~Love is Incapable of Asking For Anything~ ( Archived) (60)

May 1, 2022 9:59 AM CST ~Love is Incapable of Asking For Anything~
BB_snickersonline today!
BB_snickersonline today!BB_snickersNarnia, Ontario Canada56 Threads 3,755 Posts
The following paragraph is an excerpt from 'A Course in Miracles' which tells us why so many interpersonal relationships fail, in that they are not truly about love at all, but about getting a perceived lack, filled and refilled out of fear. Ego is the puppet master of these unholy relationships.

"Speaking about the ego’s version of ambivalent love it aptly states, “we seek in others what we feel is wanting in ourselves. We ‘love’ another in order to get something ourselves. That, in fact, is what passes for love in the dream world (this world). There can be no greater mistake than that, for love is incapable of asking for anything."

I feel that this is specifically and unalterably correct. How do you feel about above statement?

What do you think true love is and how does one attain it with another person? hug
------ This thread is Archived ------
May 1, 2022 10:12 AM CST ~Love is Incapable of Asking For Anything~
ChesneyChrist
ChesneyChristChesneyChristManchester, Greater Manchester, England UK7,144 Posts
To be really good when everybody believes you're a monster. A persecuted heart of gold. But I think that being good when there's nothing to be got by it is more achievable. Short of being hated people simply don't know what a beautiful man you are.
------ This thread is Archived ------
May 1, 2022 10:24 AM CST ~Love is Incapable of Asking For Anything~
BB_snickers: The following paragraph is an excerpt from 'A Course in Miracles' which tells us why so many interpersonal relationships fail, in that they are not truly about love at all, but about getting a perceived lack, filled and refilled out of fear. Ego is the puppet master of these unholy relationships.

"Speaking about the ego’s version of ambivalent love it aptly states, “we seek in others what we feel is wanting in ourselves. We ‘love’ another in order to get something ourselves. That, in fact, is what passes for love in the dream world (this world). There can be no greater mistake than that, for love is incapable of asking for anything."

I feel that this is specifically and unalterably correct. How do you feel about above statement?

What do you think true love is and how does one attain it with another person?
First of all, what is love? Certainly it differs with so many people. Coupled with differences in cultures, beliefs and needs, love while it's universal in nature, regard, feelings, logic and perceptions, define what love is. Then add circumstances a person is in, then love can be as convoluted as anything else.

To me whatever joys, happiness and sll that's positive between two people loving each other is love. Love not asking anything? While that seems so poetic, doesn't quite settle in my thoughts about love. Love begets love. I feel love whether I am with someone or not.
------ This thread is Archived ------
May 1, 2022 10:35 AM CST ~Love is Incapable of Asking For Anything~
BB_snickersonline today!
BB_snickersonline today!BB_snickersNarnia, Ontario Canada56 Threads 3,755 Posts
ChesneyChrist: To be really good when everybody believes you're a monster. A persecuted heart of gold. But I think that being good when there's nothing to be got by it is more achievable. Short of being hated people simply don't know what a beautiful man you are.
To be sure of what you mean Ches, what are you referring to in saying "being good". Is this compassion or genuinely caring of others or just maintaining a self notion of goodness?
------ This thread is Archived ------
May 1, 2022 10:41 AM CST ~Love is Incapable of Asking For Anything~
BB_snickersonline today!
BB_snickersonline today!BB_snickersNarnia, Ontario Canada56 Threads 3,755 Posts
lindsyjones: First of all, what is love? Certainly it differs with so many people. Coupled with differences in cultures, beliefs and needs, love while it's universal in nature, regard, feelings, logic and perceptions, define what love is. Then add circumstances a person is in, then love can be as convoluted as anything else.

