How conventional is your way of thinking? Please read the story below and choose one answer (64)

Jul 12, 2009 11:20 PM CST How conventional is your way of thinking? Please read the story below and choose one answer
Ambrose2007
Ambrose2007Ambrose2007BFE, South Dakota USA67 Threads 10 Polls 8,881 Posts
wearytraveller: Here, I dont think there is quite so much dilemma, if you are justifying your actions morally and not just acting out of sheer emotion. In the poll, the value of a human life is weighed against property rights; in your scenario, the value of a human life is weighed against the value of another human life; hence, no, you would stop far short of killing the pharmacist!


hmmm Would you kill someone - would you be justified in doing so - to preserve your own life? For example, in the classic lifeboat situation - only enough food or water for one of you can survive.
Jul 13, 2009 1:10 AM CST How conventional is your way of thinking? Please read the story below and choose one answer
wearytraveller
wearytravellerwearytravellerBrisbane, Queensland Australia2 Threads 2 Polls 12 Posts
Ambrose2007: Would you kill someone - would you be justified in doing so - to preserve your own life? For example, in the classic lifeboat situation - only enough food or water for one of you can survive.


I think if it is life versus life in a situation like the above,a sense of honour would be a wonderful tribute. I think I would rather dies with honour than live with shame! This is now going into the realm of character and love for your fellow man rather than morality. Very few of us know whether we would be heroes in this kind of situation, but sometimes there are wonderful unsung heroes who simply care enough sbout others to be self-sacrificial. Have you read "an ordinary man" by Paul Rusesabagina, the man who is the hero of the story made famous in the movie "Hotel Rwanda"? He write in the introduction,

"My job did not change in the genocide, even though I was thrust into a sea of fire. I only spoke the words that seemed normal and sane to me. I did what I believed to be the ordinary things that an ordinary man would do. I said no to outrageous actions the way that I thought anybody would, and it still mystifies me that so many others could say yes."

This man appeared very ordinary before his heroism, as so many do, but when put into a terrible situation, he proved to be a hero. Why? That I cannot say....
Nov 21, 2009 7:29 PM CST How conventional is your way of thinking? Please read the story below and choose one answer
amelie13
amelie13amelie13Sydney, New South Wales Australia16 Threads 3 Polls 327 Posts
wearytraveller: The man becomes desperate; one night, he breaks into the pharmacist's premises and steals several doses of the new treatment.

The question you need to consider is: SHOULD HE HAVE DONE THIS?


I don't blame him but in my opinion he had many other options before he broke the law. Borrowing the money, raising the money through a fund raiser, offering to work for free for the pharmacist, giving something of value to the pharmacist in exchange, imploring government health employees to help, or going on national TV to beg for a change to the situation.

I personally would have explored all of these options first. It's not that hard to raise $500 in a hurry if you need to, so to be honest, stealing it wouldn't even occur to me.
Nov 21, 2009 7:33 PM CST How conventional is your way of thinking? Please read the story below and choose one answer
strings
stringsstringsdublin, Dublin Ireland59 Posts
yes the Pharmacist was just being greedy

Share this Poll

We use cookies to ensure that you have the best experience possible on our website. Read Our Privacy Policy Here