Should Children Work? (30)

Nov 30, 2017 4:28 PM CSTShould Children Work?
lifeisadream
lifeisadreamlifeisadreamMexi Go, Mexico Mexico184 Threads 24 Polls 22,575 Posts

Should Children Work?(Vote Below)

- (To Vote: select an option above, then press this button)
yes
23%
10 Votes
no
47%
20 Votes
maybe
12%
5 Votes
it is Obama's fault also Hillary's and Soros and Jeff Bezos and all those liberal :)
7%
3 Votes
it is Trump's fault
2%
1 Votes
I like Disneyland
7%
3 Votes
it is the Muslim's fault
2%
1 Votes
it is the Christian's fault
0%
0 Votes
I have not idea
0%
0 Votes
wot?
0%
0 Votes
43 Total Votes
Should Children work?

Today I took several pairs of shoes to the shinning shop and there one of the young fellows that shine shoes had his young child (9 or 10 y.o) working there and he asked me if having his child working was wrong because a lady had lecture him about it.

The boy had not classes because his teacher had a meeting (and it looks like teachers have meeting rather frequently and not classes for the children hmmm ) and the boy could not go with his mother because no children are allowed into her job so either the boy stays alone at home or on the streets or the father takes him to work (shinning shoes) so the boy was shinning shoes and helping his father.


Thank you in advance for your comments.



bouquet
Nov 30, 2017 4:32 PM CST Should Children Work?
One2note
One2noteOne2noteLondon, Essex, England UK255 Threads 3 Polls 7,504 Posts
I hate polls.. it reminds me of people hassleing you on the street to ask pointless question for market research.
Nov 30, 2017 4:40 PM CST Should Children Work?
lifeisadream
lifeisadreamlifeisadreamMexi Go, Mexico Mexico184 Threads 24 Polls 22,575 Posts
One2note: I hate polls.. it reminds me of people hassleing you on the street to ask pointless question for market research.


market research ?


laugh
Nov 30, 2017 4:46 PM CST Should Children Work?
in my opinion If the child is doing it of his/her own inference {for want of a better word} and is doing so in an environment of love and best interest.
Then to not allow the child to work is an injustice. dunno

All children love to help their Mothers and Fathers.
Intense labour is very different conversing
Nov 30, 2017 4:49 PM CST Should Children Work?
One2note
One2noteOne2noteLondon, Essex, England UK255 Threads 3 Polls 7,504 Posts
Yes! Like What do you do whith the feedback on the data provided.
Nov 30, 2017 4:51 PM CST Should Children Work?
lifeisadream
lifeisadreamlifeisadreamMexi Go, Mexico Mexico184 Threads 24 Polls 22,575 Posts
nonsmoker: in my opinion If the child is doing it of his/her own inference {for want of a better word} and is doing so in an environment of love and best interest.
Then to not allow the child to work is an injustice.

All children love to help their Mothers and Fathers.
Intense labour is very different


the child working means he is not alone at home or on the streets and the child gets good tips while working also beyond that the father can have an eye on his child.

conversing
Nov 30, 2017 4:54 PM CST Should Children Work?
lifeisadream
lifeisadreamlifeisadreamMexi Go, Mexico Mexico184 Threads 24 Polls 22,575 Posts
One2note: Yes! Like What do you do whith the feedback on the data provided.

The feed back?



rolling on the floor laughing


comfort
Nov 30, 2017 5:08 PM CST Should Children Work?
There is nothing wrong with studying and working.
Am one of them working 8 hours during the day and studying and
going to evening school after work.-
Nov 30, 2017 5:18 PM CST Should Children Work?
marlindaponline now!
marlindaponline now!marlindapClearwater, British Columbia Canada220 Posts
instead of a lecture maybe the lady could have told the boy what a wonderful job he was doing shinning those shoes. Then the father and the son would both be proud of what they were doing. When the father first had the idea, he probably never saw anything wrong with it, nor the son. He was probably happy to think he was helping his dad, how sad the father had to question his own judgement because of one persons opinion.
Nov 30, 2017 6:02 PM CST Should Children Work?
marlindap: instead of a lecture maybe the lady could have told the boy what a wonderful job he was doing shinning those shoes. Then the father and the son would both be proud of what they were doing. When the father first had the idea, he probably never saw anything wrong with it, nor the son. He was probably happy to think he was helping his dad, how sad the father had to question his own judgement because of one persons opinion.



