Vincent Browne show (102)

Dec 8, 2010 6:17 PM CST Vincent Browne show
JohnnyT
JohnnyTJohnnyTDublin, Ireland20 Threads 3 Polls 565 Posts
What a disgusting example of media sensationalist negativity. More tripe about how this budget has hurt the "most vunerable"

A chart on nominal pay rises over a 25 year period was produced by Social Justice Ireland and a Minister grilled about the gaps between Ministers pay and the increase in social welfare over the same period.

Anyone with half a brain - which obviously the Minister didn't have, could work out that in nominal terms over the period in question, ministers pay increased by 50% while welfare increased by 300%.

The people worst affected by the budget are self employed people on a normal income - by that I mean the average industrial wage. Percentage wise the biggest tax increase is there - not that a self employed person was very well off before. Out of everyone in the tax net, a self employed person always payed the highest rate of tax in this ridiculous ultra-socialist, bordering on communist, kip of a country!!!
Dec 8, 2010 6:44 PM CST Vincent Browne show
sexydivabella
sexydivabellasexydivabellaDrogheda, Dublin Ireland44 Threads 4 Polls 5,978 Posts
JohnnyT: What a disgusting example of media sensationalist negativity. More tripe about how this budget has hurt the "most vunerable"

A chart on nominal pay rises over a 25 year period was produced by Social Justice Ireland and a Minister grilled about the gaps between Ministers pay and the increase in social welfare over the same period.

Anyone with half a brain - which obviously the Minister didn't have, could work out that in nominal terms over the period in question, ministers pay increased by 50% while welfare increased by 300%.

The people worst affected by the budget are self employed people on a normal income - by that I mean the average industrial wage. Percentage wise the biggest tax increase is there - not that a self employed person was very well off before. Out of everyone in the tax net, a self employed person always payed the highest rate of tax in this ridiculous ultra-socialist, bordering on communist, kip of a country!!!


are you self employed perchance laugh
Dec 9, 2010 5:13 AM CST Vincent Browne show
Ross30
Ross30Ross30Dublin, Ireland2 Threads 635 Posts
The problem with this country is that there are far too many do gooder vested interests. There was also an article in yesterdays Irish Independent detailing the massive increases in the dole, child benefit and the OAP from 1998-2010 yet people are moaning about minor reductions in the dole when any sensible, rational thinking person knows only too well that current rates of social welfare are completely unsustainable ditto with public sector pay and pensions.

We need a right ring government and quicksmart.
Dec 9, 2010 5:18 AM CST Vincent Browne show
Ross30
Ross30Ross30Dublin, Ireland2 Threads 635 Posts
The basic rate of social welfare in 2000 was €98.43 per week by 2009 that had increased to €204.30 per week, any rational person will admit that people who never worked when the economy was doing well will realise that the terminally unemployed gained quite a bit.

I think child benefit for the 1st child was around €53-54 per month by 2008 that had increased to €166 for the first child, welfare went through the roof during the celtic tiger and if the government had only increased social rates in line with inflation then child benefit for the first child would probably only be €90 per month, the dole would be about €135-€140 per week and the OAP would probably only be about €160 per week.

Welfare benefits increased substantially and have proven to be unsustainable.
Dec 10, 2010 5:25 AM CST Vincent Browne show
salanky
salankysalankydublin, Dublin Ireland90 Threads 1 Polls 9,888 Posts
Ross30: My father lost his job in the 1980's and he was unemployed for a few months, then he set up his own business by pulling himself up by the bootstraps.

There's far too much of a poor mouth victimhood culture in council estates in this country. Wallowing in victimhood is very sucessful in Ireland.

Also people should have been putting aside money for a rainy day, also people will need to work harder to save their marriages to stop going into poverty.

