Lobby Groups.... Is it Just Corruption ( Archived) (31)

Dec 1, 2012 9:47 AM CST Lobby Groups.... Is it Just Corruption
Nikogas
NikogasNikogasMetro, Oregon USA46 Threads 5 Polls 4,037 Posts
bagmanj: Question..... I was wondering how we can have a fair political system around the world if parties that are elected by the people only work for companies that provide money to back the party... would it be best to have political parties backed by tax payers money so they work for the people or is it okay for large donations from tobacco mining companies to back politics so the policies assist with these companies agenda? Isn't this just corruption?


in regards to this country I can say that if you have Lobbyists than you can get your way, or be heard at least. The more Lobbyists than you are ahead. I call it corruption and it is not fair in my life experience.
It does not have to be done this way but it is. Politics is about Power, Money and the Facades that are created for the majorities to accept.
------ This thread is Archived ------
Dec 1, 2012 9:47 AM CST Lobby Groups.... Is it Just Corruption
bagmanj
bagmanjbagmanjcanberra, ACT Australia4 Threads 22 Posts
Well commented rumple4skin and yes I agree with the train, and a nanny state isn't what I wanted. I was making the comment to outline that they would ban smoking if it wasn't for the lobby groups and their money. My very good friend and I debated, he believes that all drugs should be legal because it is up to a person to control his/her freedom, my argument is do you want people to be walking on the street high on ICE, some drugs are psychotic and have a need to be controlled. You seem like a very smart person and I am sure you would make the right choice in regards to your own self and self-preservation, unfortunate many others do not have the "common sense" that we may have and they need to be protected for them selfs. Just look at the turkeys on a Saturday night in your own and everybody's town, are you not glad that they can not drive totally wasted after drinking all night or is that being a nanny state. I think drink driving rules protect them and me and isn't that what we support a government for... to protect you and me not line a minister / senators or a party's pockets with corporate dollars
------ This thread is Archived ------
Dec 1, 2012 9:58 AM CST Lobby Groups.... Is it Just Corruption
Rumple4skin
Rumple4skinRumple4skinStoke-on-Trent, Staffordshire, England UK4 Threads 1 Polls 980 Posts
bagmanj: Well commented rumple4skin and yes I agree with the train, and a nanny state isn't what I wanted. I was making the comment to outline that they would ban smoking if it wasn't for the lobby groups and their money. My very good friend and I debated, he believes that all drugs should be legal because it is up to a person to control his/her freedom, my argument is do you want people to be walking on the street high on ICE, some drugs are psychotic and have a need to be controlled. You seem like a very smart person and I am sure you would make the right choice in regards to your own self and self-preservation, unfortunate many others do not have the "common sense" that we may have and they need to be protected for them selfs. Just look at the turkeys on a Saturday night in your own and everybody's town, are you not glad that they can not drive totally wasted after drinking all night or is that being a nanny state. I think drink driving rules protect them and me and isn't that what we support a government for... to protect you and me not line a minister / senators or a party's pockets with corporate dollars


Don't worry, I can tell the difference between a cigarette and heroin. Drugs and drink driving come at a significant social cost so here I believe the public has an authority/duty/right to curb the behaviour of the individual in the interest of the common good.

But if we were to ban smoking then we could call for a ban on unhealthy food, you could also argue to regulate all physical activity that is not strictly essential as some of these activities could lead to personal injury.
------ This thread is Archived ------
Dec 1, 2012 10:04 AM CST Lobby Groups.... Is it Just Corruption
TTom50
TTom50TTom50Orlando, Florida USA21 Threads 10 Polls 1,301 Posts
Were do you think a government...any government.....gets the food for a food stamp program? Or the medicines for a AIDs program? Or the fuel to run the vehicles in it military? Companies and Corporations right?

Were does the government get the communication services....computers, cell phones, wireless service....to run a government agency? Companies and corporations, right?

Were do a government get billions in corporation taxes to run a government? Companies and Corporations, right?

So the associations of these companies and corporation should not have loybbist in the government? To aid in drafting the rules and reg that they have to live under? To solve the technical issues that arise? To bring about new innovation that the government can benefit from?

The view is that the lobbyist is buying favoritism every time he/she meets with a elected official. But the truth is, very few of the lobbyist are caught with corrupt practices......how often do you see a a scandal with them being aired in the media? Because daily there are 1000s of lobbyist and government contacts being made.

Your modern day government and the company/corporation are linked at the hip.....like it or not. They need other to function......
------ This thread is Archived ------
Dec 1, 2012 10:07 AM CST Lobby Groups.... Is it Just Corruption
Nikogas: in regards to this country I can say that if you have Lobbyists than you can get your way, or be heard at least. The more Lobbyists than you are ahead. I call it corruption and it is not fair in my life experience.
It does not have to be done this way but it is. Politics is about Power, Money and the Facades that are created for the majorities to accept.


Thee are some strong lobbying groups in America - PETA, AARP

and there are also groups that lobby for clean air, environmental protection, proecting endangered species, quality of life for our elderly, homeless, disabled..... the list goes on - and then of course you have the industrial lobbyists for BIG business.

