Who owns the rain? ( Archived) (19)

Mar 21, 2016 12:43 AM CST Who owns the rain?
Dedovix
DedovixDedovixBig Place, Central Serbia Serbia12 Threads 1 Polls 5,492 Posts
Man Gets Prison Sentence For Collecting Rainwater On His Property

Collecting rainwater on your own property in the U.S. can now lead to jail time, as has been proven by a man from Oregon who was sentenced to prison for doing just that. Who owns the rain? The US government, apparently.

Not so long ago, it was common practice across much of the world to collect rainwater into man made wells on your property to use for farming, irrigation and having fresh clean water. It was just as common as canning your own food, having knowledge of at least some basic survival skills, and being self-sufficient.

It wasn’t even that many generations ago that all of this was common practice – people born before WWII were pretty adept at these skills, as they were a necessity to survival. One of the main (and easiest) ways to ensure survival was to collecting rainwater on your own property. The practical uses for storing and collecting rainwater are numerous and many people across the world in rural areas still do it today for all of the reasons listed above. However, over the past few years, laws making the collection of rainwater illegal have been causing an uproar across the US.

Now, a man from Grey Point, Oregon has been sentenced to thirty days in prison for storing collected rainwater on his very own property – and the public is outraged.

yournewswire.com/man-gets-prison-sentence-for-collecting-rainwater-on-his-own-property/
------ This thread is Archived ------
Mar 21, 2016 3:26 AM CST Who owns the rain?
Dragos1
Dragos1Dragos1Metro, Oregon USA54 Threads 1 Polls 1,982 Posts
Interesting post "Dedo". Now here where I live in Portland Oregon it is kind of interesting...sometimes a bit maddening. Let me explain.
For instance. Here our water bill and our sewer bill are combined.
So when I went away for a few months I literally turned off my water at the main and inside at another main. This means that no water, nit even a drop was able to pass and I also wrote the number from the meter so I would know that in fact no water was used.
when I returned I was surprised that I had a water bill that was not very different than usual. In fact if memory serves me it was a bit higher than the month before. So I talked with the Water Bureau and Billing.
They explained to me that I must pay for water that disperses from my property when it rains and then of course makes the way back to some sewer or even just into the ground!. Yes, I was not impressed. but like many things it is just the way it is. But kinda lame.

Here is the other one that is crazy, especially in what they did to the person in the OP. We have the option to collect water from our downspouts and then keep it contained in such a way that no mosquitoes can put their larva their as that would not be good. Then we can tap into that water for watering plants and so on. They will actually reward you in doing this and give you directions on how to do it successfully and without problems. I think they may even give you the barrels to catch the water but that may have changed.
Wow! , right before I posted this I realized the guy lives in Oregon. So I did a little more research and found on "Snopes" that though it may be true it is not exactly the way it sounded. I am now wondering how different each city or county in Oregon deals with this. here is the link to "Snopes"


Very interesting though Dedo
------ This thread is Archived ------
Mar 21, 2016 4:34 AM CST Who owns the rain?
Bspoken4
Bspoken4Bspoken4My forest, Western Cape South Africa636 Posts
Lo Gents...wave
I responded to a similar post, on Facebook, a while back...also in Oregon, but this dude build himself a massive dam...and stocked with fish and had boating /canoing going on.laugh
Whatever...but he gets my vote..! His land...and the rains that fall upon it belong to him...end of argument!
If it's the laws of the land, then the laws need to be changed! I said as much in my Facebook post also. Peoole can change it!
Back home I built a 30 000 liter dam (gold fish & flora)..collect rainwater from roof via downpipes and also top up my 100K liter swimming pool! If it becomes a law here like in Oregon...they'll have to carry me out in a body bag..!

The FB ref here:-
cheers
------ This thread is Archived ------
Mar 21, 2016 5:19 AM CST Who owns the rain?
Dragos1
Dragos1Dragos1Metro, Oregon USA54 Threads 1 Polls 1,982 Posts
Bspoken4: Lo Gents...
I responded to a similar post, on Facebook, a while back...also in Oregon, but this dude build himself a massive dam...and stocked with fish and had boating /canoing going on.
Whatever...but he gets my vote..! His land...and the rains that fall upon it belong to him...end of argument!
If it's the laws of the land, then the laws need to be changed! I said as much in my Facebook post also. Peoole can change it!
Back home I built a 30 000 liter dam (gold fish & flora)..collect rainwater from roof via downpipes and also top up my 100K liter swimming pool! If it becomes a law here like in Oregon...they'll have to carry me out in a body bag..!

