scousedon: Oh you silly man or silly boy, obviously not read a word of Kapital or Communist Manifesto to come out with such a naive statement of Marx, you have no concept of his ideology or you would realise his dialectic is still intact and if he were alive today he would be impressed by the USA as being the nation that will deliver for him.
First of all may I humbly request u not to judge others silly or real. What might appear to u as silly may appear to another as real. Respect the views of all. There was a time when the world was "long live the British Crown". All beyond it was silly. Today the world needs an electrom microscope to spot this british crown. Speak sense and behave sensibly. Thank u sir.
drbombay: We're product of environment(not saying it's right). The people who have money here seem to get more respect and have a standing in their community which I happen to disagree with but it is what it is.
integrity82: thanks for the irony, it was quite amusing to read it. look, you strayed from the point a little... you even exaggerate in some statements... i asked why they speak about money very often and i meant only this. not even that i asked because my purpose was to know the deep reasons of that. rather it was an observation followed a conversation with several amercians. sure, they also talk about million other things, yet it is clear that money seem to hold the biggest place, than in any other country. oh never mind
Funny thing about the written language. One simply cannot go back and change what they write. You said "why do Americans always speak about MONEY?" That is the title of your thread is it not? So please don't try to tell me I exaggerated.
You further state that you have gathered this information about Americans from concersations with "several Americans" And you honestly find what I wrote ironic and amusing.
I did live in The Soviet Union for quite a long time and certain stuff they built up there was real amazing. They almost solved the housing problem. They had a great health care system. They had a somewhat ok education system. And one thing I noticed was that money as such was not all that helped them to build it. And to a certain extent they proved the point that money is not what builds a nation and individuals. Yet the system collapsed.
To me what uprooted that society was not that much the call of freedom or equality. I am not saying that these principles didn't play a role, but more than that what caused the fast decay of that society was the Levi's and Lees, Coke and Pepsi, Nike and Adidas. Don't we have to analyse why those materials played a key role in the demise of a vast society? May be from that analysis we may better b in a position to evaluate what role money plays directly and indirectly in society..
nadodi: Guys.., Who created money ? Neither God nor by evolution. At the time of barter, everybody was involved in the production and distribution chain. And then the mind expanded and with that the area too. Then came the system of money. One ideological idiot by name karl marx tried to eliminate money by envisaging a grand distribution system in a stateless society. Then came too many ideologists offering their versions. But in all, money was the central theame. Why none could offer an alternative system ? Don't say it dosent exist. It does. Go, look for it.
If Karl Marx could read your Assessment of his work,he'd turn over in his Grave like a Pinwheel! You threw a half Dozen different systems together,and ascribed them to Marx! Why you don't go look for that Money-Less System,and let us know when you find it! I for one won't hold my Breath. Money is a Tool of exchange,anyone takes it any different does so at his own peril. Of course,one has every reason to hate Money,when he has obtained by any means than a honest exchange of Labor,whichever form that labor takes. If he has obtained his money by fraudulent means,it will not make him happy,but remind him every second of those means,and will destroy him in the end!
scousedonLiverpool, Cheshire, England UK1,643 posts
Conrad73: If Karl Marx could read your Assessment of his work,he'd turn over in his Grave like a Pinwheel! You threw a half Dozen different systems together,and ascribed them to Marx! Why you don't go look for that Money-Less System,and let us know when you find it! I for one won't hold my Breath. Money is a Tool of exchange,anyone takes it any different does so at his own peril. Of course,one has every reason to hate Money,when he has obtained by any means than a honest exchange of Labor,whichever form that labor takes. If he has obtained his money by fraudulent means,it will not make him happy,but remind him every second of those means,and will destroy him in the end!
Conrad73: If Karl Marx could read your Assessment of his work,he'd turn over in his Grave like a Pinwheel! You threw a half Dozen different systems together,and ascribed them to Marx! Why you don't go look for that Money-Less System,and let us know when you find it! I for one won't hold my Breath. Money is a Tool of exchange,anyone takes it any different does so at his own peril. Of course,one has every reason to hate Money,when he has obtained by any means than a honest exchange of Labor,whichever form that labor takes. If he has obtained his money by fraudulent means,it will not make him happy,but remind him every second of those means,and will destroy him in the end!
scousedonLiverpool, Cheshire, England UK1,643 posts
nadodi: First of all may I humbly request u not to judge others silly or real. What might appear to u as silly may appear to another as real. Respect the views of all. There was a time when the world was "long live the British Crown". All beyond it was silly. Today the world needs an electrom microscope to spot this british crown. Speak sense and behave sensibly. Thank u sir.
What the hell is the British Crown to do with it all, I cannot remember mentioning anything to do with Britain, can you not read a reply without looking where I live to make your comment. So you did not understand my statement so replied to my assumed nationality, yes, very clever. I do think a man (or woman) is silly to call Marx an idiot, you can believe or disbelieve his ideology if you have read it and I will bebate it, but not going to debate with someone who got his ideology from the back of a matchbox. Have a good day.
Conrad73: If Karl Marx could read your Assessment of his work,he'd turn over in his Grave like a Pinwheel! You threw a half Dozen different systems together,and ascribed them to Marx! Why you don't go look for that Money-Less System,and let us know when you find it! I for one won't hold my Breath. Money is a Tool of exchange,anyone takes it any different does so at his own peril. Of course,one has every reason to hate Money,when he has obtained by any means than a honest exchange of Labor,whichever form that labor takes. If he has obtained his money by fraudulent means,it will not make him happy,but remind him every second of those means,and will destroy him in the end!
