Is It Time To Raise The Driving Age to 21? (110)

Aug 26, 2010 6:28 AM CST Is It Time To Raise The Driving Age to 21?
mcattack: What we could do is have every cars speed restricted to the maximum speed limit, that way there will be no speeding on Moterways!!
Then i would have everyone that has a provisional licence or under the age of 23 have their cars speed restricted to 80kmph.


Nobody thinks thats a good idea???
Maybe because we all speed and would for that to happen??
Aug 26, 2010 6:43 AM CST Is It Time To Raise The Driving Age to 21?
ladylumps
ladylumpsladylumpsDublin, Ireland105 Threads 4 Polls 9,454 Posts
mcattack: Nobody thinks thats a good idea???
Maybe because we all speed and would for that to happen??


I think its a good idea or at least have some way of being able to put a lock on it so that it wouldnt be able to do speeds above a certain speed.
Also once people pass their full test they should have to have other plates to show that they have passd their test but are restricted in certain ways. I think they have or had them in the UK - R plates. Have them for 2 years and if they have no points or incidents then give them their full licence. If they get any points or violations they have to resit the test and start the 2 years over again.
Aug 26, 2010 6:44 AM CST Is It Time To Raise The Driving Age to 21?
7sins
7sins7sinsKERRY!, Kerry Ireland14 Threads 5 Polls 226 Posts
mcattack: Nobody thinks thats a good idea???
Maybe because we all speed and would for that to happen??


It depends on what the concept of speed restriction entails...does that mean then that nobody under the age of 23 will be allowed drive on motorways?
Aug 26, 2010 6:52 AM CST Is It Time To Raise The Driving Age to 21?
blarneykite
blarneykiteblarneykiteSomewhere, Carlow Ireland31 Threads 3,901 Posts
ladylumps: I think its a good idea or at least have some way of being able to put a lock on it so that it wouldnt be able to do speeds above a certain speed.
Also once people pass their full test they should have to have other plates to show that they have passd their test but are restricted in certain ways. I think they have or had them in the UK - R plates. Have them for 2 years and if they have no points or incidents then give them their full licence. If they get any points or violations they have to resit the test and start the 2 years over again.


HI

If the government was serious about road deaths they can easily introduce governers on all cars. The governer should be compulsory for all drivers under 25 with say 100kph top speed. I agreed totally with the R plate system and there's a minimal cost to it.

If all cars entering the country have governers, then repeated offenders with full licences could have the device activated to enforce the speed limits, with a mandidory 2 year ban for meddling with the device.

Whatever else, serious action needs to be taken to stop this carnage. The dead are dead, but the families, friends and communities left behind are being ripped apart by these constant tragedies.
Aug 26, 2010 6:56 AM CST Is It Time To Raise The Driving Age to 21?
ladylumps
ladylumpsladylumpsDublin, Ireland105 Threads 4 Polls 9,454 Posts
blarneykite: HI

If the government was serious about road deaths they can easily introduce governers on all cars. The governer should be compulsory for all drivers under 25 with say 100kph top speed. I agreed totally with the R plate system and there's a minimal cost to it.

If all cars entering the country have governers, then repeated offenders with full licences could have the device activated to enforce the speed limits, with a mandidory 2 year ban for meddling with the device.

Whatever else, serious action needs to be taken to stop this carnage. The dead are dead, but the families, friends and communities left behind are being ripped apart by these constant tragedies.


thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up
Aug 26, 2010 7:00 AM CST Is It Time To Raise The Driving Age to 21?
ladylumps
ladylumpsladylumpsDublin, Ireland105 Threads 4 Polls 9,454 Posts
I wonder have the RSA or the relevant bodies actually sat down with a group of males / females aged 17/25 and actually asked them what would get home to them to stop them taking the risks and speeding??? What would shock them into realising that they are only human and it can happen to them ??????????dunno
Aug 26, 2010 7:05 AM CST Is It Time To Raise The Driving Age to 21?
blarneykite
blarneykiteblarneykiteSomewhere, Carlow Ireland31 Threads 3,901 Posts
ladylumps: I wonder have the RSA or the relevant bodies actually sat down with a group of males / females aged 17/25 and actually asked them what would get home to them to stop them taking the risks and speeding??? What would shock them into realising that they are only human and it can happen to them ??????????