Yes I could survive on €150 per week, I'm very capable of rationing, Irish people had to ration in World War 2.
how could you live on 150 a week? also what about those of us who dont make enough money to put some away for a rainy day? and once again why compare now to ww2 or 20 years ago or 50 years ago times have changed and life is different now, what worked then is not gonna work now doh
Dec 10, 2010 5:37 AM CST Vincent Browne show
siacais
siacaissiacaisPhibsboro, Dublin Ireland1 Threads 99 Posts
LadyinDublin: some people will never no what its like to go without

WOW!!! WELL SAID.
You can take the girl out of Cabra but you cant take Cabra out of the girl.thumbs up
Dec 10, 2010 5:41 AM CST Vincent Browne show
robpacciani
robpaccianirobpaccianiGalway, Ireland211 Threads 3 Polls 5,134 Posts
Johnny Tit and Ross The Boss...

Spunking moronic statements...
Dec 10, 2010 7:00 AM CST Vincent Browne show
paphos
paphospaphosWexford and, Dublin Ireland673 Posts
robpacciani: Johnny Tit and Ross The Boss...

Spunking moronic statements...


Excellent constructive opinion there Rob.....laugh
Dec 10, 2010 7:23 AM CST Vincent Browne show
JohnnyT
JohnnyTJohnnyTDublin, Ireland20 Threads 3 Polls 565 Posts
paphos: First of all I wish you all the very best of luck with your new business venture and I admire your bravery for setting off on this journey at such a precarious financial time...

Secondly, I just want to express how disappointed I always am on here when someone comes on and posts what I found to be a level headed opinion about your own situation, only for you to be exposed to personal attacks and childish name calling by people who disagree with your post.

There is nothing to be gained by attacking each other for differing opinions or experiences.


Thank you Paphos. It is a bit risky and there's a good chance I could end up worse off and in serious debt as a result but it's a risk worth taking.

And yes, I may have a different opinion than many, although I'd like to think I've gained that opinion well through some pretty crazy life experiences, but yes it's a bit of a low blow when people get personal even if they do disagree with my opinions.
Dec 10, 2010 7:39 AM CST Vincent Browne show
robpacciani
robpaccianirobpaccianiGalway, Ireland211 Threads 3 Polls 5,134 Posts
Apologies Johnny, a slight over-reaction on my part. Of course you are entitled to your opinion. Did not mean to be nasty, hope your business gets off to a flyer bud. thumbs up
Dec 10, 2010 8:13 AM CST Vincent Browne show
Trossy
TrossyTrossyCork, Ireland129 Posts
JohnnyT: What a disgusting example of media sensationalist negativity. More tripe about how this budget has hurt the "most vunerable"

A chart on nominal pay rises over a 25 year period was produced by Social Justice Ireland and a Minister grilled about the gaps between Ministers pay and the increase in social welfare over the same period.

Anyone with half a brain - which obviously the Minister didn't have, could work out that in nominal terms over the period in question, ministers pay increased by 50% while welfare increased by 300%.

The people worst affected by the budget are self employed people on a normal income - by that I mean the average industrial wage. Percentage wise the biggest tax increase is there - not that a self employed person was very well off before. Out of everyone in the tax net, a self employed person always payed the highest rate of tax in this ridiculous ultra-socialist, bordering on communist, kip of a country!!!
First i want to say how lucky i am to still have a job, in saying that i dont think anyone has the right to say who has it better or not, everyone is going to find it a struggle to survive in these very hard times and its the old, disabled and young i feel the most sorry, Johnny i wish you the best, but have you thought that many people out there may not have the skills or the power to start a business, be lucky you have.
Dec 10, 2010 8:46 AM CST Vincent Browne show
JohnnyT
JohnnyTJohnnyTDublin, Ireland20 Threads 3 Polls 565 Posts
robpacciani: hope your business gets off to a flyer bud.


handshake Cheers man

Times like these makes everyone a bit passionate about things. Personally the budget changes sent me on the opening rant cos the tax changes will affect me going back to work. The welfare change doesn't make a difference - I'm so financially screwed 8 euro less a week is a drop in the ocean
Dec 10, 2010 8:52 AM CST Vincent Browne show
JohnnyT: Cheers man

