Rights and privileges ( Archived) (6)

Aug 10, 2011 5:26 PM CSTRights and privileges
Iuchi_Zien
Iuchi_ZienIuchi_ZienSheffield, South Yorkshire, England, UK21 Threads 9 Polls 1,426 Posts

Rights and privileges(Vote Below)

- (To Vote: select an option above, then press this button)
1# Not enough space, see below
7
58%
2# Not enough space, see below
1
8%
3# Not enough space, see below
2
17%
4# Not enough space, see below
2
17%
Total Votes
12
1#. Human rights and privileges are too important to be given up to make the world a safer and better place.

2#. Making the world a better and safer place should not impact upon human rights and/or privileges.

#3. I would be prepared to have some of my rights and privileges curtailed, IF it made the world a better and safer place.

#4. Other feel free to explain.


It is reckoned that 20% of the worlds population are consuming 60% of the worlds services and resources. We even enshrine consumerism in our human rights -:
Human Rights Protocol 1 (EU/UK):
Every natural or legal person is entitled to the peaceful enjoyment of his possessions.
No one shall be deprived of his possessions except in the public interest and subject to the conditions provided for by law and by the general principles of international law.


Can we ever have a fair and equal society when we refuse to allow the 80% a share of the 60% we consume? With China, India and Brazil's population looking towards first world style consumerism, what is going to give? Because there simply are not enough resources to go round are there?

Article 12: Marriage and the family(uk/EU):
Men and women of marriageable age shall have the right to marry and to found a family, according to national laws governing the exercise of this right.


Would we/Should we remove the right based upon economic position? or?

So based upon the twenty or so Human rights Articles, or UN Human rights, how many would you be prepared to give up for a safer, better world?
------ This thread is Archived ------
Aug 10, 2011 6:56 PM CST Rights and privileges
hairymonkey
hairymonkeyhairymonkeyWoBurn, Massachusetts USA38 Threads 11 Polls 254 Posts
United Nations declarations are generally a bunch of empty and insincere posturing devised to make the powerful nations feel like they pretended to endorse all the right things, as an all-purpose excuse to go on acting with total disregard for the rest of the world.
They can all stand up and applaud these profound declarations, and pat each other on the backs. Meanwhile nothing changes, nothing is done about anything, and the existence of the United Nations has not brought about a peaceful world.
In other words, it's all a big political sham. And the fact that it is based in the United States should not be viewed as insignificant.
------ This poll is Archived ------
Aug 10, 2011 7:57 PM CST Rights and privileges
joyaepace
joyaepacejoyaepaceGalway, Ireland11 Threads 2 Polls 958 Posts
hairymonkey: United Nations declarations are generally a bunch of empty and insincere posturing devised to make the powerful nations feel like they pretended to endorse all the right things, as an all-purpose excuse to go on acting with total disregard for the rest of the world.
They can all stand up and applaud these profound declarations, and pat each other on the backs. Meanwhile nothing changes, nothing is done about anything, and the existence of the United Nations has not brought about a peaceful world.
In other words, it's all a big political sham. And the fact that it is based in the United States should not be viewed as insignificant.


UN has not brought about a peaceful world, and I don't think it is possible. But it is hard to know what the world would be without UN, may be worse, may be not. Or a world without USA,lol?
------ This poll is Archived ------
Aug 10, 2011 8:01 PM CST Rights and privileges
joyaepace
joyaepacejoyaepaceGalway, Ireland11 Threads 2 Polls 958 Posts
Iuchi_Zien: 1#. Human rights and privileges are too important to be given up to make the world a safer and better place.

2#. Making the world a better and safer place should not impact upon human rights and/or privileges.

#3. I would be prepared to have some of my rights and privileges curtailed, IF it made the world a better and safer place.

