Who will win American Idol? (47)

Apr 16, 2014 2:18 PM CST Who will win American Idol?
elednuw
elednuwelednuwKamloops, British Columbia Canada9 Threads 1 Polls 122 Posts
Caeleb Johnson should win hands down.No one even comes close.If he doesn't,the show is fixed.Just like last year when Angie Millar was clearly the best but came in 3d.Whats yur thoughts?
Apr 16, 2014 7:49 PM CST Who will win American Idol?
musicfreak
musicfreakmusicfreakParadise City, British Columbia Canada20 Threads 1 Polls 670 Posts
I agree Caeleb should win. When I watch him I feel like I'm at a real rock show! If he doesn't win it's because a lot of people aren't into rock music and prefer easier listening stuff like pop music, R&B and country which is annoying. It should be based on talent. Years ago Chris Daughtry should have won and instead Taylor Hicks did. Daughtry made more in album sales than any of them that year. I just feel rock singers don't do as well on that show. But who knows maybe Caeleb will do it as he does stand well above the rest. He's the only one I care to watch.
Apr 17, 2014 8:34 PM CST Who will win American Idol?
kennn
kennnkennnMedicine Hat, Alberta Canada25 Threads 5,299 Posts
Caeleb is a very good singer, he reminds me of Meatloaf. There a couple of other very good singers as well so it will be interesting to see who wins.wave
Apr 19, 2014 1:10 AM CST Who will win American Idol?
elednuw
elednuwelednuwKamloops, British Columbia Canada9 Threads 1 Polls 122 Posts
Caeleb reminds of James Durbin a few years back.Both have great rock voices.I think Durbin came in 4th that year and he was as Caeleb is now,clearly the best.That country guy Dexter was eliminated last night.
Apr 20, 2014 2:45 AM CST Who will win American Idol?
musicfreak
musicfreakmusicfreakParadise City, British Columbia Canada20 Threads 1 Polls 670 Posts
@Ken I can see how Caleb reminds you of Meatloaf.

I want him to win but if he doesn't Jena probably will. She's very talented and her best performances have been while playing the piano. I think both will be in the final two. It's nice she does rock too but not as hard as Caleb which may give her more votes as a lot of people like more easy listening music. But I do feel Caleb as a great chance!
Apr 20, 2014 11:00 AM CST Who will win American Idol?
hotheadbrad
hotheadbradhotheadbradsaskatoon, Saskatchewan Canada2 Posts
jena is gonna win
Apr 20, 2014 2:43 PM CST Who will win American Idol?
elednuw
elednuwelednuwKamloops, British Columbia Canada9 Threads 1 Polls 122 Posts
Ya,probably Caeleb and Genna,final 2.But its about time a rocker wins.
Apr 20, 2014 5:08 PM CST Who will win American Idol?
kennn
kennnkennnMedicine Hat, Alberta Canada25 Threads 5,299 Posts
musicfreak: @Ken I can see how Caleb reminds you of Meatloaf.

I want him to win but if he doesn't Jena probably will. She's very talented and her best performances have been while playing the piano. I think both will be in the final two. It's nice she does rock too but not as hard as Caleb which may give her more votes as a lot of people like more easy listening music. But I do feel Caleb as a great chance!


Guess we will have to wait and see. At this point in the competition they are all talented in their own way but I do agree with you on the final two.wave
Apr 21, 2014 2:05 PM CST Who will win American Idol?
A_Non_A_Moose
A_Non_A_MooseA_Non_A_MooseWestlock, Alberta Canada116 Threads 8 Polls 4,340 Posts
I can honestly say that I do NOT watch AI anymore,....singers on the Voice are far superior and I miss Simon on AI,.....
Apr 23, 2014 9:04 PM CST Who will win American Idol?
kennn
kennnkennnMedicine Hat, Alberta Canada25 Threads 5,299 Posts
So who do you think will be going home after tonight's show. I am thinking it will probably be CJ, wave canada
Apr 24, 2014 12:28 AM CST Who will win American Idol?
elednuw
elednuwelednuwKamloops, British Columbia Canada9 Threads 1 Polls 122 Posts
I agree,it should be CJ,or Sam Woolf..Caleb still should win the whole thing and Jeena being runner up.
Apr 24, 2014 10:47 PM CST Who will win American Idol?
musicfreak
musicfreakmusicfreakParadise City, British Columbia Canada20 Threads 1 Polls 670 Posts
I think Sam had a good night last night. Plus he's got too many girls rooting for him.
Apr 25, 2014 3:07 PM CST Who will win American Idol?
rider4u
rider4urider4uDunchurch, Ontario Canada8 Threads 1,361 Posts
elednuw: Caeleb Johnson should win hands down.No one even comes close.If he doesn't,the show is fixed.Just like last year when Angie Millar was clearly the best but came in 3d.Whats yur thoughts?

