Ok what's this about then.

Yesterday I posted comments on blogs stating that in my opinion people have been brainwashed as far as religion goes, today I read that after a break of 5 years the Turin Shroud is to go back on view, now as I recall the item was proved to be a fake & not even the church claim it to be real, in which case case why have a million people booked to go & see it confused why would anyone want to view a dirty old sheet from person or persons unknown dunno

Post Comment

Comments (70)

Because it's fascinating and caused such a stir for so long? It's still a piece of art, isn't it?

Or because some still believe it's a relic and the scientific tests the work of the devil?

I remember all the fuss going on before it was shown to be not what it was claimed. To be fair, if you really believed it was a relic, to take a piece for testing created an issue of sacrilege.
EK, made me laugh for the first time today..applause
zman
The power of wanting to believe...lol...and ek is right...a good way to make money...too funny!!wine
Monica Lewinsky should hold onto that stained blue dress...could be worth a fortune...laugh
I read the carbon dating test was incorrect...was there a test after this that proved the Shroud invalid?
Jac, " a fascinating piece of art" uh oh wow I have to say your idea of art is different to mine, the Mona Lisa yes I can see the draw for that, as for whether it's the real one on display is another point for discussion I understand uh oh laugh rolling on the floor laughing

The rest of your comment looks to me much like the effects of brainwashing\hypnosis & if I were prosecuting counsel in a court case I'd be tempted to say " I rest my case " professor
Ek, I see that as the only logical explanation for reshowing it, if it's of any use I can help with EU import licences for your hot dog stand wink laugh rolling on the floor laughing wine
Lou, you could be onto something with both points there laugh I might even go to see the Lewinsky dress laugh rolling on the floor laughing laugh wine
Ken, I suppose in mitigation of the media, any rational (imo) person would know it was a fake therefore proof wasn't really a news story laugh
The fact that though entry is free much money will be generated by stays etc is a sad reflection on the lengths some will go to make money, against that I suppose we have to allow for the demand to see it doh beer
Calm, are you saying a further test proved otherwise dunno I know carbon dating is not that accurate but I would have thought better than some 1300 years dunno wine
zman
I think she got rid of it...but I could see it making some coin...

ken
I remember the story about the blue dress...thought it was true!!...now what about the cigar?...lol...laugh
Okay, what do you see as brainwashing in what I've said?
Okay, let me rephrase that: What do you think my interest in seeing the Turin Shroud as a piece of artwork, or as a memory aid has to do with me being brainwashed?
But it's a sheet with an image on it.

How is that different from a painting, or a photograph?
Hiya Zee hug


I think people don't really care whether it is real or not.

It is a symbol in a symbol-heavy religion.

People celebrate Christmas and Easter as if they were the exact dates Jesus was born and died, instead of important dates in the pre-Christian pagan calendar.

They take bread which is symbolic of the body of Christ, and wine as the blood.

Symbols are huge in religion, as it doesn't have much solid to go on.
Jac, it's a stain, if I spill coffee in bed it's never going to be considered art laugh rolling on the floor laughing laugh mind if I were a supermodel maybe it would dunno rolling on the floor laughing laugh
Molly, that's sort of the point I'm making, it all looks pretty desperate to me when things like this have any significance doh wine
I've just thought of a brilliant way to make even more money from it idea I bet Ariel would pay a fortune to test there latest washing powder & get it clean cheering laugh rolling on the floor laughing
I always try to tell people not to trust in any religion, but to believe in Jesus Christ! zmountainman you will be a good servant of our Lord Jesus Christ in the near future and i pray GOD, that our Lord Jesus Christ meet you in your dream and reveal HIS SELF to you.
The biggest corruption and stealing centre are churches who don't preach Christ, but look for donations or ways to raise finance.
The Mona Lisa is a stain, just a very well arranged one. laugh

I've just watched an interesting documentary, albeit a probably biased one.

The blood marks are actually blood on the shroud. The blood group (AB) matches the blood on a cloth in Spain that is supposed to be the one which covered Jesus' head after he was taken down from the cross. DNA testing would be interesting, eh? I wonder why that hasn't been done.

28 species of pollen found on the cloth correspond with plants only found in the Middle East, suggesting at some point the cloth has been there.

