Dating in hope...... (38)

Aug 23, 2011 5:58 PM CST Dating in hope......
Glengirl
GlengirlGlengirlConvoy, Donegal Ireland54 Threads 2 Polls 5,560 Posts
To follow on from Chancers poll....

If someone had on their profile that they don't want children, and you do, would you date them anyway, in the hope that they might change their mind?

This question is posed to both male and female posters conversing
Aug 23, 2011 6:03 PM CST Dating in hope......
delamer
delamerdelamerWexford, Ireland114 Threads 10 Polls 4,135 Posts
Glengirl: To follow on from Chancers poll....

If someone had on their profile that they don't want children, and you do, would you date them anyway, in the hope that they might change their mind?

This question is posed to both male and female posters


I'd date them wondering if they're possibly my soulmate. At this stage I could take it or leave it as far as having kids was concerned. I'm not a big believer in dealbreakers... as long as they're tidy and don't go to mass too often. laugh
Aug 23, 2011 6:06 PM CST Dating in hope......
jaette
jaettejaetteaughrim, Wicklow Ireland4 Threads 142 Posts
Glengirl: To follow on from Chancers poll....

If someone had on their profile that they don't want children, and you do, would you date them anyway, in the hope that they might change their mind?

This question is posed to both male and female posters


i think you can take with a pinch of salt what people put in their profiles
Aug 23, 2011 6:08 PM CST Dating in hope......
Glengirl
GlengirlGlengirlConvoy, Donegal Ireland54 Threads 2 Polls 5,560 Posts
jaette: i think you can take with a pinch of salt what people put in their profiles


Most of it, yes, but I think people would give an honest answer to the children question dunno
Aug 23, 2011 6:09 PM CST Dating in hope......
Glengirl
GlengirlGlengirlConvoy, Donegal Ireland54 Threads 2 Polls 5,560 Posts
delamer: I'd date them wondering if they're possibly my soulmate. At this stage I could take it or leave it as far as having kids was concerned. I'm not a big believer in dealbreakers... as long as they're tidy and don't go to mass too often.


For some strange reason, I have this image of frequent mass goers being ultra tidy laugh
Aug 23, 2011 6:09 PM CST Dating in hope......
fitandfun79
fitandfun79fitandfun79Laois, Leix Ireland62 Threads 3 Polls 912 Posts
Glengirl: To follow on from Chancers poll....

If someone had on their profile that they don't want children, and you do, would you date them anyway, in the hope that they might change their mind?

This question is posed to both male and female posters


it's a dealbreaker for me... if someone doesn't want kids i won't waste their time or mine.. i want kids someday.. simples
Aug 23, 2011 6:10 PM CST Dating in hope......
jaette
jaettejaetteaughrim, Wicklow Ireland4 Threads 142 Posts
Glengirl: Most of it, yes, but I think people would give an honest answer to the children question



no i have found that is the one question you will definitely not get an honest answer to, for various reasons
Aug 23, 2011 6:12 PM CST Dating in hope......
skyblue43
skyblue43skyblue43Dublin, Meath Ireland30 Threads 1 Polls 5,980 Posts
fitandfun79: it's a dealbreaker for me... if someone doesn't want kids i won't waste their time or mine.. i want kids someday.. simples


Just as a follow on from this...if you met someone, got on well but very soon after you found out she couldn't have kids would it still be a dealbreaker?
Aug 23, 2011 6:14 PM CST Dating in hope......
fitandfun79
fitandfun79fitandfun79Laois, Leix Ireland62 Threads 3 Polls 912 Posts
skyblue43: Just as a follow on from this...if you met someone, got on well but very soon after you found out she couldn't have kids would it still be a dealbreaker?



good point.. one i've often thought about... that's completly different.. if i fell in love with someone who wanted kids, but for whatever reason we couldn't have kids together, i'm sure id be devastated but would NOT break up/divorce/seperate, whatever..
Aug 23, 2011 6:14 PM CST Dating in hope......
unouwantme2
unouwantme2unouwantme2pussyville, Tipperary Ireland144 Threads 4,470 Posts
Glengirl: To follow on from Chancers poll....

If someone had on their profile that they don't want children, and you do, would you date them anyway, in the hope that they might change their mind?

This question is posed to both male and female posters
this is slightly off the point but i dont think i could date a girl with kids
Aug 23, 2011 6:16 PM CST Dating in hope......
Glengirl
GlengirlGlengirlConvoy, Donegal Ireland54 Threads 2 Polls 5,560 Posts
unouwantme2: this is slightly off the point but i dont think i could date a girl with kids


Off the point, but a good one all the same. Any particular reason?
Aug 23, 2011 6:17 PM CST Dating in hope......
skyblue43
skyblue43skyblue43Dublin, Meath Ireland30 Threads 1 Polls 5,980 Posts
fitandfun79: good point.. one i've often thought about... that's completly different.. if i fell in love with someone who wanted kids, but for whatever reason we couldn't have kids together, i'm sure id be devastated but would NOT break up/divorce/seperate, whatever..