KARL MARX IS NO ORIGINAL THINKER. HE IS AN INTELLECTUAL THIEF WHO STOLE THE THOUGHTS OF FREDERICH HEGAL AND SET IT UP IN A BLOOD STAINED COFFIN. RUSSIA EMBRACED MARXISM AND BY THE END OF 7 CENTURIES OF HIS INFLUENCE, THIS IS WHAT HAPPENED JUST OUTSIDE THE KREMLIN IN MOSCOW...The lenin statue lying in a park nearby. A group of youth approache the visitors and offer them a chance to piss on the face of lenin in exchange for a bottle of Stalichnaya (Russian Vodka) LONG LIVE MARXISM.
Sparky55: Funny thing about the written language. One simply cannot go back and change what they write. You said "why do Americans always speak about MONEY?" That is the title of your thread is it not? So please don't try to tell me I exaggerated.
You further state that you have gathered this information about Americans from concersations with "several Americans" And you honestly find what I wrote ironic and amusing.
here we go again
you seem to consider yourself so smart. show me my post where accuse or called the population of the U.S. arrogant, rude, loud, without culture if you can. the question asked is true though i believe and not only based on my experience of communicating with SEVERAL americans. in fact i have communicated with a lot of americans, and other nationalities too due to my jobs. but dont forget there is also television, internet and other means of mass media . your problem is that you pick separate words out of entire context. if you feel offended it is not my problem. read more carefully it seems like what you wrote in your previous post is absoltely true about YOU your posts sound rather negative
scousedonLiverpool, Cheshire, England UK1,643 posts
nadodi: KARL MARX IS NO ORIGINAL THINKER. HE IS AN INTELLECTUAL THIEF WHO STOLE THE THOUGHTS OF FREDERICH HEGAL AND SET IT UP IN A BLOOD STAINED COFFIN. RUSSIA EMBRACED MARXISM AND BY THE END OF 7 CENTURIES OF HIS INFLUENCE, THIS IS WHAT HAPPENED JUST OUTSIDE THE KREMLIN IN MOSCOW...The lenin statue lying in a park nearby. A group of youth approache the visitors and offer them a chance to piss on the face of lenin in exchange for a bottle of Stalichnaya (Russian Vodka) LONG LIVE MARXISM.
Excuse me, but this is truth.
And your point is, sir. Marx "turned Hegal on his head".
No country has embraced Marx, they thought they could cut corners and look where it got them.
nadodi: KARL MARX IS NO ORIGINAL THINKER. HE IS AN INTELLECTUAL THIEF WHO STOLE THE THOUGHTS OF FREDERICH HEGAL AND SET IT UP IN A BLOOD STAINED COFFIN. RUSSIA EMBRACED MARXISM AND BY THE END OF 7 CENTURIES OF HIS INFLUENCE, THIS IS WHAT HAPPENED JUST OUTSIDE THE KREMLIN IN MOSCOW...The lenin statue lying in a park nearby. A group of youth approache the visitors and offer them a chance to piss on the face of lenin in exchange for a bottle of Stalichnaya (Russian Vodka) LONG LIVE MARXISM.
you seem to consider yourself so smart. show me my post where accuse or called the population of the if you can. the question asked is true though i believe and not only based on my experience of communicating with SEVERAL americans. in fact i have communicated with a lot of americans, and other nationalities too due to my jobs. but dont forget there is also television, internet and other means of mass media . your problem is that you pick separate words out of entire context. if you feel offended it is not my problem. read more carefully it seems like what you wrote in your previous post is absoltely true about YOU your posts sound rather negative
I don't recall attributing those things (U.S. arrogant, rude, loud, without culture) to you but I can understand if you took it that way. I was actually attributing that to the many other posts. I specifically attributed the title of your thread to you.
I don't consider myself any smarter than anyone else and I don't feel offended. I actually feel more sympathy than anything else for those who generalize or stereotype others based on their interaction with a relative few from any group.
scousedonLiverpool, Cheshire, England UK1,643 posts
nadodi: I did live in The Soviet Union for quite a long time and certain stuff they built up there was real amazing. They almost solved the housing problem. They had a great health care system. They had a somewhat ok education system. And one thing I noticed was that money as such was not all that helped them to build it. And to a certain extent they proved the point that money is not what builds a nation and individuals. Yet the system collapsed.
To me what uprooted that society was not that much the call of freedom or equality. I am not saying that these principles didn't play a role, but more than that what caused the fast decay of that society was the Levi's and Lees, Coke and Pepsi, Nike and Adidas. Don't we have to analyse why those materials played a key role in the demise of a vast society? May be from that analysis we may better b in a position to evaluate what role money plays directly and indirectly in society..
Cheer up..!
Did you live in The Soviet Union? Or were you in Russia?? I am no great fan of Russia but lived there for a while working as an English teacher. Their Health care is abysmal, their education system is excellent.
Report threads that break rules, are offensive, or contain fighting. Staff may not be aware of the forum abuse, and cannot do anything about it unless you tell us about it. click to report forum abuse »
If one of the comments is offensive, please report the comment instead (there is a link in each comment to report it).
First of all may I humbly request u not to judge others silly or real. What might appear to u as silly may appear to another as real. Respect the views of all. There was a time when the world was "long live the British Crown". All beyond it was silly. Today the world needs an electrom microscope to spot this british crown. Speak sense and behave sensibly. Thank u sir.