What's a politician to do? what's a politician to do? which way to turn?
------ This thread is Archived ------
Dec 1, 2012 10:14 AM CST Lobby Groups.... Is it Just Corruption
Rumple4skin
Rumple4skinRumple4skinStoke-on-Trent, Staffordshire, England UK4 Threads 1 Polls 980 Posts
TTom50: Were do you think a government...any government.....gets the food for a food stamp program? Or the medicines for a AIDs program? Or the fuel to run the vehicles in it military? Companies and Corporations right?

Were does the government get the communication services....computers, cell phones, wireless service....to run a government agency? Companies and corporations, right?

Were do a government get billions in corporation taxes to run a government? Companies and Corporations, right?

So the associations of these companies and corporation should not have loybbist in the government? To aid in drafting the rules and reg that they have to live under? To solve the technical issues that arise? To bring about new innovation that the government can benefit from?

The view is that the lobbyist is buying favoritism every time he/she meets with a elected official. But the truth is, very few of the lobbyist are caught with corrupt practices......how often do you see a a scandal with them being aired in the media? Because daily there are 1000s of lobbyist and government contacts being made.

Your modern day government and the company/corporation are linked at the hip.....like it or not. They need other to function......


We need a separate house to represent the economic powers which would also include Academics, technocrats and Unions.

I believe modern society needs a functional/meritocratic representative as well as a populist/Democratic one. The former is the role our house of Lords in Britain was originally established for before politics descended into pure populist corruption.
------ This thread is Archived ------
Dec 1, 2012 7:58 PM CST Lobby Groups.... Is it Just Corruption
TTom50
TTom50TTom50Orlando, Florida USA21 Threads 10 Polls 1,301 Posts
Rumple4skin: We need a separate house to represent the economic powers which would also include Academics, technocrats and Unions.

I believe modern society needs a functional/meritocratic representative as well as a populist/Democratic one. The former is the role our house of Lords in Britain was originally established for before politics descended into pure populist corruption.
Rumple4skin: We need a separate house to represent the economic powers which would also include Academics, technocrats and Unions.

I believe modern society needs a functional/meritocratic representative as well as a populist/Democratic one. The former is the role our house of Lords in Britain was originally established for before politics descended into pure populist corruption.


I really only one things to say.....1776
------ This thread is Archived ------
Dec 1, 2012 8:47 PM CST Lobby Groups.... Is it Just Corruption
Nikogas
NikogasNikogasMetro, Oregon USA46 Threads 5 Polls 4,037 Posts
JeanKimberley: Thee are some strong lobbying groups in America - PETA, AARP

and there are also groups that lobby for clean air, environmental protection, proecting endangered species, quality of life for our elderly, homeless, disabled..... the list goes on - and then of course you have the industrial lobbyists for BIG business.

What's a politician to do? what's a politician to do? which way to turn?

yes and many more too, for groups that can't afford a lobbyist or understand what the advantage is of having that extra voice for their cause or occupation it is to me just a unfair advantage. Like in my occupation many years ago there was one Lobbyist working but now this is not the case, and so there is no one that speaks up for the Hairstylists and Barbers. So to most people that means little or nothing, but to those that have dedicated their lives to that profession ( and this does apply to other groups as well ) but to those groups that don't have that edge they just have to deal with what they get. SO for instance if you are a teacher or your job is involved with education that is a whole different story. Lobbyists for Education are many, in this state of Oregon there are so many sources that have been created to get money to keep people that are in the business of education healthy, stable and with plenty of food on their plate and much much more. Does your group need more money? Well, those lobbyist can make sure that the people that make those big decisions and where the money is allocated is in your favor. That is just part of the way it is today. So it always goes back to money and power. If your group is not united and have the money to play this game then they may very well just stay at the bottom and that is if they don't just disappear.
------ This thread is Archived ------
Dec 1, 2012 9:39 PM CST Lobby Groups.... Is it Just Corruption
raphael111
raphael111raphael111washington d.c., Virginia USA3 Threads 173 Posts
Since the 1970s, lobbying activity has grown immensely in terms of the numbers of lobbyists and the size of lobbying budgets, and has become the focus of much criticism of American governance.

Corruption in American politics today= lobbying in Washington, concentration of over half the wealth of this country in the hands of a tiny group of people, and currently the ludicrous Grover Norville.
------ This thread is Archived ------
Dec 1, 2012 9:41 PM CST Lobby Groups.... Is it Just Corruption
raphael111
raphael111raphael111washington d.c., Virginia USA3 Threads 173 Posts
oooops- credit the first paragraph to Wikipedia article please!
------ This thread is Archived ------
Dec 1, 2012 11:33 PM CST Lobby Groups.... Is it Just Corruption
gininitaly
gininitalygininitalyPadova, Veneto Italy23 Threads 2,454 Posts
------ This thread is Archived ------
Post Comment - Post a comment on this Forum Thread

This Thread is Archived

This Thread is archived, so you will no longer be able to post to it. Threads get archived automatically when they are older than 3 months.

« Go back to All Threads
Message #318

Share this Thread

We use cookies to ensure that you have the best experience possible on our website. Read Our Privacy Policy Here