon, which is the one known Earth life uses. Carbon based life requires the presence of both Hydrogen and Oxygen. Fortunately on our planet those are usually found together in the form we call water. For us on our planet Carbon Hydrogen and Oxygen with a little Nitrogen thrown in (the combination is usually called CHNO and with various numbers between the letters it forms the basis of many, many things on Earth). Luckily our atmosphere is just full of Nitrogen as a gas we breath. The other element that can support life is Silicon There is however a problem with Silicon based life existing on our planet. The postulated respiration by-product of a Silicon based life form that uses Oxygen for it's electron exchanges is SiliconDiOxide. On Earth Silicon DiOxide is a quartz. Breathing it out here would be painful. At a much higher temperature and pressure than a human could survive that quartz becomes more breathable.
If silicon based life does exist somewhere, we probably won't have much contact with such creatures nor would they be terribly excited about coming here. We would turn to ash on their world and they would burst from internal pressure and suffocate here while also freezing. So we won't waste time on them and theirgiant molten worlds.
To find life, we should probably find water first. As of 1 March 2023 there are 23 moons and planets with water (including Earth) in our solar system. Most of it is ice. Some far away moons are literally coated with ice that is miles thick. Because of internal planet heat it is possible down at the bottom there is liquid water and life of some kind, but not accessible in any way with today's technology and probably not for hundreds of years to come.
Look instead for a world close enough to it's sun (aka the habitable zone) to have liquid water in a stable orbit, hopefully about the same size as Earth if you want to find life. Star Trek called worlds fitting that description with Oxygen atmospheres Class M planets. Earth is a class M planet.
Using data from NASA’s Transiting Exoplanet Survey Satellite, scientists have identified an Earth-size world, called TOI 700 e, orbiting within the habitable zone of its star – the range of distances where liquid water could occur on a planet’s surface. The world is 95% Earth’s size and likely rocky. There are three other planets in that star system. It is suspected one of the others may also have water. So that is two worlds where life is possible, both orbiting a Red dwarf star which is only 218 light years from Earth. The years there are short with a complete rotation of that sun only taking less than a month our time.
Meanwhile Hubble has determined a large world in the Leo Constellation orbiting the sun known as K2-18 which reveals the molecular signal of the presence of water. This star is only 110 Light years away from us. That planet is in the Habitable zone making much of that water liquid. Since that world has 8 times the mass of Earth the gravity is much more than Earth's. Additionally that star, another red dwarf, is pretty active and there may be a lot of radiation hitting that planet. Not a good vacation spot.
My point is we are just beginning to look and already we have found 3 worlds where life can, in theory exist

.
The sad thing is SETI has been calling for decades and no one answers. Or!!! They are already here.dum de dum! One issue I have is the need for humans to base life forms on what is known on earth. We need water so they must also. We need O2 so that has to be the norm. If..and that is a big if..there are life forms on some distant planet, they may be as alien to us as those blind snakes in caves or diatoms in the sea. Man has a big problem. He thinks everything has to fit the mold HE makes.scold roll eyes
The fact that we view and interpret from our own value framework is a part of why this is so interesting.

In contemplating communication with others, it informs us of ourselves.
I support the idea that another galaxy having a planet similar to earth with an oxygen atmosphere exists...

WHY ARE WE ALL THINKING THEY HAVE CAPABILITIES OF SPACE TRAVEL?

Seriously, the chances of humanoid creatures with a primitive lifestyle is far greater than civilizations who are sending out electronic signals (like us) looking for signs of life elsewhere.
That's a very good question.

Are we seeking higher beings that with look after us, rather than us feeling alone, or feeling responsible for others?
Hi jac, wave

As the apparent "edges" of the observable universe are expanding away from us, at an exponential rate; then this adds to the difficulty of alien "contact"

Also if the Solar System was shrunk down to the size of a dime, then our Milky Way Galaxy, would be the size of America!

And there are trillions of galaxies, hence at these scales, the extraterrestrials may exist, but the distances are too great to bridge, even travelling at near the speed of light. Recent estimates put the real size of the universe at AT LEAST 250x larger than the observable universe! I hope you can see my point here.

Firstly, they thought that the Earth was so amazing, the Sun revolved around it. When this was disproved, it was held that the Sun is a pretty amazing star. Later it was discovered that the Sun was just a run of the mill "average" small to medium sized star. Clutching at straws, perhaps, it was then asserted (by some) that our galaxy is amazing and unique, when, in reality, it is just one of trillions. Now the universe is pretty amazing, but maybe it is but one of infinitely many universes itself (a multiverse)?


dunno
For these reasons, radio contact with extraterrestrials is also unlikely


wave
Hello lovely. wave

This thread is turning out to be a bit of a nerdathon, which I'm enjoying very much indeed.

I terms of the size of the universe (as we know it, Jim), when we send radio signals, how long do they last?

If we are truly obsessed with our own uniqueness, wouldn't we avoid trying to make contact with other life forms? Or maybe we like the state of permanent anticipation. laugh
To answer your question, jac...radio waves, being a form of electromagnetic radiation, will in fact last forever, unless such wave/s meet an object (cosmic dust, etc). Generally, however, this does not happen, since the matter in the universe is very diffuse (when averaged out over the volume of space it occupies)



professor


(I guess you knew a professor was bound to show up here)
(The emoji, that is), I'm just a mildly knowledgeable former maths student....



wave
Post Comment - Let others know what you think about this Blog.
Meet the Author of this Blog
jac_the_gripper

jac_the_gripper

Tonyrefail, South Glamorgan, Wales, UK

About me...?

All about me is chaos. I'm thinking of promoting myself to the Goddess of Entropy.

It might be fun.

Better fun than being Empress of the Universe, anyway. I abdicated because the tiaras weren't as shiny as I expected for the pos [read more]

About this Blog

created Mar 2023
1,783 Views
Last Viewed: Apr 24
Last Commented: Apr 2023
jac_the_gripper has 20 other Blogs

Like this Blog?

Do you like this Blog? Why not let the Author know. Click the button to like the Blog. And your like will be added. Likes are anonymous.

Feeling Creative?