I hope cash is here to stay, although I mostly use card for convenience.
A cashless society, or even a cardless society where everything is arranged by mobile phone, will disadvantage the most vulnerable in society. There's not much point in being able to spare a digit for the homeless, or use public transport if they won't accept cash, card, or disability/pensioner pass.
Digital finance already obscures how poorly paid and under-valued most people are in our societies.
MariaR33Couva, Couva-Tabaquite-Talparo Trinidad and Tobago1 Threads43 Posts
MariaR33Couva, Couva-Tabaquite-Talparo Trinidad and Tobago43 posts
rohaan: Cash is here to stay. Let's talk about it---(many people are predicting that a "cashless society" is unavoidable. I say it isn't going to happen).
I hope you're right. Even in my country they're pushing for all digital.
jac_the_gripper: I hope cash is here to stay, although I mostly use card for convenience.
A cashless society, or even a cardless society where everything is arranged by mobile phone, will disadvantage the most vulnerable in society. There's not much point in being able to spare a digit for the homeless, or use public transport if they won't accept cash, card, or disability/pensioner pass.
Digital finance already obscures how poorly paid and under-valued most people are in our societies.
The major cases here (America) are that way too many people use cash, and want to use cash. Just too many of us that would soundly refuse. Also, literally hundreds of times in the past 20 years, including very recent, natural disasters have required the solitary use OF cash only, as banks were closed, ATM's were non-functioning, credit card appliances fritzed out, etc.... so that was a good argument in favor of cash, as well. Several states in The United States have actually mandated that a business cannot REFUSE cash, as many are attempting to. In Portland, a couple of years ago, a filling station refused to accept cash after fueling up a man's car. He did not carry debit or credit cards, so cash was his only option. Well, they called the police, who arrived promptly. After discussing the problem with both vendor and customer, the police told the vendor "No crime has been committed here. He willingly offered payment in a form recognized by our government. If you refuse to take the money, he can leave free and clear". They took the cash.
MariaR33: I hope you're right. Even in my country they're pushing for all digital.
I can't answer for your country--but I do know that The United States is frequently a fiscal deciding factor, globally, and I am very, very sure that we will be actively using cash for a long, long, long time. Fact: Approximately 30 million people in The U.S. do NOT participate with electronics, and a whopping 12 million people do not use banks. It is still legal and must be accommodated, to receive one's pay in cash. K-Mart paid this way for years.
rohaan: The major cases here (America) are that way too many people use cash, and want to use cash. Just too many of us that would soundly refuse. Also, literally hundreds of times in the past 20 years, including very recent, natural disasters have required the solitary use OF cash only, as banks were closed, ATM's were non-functioning, credit card appliances fritzed out, etc.... so that was a good argument in favor of cash, as well.
Doesn't that require people to have large quantities of cash under the mattress at all times just in case? Surely that's not a good combination with your gun laws?
Not that I'm against cash.
You have reminded me that I really ought to put my money where my mouth is and use cash as much as possible. The thing is, public transport struggles with change and I find myself using shops less and less. I'd like to support real shops, but so few sell environmentally responsible produce/products.
Do I use my small rectangle of plastic online, or buy stuff encased in enough plastic to make goodness knows how many cards?
rohaan: Several states in The United States have actually mandated that a business cannot REFUSE cash, as many are attempting to. In Portland, a couple of years ago, a filling station refused to accept cash after fueling up a man's car. He did not carry debit or credit cards, so cash was his only option. Well, they called the police, who arrived promptly. After discussing the problem with both vendor and customer, the police told the vendor "No crime has been committed here. He willingly offered payment in a form recognized by our government. If you refuse to take the money, he can leave free and clear". They took the cash.
rohaan: I can't answer for your country--but I do know that The United States is frequently a fiscal deciding factor, globally, and I am very, very sure that we will be actively using cash for a long, long, long time. Fact: Approximately 30 million people in The U.S. do NOT participate with electronics, and a whopping 12 million people do not use banks. It is still legal and must be accommodated, to receive one's pay in cash. K-Mart paid this way for years.
