Ok...I need some advice.....PLEASE!!!! ( Archived) (37)

Apr 19, 2006 7:38 AM CST Ok...I need some advice.....PLEASE!!!!
patientlywating
patientlywatingpatientlywatingNew Salisbury, USA14 Threads 254 Posts
My son is 13...he is in 7th grade...he is failing...
I have 2 options....1. let them hold him back in 7th grade next year.... 2. Pay for summer school

Here is my stand....He did it to himself...not doing homework....goofing of in school...I told him it was his choice to pass or not..
But...if he gets held back...the other kids in school will pick on him....and since we are new here...he is having a hard enough time adjusting.....
So...do I let him deal with his actions and stay in 7th grade...or do I help him out and Pay for summer school??
I think Let him get held back....But a I just being mean???

Any input is greatly appreciated.....Tonya
------ This thread is Archived ------
Apr 19, 2006 7:40 AM CST Ok...I need some advice.....PLEASE!!!!
nwnstar
nwnstarnwnstarConway, USA38 Threads 5,464 Posts
maybe....middle ground. pay for the summer school, but make him do summer jobs...like mowing yards and stuff...to pay YOU back. two lessons in one.
------ This thread is Archived ------
Apr 19, 2006 7:41 AM CST Ok...I need some advice.....PLEASE!!!!
TexasTornado
TexasTornadoTexasTornadofairfield, USA22 Threads 2,701 Posts
personally if he did it himself by goofing off and not doing what he needed to i'd let them hold him back a year.. maybe then he'll realize what he needs to do.. if it was reasons like learning problems or anything like that , then i would pay for summer school
------ This thread is Archived ------
Apr 19, 2006 7:41 AM CST Ok...I need some advice.....PLEASE!!!!
magmod80
magmod80magmod80Vienna, Austria13 Threads 505 Posts
Why is he goofing off at school? Is he distracted? Is he embrassed by something? Summer school would be a consequence for him...all his buddies get to play, and he has to go back to school. That, in itself, is humiliating enough as well. I would also make him work off what he owes for school by having him do chores, mow the neighbors lawn, or something. Give him an insight to what sort of life he can have if he doesn't finish school.
------ This thread is Archived ------
Apr 19, 2006 7:44 AM CST Ok...I need some advice.....PLEASE!!!!
Windygirl
WindygirlWindygirlDayton, Ohio USA21 Threads 1,846 Posts
That's a toughy.

Is this the first year his grades weren't up to snuff? Maybe it's because of the move. If that's the case, I'd let him advance to the next grade and do summer school.

If it's becoming habitual, he'll need held back to catch up and be successful.

If you let him go to the next grade, he'd damn sure be in "summer school" regardless. His summer would not be overly pleasant. lol Consider a tutor, require he read a book once a week before any extracurricular activities, blah, blah, blah.

There's always the option of HIM paying for summer school. He can mow, deliver papers, and then some.
------ This thread is Archived ------
Apr 19, 2006 7:53 AM CST Ok...I need some advice.....PLEASE!!!!
patientlywating
patientlywatingpatientlywatingNew Salisbury, USA14 Threads 254 Posts
Thanks all.....

He has been goofing off in school for the past few yrs...
He thinks it is funny to be the class clown!!!

You all have good points....If I do let him go to summer school HE WILL BE PAYING FOR IT!!!!
------ This thread is Archived ------
Apr 19, 2006 8:02 AM CST Ok...I need some advice.....PLEASE!!!!
mastic55
mastic55mastic55Long Island, New York USA167 Threads 6,859 Posts
I think summer school is good,better than being left back.If the cost is too much could he try a class at a church or youth center.But if he is left back,I think he will be o.k.. I was left back and for a while I would say I wish I stayed with my class,it gave me a complex,but I got over it.The thing I did'nt like was my teacher and parent decided to leave me back,I had no input.And when I repeated the class for a second time,my grades were lower and they passed me on to the next grade anyway,so what was the point?
Sit down with you son and explain his options,at lest he will have a say in the matter. Also take into account that the new move may have somthing to do with it, he may need time to adjust. Best of luck.
------ This thread is Archived ------
Apr 19, 2006 8:09 AM CST Ok...I need some advice.....PLEASE!!!!
TabooN
TabooNTabooNClaremont, USA47 Threads 12,843 Posts
curious what the guidance counsilors are telling you. There are structured programs.
My son was super intelligent and made it a mission to out smart the system... and he did! however, he is paying for it to this day...he is now 19.

Do you have an IEP with the school? sometimes unless you make them do thier jobs, you don't get anywhere...
------ This thread is Archived ------
Apr 19, 2006 8:18 AM CST Ok...I need some advice.....PLEASE!!!!
prettywoman01
prettywoman01prettywoman01sharon grove, Kentucky USA21 Threads 8 Polls 442 Posts
if it is a matter of him goofing off and not trying then you do what you see fit....

if he did try, and try to help him learn some new study techniques so he could know how to study better...

eitehr way, if he had to take an extra class to learn how to study, it would help him in the long run....maybe a local church is offering something or maybe the school guideance counseler may know of something...
------ This thread is Archived ------
Apr 19, 2006 8:23 AM CST Ok...I need some advice.....PLEASE!!!!
Windygirl
WindygirlWindygirlDayton, Ohio USA21 Threads 1,846 Posts
Just one more thought...