I know from my point of view, that at 18/21 i wanted no-one telling me what to do, as i knew it all and was immortal. It's the nature of youth. It wasn't until 24/25 that i realised just how little i knew about the world... really. Now I was driving since i was 13, around local fields where we learnt to handle a car. The only thing that may shock them into listening is a trip to the A&E to see the results of a bad crash, the carnage, death and suffering. This may seem extreme, but extreme mearuses are whats needed
Aug 26, 2010 7:06 AM CST Is It Time To Raise The Driving Age to 21?
blarneykite
blarneykiteblarneykiteSomewhere, Carlow Ireland31 Threads 3,901 Posts
blarneykite: I know from my point of view, that at 18/21 i wanted no-one telling me what to do, as i knew it all and was immortal. It's the nature of youth. It wasn't until 24/25 that i realised just how little i knew about the world... really. Now I was driving since i was 13, around local fields where we learnt to handle a car. The only thing that may shock them into listening is a trip to the A&E to see the results of a bad crash, the carnage, death and suffering. This may seem extreme, but extreme mearuses are whats needed


Measures
Aug 26, 2010 7:15 AM CST Is It Time To Raise The Driving Age to 21?
ladylumps
ladylumpsladylumpsDublin, Ireland105 Threads 4 Polls 9,454 Posts
blarneykite: I know from my point of view, that at 18/21 i wanted no-one telling me what to do, as i knew it all and was immortal. It's the nature of youth. It wasn't until 24/25 that i realised just how little i knew about the world... really. Now I was driving since i was 13, around local fields where we learnt to handle a car. The only thing that may shock them into listening is a trip to the A&E to see the results of a bad crash, the carnage, death and suffering. This may seem extreme, but extreme mearuses are whats needed


Well thats what Im trying to get at. At that age you do think that it will never happen to you and yes that you do know everything. Would a trip to A&E or a rehab clinic be enough to drum it home to them. Or would it take listening to mothers,fathers,brothers,sister or friends talking about how it has impacted on their lives to get it home???????? Only the kids will be able to say this is what would make me sit up and listen. I'm all for shock tactics with kids if it keeps them around to grow up into adults. And although Im not a parent Im sure any parent would be the same.dunno
Aug 26, 2010 7:27 AM CST Is It Time To Raise The Driving Age to 21?
blarneykite
blarneykiteblarneykiteSomewhere, Carlow Ireland31 Threads 3,901 Posts
ladylumps: Well thats what Im trying to get at. At that age you do think that it will never happen to you and yes that you do know everything. Would a trip to A&E or a rehab clinic be enough to drum it home to them. Or would it take listening to mothers,fathers,brothers,sister or friends talking about how it has impacted on their lives to get it home???????? Only the kids will be able to say this is what would make me sit up and listen. I'm all for shock tactics with kids if it keeps them around to grow up into adults. And although Im not a parent Im sure any parent would be the same.


I agree with you. I have two young sons 5 & 3. I want them to be around to grow up into adulthood. May be a group of 25/28 year olds, who have hopefully past the, "you'll not tell me what to do stage" could offer an insight into possible actions required. When i was given the right to drive on the roads at 17, in grew up in delagny in wicklow, I was checked for drink every now and again when i arrived home, and the rules were simple if you get caught speeding... no driving for a month. Parents need to parent too, and remove privilages from kids who break the rules. So many parents want to be their kids friends, where kids need parents who set and impose the rules... Until they show that they are responsible and can be trusted. IMHO
Aug 26, 2010 7:33 AM CST Is It Time To Raise The Driving Age to 21?
Godsgift
GodsgiftGodsgiftEnnis, Clare Ireland251 Threads 13 Polls 10,040 Posts
blarneykite: I agree with you. I have two young sons 5 & 3. I want them to be around to grow up into adulthood. May be a group of 25/28 year olds, who have hopefully past the, "you'll not tell me what to do stage" could offer an insight into possible actions required. When i was given the right to drive on the roads at 17, in grew up in delagny in wicklow, I was checked for drink every now and again when i arrived home, and the rules were simple if you get caught speeding... no driving for a month. Parents need to parent too, and remove privilages from kids who break the rules. So many parents want to be their kids friends, where kids need parents who set and impose the rules... Until they show that they are responsible and can be trusted. IMHO


thumbs up I totally agree with yourself and Ladylumps and this is the kind of discussion I was wanting to see on here and had we had competent politicians, it's the kind if discussion we should be seeing in the Dail.....but of course while the country's in turmoil they've extended their holidays! Stop them doind any more damage I suppose!
Aug 26, 2010 7:33 AM CST Is It Time To Raise The Driving Age to 21?
snowpatrol
snowpatrolsnowpatrolThe North West, Donegal Ireland18 Threads 2 Polls 261 Posts
blarneykite: I agree with you. I have two young sons 5 & 3. I want them to be around to grow up into adulthood. May be a group of 25/28 year olds, who have hopefully past the, "you'll not tell me what to do stage" could offer an insight into possible actions required. When i was given the right to drive on the roads at 17, in grew up in delagny in wicklow, I was checked for drink every now and again when i arrived home, and the rules were simple if you get caught speeding... no driving for a month. Parents need to parent too, and remove privilages from kids who break the rules. So many parents want to be their kids friends, where kids need parents who set and impose the rules... Until they show that they are responsible and can be trusted. IMHO

