should ghurkhas be allowed to live in the united kingdom after leaving the british army ? ( Archived) (14)

Apr 24, 2009 7:55 AM CST should ghurkhas be allowed to live in the united kingdom after leaving the british army ?
gillyloves69
gillyloves69gillyloves69london, Greater London, England UK1,533 Threads 7 Polls 7,359 Posts
Gurkhas have lost a bid to overturn a ruling that stopped them automatically settling in the UK after leaving the Army. Skip related content

RELATED PHOTOS / VIDEOS
Government accused of betraying Gurkhas
Play video
RELATED CONTENT
Gurkhas refused full settlement rights
Video: Government accused of betraying Gurkhas
New settlement rules disappoint Gurkhas
Related Hot Topic: Immigration & Asylum
Have your say: Immigration & Asylum
Those who left the Army before 1997 were not given the right to automatically settle in the UK after four years' service.

Last year, a High Court judge ruled that the policy excluding older veterans was unlawful and in need of urgent review.

Instead of overturning the ruling, the Government has now decided to allow those soldiers who retired prior to July 1997 the automatic right to live in the UK - but only if special circumstances apply, such as they were injured or were awarded a medal for bravery.

Actress Joanna Lumley, who has backed the campaign, said: "The Gurkhas cannot meet these new criteria. "It makes me ashamed of our government. We will fight on. We don't stop. This has been a setback but that is all."

There are currently around 3,500 serving Gurkhas. More than 200,000 fought during the First and Second World Wars, with 43,000 giving their lives.

Ragprasad Purja, 43, served with the Gurkhas for 17 years. He said: "It is the saddest day for the Gurkhas and the saddest day for the British Government.

"I cannot believe that this Government made such a decision. I was proud of my service but now I am very sad."

David Enright, of Howe and Co solicitors, said: "They have set criteria that are unattainable.

"It's a sham and an absolute disgrace. It's far more restrictive than the old policy."

Prime Minister Gordon Brown said: "Anybody who has done 20 years service before 1997 is going to benefit from this decision. They can make the choice if they want to come to Britain.

"Anybody that has suffered injuries or who has got rewards for gallantry can also come to Britain."

Immigration Minister Phil Woolas said the changes will benefit around 4,300 more ex-Gurkhas out of a total of 36,000, who retired before 1997.

He said: "This guidance honours the service, commitment and gallantry of those who served with the Gurkhas brigade.

"Where there are strong reasons, there has been scope for Gurkhas who retired prior to July 1997 to apply to settle in the UK.

"In fact, because of rules brought in by the Government, we have already welcomed around 6,000 Gurkhas and family members to Britain.

"We will work with the Ministry of Defence to actively inform those who might be eligible in Nepal of these changes."

The Gurkha brigade was formed following the partition of India in 1947 but Nepalese Gurkha soldiers have been part of the British Army for almost 200 years.
------ This thread is Archived ------
Apr 24, 2009 7:58 AM CST should ghurkhas be allowed to live in the united kingdom after leaving the british army ?
roseofsharon
roseofsharonroseofsharonmanchester, Hampshire, England UK60 Threads 3 Polls 8,699 Posts
At long last..... a sensible question worth posing AND worth posting to!! thumbs up

In response..... a resounding, definite YES!!!!!!
------ This thread is Archived ------
Apr 24, 2009 11:26 AM CST should ghurkhas be allowed to live in the united kingdom after leaving the british army ?
passion8
passion8passion8Shropshire, England UK3 Threads 158 Posts
Most definitely YES. They have more of a right to be here than many other people.
------ This thread is Archived ------
Apr 24, 2009 11:29 AM CST should ghurkhas be allowed to live in the united kingdom after leaving the british army ?
zee1ander
zee1anderzee1anderSomewhere, Kentucky USA52 Threads 4 Polls 1,758 Posts
Oh heck yes..... and while you're at it you might invite the Taliban too .... and maybe even some Americans.

zee
------ This thread is Archived ------
Apr 24, 2009 11:35 AM CST should ghurkhas be allowed to live in the united kingdom after leaving the british army ?
celtictony
celtictonyceltictonyIreland, Kerry Ireland8 Posts
Respect to the Gurkhas
------ This thread is Archived ------
Apr 24, 2009 11:38 AM CST should ghurkhas be allowed to live in the united kingdom after leaving the british army ?
Tbilisigal
TbilisigalTbilisigalTbilisi, Georgia4 Threads 83 Posts
zee1ander: I think we are talking apples and oranges here. They are free to do as they please as long as it is within the confines of the law as is with every other US Citizen.

zee

Do not discriminate in the name of race and color . Whitemen has lost the control of the world long back .Now its countries like India and China are going to rule the world. lets be humanbeing for a change
------ This thread is Archived ------
Apr 24, 2009 11:42 AM CST should ghurkhas be allowed to live in the united kingdom after leaving the british army ?
celtictony
celtictonyceltictonyIreland, Kerry Ireland8 Posts
I wasn't around then. nor were these welfare mungers,there are fiddling todays system it will not help or change the past.
Yes the Brits have nothing to be proud of, the Romans did did the same to us, but you don't see hoards of us claiming free hand outs in Italy.
------ This thread is Archived ------
Apr 24, 2009 11:53 AM CST should ghurkhas be allowed to live in the united kingdom after leaving the british army ?
canairforcetech
canairforcetechcanairforcetechTrenton, Ontario Canada4 Threads 130 Posts
I can't speak as a citizen of the UK but as a Canadian citizen, I wouldn't mind seeing Gurkha retirees from the British Army settle here. We have some former Paras (among others)not only living here but serving in our Armed Forces. IMO, anyway.
------ This thread is Archived ------
Apr 24, 2009 11:54 AM CST should ghurkhas be allowed to live in the united kingdom after leaving the british army ?
Tbilisigal
TbilisigalTbilisigalTbilisi, Georgia4 Threads 83 Posts
celtictony: I wasn't around then. nor were these welfare mungers,there are fiddling todays system it will not help or change the past.
Yes the Brits have nothing to be proud of, the Romans did did the same to us, but you don't see hoards of us claiming free hand outs in Italy.