The FB ref here:-


Yes, I can tell you read a lot more of it then I did but I did read enough to see that it was more than a bit of grabbing some of the runoff for watering the lawn in a dry spell. But especially because here in Oregon I have to pay for the water that falls on my home and land it seems that I would be able to do what I want with it as long as I was not breaking some other law or creating a hardship on my neighbors. But of course this is just one of the very incredibly unfair and strange laws that I have seen others fall prey to. For instance I say where a Barber that was well past the age of retiring trying to keep himself as a self sufficient human in this time where many just give up and/or might be unable to make it so end up on the street or losing their home Fined and also barred from continuing to be a Barber because of not renewing a particular license that though is the law it seems like they just made it impossible for him to make reasonable amends and continue on. It is maddening.
------ This thread is Archived ------
Mar 21, 2016 5:22 AM CST Who owns the rain?
tomcatwarne
tomcatwarnetomcatwarneOcean City, Plumouth, Devon, England UK289 Threads 7 Polls 17,106 Posts
In the UK the water board own the water and it's metered and sold to you.

Although you can collect water in water butts, from the roof and this is used for watering gardens, and is not charged for.
------ This thread is Archived ------
Mar 21, 2016 5:35 AM CST Who owns the rain?
TheRedSquirrel87
TheRedSquirrel87TheRedSquirrel87Manchester, Greater Manchester, England UK1 Threads 1,107 Posts
Dedovix: Man Gets Prison Sentence For Collecting Rainwater On His Property

Collecting rainwater on your own property in the U.S. can now lead to jail time, as has been proven by a man from Oregon who was sentenced to prison for doing just that. Who owns the rain? The US government, apparently.

Not so long ago, it was common practice across much of the world to collect rainwater into man made wells on your property to use for farming, irrigation and having fresh clean water. It was just as common as canning your own food, having knowledge of at least some basic survival skills, and being self-sufficient.

It wasn’t even that many generations ago that all of this was common practice – people born before WWII were pretty adept at these skills, as they were a necessity to survival. One of the main (and easiest) ways to ensure survival was to collecting rainwater on your own property. The practical uses for storing and collecting rainwater are numerous and many people across the world in rural areas still do it today for all of the reasons listed above. However, over the past few years, laws making the collection of rainwater illegal have been causing an uproar across the US.

Now, a man from Grey Point, Oregon has been sentenced to thirty days in prison for storing collected rainwater on his very own property – and the public is outraged.

yournewswire.com/man-gets-prison-sentence-for-collecting-rainwater-on-his-own-property/


What is the state's explanation? Surely drinking/collecting rainwater is not the crime in and of itself unless it could be argued that it's disturbing the waterways and the ecosystem in some way?

This would never have happened in the old Soviet Union or China. Want a river pointing in a different direction? Blow up the town and mountain standing in the way. Nothing in the natural world was off limits to a commie.
------ This thread is Archived ------
Mar 21, 2016 5:39 AM CST Who owns the rain?
Babettefr
BabettefrBabettefrLa France, Pays de la Loire France13 Threads 1,955 Posts
Bspoken4: Lo Gents...
I responded to a similar post, on Facebook, a while back...also in Oregon, but this dude build himself a massive dam...and stocked with fish and had boating /canoing going on.
Whatever...but he gets my vote..! His land...and the rains that fall upon it belong to him...end of argument!
If it's the laws of the land, then the laws need to be changed! I said as much in my Facebook post also. Peoole can change it!
Back home I built a 30 000 liter dam (gold fish & flora)..collect rainwater from roof via downpipes and also top up my 100K liter swimming pool! If it becomes a law here like in Oregon...they'll have to carry me out in a body bag..!

The FB ref here:-


This just shows how diverse the mentalities are.
In France, we are encourgaed to collect rain waters for our gardens, it's more ecological & economical.