To me whatever joys, happiness and sll that's positive between two people loving each other is love. Love not asking anything? While that seems so poetic, doesn't quite settle in my thoughts about love. Love begets love. I feel love whether I am with someone or not.
Thanks lindsy. The beginning of your reply pretty much encompasses what the ego thinks is love but then; and I'm sure you realize that there is a contradiction in your statements of 'love does not ask for anything' and 'I feel love whether I am with someone or not' . smile

And wouldn't this be where real love is? "I feel love". Only when we add ego's ideas and wants does the responsibility get put on another.
------ This thread is Archived ------
May 1, 2022 11:08 AM CST ~Love is Incapable of Asking For Anything~
bodleing2
bodleing2bodleing2Manchester, Greater Manchester, England UK84 Threads 6,132 Posts
As love is not an external energy it cannot be attained or aquired. That truth escapes us as we search for love, it ensures we will always fail. The association with love and romance only serves to strengthen the myth that love is something we can find outside ourselves...
to be aquired. This association teaches us that love is only possible when we find the right person....the 'one.'
The illusion is, that when found they will be the true source of love and our search is over....life is saved....Hallelujah!!!!
In reality, this will keep us looking in the wrong direction, outside and away from our self. Love is within us, it always is and it always was. We cant find what we already have.
------ This thread is Archived ------
May 1, 2022 11:08 AM CST ~Love is Incapable of Asking For Anything~
ChesneyChrist
ChesneyChristChesneyChristManchester, Greater Manchester, England UK7,144 Posts
A world for two but not the only two. The person has your undivided attention but that person is not always the same person. One at a time. Any person could be your main focus of attention just not every person right now like you were having a heart to heart across the town square through a megaphone.
------ This thread is Archived ------
May 1, 2022 11:09 AM CST ~Love is Incapable of Asking For Anything~
BB_snickers: Thanks lindsy. The beginning of your reply pretty much encompasses what the ego thinks is love but then; and I'm sure you realize that there is a contradiction in your statements of 'love does not ask for anything' and 'I feel love whether I am with someone or not' .

And wouldn't this be where real love is? "I feel love". Only when we add ego's ideas and wants does the responsibility get put on another.
I'm not sure if it's contadicting anything. But what I meant is that love is a very different if not difficult to measure because of so many variables. When I said I feel loved even if I am loved by others or simply by myself. I certainly don't prefer the latter. I do know what a glorious feelings there is when someone loves you and you get fulfilled in many ways. Love is not as simple as holding hands, talks about sweet nothings, no.

Either way. Love not asking anything is , like I said a most ideal thought. In a world so torn with cruelty and hatred, I wish love always prevail and eliminate all negative aspects of life. wave
------ This thread is Archived ------
May 1, 2022 11:15 AM CST ~Love is Incapable of Asking For Anything~
d4nI314
d4nI314d4nI314Planet Earth, Valencia Spain7 Threads 453 Posts
BB_snickers: The following paragraph is an excerpt from 'A Course in Miracles' which tells us why so many interpersonal relationships fail, in that they are not truly about love at all, but about getting a perceived lack, filled and refilled out of fear. Ego is the puppet master of these unholy relationships.

"Speaking about the ego’s version of ambivalent love it aptly states, “we seek in others what we feel is wanting in ourselves. We ‘love’ another in order to get something ourselves. That, in fact, is what passes for love in the dream world (this world). There can be no greater mistake than that, for love is incapable of asking for anything."

I feel that this is specifically and unalterably correct. How do you feel about above statement?

What do you think true love is and how does one attain it with another person?
Hi BB...wave

I've never read the book, but I have a similar philosophy.

I agree with the above statement "seeking in others what we lack of in ourselves".

I think that "true" love is unconditional.
One should be able to give without expecting anything in return.