This is intolerence . let there not be any asians ,blacks and whites .let there be only human being then your problem will be solved . the earth belongs to all . not only fot the whites to exploit
------ This thread is Archived ------
Apr 24, 2009 12:05 PM CST should ghurkhas be allowed to live in the united kingdom after leaving the british army ?
celtictony
celtictonyceltictonyIreland, Kerry Ireland8 Posts
Tb, I really do not have a problem with Asias, blacks or any other culture, I have lots of friends from all over the world.
What I do have a problem with, is spongers and I can't change the fact that the biggists spongers in the uk, are mainley Pakistans, Bangladishi, Indian, etc, my god I wish it wasn't true.
------ This thread is Archived ------
Apr 24, 2009 1:18 PM CST should ghurkhas be allowed to live in the united kingdom after leaving the british army ?
bollywood
bollywoodbollywoodTRIVANDRUM, Kerala India53 Threads 2 Polls 973 Posts
celtictony: Tb, I really do not have a problem with Asias, blacks or any other culture, I have lots of friends from all over the world.
What I do have a problem with, is spongers and I can't change the fact that the biggists spongers in the uk, are mainley Pakistans, Bangladishi, Indian, etc, my god I wish it wasn't true.


laugh Sir Your forefathers had lavishly sponged our countries and divided into three creating eternal conflictis . I am sure the defence expenditure we incurr because of this division is much more thant the sponging ..so let them .Please accomodate them sir.hug
------ This thread is Archived ------
Apr 24, 2009 1:59 PM CST should ghurkhas be allowed to live in the united kingdom after leaving the british army ?
rusty_knight
rusty_knightrusty_knightGozo, Malta175 Threads 2 Polls 6,840 Posts
Tbilisigal: This is intolerence . let there not be any asians ,blacks and whites .let there be only human being then your problem will be solved . the earth belongs to all . not only fot the whites to exploit


Tbilisigal - you have a 'strong' profile...... I have a good friend from Georgia who now works in Abu Dhabi....... I think you Georgians are very interesting people and I think Prime Minister Putin of Russia would probably have to agree!

Hmmmm......... re. the blacks in the USA - should the Russians allow YOU the freedom you want or should they be allowed to invade Georgia whenever they feel like it and without any real protest from the EU?

dunno
------ This thread is Archived ------
Apr 24, 2009 2:05 PM CST should ghurkhas be allowed to live in the united kingdom after leaving the british army ?
rusty_knight
rusty_knightrusty_knightGozo, Malta175 Threads 2 Polls 6,840 Posts
celtictony: Tb, I really do not have a problem with Asias, blacks or any other culture, I have lots of friends from all over the world.
What I do have a problem with, is spongers and I can't change the fact that the biggists spongers in the uk, are mainley Pakistans, Bangladishi, Indian, etc, my god I wish it wasn't true.


Strange that - all the Pakistanis, Bangladeshis, Indians and Sri Lankans that I have met are far harder working than the indiginous population............ and where have you got your impression from and do you have any facts to support your allegations?

Asians have a far stronger family culture than many native brits and they have high aspirations - hence the many Asian doctors and lawyers we now have in the UK.......... beibng so family orientated has both advantages and disadvantages, but the culture of most British and American people is far more based on the individual and generally-speaking far more selfish.

I have a home in Swansea, South Wales, UK - without doubt the biggest spongers there are the natives........ often illegitimate and living off the state from cradle to grave - being served their tax-payers paid Indian and Chinese take-aways by......... Asians!

(I know because I worked for a Bangladeshi take-away in a poor council estate)
------ This thread is Archived ------
Apr 25, 2009 8:21 AM CST should ghurkhas be allowed to live in the united kingdom after leaving the british army ?
Tbilisigal
TbilisigalTbilisigalTbilisi, Georgia4 Threads 83 Posts
rusty_knight: Tbilisigal - you have a 'strong' profile...... I have a good friend from Georgia who now works in Abu Dhabi....... I think you Georgians are very interesting people and I think Prime Minister Putin of Russia would probably have to agree!

Hmmmm......... re. the blacks in the USA - should the Russians allow YOU the freedom you want or should they be allowed to invade Georgia whenever they feel like it and without any real protest from the EU?


I am not strong as my profile looks rolling on the floor laughing .I am just a normal woman . I guess you find interesting people everywhere .not only in Georgia .

Lets sticks to our own issues then nobody is going to invade you ( except the US ) .Russians are failry good people . they acted against some of the Georgian acts . Now we are good neibhours ..pleace for all . I dont want a southeast Asia happening here .and I hope for peace .
------ This thread is Archived ------
Post Comment - Post a comment on this Forum Thread

This Thread is Archived

This Thread is archived, so you will no longer be able to post to it. Threads get archived automatically when they are older than 3 months.

« Go back to All Threads
Message #318

Stats for this Thread

747 Views
13 Comments
by gillyloves69 (1,533 Threads)
Created: Apr 2009
Last Viewed: Apr 24
Last Commented: Apr 2009

Share this Thread

We use cookies to ensure that you have the best experience possible on our website. Read Our Privacy Policy Here