I've just googled and it's legal for employers to pay employees in cash in the UK, but I can't find anything that says employees have the legal right to be paid in cash.
I'd be really interested if anyone can enlighten me.
jac_the_gripper: I've just googled and it's legal for employers to pay employees in cash in the UK, but I can't find anything that says employees have the legal right to be paid in cash.
I'd be really interested if anyone can enlighten me.
rohaan: The major cases here (America) are that way too many people use cash, and want to use cash. Just too many of us that would soundly refuse. Also, literally hundreds of times in the past 20 years, including very recent, natural disasters have required the solitary use OF cash only, as banks were closed, ATM's were non-functioning, credit card appliances fritzed out, etc.... so that was a good argument in favor of cash, as well. Several states in The United States have actually mandated that a business cannot REFUSE cash, as many are attempting to. In Portland, a couple of years ago, a filling station refused to accept cash after fueling up a man's car. He did not carry debit or credit cards, so cash was his only option. Well, they called the police, who arrived promptly. After discussing the problem with both vendor and customer, the police told the vendor "No crime has been committed here. He willingly offered payment in a form recognized by our government. If you refuse to take the money, he can leave free and clear". They took the cash.
Good post. Portland is different, in many ways behind the times it appears. Most if not all filling stations around here are pre-paid only.
I gather no one has been paying attention to the slow decline in cash. First banks started keeping a limited amount of cash, then the coin shortage then all the restrictions on sales involving ever shrinking amounts that require reporting. I think the last was sales over $600. Everything requires a credit or debit card. I rarely see or carry cash. oddly Lottery tickets can only be purchased with cash and on the res weed is cash based. Banks don't pay you anything in interest, so why leave any money for them to loan out of your account? Interest rates on CC's are through the roof. Cash is being weeded out,
Members of the U.S. banking community today announced the launch of a proof of concept (PoC) project that will explore the feasibility of an interoperable digital money platform known as the regulated liability network (RLN). Using distributed ledger technology, the proposed platform would create innovation opportunities to improve financial settlements and would include participation from central banks, commercial banks of various sizes and regulated non-banks.
Basically, Fedcoin is advancing and is now in the testing stage:
The 12-week PoC will test a version of the RLN design that operates exclusively in U.S. dollars where commercial banks issue simulated digital money or “tokens” – representing the deposits of their own customers – and settle through simulated central bank reserves on a shared multi-entity distributed ledger.
rohaan: Cash is here to stay. Let's talk about it---(many people are predicting that a "cashless society" is unavoidable. I say it isn't going to happen).
I am a plastic person and use my card most of the time. Before debit cards I always wrote checks. I don’t like to carry cash.
jac_the_gripper: I've just googled and it's legal for employers to pay employees in cash in the UK, but I can't find anything that says employees have the legal right to be paid in cash.
I'd be really interested if anyone can enlighten me.
i
Many, many years ago, when I worked at a casino in Reno, Nevada, we were paid in cash, we received a little hand written slip of what they took out along with our cash. One time I stepped out back and opened my pay envelope and kept pulling out 100 dollar bills, way more than I, as a mere booth cashier made, one of the office personnel was standing there next to me, I said I had to go back in, this is totally wrong. She’s telling me to keep it over and over, the weirdo. I took it straight back in there, turns out our names on one whole ledger were on the wrong pay, it was a mess! I always wondered who made that money. It was quite a bit.
Butcher559Whangarei, Northland New Zealand750 posts
Govt and inland revenue like people to pay govt departments with online banking and leave a paper trail to trace, paper trail needed for money going into your bank accounts (proceeds of crime proof)
Report threads that break rules, are offensive, or contain fighting. Staff may not be aware of the forum abuse, and cannot do anything about it unless you tell us about it. click to report forum abuse »
If one of the comments is offensive, please report the comment instead (there is a link in each comment to report it).