Dissent Irish Republicanism (253)

Nov 12, 2010 10:45 AM CST Dissent Irish Republicanism
Phoenix
PhoenixPhoenixSarkoville, Ile-de-France France110 Threads 32 Polls 2,591 Posts
Whats your take on it folk's....?
Nov 12, 2010 10:46 AM CST Dissent Irish Republicanism
baldydude
baldydudebaldydudefermoy, Cork Ireland164 Threads 4,643 Posts
Phoenix: Whats your take on it folk's....?
oh boy ..... wonder how long it'll take for this thread to either get locked or taken down conversing
Nov 12, 2010 10:48 AM CST Dissent Irish Republicanism
Phoenix
PhoenixPhoenixSarkoville, Ile-de-France France110 Threads 32 Polls 2,591 Posts
baldydude: oh boy ..... wonder how long it'll take for this thread to either get locked or taken down


Depends on how intelligent the post's are....
Nov 12, 2010 10:49 AM CST Dissent Irish Republicanism
Ross30
Ross30Ross30Dublin, Ireland2 Threads 635 Posts
Phoenix: Depends on how intelligent the post's are....


Are you referring to the CIRA and the RIRA?
Nov 12, 2010 10:50 AM CST Dissent Irish Republicanism
wittyone
wittyonewittyoneDerry, Ireland9 Threads 8,815 Posts
Phoenix: Whats your take on it folk's....?



thumbs down

The majority has spoken through their vote for peace, what the hell happened to democracy. thumbs down thumbs down

I won't be posting again under this. handshake
Nov 12, 2010 10:50 AM CST Dissent Irish Republicanism
rockthatbody
rockthatbodyrockthatbodyMaynooth, Kildare Ireland171 Posts
Phoenix: Whats your take on it folk's....?


I love itireland
It makes 1 proud to be a true Irish person when you have organisations like the RIRA who are willing to shoot people dead or blow them to smithereens for a united Ireland
Tiocfaidh ar la



The sound track is Blood of the Irish by Cuchulainn
Nov 12, 2010 10:51 AM CST Dissent Irish Republicanism
GalwayGuy35
GalwayGuy35GalwayGuy35galway, Galway Ireland25 Threads 1,537 Posts
Phoenix: Whats your take on it folk's....?

i think they need to move on with everyone else. they must know deep down that they wont get a united Ireland through voilence. it didnt work for the ra and it wont work for them.
Nov 12, 2010 10:51 AM CST Dissent Irish Republicanism
Ross30
Ross30Ross30Dublin, Ireland2 Threads 635 Posts
wittyone: The majority has spoken through their vote for peace, what the hell happened to democracy.

I won't be posting again under this.


Well said, as Martin McGuinness said in March 2009 "These people are traitors to the people of Ireland".
Nov 12, 2010 10:55 AM CST Dissent Irish Republicanism
Phoenix
PhoenixPhoenixSarkoville, Ile-de-France France110 Threads 32 Polls 2,591 Posts
Ross30: Well said, as Martin McGuinness said in March 2009 "These people are traitors to the people of Ireland".


I wont poke fun at you...But Martin..planned and killed..was on the Army Council...His opinion counts for nothing..So who is the traitor..
Nov 12, 2010 10:59 AM CST Dissent Irish Republicanism
Ross30
Ross30Ross30Dublin, Ireland2 Threads 635 Posts
Phoenix: I wont poke fun at you...But Martin..planned and killed..was on the Army Council...His opinion counts for nothing..So who is the traitor..


The PIRA army council led by Adams and McGuinnes recognised by the late 80's that armed struggle wasn't going to achieve a United Ireland hence the reason why after 1987 they pursued a gradual move towards a permanent ceasefire.