Very well said,
Yes The questioning of self judgement can be quite damaging, especially when it comes to relationships.
I am sure there are loads of kids with no Fathers, Mothers and sadly Many without both, that would understand the true merit and value of the dream of working and helping a Parent . wave
Nov 30, 2017 6:04 PM CST Should Children Work?
lifeisadream: the child working means he is not alone at home or on the streets and the child gets good tips while working also beyond that the father can have an eye on his child.


Indeed, It makes for a health of society. wine
Dec 1, 2017 12:25 AM CST Should Children Work?
ChesneyChristonline today!
ChesneyChristonline today!ChesneyChristManchester, Greater Manchester, England UK2,969 Posts
Ideally parents would have the time and money to put the kids first and not take them along to work.
Dec 1, 2017 12:35 AM CST Should Children Work?
ChesneyChristonline today!
ChesneyChristonline today!ChesneyChristManchester, Greater Manchester, England UK2,969 Posts
ChesneyChrist: Ideally parents would have the time and money to put the kids first and not take them along to work.


Personally I liked the jobs I got myself as a boy, I was cleaning wheelie bins when I was 8. But I didn't enjoy all those summer weeks working in mum's sandwich shop or every weekend passing tools to my dad all year round.
Dec 1, 2017 12:49 AM CST Should Children Work?
ChesneyChristonline today!
ChesneyChristonline today!ChesneyChristManchester, Greater Manchester, England UK2,969 Posts
ChesneyChrist: Personally I liked the jobs I got myself as a boy, I was cleaning wheelie bins when I was 8. But I didn't enjoy all those summer weeks working in mum's sandwich shop or every weekend passing tools to my dad all year round.


Although to be honest the most rewarding part in washing wheelie bins was when they gave me my money. And frankly speaking I was counting down the days until I was old enough to become a latchkey kid there's only so much bread buttering and bollocking for passing the wrong spanner a boy can take.
Dec 1, 2017 1:38 AM CST Should Children Work?
stemik62
stemik62stemik62Denver, Colorado USA6 Posts
If the child had no classes, then yes it is ok. The child is with his father and what better place could this child be? Family is so important in raising children.
Dec 1, 2017 6:36 AM CST Should Children Work?
Len05
Len05Len05Antwerp, Antwerpen Belgium39 Threads 13 Polls 1,352 Posts
yes making children productive will make adults have benefits from children and more children will be born.

I'm now talking about a modern society and not the stone age countries referred by OP
Dec 1, 2017 12:21 PM CST Should Children Work?
jac_the_gripper
jac_the_gripperjac_the_gripper..., South Glamorgan, Wales UK15 Threads 3,719 Posts
My daughter had her own paper round business by the time she was 12.

I did it with her, so it was a safe learning experience.

She paid for her bedroom decoration and furniture, 2 school ski trips, a school trip to Disneyland Paris and more.

I had the child benefit (which all parents get in the UK) paid into her account and she budgeted that for swimming, martial arts, horse riding, skiing and ballet lessons/equipment.

It's educational for children to work, earn and budget. It's educational (and fun) for children to save up for extra-curricula lessons and experiences.

12 hour shifts in a sweatshop for two bowls of rice and a hard floor to sleep on, no.
Dec 1, 2017 12:26 PM CST Should Children Work?
there are children around the world enslaved, working for Ivanka Trump

while she's getting richer by doing nothing in Americacool
Dec 1, 2017 12:31 PM CST Should Children Work?
jac_the_gripper
jac_the_gripperjac_the_gripper..., South Glamorgan, Wales UK15 Threads 3,719 Posts
My granddaughter's second home is the shop where my daughter works. All the staff are her parents.

She's beside herself with glee if she gets to help out. She's 6 years old.