I have 2 friends who owns hectares of woods and with it large lake for fishes and wild ducks,,and it created an ecosystem that is a beauty to behold , butterflies, birds, dragonflies, wild plants ,, there might had been a valid argument to back up this case ?confused confused confused
------ This thread is Archived ------
Mar 21, 2016 5:47 AM CST Who owns the rain?
JoyCrest
JoyCrestJoyCrestGeneva, Switzerland18 Threads 494 Posts
TheRedSquirrel87: What is the state's explanation? Surely drinking/collecting rainwater is not the crime in and of itself unless it could be argued that it's disturbing the waterways and the ecosystem in some way?

This would never have happened in the old Soviet Union or China. Want a river pointing in a different direction? Blow up the town and mountain standing in the way. Nothing in the natural world was off limits to a commie.


I find this disturbing. How about artesian water....Is FIJI water bad for the ecosystem! Artesian water comes from the earth, even if you have property, there should be a permit to get artesian water? Who owns the earth?sad flower
------ This thread is Archived ------
Mar 21, 2016 6:00 AM CST Who owns the rain?
TheRedSquirrel87
TheRedSquirrel87TheRedSquirrel87Manchester, Greater Manchester, England UK1 Threads 1,107 Posts
JoyCrest: I find this disturbing. How about artesian water....Is FIJI water bad for the ecosystem! Artesian water comes from the earth, even if you have property, there should be a permit to get artesian water? Who owns the earth?


The earth is common property. Now you can take that as the commies did as a license to do whatever you want with it or you could take that like the Native Americans did as an obligation to look after the natural world as you are only leasing the natural whilst your alive and you have a duty to leave the land in tact for your posterity.

Does the fact that it belongs to all make the earth a gimmedat free-for-all or a matter of shared responsibility?
------ This thread is Archived ------
Mar 21, 2016 6:07 AM CST Who owns the rain?
Babettefr
BabettefrBabettefrLa France, Pays de la Loire France13 Threads 1,955 Posts
JoyCrest: I find this disturbing. How about artesian water....Is FIJI water bad for the ecosystem! Artesian water comes from the earth, even if you have property, there should be a permit to get artesian water? Who owns the earth?



Artesian water i think is different, it's a sort of exploitation.
When we constructed our house, we asked for a forage for an ample supply of water for our garden in an economical way, good debit of water was found at 36 meters deep,, that says how scarce water is at some areas,,and we are taxed for the forage,, it seems that undergrown riches belongs to the state,, in France i say ,,dunno with other countries.handshake
------ This thread is Archived ------
Mar 21, 2016 6:12 AM CST Who owns the rain?
TheRedSquirrel87
TheRedSquirrel87TheRedSquirrel87Manchester, Greater Manchester, England UK1 Threads 1,107 Posts
TheRedSquirrel87: The earth is common property. Now you can take that as the commies did as a license to do whatever you want with it or you could take that like the Native Americans did as an obligation to look after the natural world as you are only leasing the natural whilst your alive and you have a duty to leave the land in tact for your posterity.

Does the fact that it belongs to all make the earth a gimmedat free-for-all or a matter of shared responsibility?


Of course in red china there's no obligation to the natural world at all. And western business has capitalised on the ghastly oriental and his willingness to sacrifice everything beautiful with his cash register for a soul.
------ This thread is Archived ------
Mar 21, 2016 6:19 AM CST Who owns the rain?
TheRedSquirrel87
TheRedSquirrel87TheRedSquirrel87Manchester, Greater Manchester, England UK1 Threads 1,107 Posts
TheRedSquirrel87: Of course in red china there's no obligation to the natural world at all. And western business has capitalised on the ghastly oriental and his willingness to sacrifice everything beautiful with his cash register for a soul.


Now putting a bucket out and collecting rainwater is one thing. Every holiday with my dad to southern europe was the same, the tightass wouldn't buy bottled water and we'd collect it off the roof until we got sick thereby.

