Turkey in European Union (98)

Jun 19, 2009 1:33 PM CST Turkey in European Union
mariestads
mariestadsmariestadsMalmö, Skane Sweden4 Posts
WhovianGeneva: As Switzerland isn't in European Union, my answer counts for nothing, but I'm happy to give it to you....

In European Union there's the word Europe.....

Where is the bigger part of Turkey ? Not in Europe.

End of the story....




So, you see EU as a geographical organisation?

Do you have any idea where Turkiye and Cyprus are?

All discussions come to a point in the end. The EU can simply not allow any non-christian country as a member. it is mostly about religion!

Turkiye plays a critical role as a laicist republic , which can be a model for many other islamic countries.
Turkiye has a stronger economy than many EU members.
The EU just ignores all benefits it can have letting Turkiye in, this decision can not be rational. It is obviously religous!

And i have never met any single french person who liked turkiye. I can not help wondering where this hatred comes from?

To answer the question: :In my opinion, even being a candidate has made turkiye to complete very important reforms. Being a member will make Turkiye a stronger country. However, being quite sure the EU will never accept Türkiye, I think Türkiye should start looking for other alternatives. China,Russia and some big Asian countries are talking about forming their own union. It will be EU's lost if Turkiye hopefully be a part of another organisation.
Jun 19, 2009 2:03 PM CST Turkey in European Union
WhovianGeneva
WhovianGenevaWhovianGenevaGeneva, Switzerland28 Threads 1 Polls 466 Posts
mariestads: So, you see EU as a geographical organisation?

Do you have any idea where Turkiye and Cyprus are?

Do you know where switzerland is. It's a stupid question and not about Cyprus.

All discussions come to a point in the end. The EU can simply not allow any non-christian country as a member. it is mostly about religion!

It shouldn't be but you're right. And it has started a long time ago.... a very long time....

Turkiye plays a critical role as a laicist republic , which can be a model for many other islamic countries.
Turkiye has a stronger economy than many EU members.
The EU just ignores all benefits it can have letting Turkiye in, this decision can not be rational. It is obviously religous!

There's also the Armenian problem

And i have never met any single french person who liked turkiye. I can not help wondering where this hatred comes from?

Can't help you, I'm Swiss.

To answer the question: :In my opinion, even being a candidate has made turkiye to complete very important reforms. Being a member will make Turkiye a stronger country. However, being quite sure the EU will never accept Türkiye, I think Türkiye should start looking for other alternatives. China,Russia and some big Asian countries are talking about forming their own union. It will be EU's lost if Turkiye hopefully be a part of another organisation.


Or it can do like Switzerland did : Bilateral Accords with European Union.
Jun 19, 2009 2:04 PM CST Turkey in European Union
WhovianGeneva
WhovianGenevaWhovianGenevaGeneva, Switzerland28 Threads 1 Polls 466 Posts
Oh, I was going to forget beer
Jun 19, 2009 4:41 PM CST Turkey in European Union
mariestads
mariestadsmariestadsMalmö, Skane Sweden4 Posts
what i mean was, having most of its land in asia can not be a reason for EU not to let Turkiye in. I gave Cyprus as an example. They have joined, and the island is far away from europe.
So it can not be about geography.

turks on cyprus voted 'yes' for UN's plan for a solution. Greek part of cyprus voted 'no' and they have got their prize, they are a member now.


And it can not be economics, Turkish economy is much larger and stronger than most of the countries below, (or lets say , at least in the same level)
-Bulgaria
-Cyprus
-Czech Republic
-Estonia
-Greece
-Hungary
-Ireland
-Latvia
-Lithuania
-Luxembourg
-Malta
-Poland
-Portugal
-Romania
-Slovakia
-Slovenia

I think what EU became is just a religious brotherhood. in real demoracies, religion is not a part of politics. EU has to be democratic itself to question others.