Many have pets to fulfill their lack of love.
------ This thread is Archived ------
May 1, 2022 11:20 AM CST ~Love is Incapable of Asking For Anything~
d4nI314
d4nI314d4nI314Planet Earth, Valencia Spain7 Threads 453 Posts
bodleing2:
. Love is within us, it always is and it always was. We cant find what we already have.
Very true! Hi Bod wave
------ This thread is Archived ------
May 1, 2022 11:26 AM CST ~Love is Incapable of Asking For Anything~
BB_snickersonline today!
BB_snickersonline today!BB_snickersNarnia, Ontario Canada56 Threads 3,755 Posts
ChesneyChrist: A world for two but not the only two. The person has your undivided attention but that person is not always the same person. One at a time. Any person could be your main focus of attention just not every person right now like you were having a heart to heart across the town square through a megaphone.
Oh, ok I understand now.
This is a much better assessment imo, though I think that implying that it can only be one person at a time isn't necessarily how it can work. head banger
------ This thread is Archived ------
May 1, 2022 11:27 AM CST ~Love is Incapable of Asking For Anything~
Ten_of_cupss
Ten_of_cupssTen_of_cupssShumen, Bulgaria2 Threads 1,375 Posts
bodleing2: As love is not an external energy it cannot be attained or aquired. That truth escapes us as we search for love, it ensures we will always fail. The association with love and romance only serves to strengthen the myth that love is something we can find outside ourselves...
to be aquired. This association teaches us that love is only possible when we find the right person....the 'one.'
The illusion is, that when found they will be the true source of love and our search is over....life is saved....Hallelujah!!!!
In reality, this will keep us looking in the wrong direction, outside and away from our self. Love is within us, it always is and it always was. We cant find what we already have.
Exactly!
If one looks for something it means they lack it...
The need isn't the moving force of love...
If you don't have it you will never find it...
Ego is what makes us searching our own boundaries and forces, the knowledge of ourselves and the matters of the Universe.
Ego is the meaning of what we are and what we can become...
------ This thread is Archived ------
May 1, 2022 11:27 AM CST ~Love is Incapable of Asking For Anything~
BB_snickersonline today!
BB_snickersonline today!BB_snickersNarnia, Ontario Canada56 Threads 3,755 Posts
bodleing2: As love is not an external energy it cannot be attained or aquired. That truth escapes us as we search for love, it ensures we will always fail. The association with love and romance only serves to strengthen the myth that love is something we can find outside ourselves...
to be aquired. This association teaches us that love is only possible when we find the right person....the 'one.'
The illusion is, that when found they will be the true source of love and our search is over....life is saved....Hallelujah!!!!
In reality, this will keep us looking in the wrong direction, outside and away from our self. Love is within us, it always is and it always was. We cant find what we already have.
On the mark again Bod. So for you what is the purpose of real love and connecting with other people. wave
------ This thread is Archived ------
May 1, 2022 11:35 AM CST ~Love is Incapable of Asking For Anything~
BB_snickersonline today!
BB_snickersonline today!BB_snickersNarnia, Ontario Canada56 Threads 3,755 Posts
lindsyjones: I'm not sure if it's contadicting anything. But what I meant is that love is a very different if not difficult to measure because of so many variables. When I said I feel loved even if I am loved by others or simply by myself. I certainly don't prefer the latter. I do know what a glorious feelings there is when someone loves you and you get fulfilled in many ways. Love is not as simple as holding hands, talks about sweet nothings, no.

Either way. Love not asking anything is , like I said a most ideal thought. In a world so torn with cruelty and hatred, I wish love always prevail and eliminate all negative aspects of life.
Yeah, I understand lindsy what you are saying. What I was saying is that one of those things is true. The other is not, hence the contradiction. I think your heart and your spirit know truth but the ego wants what it wants so it tries to hide behind something saying that it's better for you to have something for love, when it really may not be. dunno Love knows that giving is receiving and yes as you say for most of us it's just an ideal. sad flower

What stops you specifically from applying love as you say instead of the cruelty and hatred, fighting, arguing etc.,. I mean it starts for us all, at home yeah?
------ This thread is Archived ------
May 1, 2022 11:38 AM CST ~Love is Incapable of Asking For Anything~
Name_Taken_Two
Name_Taken_TwoName_Taken_TwoBelfast, Antrim Ireland75 Threads 2,322 Posts
Ten_of_cupss: Exactly!
If one looks for something it means they lack it...
The need isn't the moving force of love...
If you don't have it you will never find it...
Ego is what makes us searching our own boundaries and forces, the knowledge of ourselves and the matters of the Universe.
Ego is the meaning of what we are and what we can become...
I have to disagree with that.. I have lots of love, but also looking for some..wink
------ This thread is Archived ------
May 1, 2022 11:39 AM CST ~Love is Incapable of Asking For Anything~
BB_snickersonline today!
BB_snickersonline today!BB_snickersNarnia, Ontario Canada56 Threads 3,755 Posts
d4nI314: Hi BB...

