Who is the real prophet, Neale Walsch or Muhammad?

I have written about Muhammad several times in blogs and every time Muslim friends asked me to study Quran well. So I spent my time to study it little more and understood that Allah has given us easy and enjoyable ways of living. For an example, Allah says plundering is lawful but only if that plundering is done for the sake of Allah.

Tabari VII p. 80
When the events of Badr were over, Allah revealed al-Anfal (Surah 8) in its entirety concerning it. On the day of Badr, the two armies met, and Allah defeated the polytheists. Seventy of them were killed, and seventy were taken captive.

On that day Allah revealed to Muhammad:

Quran 8:67: It is not for a Prophet that he should have prisoners of war until he had made a great slaughter in the land. You desire the good of this world (i.e. the money of ransom for freeing the captives), but Allâh desires (for you) the Hereafter. And Allâh is All-Mighty, All-Wise.

Quran 8:69: So enjoy what you have gotten of booty in war, lawful and good, and be afraid of Allâh. Certainly, Allâh is Oft-Forgiving, Most Merciful.

After that, Allah made booty lawful to them.
laugh

Nowadays I am fed up with my teaching profession and seeking for an easy way for living. So I am ready to embrace Islam and join with a underworld gang. But my problem is I have found another prophet called Neale Donald Walsch. His god also provides good ideas for easy ways of living.

Walsch : at a low period in my life, I wrote an angry letter to God asking questions about why my life wasn't working. After writing down all of my questions, I heard a voice over my right shoulder say: "Do you really want an answer to all these questions or are you just venting?" Though when I turned around I saw no one there, I felt answers to my questions filling my mind and decided to write them down. The ensuing dialogue became the Conversations with God(CwG) books.

Walsch: CwG says that Hitler went to heaven. This does not mean that the soul of Hitler did not experience the consequence of Hitler's actions. It does mean that those consequences, once experienced, produce growth, not eternal punishment--and growth is the highest outcome of Life itself. It is, in short, heaven.
There is no punishment in God's kingdom, but there are consequences. That is, things that happen as a result of other things. But this system is not a process of "pay back" of "karmic debt." It is simply the way the process of Life Itself works. Outcomes are the result of out puts .

This god says that every thing is inevitable. We haven't free will. therefore I can do anything without any regret.laugh

So I like both prophets and their gods. But which prophet is the real prophet? confused If Muhammad is the real prophet Walsch should be a liar because according to Muhammad he is the last prophet. If Walsch is the real prophet Muhammad becomes a liar because of the same reason.

So dear friends, please help me to find out real prophet.
Post Comment

Comments (13)

To add further confusion to your question (which, I know, is not the point), Christianity teaches that the followers of Christ can walk in his footsteps and prophecy (hence... there would be no definite "last" prophet).
but Travisc06489 I can not compare Jesus with Walsch and Muhammad. Jesus is a loving man, I understand Jesus in a different way than Christians.
Madnesssssssssssssssss
sorry ,but you always try to shows you know manythings and you say words that is bigger than your mouth,but how much you talk more,. we will know that you know nothing.
Yes I know that I know nothing. Do you know catgloves Socrates also knew that he knew nothing laugh
Who cares?
Live your own life
You cared shybeats laugh
hi dear catgloves, what you have heard ( written here) about me is wrong. But I don't see any way to prove it. If you want to find out the truth think I think this is the best way:

"Don't believe in tradition, don't believe in mere hearsay. Don't accept anything because things are in the scriptures. Don't accept anything because the teacher appears to be a very honorable, sincere person. Don't accept anything because it appeals to intellect, to logic or philosophy. Don't accept anything because you like it. Check with your own experience, investigate, discuss, meditate upon, and question. And then, if what you learned is good for yourself, good for others, good for both, then accept it. If it is not good for you, not good for others, not good for both, reject it."

--------- Buddha --------

I don't think your English is not good. How can I think so, I am also poor in English
catgloves, why do you want to know whether I take money or not from an organization for my writings? Are my writings so good to make someone to offer me money? laugh If you think so I am proud of it yay If someone want to offer me money for my writings I am ready to accept it. If you know that kind of person or organization please inform me help
AS I HEARD YOU ARE TAKING MONEY FROM 2 GROPS AND YOU NO VERY GOOD WHAT I MEAN ; 1-THE PEOPLE ARE GIVING MONEY TO YOU TO SAY AGAINST CHRISTIAN AND MOSLEM ARE THE PEOPLE WHO TAKE YOU TO THAT RELIGION THAT YOU ARE NOW BLONG TO.2-AND THE (MEN INNEED )IN STREET;THAT THEY WILL PAY TO YOU. YOU KNOW WHAT I MEAN:BUT THIS SECOND JOB YOU HAVE IT IS YOUR BUSINESS;BUT IF YOU DONT TAKE THE CHILD WITH YOU TO STREET AS YOU WILL DO IT: ;ACTUALLY I AM SORRY FOR THIS CHILD THAT YOU HIDE YOURSELF BEHIND HER.
Jesus was crucified, Socrates was poisoned, .....so no wonder catgloves,sad flower

Don't worry about that child, he is my sister's son, he has well educated parents.
AS THAT LADY SAID U ARE JUST BIG MOUTH U KNOW NOTHING ABOUT RELIGIONS , BETTER FIND A GOOD JOB FOR URSELF,
LEAVE RELIGIONS ALONE , DONT START MAKING TROUBLES BETWEEN RELIGIONS'FOLLOWERS AS IT IS HAPPINING IN UR COUNTRY
ENOUGH
STOPPPPPPP very mad
sometimes ignorant is real bliss !grin
Post Comment - Let others know what you think about this Blog.

About this Blog

by Unknown
created Jul 2009
625 Views
Last Viewed: Apr 23
Last Commented: Sep 2009

Feeling Creative?