and my swiss friend, dont play the swiss army to defend the new vatican :)
cheers
Jun 20, 2009 6:18 AM CST Turkey in European Union
mariestads: what i mean was, having most of its land in asia can not be a reason for EU not to let Turkiye in. I gave Cyprus as an example. They have joined, and the island is far away from europe.
So it can not be about geography.

turks on cyprus voted 'yes' for UN's plan for a solution. Greek part of cyprus voted 'no' and they have got their prize, they are a member now.And it can not be economics, Turkish economy is much larger and stronger than most of the countries below, (or lets say , at least in the same level)
-Bulgaria
-Cyprus
-Czech Republic
-Estonia
-Greece
-Hungary
-Ireland
-Latvia
-Lithuania
-Luxembourg
-Malta
-Poland
-Portugal
-Romania
-Slovakia
-Slovenia

I think what EU became is just a religious brotherhood. in real demoracies, religion is not a part of politics. EU has to be democratic itself to question others.

and my swiss friend, dont play the swiss army to defend the new vatican :)
So you think the Swiss Army consists of that One Company in the Vatican?rolling on the floor laughing
Jun 20, 2009 6:45 AM CST Turkey in European Union
Tulefel
TulefelTulefelGöteborg, Vastra Gotaland Sweden24 Threads 1 Polls 2,848 Posts
My opinion is based on an impression that I’ve got since some of East European countries became EU members:

They are considered as a lower sort of people: you just listen to all tasteless jokes about Polish and Lithuanian and former Yugoslavian workers that Brits and Frenchmen and Swedes are creating and laughing at.

My impression again: they were let into EU very reluctantly, as Brussels had to choose between to leave them at free drift where they can join exactly everything (considering energy-carriers’ prices they could turn back to Russia, gods verboten grief!), or “embrace” them – the more the merrier, kind of.

On the one side, the Turkish people (I mean usual people) would be better of if Turkey would join EU, especially ethnic minorities and women. EU has its demands on the subject, though I doubt that the said demands are frank.

On the other side… what’s the point to join a stillborn body that itself doesn’t know why it exists. To become a second sort member?

I’m sure, Turkey, as any country, would manage on its own. Just because there’s no choice: you either manage on your own or you disappear, as simple as that. And I don’t see any reason why Turkey would disappear, it’s managing on its own for centuries now.
Jun 20, 2009 7:25 AM CST Turkey in European Union
markizamkd25
markizamkd25markizamkd25Skive, Central Jutland Denmark235 Threads 5 Polls 4,706 Posts
I WANT VISA TO TRAVEL very mad
Jun 20, 2009 7:35 AM CST Turkey in European Union
Lagoona22
Lagoona22Lagoona22Bugibba, Majjistral Malta161 Threads 11 Polls 10,711 Posts
Ok, it's in the mail....angel
Jun 20, 2009 1:56 PM CST Turkey in European Union
mariestads
mariestadsmariestadsMalmö, Skane Sweden4 Posts
Conrad73: So you think the Swiss Army consists of that One Company in the Vatican?


Of course not :) I guess i should have said Swiss Guards and Swiss Army..

I like Swiss people and Swiss knives, did not mean to offense you... angel
Jun 20, 2009 2:01 PM CST Turkey in European Union
mariestads
mariestadsmariestadsMalmö, Skane Sweden4 Posts
Tulefel: My opinion is based on an impression that I’ve got since some of East European countries became EU members:

They are considered as a lower sort of people: you just listen to all tasteless jokes about Polish and Lithuanian and former Yugoslavian workers that Brits and Frenchmen and Swedes are creating and laughing at.

My impression again: they were let into EU very reluctantly, as Brussels had to choose between to leave them at free drift where they can join exactly everything (considering energy-carriers’ prices they could turn back to Russia, gods verboten grief!), or “embrace” them – the more the merrier, kind of.

On the one side, the Turkish people (I mean usual people) would be better of if Turkey would join EU, especially ethnic minorities and women. EU has its demands on the subject, though I doubt that the said demands are frank.

On the other side… what’s the point to join a stillborn body that itself doesn’t know why it exists. To become a second sort member?