She assumes a similar position in the local mini-market and the staff are happy to oblige. She likes to collect empty boxes off the shelves there.

We live in an inclusive community. It's healthy for children to be allowed to learn and help out in a fun way.

It's fun for people doing repetitive jobs, too.

Enrichment is no bad thing.
Dec 1, 2017 12:34 PM CST Should Children Work?
lifeisadream
lifeisadreamlifeisadreamMexi Go, Mexico Mexico184 Threads 24 Polls 22,575 Posts
chris27292729: There is nothing wrong with studying and working.
Am one of them working 8 hours during the day and studying and
going to evening school after work.-

Lots of people do it.
marlindap: instead of a lecture maybe the lady could have told the boy what a wonderful job he was doing shinning those shoes. Then the father and the son would both be proud of what they were doing. When the father first had the idea, he probably never saw anything wrong with it, nor the son. He was probably happy to think he was helping his dad, how sad the father had to question his own judgement because of one persons opinion.
nonsmoker: Indeed, It makes for a health of society.

Any job being legal should make people proud of proving for themselves.

Answering the OP question; Should children work?
my answer would be no as an intensive exploiting labor but in the circumstances described it is not only ok but good for the family.
Dec 1, 2017 12:41 PM CST Should Children Work?
lifeisadream
lifeisadreamlifeisadreamMexi Go, Mexico Mexico184 Threads 24 Polls 22,575 Posts
Len05: yes making children productive will make adults have benefits from children and more children will be born.

I'm now talking about a modern society and not the stone age countries referred by OP


You brought a very importan point there, some parents do benefit from the work of their children they do exploit their own children, that is not the case in the scenario presented for this thread.

stemik62: If the child had no classes, then yes it is ok. The child is with his father and what better place could this child be? Family is so important in raising children.


Exactly!
Dec 1, 2017 12:42 PM CST Should Children Work?
in Asia, Africa, Central and South America children bein forced to work

for people like Ivanka Trump. then she puts her name on those products

and sells them by the thousands. this is no secret.cool Is why I know it

cos is out therebeer
Dec 1, 2017 12:44 PM CST Should Children Work?
lifeisadream
lifeisadreamlifeisadreamMexi Go, Mexico Mexico184 Threads 24 Polls 22,575 Posts
Duromojon: there are children around the world enslaved, working for Ivanka Trump

while she's getting richer by doing nothing in America


Ivanka is not the only one and you are obsessed with Mr. Trump and his family to the point of boredom.

Mr. Trump is your president whether you like or not and if you really want to criticize his job get informed and well informed and believe me, you will find pretty good reasons for it.


laugh
Dec 1, 2017 12:48 PM CST Should Children Work?
lifeisadream
lifeisadreamlifeisadreamMexi Go, Mexico Mexico184 Threads 24 Polls 22,575 Posts
ChesneyChrist: Personally I liked the jobs I got myself as a boy, I was cleaning wheelie bins when I was 8. But I didn't enjoy all those summer weeks working in mum's sandwich shop or every weekend passing tools to my dad all year round.

it should be more common than not that children enjoy their parents company even if the children have to help them.

As a child and even as a teenager I do remember helping my father doing some mechanical tasks when he was fixing/cleaning his cab (taxi) in fact I would have liked learning more from him while I was not very fond of cooking as a child grin which was done by my mother.
Dec 1, 2017 12:48 PM CST Should Children Work?
lifeisadream: Ivanka is not the only one and you are obsessed with Mr. Trump and his family to the point of boredom.

Mr. Trump is your president whether you like or not and if you really want to criticize his job get informed and well informed and believe me, you will find pretty good reasons for it.
always


always call Trump, president. the problem is exactly that he's the presidentlaugh

and his Ivanka abusing children around the world. is a factthumbs up
Dec 1, 2017 12:49 PM CST Should Children Work?
lifeisadream
lifeisadreamlifeisadreamMexi Go, Mexico Mexico184 Threads 24 Polls 22,575 Posts
jac_the_gripper: My daughter had her own paper round business by the time she was 12.

I did it with her, so it was a safe learning experience.

