No, and that also means uniforms, as any one can rent one from any costume shop; they photographic ID and a call to their official HQ would be better for verification…I inadvertently found out that most police do not actually carry any valid ID on them but depend on their uniforms and that people will believe them when they come knocking and have no warrants…Best to be extra careful.
I got a call from a guy who claimed to be a police officer collecting some money for some charity and when I asked for his badge number so I could verify who he was he hung up.
I knew when he mentioned the word charity and that he was a police officer it was a scam.
A bit different here in New Zealand in our local Village we know our people and they dont carry a badge no need and i know we have a few problems here just we dont have all the issues as many have over sea,s
We are a small county so makes things a lot less stressfull ,
Kattte: No, and that also means uniforms, as any one can rent one from any costume shop; they photographic ID and a call to their official HQ would be better for verification…I inadvertently found out that most police do not actually carry any valid ID on them but depend on their uniforms and that people will believe them when they come knocking and have no warrants…Best to be extra careful.
Regardless of how we feel about it, perhaps driven by a need for simplicity, many courts have already opined that the badge is ID enough in the case of law enforcement personnel and an ID card is not legally required for someone to be appointed to a position. In truth I once held a government appointment for an obscure group and was told to make my own ID card with certain phraseology included, send it in and the appointing official would sign it, copy it and send it back so I could laminate it and carry it if someone wanted to see an ID, and that is what I did. It looked good enough so that on the very few occasions I had to pull it out 95% of the time just showing it was enough so folks would let me in their homes or behind the counter at their place of business. A few years later that group found some budget money and actually had ID cards and badges made for those doing such work.
We need to understand that ID cards are something that have emerged within the span of my lifetime and when the laws were first written, no one had IDs.
Yes, a uniform can be store bought or items found on the Internet, but common sense coupled with the circumstances of the confrontation and the needs of society is what the court will look at before handing down their judgment.
So go ahead, when you are caught urinating on the subway and a uniform cop chases you, tell the court you only tried to get away and resist arrest because you thought his uniform was fake. Good luck to you.
I've read your loaded question and my answer is yes, most times I would trust their ID. I can't think of one occasion where I've been shown a fake ID or any occasion where the validity of my own ID has been called into question. It would take a reason for me to doubt them, say an engineer who seems blatantly incompetent or a policeman who clearly doesn't know the process etc.
Report threads that break rules, are offensive, or contain fighting. Staff may not be aware of the forum abuse, and cannot do anything about it unless you tell us about it. click to report forum abuse »
Would you trust that anyone that flashes a badge is who they say ?(Vote Below)