Forced into womanhood at 12 betrayed by those you trusted abused daily mentally and physically forced to sleep in the animal shed Your escape was short-lived being captured and returned to your tormentors
In the mountains the cruel knife passed on your innocent face No, Aisha that is not cold water in your nose It is your blood your nose is gone and so are your ears
Your tormentors have gone away and left you alone to die But you refused to lay down and die With your defiant spirit you crawled down the mountain to those who cared and protected you and helped you to a new life away from the evil unjust system you inherited by birth
What was your crime to be dealt such cruelty?
~ ~ ~ ~ ~
Posted: Aug 2013
About this poem:
In a practice known as baad, Aisha's father promised her to a Taliban fighter when she was 12 years old as a compensation for a killing that a member of her family had committed. She was married at 14 and subjected to constant abuse. At 18, she fled the abuse and was caught by the police, jailed and returned to her family. her father returned her to her in-laws. To take revenge on her escape, her father-in-law, husband and three other family members took Aisha to the mountains, cut off her nose and ears and left her to die. She was still alive however, and managed to crawl to her grandfather's house from where her father smuggled her to an American medical facility where she was looked after for ten weeks. Subsequently, she was brought to the US where she under went further treatment.
socrates44OPSan Fernando, Trinidad and TobagoOct 22, 2013
Hi ladyjewel
Thank you for your comment. I posted this quite some time ago. I had thought it would receive more comments. I have updated the footnote for those who may not have known the story. Further information can be viewed at:
Socrates sometimes I wonder what is giving birth to such evil. The mind must be wired so different when this can be done to a young girl. How do you bring justice for that young women. Glad she is being helped now. Hope she leads a happier life even in disfigurement sometimes you cannot touch the person inside. Hope that is the case here.
Odette67Penrith, Cumbria, England UKOct 23, 2013
What was your crime to be dealt such cruelty?
Mans inhumanity to man, knows no bounds, my heart bleeds, nicely done.
Thats as real as it can get. Its hard to understand practices and traditions from other countries at times. Some I think are just inhumane and then there are those that I feel who am I to judge although inhumane. None the less I am glad to be where I am at at times because here although brutal it wheres a mask. This is a sad story and your lines captured it well. ...Jesse
socrates44OPSan Fernando, Trinidad and TobagoOct 25, 2013
Hi Redex
Thank you for your comment. I also wonder the same thing about the world. It is sad that many times when such cruelty takes place, the innocent and helpless are the target, especially girls. Malala is another similar case. The psychological damage may be even more severe. I admire the courage and determination of these young women who are determined to move on. I wish them all the best for the future.
Wow Socrates, That's about as harrowing a poem as I have ever read, truly shocking!As someone with three daughters...I could never forgive people like that. Well done on highlighting this
socrates44OPSan Fernando, Trinidad and TobagoOct 25, 2013
Hi Jesse
Thank you for your comment. I appreciate it's honesty. It would appear that each culture has it's own reality which determines it's cultural norms. Some may argue that human behaviour in a society should be judged according to it norms. This may seem be a valid claim as you have pointed out. Yet, this incident is so heart-wrenching that it makes one wonder about universal "noble human nature" as professed by some.
"For Mercy has a human heart Pity, a human face:" This is part of a quote from William Blake's "Songs of Innocence". He is probably turning in his grave at incidents like this one.
socrates44OPSan Fernando, Trinidad and TobagoOct 25, 2013
Hi Ravensgold
Thank you for your comment. This is indeed a very sad episode. One can only try to imagine the terror, pain and suffering experienced by that poor young woman. I remember viewing one of your poems which highlighted your love for your daughter. I am sure that they feel a similar love for you. Have a nice day!
socrates44OPSan Fernando, Trinidad and TobagoOct 25, 2013
Hi gnj4u
Thank you for your comment stating the report by Human Rights Watch. The 87% figure is staggering. As long as those women are denied the opportunity to educate themselves and to improve their position in life, this situation is likely to continue, sad to say. Have a pleasant day!
Comments (11)
Thank you for your comment. I posted this quite some time ago. I had thought it would receive more comments. I have updated the footnote for those who may not have known the story. Further information can be viewed at:
to be dealt such cruelty?
Mans inhumanity to man, knows no bounds, my heart bleeds, nicely done.
Thank you for your comment.
I also wonder the same thing about the world. It is sad that many times when such cruelty takes place, the innocent and helpless are the target, especially girls. Malala is another similar case. The psychological damage may be even more severe. I admire the courage and determination of these young women who are determined to move on. I wish them all the best for the future.
Thank you for your comment which highlighted the main theme of my piece. It is indeed man's inhumanity to man!
Have a nice day!
Well done on highlighting this
Thank you for your comment. I appreciate it's honesty. It would appear that each culture has it's own reality which determines it's cultural norms. Some may argue that human behaviour in a society should be judged according to it norms. This may seem be a valid claim as you have pointed out. Yet, this incident is so heart-wrenching that it makes one wonder about universal "noble human nature" as professed by some.
"For Mercy has a human heart
Pity, a human face:"
This is part of a quote from William Blake's "Songs of Innocence".
He is probably turning in his grave at incidents like this one.
Thank you for your comment.
This is indeed a very sad episode. One can only try to imagine the terror, pain and suffering experienced by that poor young woman.
I remember viewing one of your poems which highlighted your love for your daughter. I am sure that they feel a similar love for you.
Have a nice day!
Thank you for your comment stating the report by Human Rights Watch. The 87% figure is staggering. As long as those women are denied the opportunity to educate themselves and to improve their position in life, this situation is likely to continue, sad to say.
Have a pleasant day!