She paid for her bedroom decoration and furniture, 2 school ski trips, a school trip to Disneyland Paris and more.

I had the child benefit (which all parents get in the UK) paid into her account and she budgeted that for swimming, martial arts, horse riding, skiing and ballet lessons/equipment.

It's educational for children to work, earn and budget. It's educational (and fun) for children to save up for extra-curricula lessons and experiences.

12 hour shifts in a sweatshop for two bowls of rice and a hard floor to sleep on, no.
Exactly!
Dec 1, 2017 11:16 PM CST Should Children Work?
When I was 4 I'd go door to door with my "artwork" and sell it.

I don't remember a time when I didn't work as a child.

I used to work all day for some change, and pop bottles.

The money I earned would always get borrowed by my stepdad, and I'd never get it back.

When I asked for it, he'd say, "You ate didn't you?"

We always had Chivas Regal, Coors, Camels, and good wine in our house; and I was always hungry.

I only went to school, so that I could steal the other children's lunches.

I learned that if you work hard, and save all your money...

Somebody else will spend it, while you starve.
Dec 4, 2017 8:50 AM CST Should Children Work?
stemik62
stemik62stemik62Denver, Colorado USA6 Posts
jac_the_gripper: My daughter had her own paper round business by the time she was 12.

I did it with her, so it was a safe learning experience.

She paid for her bedroom decoration and furniture, 2 school ski trips, a school trip to Disneyland Paris and more.

I had the child benefit (which all parents get in the UK) paid into her account and she budgeted that for swimming, martial arts, horse riding, skiing and ballet lessons/equipment.

It's educational for children to work, earn and budget. It's educational (and fun) for children to save up for extra-curricula lessons and experiences.

12 hour shifts in a sweatshop for two bowls of rice and a hard floor to sleep on, no.



Thanks for reminding me about my childhood. When I was 14 years in 1978, I had 3 paper routes, cut grass and shoveled snow. I had over $3000 in the bank by the time I was 16. And I had bought all my own record albums (over 300) and books and WW2 model airplanes.
Dec 4, 2017 8:59 AM CST Should Children Work?
lifeisadream
lifeisadreamlifeisadreamMexi Go, Mexico Mexico184 Threads 24 Polls 22,575 Posts
mykingdomforanam: When I was 4 I'd go door to door with my "artwork" and sell it.

I don't remember a time when I didn't work as a child.

I used to work all day for some change, and pop bottles.

The money I earned would always get borrowed by my stepdad, and I'd never get it back.

When I asked for it, he'd say, "You ate didn't you?"

We always had Chivas Regal, Coors, Camels, and good wine in our house; and I was always hungry.

I only went to school, so that I could steal the other children's lunches.

I learned that if you work hard, and save all your money...

Somebody else will spend it, while you starve.


Unfortunately some parents should not be parents, the good thing is to learn from the past and not to do the same or worse.

My father never drank (except for a time or two as a teenager) and he knew at an early age that not drinking would made a difference in his life. Although, he would have some liquor at our home for visits and one of my brother would take some but my father had measured the line of the liquor in the bottle and he would lecture my brother because he knew it was my brother, later my brother would take some liquor and then pour some water so the level was the same laugh
Dec 4, 2017 2:30 PM CST Should Children Work?
Cachuchi
CachuchiCachuchiunknown, Navarra Spain15 Threads 2 Polls 1,123 Posts
Yes, important values and responsabilities can be learned from part time early jobs. Make our kids do chores and do not let them think they're absolved of not only the work, but of learning that work has to be done and that each one of us must contribute for the betterment of the whole....family, society, world handshake
Dec 4, 2017 2:44 PM CST Should Children Work?
I think it's good for children to learn responsibility early on whether it's chores or a little job as long as it isn't something that's forced on them.

Stats for this Poll

43 Votes
1,374 Views
30 Comments
by lifeisadream (24 Polls)
Created: Nov 30, 2017
Last Viewed: 9 hrs ago
Last Commented: Dec 4
Last Voted: Apr 1

Share this Poll

Post Comment Vote on this Poll back to top
pedro27: "24--4--7"(meet us in the forums)