I've never read the book, but I have a similar philosophy.

I agree with the above statement "seeking in others what we lack of in ourselves".

I think that "true" love is unconditional.
One should be able to give without expecting anything in return.

Many have pets to fulfill their lack of love.
Hi Dani,

What does unconditional mean to you. And what would be required to invoke unconditional love from you Dani? In general of course.

I think some may have pets for other reasons. For example, knowing that pets are in their own stage of growth/enlightenment they have them to assist in that process. I expect this is a small crowd but still they exist.
------ This thread is Archived ------
May 1, 2022 11:41 AM CST ~Love is Incapable of Asking For Anything~
Ten_of_cupss
Ten_of_cupssTen_of_cupssShumen, Bulgaria2 Threads 1,375 Posts
Name_Taken_Two: I have to disagree with that.. I have lots of love, but also looking for some..
You look for someone to share what you have, Dino...
------ This thread is Archived ------
May 1, 2022 11:45 AM CST ~Love is Incapable of Asking For Anything~
BB_snickersonline today!
BB_snickersonline today!BB_snickersNarnia, Ontario Canada56 Threads 3,755 Posts
Ten_of_cupss: Exactly!
If one looks for something it means they lack it...
Probably true and hard to deny. hmmm

Ten_of_cupss: The need isn't the moving force of love...
I think we are all searching ToC. What drives that search is a desire me thinks. confused

Ten_of_cupss:
Ego is what makes us searching our own boundaries and forces, the knowledge of ourselves and the matters of the Universe.
Ego is the meaning of what we are and what we can become...
I think love does this and that ego sets boundaries and limits, thus discouraging us from searching beyond our perceived boundaries.
------ This thread is Archived ------
May 1, 2022 11:45 AM CST ~Love is Incapable of Asking For Anything~
BB_snickers: Yeah, I understand lindsy what you are saying. What I was saying is that one of those things is true. The other is not, hence the contradiction. I think your heart and your spirit know truth but the ego wants what it wants so it tries to hide behind something saying that it's better for you to have something for love, when it really may not be. Love knows that giving is receiving and yes as you say for most of us it's just an ideal.

What stops you specifically from applying love as you say instead of the cruelty and hatred, fighting, arguing etc.,. I mean it starts for us all, at home yeah?
I'm feeling the vibe BB. The ego is conceding. Now I know and feel what you meant. In an ideal world, love is the king, the good spirit, the energy that sustains everything. Sans ego, it's a perfect world. I am endowed with the power to hold unto. Yes, now here's my question. Why does ego factor in in all that we do? 8 billion people B, why?

Better question. What do we do to enlighten the world and eliminate ego?
------ This thread is Archived ------
May 1, 2022 11:45 AM CST ~Love is Incapable of Asking For Anything~
Name_Taken_Two
Name_Taken_TwoName_Taken_TwoBelfast, Antrim Ireland75 Threads 2,322 Posts
Ten_of_cupss: You look for someone to share what you have, Dino...
I have a large family, lots of mutual love there, I suppose I am wanting to share what I have, I'm not lacking in the love stakes I must say, well sometimes on here maybe..wink
------ This thread is Archived ------
Post Comment - Post a comment on this Forum Thread

This Thread is Archived

This Thread is archived, so you will no longer be able to post to it. Threads get archived automatically when they are older than 3 months.

« Go back to All Threads
Message #318

Stats for this Thread

1,849 Views
59 Comments
by BB_snickers (56 Threads)
Created: May 2022
Last Viewed: 6 hrs ago
Last Commented: May 2022

Share this Thread

We use cookies to ensure that you have the best experience possible on our website. Read Our Privacy Policy Here