Why do so many women have depression?
Novelist Allison Pearson is the latest in a long line of high-profile women to talk publicly about their depression. All these women had pretty terrific lives – or that's how it looked from the outside. So what went wrong?
In 2002, Allison Pearson emerged as the chief chronicler of a very modern female malady: the crazed pursuit of the perfect life. Her novel, I Don't Know How She Does It, which started life as a column in the Daily Telegraph, told the story of that rarely sighted beast, a female hedge fund manager, and followed her struggle to juggle two children with her very full-time job. The protagonist, Kate Reddy, may have had a nanny and a husband who was both gainfully employed and nifty in the kitchen, but her life seemed full of comic anxieties. (The novel opened with her attempts to "distress" some Sainsbury's mince pies that her daughter was taking to school, so that they looked appropriately, maternally, handmade.) And while the book depicted an aspirational bubble that floats way over most of our heads, it found an immediate audience. In fact, it became a bestseller, the film rights were sold, and Oprah Winfrey – that essential filter of the modern female experience – described it as a "bible for the working mother".
In her worldly success, and her approach to life, it was assumed that Pearson was very similar to her protagonist. She's a high-flying journalist who has won a number of awards; her partner is New Yorker writer Anthony Lane; she has two children. In precis, it's a convincing portrait of a perfect life. But yesterday, her comic tone was jettisoned. Pearson has been writing for the Daily Mail for some years now, but this column was to be her last, she said, because she has depression. She had always wanted to be "the best kind of girl", but recently she found herself in a psychiatrist's consulting room, assessing just how unhappy she was. The psychiatrist asked if she'd had any suicidal thoughts, and "I didn't mention the strange allure of a nearby motorway bridge at dead of night . . . Eventually, I blurted into the silence: 'Sometimes, I think it would be easier not to be. Not to be dead. I have two children, I can't leave them. But just to stop, you know. To not exist for a while.'"
Pearson went on to describe herself as a "sandwich woman", one of a generation who had waited until their 30s to have children and then, just as their offspring were "sleeping through the night, one of parents fell ill". The stress of this situation – and a job on top – has taken its toll. "Is it women who are mad, or is it the society we live in?" she asked. "We always suspected there would be a price for Having it All, and we were happy to pay it; but we didn't know the cost would be to our mental health."
Comments (21)
It some times takes your privacy, your childhood, your familly, your friends, your time. . . .etc
but to think that u said many women have deppression, maybe thats why they build so many shopping malls lately, hehehe
I dont agree at all that pot is a catalyst for depression..but thats a whole different topic.
anyway, everyone is subject to depression, men and women alike. I read somewhere that the best cure for depression is to help someone else. I think this is true.
People get so absorbed in their own problems they rarely realize how insignificant they are in the grand scheme of things.
I think depression is a state of mind, and regardless of how it is induced, the person with "depression" needs to take charge of their situation and change it.
Depression comes from a feeling of disempowerment. There is an emotional scale that Abraham-Hicks talks about.
The lowest emotion on the scale is this feeling of depression, disempowerment, hopelessness.
The next rung up is anger and revenge. Most think that it is terrible for them to feel emotions of anger and revenge. They feel so guilty for having those emotions that they put themselves right back into depression again.
I say go beat the hell out of a pillow and yell and get out all of the buried anger. It can not fester forever. It will either come out in harm to oneself or to another or in disease if not released in a non threatening way.
The scale goes up from there to things like, discouragement, frustration, boredom, hopefulness, etc. But one step at a time is the way to joy.
jk. in all seriousness I agree with venusenvy and smitten. I couldnt' add anything they haven't already said.
Of course there is depression, and then there are the blues - 2 different problems. The blues can be resvolved far more readily with self help to get out of the low, depression definitely needs medical support and assistance.
If everyone on this planet did what they came here to do, no one would be depressed. Life is the journey of figuring out what makes us happy
There is no shame in admitting you need help
I thank every one who has helped me .. luckily I am a survivor
Good to see ya again babe. Not through my problems yet but getting there slowly.
Really didnt understand depression at all untill I suffered it too. People say things like 'pull your self together' and 'he wouldnt want you to be like this' thus making me feel worse!!
Oh well I will get there in the end with the help of friends
Take care babe xx