Do the CIRA and the RIRA actually believe its winnable?
Nov 12, 2010 10:59 AM CST Dissent Irish Republicanism
baldydude
baldydudebaldydudefermoy, Cork Ireland164 Threads 4,643 Posts
Phoenix: Depends on how intelligent the post's are....
well think you got an idea of the replies now nd why it wont take long for the mods to take over dunno personally i find it was a stupit question to post in the 1st place doh
Nov 12, 2010 11:00 AM CST Dissent Irish Republicanism
Phoenix
PhoenixPhoenixSarkoville, Ile-de-France France110 Threads 32 Polls 2,591 Posts
wittyone: The majority has spoken through their vote for peace, what the hell happened to democracy.

I won't be posting again under this.


Witty...

I like you grew up during the troubles...And if you look at the breakdown of the 'vote' for the 1998 GFA..you'll find that the majority of proestant people didn't vote or were against it (GFA)...

And if you add the totals of the vote together you'll find that the majority wanted an 32 county republic...
Nov 12, 2010 11:01 AM CST Dissent Irish Republicanism
Phoenix
PhoenixPhoenixSarkoville, Ile-de-France France110 Threads 32 Polls 2,591 Posts
Ross30: The PIRA army council led by Adams and McGuinnes recognised by the late 80's that armed struggle wasn't going to achieve a United Ireland hence the reason why after 1987 they pursued a gradual move towards a permanent ceasefire.

Do the CIRA and the RIRA actually believe its winnable?


The PIRA by the late 80's were infiltrated by MI5/6...and they SF were since the 1981 hunger strike on a polictal agenda not since 1987...
Nov 12, 2010 11:02 AM CST Dissent Irish Republicanism
Phoenix
PhoenixPhoenixSarkoville, Ile-de-France France110 Threads 32 Polls 2,591 Posts
GalwayGuy35: i think they need to move on with everyone else. they must know deep down that they wont get a united Ireland through voilence. it didnt work for the ra and it wont work for them.


Almost worked in 1916 and under Micky Collin's.....
Nov 12, 2010 11:03 AM CST Dissent Irish Republicanism
Ross30
Ross30Ross30Dublin, Ireland2 Threads 635 Posts
Phoenix: The PIRA by the late 80's were infiltrated by MI5/6...and they SF were since the 1981 hunger strike on a polictal agenda not since 1987...


Aren't the CIRA and the RIRA infiltrated by informers as well?
Nov 12, 2010 11:03 AM CST Dissent Irish Republicanism
Phoenix
PhoenixPhoenixSarkoville, Ile-de-France France110 Threads 32 Polls 2,591 Posts
rockthatbody: I love it
It makes 1 proud to be a true Irish person when you have organisations like the RIRA who are willing to shoot people dead or blow them to smithereens for a united Ireland
Tiocfaidh ar la



The sound track is Blood of the Irish by Cuchulainn


A good Ulster man
Nov 12, 2010 11:03 AM CST Dissent Irish Republicanism
rockthatbody
rockthatbodyrockthatbodyMaynooth, Kildare Ireland171 Posts
Phoenix: Almost worked in 1916 and under Micky Collin's.....


He was a sell out
Nov 12, 2010 11:05 AM CST Dissent Irish Republicanism
rockthatbody
rockthatbodyrockthatbodyMaynooth, Kildare Ireland171 Posts
Phoenix: A good Ulster man




Its blood of cuchulainn by boondock saints
got it wrong earlierireland
Nov 12, 2010 11:06 AM CST Dissent Irish Republicanism
Phoenix
PhoenixPhoenixSarkoville, Ile-de-France France110 Threads 32 Polls 2,591 Posts
rockthatbody: He was a sell out


Not going to argue with you....but 26 is better than 0...
Nov 12, 2010 11:07 AM CST Dissent Irish Republicanism
rockthatbody
rockthatbodyrockthatbodyMaynooth, Kildare Ireland171 Posts
Phoenix: Not going to argue with you....but 26 is better than 0...


Its all or nothingireland
Post Comment - Post a comment on this Forum Thread

Stats for this Thread

9,008 Views
252 Comments
by Phoenix (110 Threads)
Created: Nov 2010
Last Viewed: 6 hrs ago
Last Commented: Nov 2010

Share this Thread

We use cookies to ensure that you have the best experience possible on our website. Read Our Privacy Policy Here