pat8lanips: I think the real problem is disparity. People get into power, then award themselves heaps of medals and a chauffer driven bullet proof BMW, while everybody else starves. Wasting money on the military/civil war, then blaming drought and famine are also common themes. A lot of the time we are actually enabling this to go on and on, like in Ethiopia. Personally, I think these places might be better off being run by women, OK maybe not Mugabes wife...
Pat, I agree. Corruption is rife in too many countries, and the populations suffer as a result.
Putting too much money into the hands of any small group of people is never a good thing. Greed takes over.
All governments should have to account for every penny they spend in a clear and transparent manner.
pat8lanips: I think the real problem is disparity. People get into power, then award themselves heaps of medals and a chauffer driven bullet proof BMW, while everybody else starves. Wasting money on the military/civil war, then blaming drought and famine are also common themes. A lot of the time we are actually enabling this to go on and on, like in Ethiopia. Personally, I think these places might be better off being run by women, OK maybe not Mugabes wife...
The Kenyan GiveDirectly seems to be working fairly well. Giving them free money has improved their health and increased the numbers of hours they work. We can use technology to bypass corruption it's not as though African countries are real countries with a heritage and identity, they're fake nations of diversity created by arbitrarily drawing lines on a map. There's no reason to honour their government or leaders who spend the money on an amulet made from human finger bones.
Hmm, there's something about derogating people from poorer countries for not being productive enough, whilst they grow crops for richer countries to waste, that I can't quite put my finger on.
As for modern medicine, despite the various ethical issues of the industry, how many people would be willing to sacrifice their own for the benefit of all? It would be rather odd if people didn't fight for their loved ones' survival.
Perhaps a change of mindset and some reorganisation would help avoid an apocalypse.
ChesneyChrist: The Kenyan GiveDirectly seems to be working fairly well. Giving them free money has improved their health and increased the numbers of hours they work. We can use technology to bypass corruption it's not as though African countries are real countries with a heritage and identity, they're fake nations of diversity created by arbitrarily drawing lines on a map. There's no reason to honour their government or leaders who spend the money on an amulet made from human finger bones.
Forget Oxfam and forget foreign aid. Simply wire the money into grassroots accounts and allow it to trickle-up.
I think that's the happy medium between the status-quo and the old way. In the greatest generation days we didn't trust Africans to run things for themselves and we'd do the organising for them and things sort of worked(although Africans learned nothing), today we trust them to self-organise and nothing really works.
Africans are too childish and primitive to organise beyond the individual level. Government is odious in Africa because they're not very mature. But just because they're not grown up enough to organise collectively does not mean they're incapable of the much more basic and animal concept of personal responsibility. Buliding on personal responsibility may very well develop them into a people who can run their own government. They may take that civilised step from self into society.
pat8lanips: I think the real problem is disparity. People get into power, then award themselves heaps of medals and a chauffer driven bullet proof BMW, while everybody else starves. Wasting money on the military/civil war, then blaming drought and famine are also common themes. A lot of the time we are actually enabling this to go on and on, like in Ethiopia. Personally, I think these places might be better off being run by women, OK maybe not Mugabes wife...
jac_the_gripper: Hmm, there's something about derogating people from poorer countries for not being productive enough, whilst they grow crops for richer countries to waste, that I can't quite put my finger on.
As for modern medicine, despite the various ethical issues of the industry, how many people would be willing to sacrifice their own for the benefit of all? It would be rather odd if people didn't fight for their loved ones' survival.
Perhaps a change of mindset and some reorganisation would help avoid an apocalypse.
Depends where you're from I guess. We do broadacre farming here, not much we can viably import from elsewhere. Coffee and chocolate are the exceptions, they require huge amounts of child labour to produce. We do gourmet chocky and coffee, about 4 times the price of regular stuff...
We actually already have programs where we factor in giving some to poor countries, but this is not actually overly popular here. Of course, nobody cares about medications on the PBS (government funded) we figure they can have a little suck on the government tit, but if aids/cancer victims appear to be taken advantage of thats not gonna fly.
ChesneyChrist: Forget Oxfam and forget foreign aid. Simply wire the money into grassroots accounts and allow it to trickle-up.
Africans are too childish and primitive to organise beyond the individual level. .
You can text money to any phone in Africa; but the people I want to help don't own phones.
As for Africans being too primitive to organize beyond the individual level...
Africans are tribal by nature. It's not uncommon to see 10-12 black people all dressed alike in nice clothes, walking down the street.
It's white people that tend to organize on an individual level. You won't see 10-12 white people walking down the street, unless they're a baseball team, or in a uniform they get paid to wear...
Report threads that break rules, are offensive, or contain fighting. Staff may not be aware of the forum abuse, and cannot do anything about it unless you tell us about it. click to report forum abuse »
If one of the comments is offensive, please report the comment instead (there is a link in each comment to report it).
Wasting money on the military/civil war, then blaming drought and famine are also common themes.
A lot of the time we are actually enabling this to go on and on, like in Ethiopia.
Personally, I think these places might be better off being run by women, OK maybe not Mugabes wife...
Pat, I agree. Corruption is rife in too many countries, and the populations suffer as a result.
Putting too much money into the hands of any small group of people is never a good thing. Greed takes over.
All governments should have to account for every penny they spend in a clear and transparent manner.