Good post mate.
From experience parents are the main problem, or their lack of parenting skills.
Aug 26, 2010 7:37 AM CST Is It Time To Raise The Driving Age to 21?
Batty000
Batty000Batty000dublin, Dublin Ireland2 Threads 154 Posts
what i do think is hilarous(this shows hoe backwards we are) a learner is technically not permitted to drive on a motorway but as soon as they pass their test they are free to drive on a road that they have no experiece on,, now that is pure kerryman style!
Aug 26, 2010 7:39 AM CST Is It Time To Raise The Driving Age to 21?
ladylumps
ladylumpsladylumpsDublin, Ireland105 Threads 4 Polls 9,454 Posts
Batty000: what i do think is hilarous(this shows hoe backwards we are) a learner is technically not permitted to drive on a motorway but as soon as they pass their test they are free to drive on a road that they have no experiece on,, now that is pure kerryman style!


Yes good point misses and even if you fail your test you can still walk out of the test centre get into your car and drive off ?????????????????????????? WTF !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Aug 26, 2010 7:40 AM CST Is It Time To Raise The Driving Age to 21?
blarneykite
blarneykiteblarneykiteSomewhere, Carlow Ireland31 Threads 3,901 Posts
snowpatrol: Good post mate.
From experience parents are the main problem, or their lack of parenting skills.


Well i've said it for years, " You need a licience to have a dog, car, tv or a gun, and yet any idiot can have a child". May be when they start driver ed. in the schools they will run a parenting class alongside it
Aug 26, 2010 7:40 AM CST Is It Time To Raise The Driving Age to 21?
Batty000
Batty000Batty000dublin, Dublin Ireland2 Threads 154 Posts
well your still on your provisional if you fail!!!
Aug 26, 2010 7:40 AM CST Is It Time To Raise The Driving Age to 21?
ladylumps
ladylumpsladylumpsDublin, Ireland105 Threads 4 Polls 9,454 Posts
blarneykite: I agree with you. I have two young sons 5 & 3. I want them to be around to grow up into adulthood. May be a group of 25/28 year olds, who have hopefully past the, "you'll not tell me what to do stage" could offer an insight into possible actions required. When i was given the right to drive on the roads at 17, in grew up in delagny in wicklow, I was checked for drink every now and again when i arrived home, and the rules were simple if you get caught speeding... no driving for a month. Parents need to parent too, and remove privilages from kids who break the rules. So many parents want to be their kids friends, where kids need parents who set and impose the rules... Until they show that they are responsible and can be trusted. IMHO



thumbs up thumbs up thumbs up
Aug 26, 2010 7:41 AM CST Is It Time To Raise The Driving Age to 21?
earleybird66
earleybird66earleybird66wexford, Wexford Ireland98 Posts
what i want to ask is what was 2 15 yr old kids doin out partyin
Aug 26, 2010 7:41 AM CST Is It Time To Raise The Driving Age to 21?
7sins
7sins7sinsKERRY!, Kerry Ireland14 Threads 5 Polls 226 Posts
Batty000: what i do think is hilarous(this shows hoe backwards we are) a learner is technically not permitted to drive on a motorway but as soon as they pass their test they are free to drive on a road that they have no experiece on,, now that is pure kerryman style!


scold Leave Kerry out of this!


Up Kerry!!!

laugh laugh
Aug 26, 2010 7:42 AM CST Is It Time To Raise The Driving Age to 21?
blarneykite
blarneykiteblarneykiteSomewhere, Carlow Ireland31 Threads 3,901 Posts
Batty000: what i do think is hilarous(this shows hoe backwards we are) a learner is technically not permitted to drive on a motorway but as soon as they pass their test they are free to drive on a road that they have no experiece on,, now that is pure kerryman style!


I lived ion London for 4 years, and not one of my mates there could believe that we could drive in a learner permit.. now i know they have changed that rule but you still see L plated drivers on their own ON MOTORWAYS
Post Comment - Post a comment on this Forum Thread

Share this Thread

We use cookies to ensure that you have the best experience possible on our website. Read Our Privacy Policy Here