Times like these makes everyone a bit passionate about things. Personally the budget changes sent me on the opening rant cos the tax changes will affect me going back to work. The welfare change doesn't make a difference - I'm so financially screwed 8 euro less a week is a drop in the ocean


4.5 million people on the scratcher now and when they deduct the 8 quid from it they will be saving 3.6 million quid a week.....
Annually its 187 million a year, i think thats enough money to be taking off the people that need money the most
Dec 10, 2010 9:03 AM CST Vincent Browne show
CurvyGal20
CurvyGal20CurvyGal20Dublin, Ireland21 Threads 2 Polls 562 Posts
mcattack: 4.5 million people on the scratcher now and when they deduct the 8 quid from it they will be saving 3.6 million quid a week.....
Annually its 187 million a year, i think thats enough money to be taking off the people that need money the most


450,000 you clown not 4.5 millionlaugh
Dec 10, 2010 9:17 AM CST Vincent Browne show
stanley8m
stanley8mstanley8mkildare, Kildare Ireland156 Threads 7 Polls 5,341 Posts
mcattack: 450,000 on the scratcher now and when they deduct the 8 quid from it they will be saving 3.6 million quid a week.....
Annually its 187 million a year, i think thats enough money to be taking off the people that need money the most


A lot of those will be young Irish lads and girls living at home and getting paid the minimum so When you consider that one fifth, that is 90,000 people claiming social welfare are non nationals and all of them will be getting rent allowance, it doesn't take a genius to figure out an easy way of saving the country billions..
Dec 10, 2010 9:20 AM CST Vincent Browne show
CurvyGal20
CurvyGal20CurvyGal20Dublin, Ireland21 Threads 2 Polls 562 Posts
stanley8m: A lot of those will be young Irish lads and girls living at home and getting paid the minimum so When you consider that one fifth, that is 90,000 people claiming social welfare are non nationals and all of them will be getting rent allowance, it doesn't take a genius to figure out an easy way of saving the country billions..


send them all back home on the banana boat they came over

onlaugh
Dec 10, 2010 9:39 AM CST Vincent Browne show
Ross30
Ross30Ross30Dublin, Ireland2 Threads 635 Posts
Also regarding the IMF we should be thankful that they haven't forced the government to reduce welfare to UK levels ditto with public sector pay as well. I certainly wouldn't supoort such extreme cuts but the IMF have been known to be a lot more ruthless with other countries then they have been with Ireland.
Dec 10, 2010 10:42 AM CST Vincent Browne show
Altogether now barf barf barf barf barf barf barf barf barf barf barf

But yeah i do deserve stick for my obvious mistake.........but then so do you for being a freaky little strange oddball of a man

Still livin the dream i see comfort
Dec 10, 2010 10:54 AM CST Vincent Browne show
CurvyGal20
CurvyGal20CurvyGal20Dublin, Ireland21 Threads 2 Polls 562 Posts
mcattack: Altogether now

But yeah i do deserve stick for my obvious mistake.........but then so do you for being a freaky little strange oddball of a man

Still livin the dream i see


are you blind?

Im a woman not a strange oddball of a man, Thats how I would

describe you and you cant count eitherlaugh
Dec 10, 2010 10:55 AM CST Vincent Browne show
whiteontop
whiteontopwhiteontopBelfast, Armagh Ireland16 Threads 1,389 Posts
paphos: I am self employed too, so in that same non banana boat with you! But if we adopt the send them all home policy, we might be tempting fate that other countries would accept the same intolerant policy and that all our own crowd claiming social welfare or working illegally in other countries might come trundling back....

Then we would be even more up the creek!!


Thats what was in my mind.

Hasn't Ireland come a long way when it can talk of sending back foreign nationals.ireland
Post Comment - Post a comment on this Forum Thread

Stats for this Thread

4,627 Views
101 Comments
by JohnnyT (20 Threads)
Created: Dec 2010
Last Viewed: Apr 20
Last Commented: Dec 2010

Share this Thread

We use cookies to ensure that you have the best experience possible on our website. Read Our Privacy Policy Here