Yeah I think its most peoples answer...but it does show that kids are an absolute 100% necessity for you...dunno
Aug 23, 2011 6:19 PM CST Dating in hope......
fitandfun79
fitandfun79fitandfun79Laois, Leix Ireland62 Threads 3 Polls 912 Posts
skyblue43: Yeah I think its most peoples answer...but it does show that kids are an absolute 100% necessity for you...


they are.. i do want a family... i do want to be a dad (a good one hopefully)... i guess it's important that someone i want to settle down with wants the same thing. The idea of having a family is important to me
Aug 23, 2011 6:22 PM CST Dating in hope......
delamer
delamerdelamerWexford, Ireland114 Threads 10 Polls 4,135 Posts
Glengirl: Oh, don't go there


I dare not. innocent I've made my point anyway. tongue laugh
Aug 23, 2011 6:23 PM CST Dating in hope......
unouwantme2
unouwantme2unouwantme2pussyville, Tipperary Ireland144 Threads 4,470 Posts
Glengirl: Off the point, but a good one all the same. Any particular reason?
call it greedy if you like but just couldnt be with a girl who has kids from another lad, especially if he is still constantly in my gf's life along with the kids.. i just think me(who loves going out) getting it on with a girl who has 1 or more kids is an open wound for disaster
Aug 23, 2011 6:23 PM CST Dating in hope......
skyblue43
skyblue43skyblue43Dublin, Meath Ireland30 Threads 1 Polls 5,980 Posts
fitandfun79: they are.. i do want a family... i do want to be a dad (a good one hopefully)... i guess it's important that someone i want to settle down with wants the same thing. The idea of having a family is important to me


I know its difficult to be specific but at what point in a relationship would you raise the question......and also as regards not breaking up would there be some point in time that would need to be passed...ie...If you were dating someone for 5 years and engaged to be married and you found out she could not have kids you would stay in the relationship. If you met a girl one night, got on well and in conversation she happened to mention she could not have kids I'm guessing you'd not look for a second date...do you have a notional cut off point?
Aug 23, 2011 6:27 PM CST Dating in hope......
Glengirl
GlengirlGlengirlConvoy, Donegal Ireland54 Threads 2 Polls 5,560 Posts
unouwantme2: call it greedy if you like but just couldnt be with a girl who has kids from another lad, especially if he is still constantly in my gf's life along with the kids.. i just think me(who loves going out) getting it on with a girl who has 1 or more kids is an open wound for disaster


An honest answer, and there's nothing wrong with that. If you're not comfortable with the fact that she already has kids, it's better for everyone that you stay away thumbs up
Aug 23, 2011 6:27 PM CST Dating in hope......
fitandfun79
fitandfun79fitandfun79Laois, Leix Ireland62 Threads 3 Polls 912 Posts
skyblue43: I know its difficult to be specific but at what point in a relationship would you raise the question......and also as regards not breaking up would there be some point in time that would need to be passed...ie...If you were dating someone for 5 years and engaged to be married and you found out she could not have kids you would stay in the relationship. If you met a girl one night, got on well and in conversation she happened to mention she could not have kids I'm guessing you'd not look for a second date...do you have a notional cut off point?


lot to answer there...

and to be honest, i don't know how well i can answer it. as regards your past point, yes there would be no second date if it came up in conversation that she wanted no kids.
yes, if i was engaged and with someone years and we found out she couldnt have kids, as long as i loved her (which i should if im engaged) then i would stay. (there is always adoption)
I'll put it like this, it's a dealbreaker for me if it comes up when i first start seeing someone that they don't want kids.
There is no specific 'cut off point'.
Aug 23, 2011 6:30 PM CST Dating in hope......
skyblue43
skyblue43skyblue43Dublin, Meath Ireland30 Threads 1 Polls 5,980 Posts
fitandfun79: lot to answer there...

and to be honest, i don't know how well i can answer it. as regards your past point, yes there would be no second date if it came up in conversation that she wanted no kids.
yes, if i was engaged and with someone years and we found out she couldnt have kids, as long as i loved her (which i should if im engaged) then i would stay. (there is always adoption)
I'll put it like this, it's a dealbreaker for me if it comes up when i first start seeing someone that they don't want kids.
There is no specific 'cut off point'.


Makes sense...I remember when I was faced with the possibility of no kids within my marriage and it scared me...thankfully things changed...
Aug 23, 2011 6:31 PM CST Dating in hope......
fitandfun79
fitandfun79fitandfun79Laois, Leix Ireland62 Threads 3 Polls 912 Posts
skyblue43: Makes sense...I remember when I was faced with the possibility of no kids within my marriage and it scared me...thankfully things changed...


glad to hear that thumbs up
Post Comment - Post a comment on this Forum Thread

Stats for this Thread

1,989 Views
37 Comments
by Glengirl (54 Threads)
Created: Aug 2011
Last Viewed: Apr 27
Last Commented: Aug 2011

Share this Thread

We use cookies to ensure that you have the best experience possible on our website. Read Our Privacy Policy Here