But you can't go around damming waterways willy-nilly. You do have an obligation to consider the consequences of your actions.
------ This thread is Archived ------
Mar 21, 2016 6:26 AM CST Who owns the rain?
thelad2007
thelad2007thelad2007Waterford, Ireland645 Posts
you gotta love neoliberalism! NOT!
------ This thread is Archived ------
Mar 21, 2016 6:30 AM CST Who owns the rain?
KremaP
KremaPKremaPAt home, Shumen Bulgaria3,793 Posts
I actually see a point here...
You can't just do what you think is good for your own part of the puzzle without considering what it does to the whole picture...
I guess a bit of information has been skipped about this case...
------ This thread is Archived ------
Mar 21, 2016 7:33 AM CST Who owns the rain?
Dragos1
Dragos1Dragos1Metro, Oregon USA54 Threads 1 Polls 1,982 Posts
KremaP: I actually see a point here...
You can't just do what you think is good for your own part of the puzzle without considering what it does to the whole picture...
I guess a bit of information has been skipped about this case...


Yes, I think this one definitely was much more involved once I looked into it.

thumbs up
------ This thread is Archived ------
Mar 21, 2016 10:21 AM CST Who owns the rain?
lifeisadream
lifeisadreamlifeisadreamMexi Go, Mexico State Mexico156 Threads 20 Polls 16,713 Posts
Dedovix: Man Gets Prison Sentence For Collecting Rainwater On His Property

Collecting rainwater on your own property in the U.S. can now lead to jail time, as has been proven by a man from Oregon who was sentenced to prison for doing just that. Who owns the rain? The US government, apparently.

Not so long ago, it was common practice across much of the world to collect rainwater into man made wells on your property to use for farming, irrigation and having fresh clean water. It was just as common as canning your own food, having knowledge of at least some basic survival skills, and being self-sufficient.

It wasn’t even that many generations ago that all of this was common practice – people born before WWII were pretty adept at these skills, as they were a necessity to survival. One of the main (and easiest) ways to ensure survival was to collecting rainwater on your own property. The practical uses for storing and collecting rainwater are numerous and many people across the world in rural areas still do it today for all of the reasons listed above. However, over the past few years, laws making the collection of rainwater illegal have been causing an uproar across the US.

Now, a man from Grey Point, Oregon has been sentenced to thirty days in prison for storing collected rainwater on his very own property – and the public is outraged.

yournewswire.com/man-gets-prison-sentence-for-collecting-rainwater-on-his-own-property/


Hi Boban!

No body owns the rain, so far.
However, once the rain hits the ground it is regulated by the Fed gov (here) under "superficial water".

More info is needed to make a fair assessment.

coffee
------ This thread is Archived ------
Mar 21, 2016 10:57 AM CST Who owns the rain?
tomcatwarne
tomcatwarnetomcatwarneOcean City, Plumouth, Devon, England UK289 Threads 7 Polls 17,106 Posts
tomcatwarne: In the UK the water board own the water and it's metered and sold to you.

Although you can collect water in water butts, from the roof and this is used for watering gardens, and is not charged for.


I must add, I put the rainwater through a purifier and use it for drinking water and coffee and tea, it is so much more deliceous. The water the water company supplies is loaded down with chemicals and you can taste them.

Don't tell the water companygrin grin grin grin
------ This thread is Archived ------
Mar 21, 2016 6:47 PM CST Who owns the rain?
Ocee102
Ocee102Ocee102unkown, California USA10 Threads 1,399 Posts
This isn't about someone collecting the run off from their roof.



It's about massive reservoirs and a large-ish(170 acre) parcel, and whether he's allowed to keep and store the water or if he's supposed to be allowing it to flow to down stream so others can use it too.
------ This thread is Archived ------
Apr 26, 2016 3:10 PM CST Who owns the rain?


Creedence Clearwater Revival - Have You Ever Seen The Rain
------ This thread is Archived ------
Post Comment - Post a comment on this Forum Thread

This Thread is Archived

This Thread is archived, so you will no longer be able to post to it. Threads get archived automatically when they are older than 3 months.

« Go back to All Threads
Message #318

Stats for this Thread

1,708 Views
18 Comments
by Dedovix (12 Threads)
Created: Mar 2016
Last Viewed: Apr 13
Last Commented: Apr 2016

Share this Thread

We use cookies to ensure that you have the best experience possible on our website. Read Our Privacy Policy Here