I’m sure, Turkey, as any country, would manage on its own. Just because there’s no choice: you either manage on your own or you disappear, as simple as that. And I don’t see any reason why Turkey would disappear, it’s managing on its own for centuries now.


I totally agree..
And one point i want to add is population. Turkiye has a young and growing population of almost 70 million people. It is quite a big number. this is another big obstacle for Turkiye to join the union.
Jun 20, 2009 7:56 PM CST Turkey in European Union
heidi2765
heidi2765heidi2765GLASGOW, Central, Scotland UK5 Threads 737 Posts
NOOOOO....don't want them to join....EU is big enough! Let's sort out our mess before inviting more people to the party!!!doh frustrated frustrated
Jun 21, 2009 12:28 AM CST Turkey in European Union
gopi59
gopi59gopi59chennai, Tamil Nadu India20 Threads 2 Polls 260 Posts
AwesomeChoice: Absolutely favor!!!..........Turkish coffee is my favorite

Welcome Roomi


Actually it is Cypriot coffee!!!!! laugh
Jun 22, 2009 8:24 AM CST Turkey in European Union
gangel
gangelgangelPlovdiv, Bulgaria, Hampshire, England UK52 Threads 16 Polls 5,028 Posts
markizamkd25: Well ull be my naighbour soon again we will have chalga party


Now that will be nice.I have not been at one for agesgiggle reunion

buddies party hat
Jun 22, 2009 11:30 AM CST Turkey in European Union
Fallingman
FallingmanFallingmanDublin, Ireland29 Threads 12 Polls 11,436 Posts
chalga....do you eat it or drink it? confused
Jun 22, 2009 2:17 PM CST Turkey in European Union
cristina
cristinacristinaLisbon, North Holland Netherlands286 Threads 10 Polls 17,243 Posts
rodolpho: nothing wrong with eastern europe but we do have to pay the most contribution to the EU. We paid dearly for the euro.IMO I dont need the EU at all.

I would like to have my rocksolid dutch guilder back.I dont wanna be dependent on every other country to keep its budget straight.

I do like open trade but not another meddlin political body wich is the EU more and more.I dont wanna become another america.

so screw the EU I dont want any membership of it.


That's exactly my standing! 100%thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up
Jun 22, 2009 2:20 PM CST Turkey in European Union
cristina
cristinacristinaLisbon, North Holland Netherlands286 Threads 10 Polls 17,243 Posts
cristina: That's exactly my standing! 100%


EU with more power stucks us!
I want to have plenty of alternatives and less powerful people conducting the world!

Free trade, movement is cool, but not more!cool
Jun 22, 2009 2:22 PM CST Turkey in European Union
cristina
cristinacristinaLisbon, North Holland Netherlands286 Threads 10 Polls 17,243 Posts
markizamkd25: I WANT VISA TO TRAVEL


You can always have visa to travel. What are you talking about? Don't tell me that you are stucked there believing you can't travel? That doesn't exist on earth!wave
Jun 27, 2009 3:04 AM CST Turkey in European Union
Mike_3215662324
Mike_3215662324Mike_3215662324Almuñécar, Andalusia Spain1 Threads 44 Posts
Since the fall of the wall, the opening up of some of the east, the increased availability of travel info and common healthcare this Europe has become more vivid, more live.

It's sad that the old song about money is making it self heard as a reason to slow down opening up the routes again.

Of course it costs money, huge money. What do we get for it? I encourage you that have not yet found out to do so.

And Turkey? It's part of European history. Just because someone drew a line on a map and claimed half was Asia, it has nothing to do with history, it's a geographical feature.

I so dislike the we/them thinking, unfortunately the last treaty on the table contain a lot of that...

If all the "others" are so bad, why am I not converted, robbed and murdered already? And why is it that all the people that I've met, who travelled and lived throughout this world, sounds just like me?

Wake up, for fx sake.
Post Comment - Post a comment on this Forum Thread
We use cookies to ensure that you have the best experience possible on our website. Read Our Privacy Policy Here