If that's what you really think then you don't understand the premise of the show...it's the public that casts the votes and they are a young audience. Ange was great but so were the other top contestants. The judges and the network don't have control over the final outcome (it would be too tempting to fix and that would ruin the show). jmho wave
Apr 27, 2014 11:12 AM CST Who will win American Idol?
elednuw
elednuwelednuwKamloops, British Columbia Canada9 Threads 1 Polls 122 Posts
If Caleb doesn't win,then I know its fixed.He's the obvious clear cut winner,just like Angie miller and Daughtry from a few years back were.They fix it so the best singer doesn't win just to create controversy so people will watch it more cause they're pissed off.
Apr 30, 2014 9:05 PM CST Who will win American Idol?
kennn
kennnkennnMedicine Hat, Alberta Canada25 Threads 5,299 Posts
Caeleb rocked the house tonight and Jenna was equally impressive. I think Sam might be on his way out tomorrow evening.
May 1, 2014 12:42 AM CST Who will win American Idol?
elednuw
elednuwelednuwKamloops, British Columbia Canada9 Threads 1 Polls 122 Posts
Yes Caleb is the clear cut leader and should win the whole thing.Everyone else I thought stepped up especially Alex Preston.The ladies where very good but I agree,Sam Woolfe should be the next one to go.
May 1, 2014 1:41 AM CST Who will win American Idol?
musicfreak
musicfreakmusicfreakParadise City, British Columbia Canada20 Threads 1 Polls 670 Posts
I think with American Idol some of the voting has to do with geographics. Sometimes it doesn't matter as much the closer to the finals they get as by then certain contestants have won others over no matter their location.

America isn't into rock. They like pop music, country, R&B, easy listening music etc. But this year I don't think the talent is as good as other years with the exception of Jena, Caleb and maybe Alex. So this year I think a rocker will finally win. Caleb blew the roof of the place tonight. That last song (one of my faves) was incredible. He should win based on that performance alone. Well include the Led Zep one too! Just amazing! He's the only one that makes you feel like you're at a rock concert!

I was busy tonight so I just caught performances here and there. I missed both of Jena's. I'll have to check youtube.

Last week I predicted everything right including bottom 3.

I think the top 3 in the finals will be Caleb, Jena and Alex. I think Alex should be there as out of everyone he has the most artistry. Caleb and Jena are just good singers.

Based on who's left, Sam Wolf should go tomorrow as I think Jessica had a decent night. But Sam is from Florida, (also has lots of teen girl votes) and Jessica is from Alabama. Let's see if location means anything now. Being it's so far into the show now it may not matter.
May 1, 2014 9:24 PM CST Who will win American Idol?
kennn
kennnkennnMedicine Hat, Alberta Canada25 Threads 5,299 Posts
I think everyone in the top five can and probably will have a good musical career. Sam went home based on his performance last night although he sounded pretty good with his song tonight. Next to go home will probably be Jessica. Alex needs to do something with his ankle-knockers if he wants to get past Caeleb or Jenna, but we will see. lollaugh
May 3, 2014 12:15 AM CST Who will win American Idol?
musicfreak
musicfreakmusicfreakParadise City, British Columbia Canada20 Threads 1 Polls 670 Posts
kennn: I think everyone in the top five can and probably will have a good musical career. Sam went home based on his performance last night although he sounded pretty good with his song tonight. Next to go home will probably be Jessica. Alex needs to do something with his ankle-knockers if he wants to get past Caeleb or Jenna, but we will see. lol


Yes, I agree all will have great careers but only 1, maybe 2 (but I doubt it) will be on the charts and have great album sales. I agree with Jessica being next also. Funny how Alex wears those pants! laugh A few guys dress like that. He looks New Wave or something. laugh I really liked his last performance (Say Something). I thought it was his best one.
May 4, 2014 1:57 PM CST Who will win American Idol?
musicfreak
musicfreakmusicfreakParadise City, British Columbia Canada20 Threads 1 Polls 670 Posts
This may affect Caleb's chances. Hopefully fans will forgive. Seems he has lots of support still in the comment section. I think he needs to learn how to deal with the press better.

Post Comment - Post a comment on this Forum Thread

Stats for this Thread

2,584 Views
46 Comments
by elednuw (9 Threads)
Created: Apr 2014
Last Viewed: Apr 18
Last Commented: May 2014

Share this Thread

We use cookies to ensure that you have the best experience possible on our website. Read Our Privacy Policy Here