#4. Other feel free to explain.It is reckoned that 20% of the worlds population are consuming 60% of the worlds services and resources. We even enshrine consumerism in our human rights -:Can we ever have a fair and equal society when we refuse to allow the 80% a share of the 60% we consume? With China, India and Brazil's population looking towards first world style consumerism, what is going to give? Because there simply are not enough resources to go round are there?
Would we/Should we remove the right based upon economic position? or?

So based upon the twenty or so Human rights Articles, or UN Human rights, how many would you be prepared to give up for a safer, better world?


Not easy to answer. May be property right will have to be removed when humanity will run out of resources? Or unconditional right for reproduction? Or the ship will go down proudly with all the rights?
------ This poll is Archived ------
Aug 11, 2011 6:35 AM CST Rights and privileges
Iuchi_Zien
Iuchi_ZienIuchi_ZienSheffield, South Yorkshire, England UK21 Threads 9 Polls 1,426 Posts
joyaepace: Not easy to answer. May be property right will have to be removed when humanity will run out of resources? Or unconditional right for reproduction? Or the ship will go down proudly with all the rights?


I was thinking about a conversation I had with an old Russian friend and he was talking about the 'good old days' of communism. I asked would he really want to go back to that time, no freedom of speach etc. His response was that he would rather sleep comfortably at night knowing he had a job and a future. The woreying thing was to some extent I agree.
------ This poll is Archived ------
Aug 11, 2011 8:45 PM CST Rights and privileges
joyaepace
joyaepacejoyaepaceGalway, Ireland11 Threads 2 Polls 958 Posts
I lived in that system. True, there was always job security, but for promotion one had to be a party member. Well, not that many gave it a thought, if you have, you have. Kind of boring obligation to attend meetings and listen nonsense, but OK. People had more time for themselves, family, culture and education. Nobody took seriously party leaders, jokes about them were a theme of conversations all the time. Wages were not high, but prices were low too, and there were little choice of goods. For us girls, it was a big grief, we wanted to look nice. There also was shortage of apartments and a bit crowded conditions of living. Not to be able to travel was bad, we wanted to see the world. And we sense that it is all lies, no communism or socialism, just privileges for some and safe, but bland life for others. Now, lived also in capitalism, what shall I say. That system is bankrupt, and this is probably going same way. dunno I have that same feeling I had in mid eighties. Hopelessness and sense that something must happen.
------ This poll is Archived ------
Aug 11, 2011 9:36 PM CST Rights and privileges
Iuchi_Zien
Iuchi_ZienIuchi_ZienSheffield, South Yorkshire, England UK21 Threads 9 Polls 1,426 Posts
hairymonkey: United Nations declarations are generally a bunch of empty and insincere posturing devised to make the powerful nations feel like they pretended to endorse all the right things, as an all-purpose excuse to go on acting with total disregard for the rest of the world.
They can all stand up and applaud these profound declarations, and pat each other on the backs. Meanwhile nothing changes, nothing is done about anything, and the existence of the United Nations has not brought about a peaceful world.
In other words, it's all a big political sham. And the fact that it is based in the United States should not be viewed as insignificant.


Here's the problem I see with your argument. Some time ago I was involved in a discussion about the greatest things the US has brought to the world, the general consensus was the Bill of human rights. I disagreed vehemently that it was worthless at no point, in history has the US ever followed the premise 'All men are created equal' the response was that it was something to strive towards, in what way is that different from the UN Charter of human rights? The UN while ever it has countries with the capability to veto is always going to be fighting one handed. All of this however is off topic the question is What rights would you be prepared to give up for job security, safety, for you and your children?

God I HATE this new keyboard!!!
------ This poll is Archived ------

This Poll is Archived

This Poll is archived, so you will no longer be able to post to it. Poll get archived automatically when they are older than 3 months.
Message #318

Stats for this Poll

12 Votes
1,109 Views
6 Comments
Created: Aug 2011
Last Viewed: Apr 21
Last Commented: Aug 2011
Last Voted: Jul 2017

Share this Poll

We use cookies to ensure that you have the best experience possible on our website. Read Our Privacy Policy Here