The image is a negative, like the negative of a photograph. The image has not been painted on the cloth because, unlike the blood stains, nothing has soaked into the cloth.

The image corresponds to common imagery of Jesus for centuries and it has been suggested that the image on the Turin Shroud might be the prototype for all the subsequent imagery.

The image on the cloth appears to replicate internal skeletal structure in places, suggesting it could have been formed by radiation, like an X-ray image.

The fibres of the cloth have been coated with some kind of bacterial residue which may have affected the carbon dating, ie. the bacterial contamination is from 700 years ago, but the cloth might be much older.

Even if it was shown to be about 2,000 years old, it doesn't prove it's the image of Jesus. Even if it could be proved it's Jesus, it doesn't prove that Jesus was the son of a god, or that a god exists.

I do find it interesting that it's at least 700 years old and the image doesn't appear to have been painted on. Don't you find that interesting?
Jaq - That's the old view. The newer one is it WAS painted on.
laugh
"Molly, that's sort of the point I'm making, it all looks pretty desperate to me when things like this have any significance "


Z, I guess people need symbols, whether for religion or not, but especially in religion.

But they also like mysteries, and unexplained things.

The Shroud covers all of that.
Didier, I can promise you I will never be a servant of Jesus or anyone else for that matter, this world has too many defects to warrant praise in my opinion, so even if you managed to prove his existence I still wouldn't be interested beer
@ Ken... Time for me to watch another documentary, then. laugh
Jac, ok so here it is so we can remind ourselves what it looks like


Embedded image from another site
Molly, I still reckon a good soak & into my washing machine would bring it back good as new, maybe like this

Embedded image from another site


laugh rolling on the floor laughing laugh
zman
Looks like an old cartoon...lol...grin laugh
Looking at like that, the outline with the hands crossed reminds me of images of knights in shining armour. dunno
Last year I had a guest stay here in mid summer, he'd been sun bathing on a sun lounger but got too hot, so he decided to have a siesta, unfortunately he didn't bother to shower off the sun tan lotion before laying on the bed doh I had to wash the sheet 6 times before I stop calling it The Shroud of Turin doh laugh rolling on the floor laughing laugh
Jac, it does, here's a knight



Embedded image from another site
Lou, laugh I love table cloth one laugh rolling on the floor laughing laugh
zman
Trying to lighten up...lots of political/religious stuff at the moment!!...cartoons are always good for a laugh!!wine
I'm struggling to find an unbiased, or up to date documentary. Any links would be gratefully received.

It has occurred to me that this is an important subject to you, Zee. Why create a blog about it if it didn't have some kind of impact, or emotional investment for you?

I also wonder if total rejection, even to the point of denying that it's an interesting piece of art, or history strikes me as fanatical as those who start talking about black holes and resurrection phenomena in relation to the Turin Shroud.
Here you go Jaq.

Of course you may wish to embrace the new theory which recovers Jesus being connected to the shroud, i.e., we were all wrong and Jesus lived in the 12th century not the first. laugh



Simmo, it's lucky you lived to tell the tale laugh rolling on the floor laughing laugh
I must admit I do have a soft spot for some of the art forgers, you've got laugh when their paintings are passed as genuine by the art experts laugh at least with them you do get something as good as the real thing beer
Ken, laugh that'll set the cat amongst pigeons laugh rolling on the floor laughing laugh
Thanks for the video Ken, but I was hoping for a bit more.

In the documentary I watched, they had the fella who invented carbon dating. It seems the fibres had a residue on them due to bacterial contamination. This wasn't known about at the time when it was tested and the cleaning processes used at the time were ineffective against it. I think that means they carbon dated the residue, not the shroud fibres.

He basically said work was being done to find a way of removing the residue and when that had been sorted, they'd offer to test the shroud fibres again...but he couldn't say if the offer would be accepted. laugh
And Ken...I still can't find anything conclusive to say it's a painting.

So far, I'm just seeing stuff which says nobody really knows how it was created.

dunno
Post Comment - Let others know what you think about this Blog.
Meet the Author of this Blog
zmountainmanonline today!

zmountainman

Motril, Andalusia, Spain

Originally from the UK I retired & moved to Spain 20 years ago, whilst it's not paradise it's probably as close as I'll ever come to it, living on a mountain with the sea in front & mountains behind & 320 days of sunshine a year. Still reasonably fit [read more]