brian johnson v bon scott (11)
robpaccianiGalway, Ireland211 Threads 3 Polls 5,134 Postsok folks, so tell me who do you think has/had the better voice. for those who dont know them bon scott was the old ACDC singer, brian johnson is the present.. in there prime who was a better singer.. i would have to say bon scott, it was effortless and amazing... id love to hear him sing thunderstruck, im gutted i never got to see him!! 
robpacciani: ok folks, so tell me who do you think has/had the better voice. for those who dont know them bon scott was the old ACDC singer, brian johnson is the present.. in there prime who was a better singer.. i would have to say bon scott, it was effortless and amazing... id love to hear him sing thunderstruck, im gutted i never got to see him!!
They are both good singers and don't take anything away from Brian asx he was the only person who could take over from Bon and do him justice. In fact there are a few Bon songs that Brian will never do live as he feels he can't do them justice.thedoode: They are both good singers and don't take anything away from Brian asx he was the only person who could take over from Bon and do him justice. In fact there are a few Bon songs that Brian will never do live as he feels he can't do them justice.
yeah that is true.. dont get me wrong, i love brian too, he is also unique, but i feel bon scott had a better voice and that is saying something as brian is absolutely gifted... but angus young, what a guitarist
robpacciani: ok folks, so tell me who do you think has/had the better voice. for those who dont know them bon scott was the old ACDC singer, brian johnson is the present.. in there prime who was a better singer.. i would have to say bon scott, it was effortless and amazing... id love to hear him sing thunderstruck, im gutted i never got to see him!!
Afraid I'm biased here.Years ago I used to be a bit of a fan of a Newcastle band called Geordie with Brian Johnson and his brother Vic but I can understand why you'd prefer Bon Scott. I have the same debate between Peter Gabriel and Phil Collins ex Genesis.
Godsgift: Afraid I'm biased here.Years ago I used to be a bit of a fan of a Newcastle band called Geordie with Brian Johnson and his brother Vic but I can understand why you'd prefer Bon Scott. I have the same debate between Peter Gabriel and Phil Collins ex Genesis.
i would have to side with phil collins on that one, but lots would disagree with me
robpacciani: yeah that is true.. dont get me wrong, i love brian too, he is also unique, but i feel bon scott had a better voice and that is saying something as brian is absolutely gifted... but angus young, what a guitarist
I saw the live earlier this year and what a show. Angus rocked as usual and Brian was an amazing frontman.Ah, we'll agree to differ.At least ACDC maintained their integrity where Genesis changed from a mega band (they were up there with Pink Floyd and had a 21st century stage show back in the 70s)...but as I say, they changed to a backing band for Phil Collins.
Godsgift: Ah, we'll agree to differ.At least ACDC maintained their integrity where Genesis changed from a mega band (they were up there with Pink Floyd and had a 21st century stage show back in the 70s)...but as I say, they changed to a backing band for Phil Collins.
im also a big fan of bruce springsteen.. would you like his music?
robpacciani: im also a big fan of bruce springsteen.. would you like his music?
I certainly do particularly his older stuff. I saw him in Leeds in 1984. Born in The USA tour. That's when he really became popular. Before that he had a cult following.
Godsgift: I certainly do particularly his older stuff. I saw him in Leeds in 1984. Born in The USA tour. That's when he really became popular. Before that he had a cult following.
WELL I ONLY GOT INTO HIS MUSIC 2 YEARS AGO... I HAVE GONE TO HIS CONCERTS THE PAST 2 YEARS, ABSOLUTELY BRILLIANT.. although i was disappointed that he never played "the river" or "born in the usa"
robpacciani: WELL I ONLY GOT INTO HIS MUSIC 2 YEARS AGO... I HAVE GONE TO HIS CONCERTS THE PAST 2 YEARS, ABSOLUTELY BRILLIANT.. although i was disappointed that he never played "the river" or "born in the usa"
Ah, you're a traditionalist, wise before your time. Here's the Boss at his best!
More Threads
Been a Long Time
How To Secure Your Gate
Isis
Blast From The Past
When you look inside your heart ? what do you truly want..
the death nail for dating websites
New here. Single Guy from Grand Rapids, MI.
What does it mean to be a man or a woman?
a question
Thinking out loud #3
More Threads
Report threads that break rules, are offensive, or contain fighting. Staff may not be aware of the forum abuse, and cannot do anything about it unless you tell us about it. click to report forum abuse »
If one of the comments is offensive, please report the comment instead (there is a link in each comment to report it).
If one of the comments is offensive, please report the comment instead (there is a link in each comment to report it).
Stats for this Thread
328 Views
10 Comments
Created: Dec 2009
Last Viewed: May 20
Last Commented: Dec 2009
0 Likes