Don't badger him half to death over it. Some kids just aren't "school material". Meaning some of the most brilliant, successful people in the world didn't do worth a flip in school. Help him find what he likes to do or what he's good at, then capitalize on it.
------ This thread is Archived ------
Apr 19, 2006 8:37 AM CST Ok...I need some advice.....PLEASE!!!!
dbert
dbertdbertParis, Ile-de-France France29 Threads 884 Posts
Summer school, but make him pay. Part time jobs, doing work for you, whatever. Perhaps over a long period of time, not the summer when he's also in school. Holding him back will put him in a worse position in school and in life. He's still a minor, so still your responsibility. If you feel he has failed, you also mean that you mean you have failed. If he committed a crime, you'd still be liable, no?

But he should pay the costs.
------ This thread is Archived ------
Apr 19, 2006 8:40 AM CST Ok...I need some advice.....PLEASE!!!!
peekarose
peekarosepeekarosecanton, North Carolina USA2 Posts
i know ur pain i to am a single parent and had the same problem with my daughter. here is what i did i gave her a choice she could either get held back or go to summer school but if she chose to go to summer school she would have to work off what i had to pay for summer school by doing extra chores and baby-sitting for a family friend. if that helps any.
------ This thread is Archived ------
Apr 19, 2006 8:55 AM CST Ok...I need some advice.....PLEASE!!!!
kyuzo
kyuzokyuzoBratislava, New Brunswick Canada2 Threads 14 Posts
Hi,
I'm no professional. Well, I'm a teacher at a high school, but...no professional counselor or anything like that. However, I've had tons of experience with children and teaching them and dealing with kids who goof around instead of working, so maybe I can be of some help.
His lack of concentration could be due to a variety of things. He may be looking for attention from you or anybody else (this is often the case). It this is the reason, then I would suggest the summer school, but you should sit down with him every day while he does his work and help him with it. Many parents I meet are 'too busy' or something or other to help their children with their problems (I'm not saying that you are one of these) and my response is that we only get one chance to help our children and if work is more important than they are, then there are some priority checks that need to be considered. Another possibility is that the work he is doing has become too challenging for him and so he is acting up and goofing around in order to hide this. Again, it's not going to help to put him in summer school and leave it at that. Quality time with him is the best answer. It may be challenging for both of you because he may resist your help because he doesn't want to admit that he's having problems. And another possibility is that he's hyperactive or more of an artistically minded child, not a 'thinker' who can sit for long times and listen quietly. This is common and people tend to think that children are 'hyperactive' or not smart because of their behaviour, when in fact, it's because they are extremely talented, but in another area. Does he doodle a lot in class? Does he spend more time creating things instead of studying things? Does he draw a lot? This is a good indication that he's more artistic. The last thing is that he may simply just need more discipline. Kids are kids, and when they can get away with doing nothing, that's what they'll do. If my mom didn't sit me down and force me to do my work, it never would've gotten done. If this is the case, sitting down with him while he does his work may be the best thing. Showing him that you're willing to make the same sacrifice that he is in order for him to learn will show him how important this is to him. There was one more, but I'm forgotten it. I'm very sorry. I hope that this has helped you.
Good luck.
-Kyuzo
"Train as you live, and live as you train."
------ This thread is Archived ------
Apr 19, 2006 8:59 AM CST Ok...I need some advice.....PLEASE!!!!
TabooN
TabooNTabooNClaremont, USA47 Threads 12,843 Posts
"And another possibility is that he's hyperactive or more of an artistically minded child, not a 'thinker' who can sit for long times and listen quietly. This is common and people tend to think that children are 'hyperactive' or not smart because of their behaviour, when in fact, it's because they are extremely talented, but in another area. Does he doodle a lot in class? Does he spend more time creating things instead of studying things? Does he draw a lot? This is a good indication that he's more artistic. The last thing is that he may simply just need more discipline. Kids are kids, and when they can get away with doing nothing, that's what they'll do."

hit it on the head there...

kids aren't recognized as individuals anymore... hearded in sat and test boxes...

and, discipline? you bet! Just make sure to follow through with ti. They learn our tolerance levels and will push beyond until you give in, lol.
------ This thread is Archived ------
Apr 19, 2006 9:12 AM CST Ok...I need some advice.....PLEASE!!!!
kyuzo
kyuzokyuzoBratislava, New Brunswick Canada2 Threads 14 Posts
If I could just add something, please. My mother was also a single parent and had to raise my sister and I by herself. It was so very hard for her, but she still made time to help us. If you're too busy, perhaps a peer group or a program like that will help him. On the other hand, if it's YOU that he's trying to get the attention of, then I'm afraid you need to be the one to spend the time with him.
In all my experience, very seldom does the 'sink or swim' approach that many people are suggesting actually work. He's 13. It's terribly hard, I know, but he probably just needs your help rather than being forced to learn 'the hard way'. In many cases, teaching 'the hard way' only causes resentment and worse behaviour, whether now or later in life.
When he reaches 16 or 17, then I would suggest letting him learn by stronger methods. At 13, it's just going to get worse. At this age, he's deciding and learning how he's going to behave for the rest of his life. 13 is the start. At 14, my students begin to really jump into puberty and their attitudes change dramatically. At 15, they become wild animals bent on the destruction of teacher-kind as we know it (I'm embellishing a bit). At 16, they begin to calm down or stay at the 15 stage. At 17, they start to realize that there's a bigger world out there (and develope the attitude that they're ready for it!). At 18, this trend of 'I'm old enough for anything' tends to continue. At 19, well, just hope that they've made it through and they're off at university. 19 tends to be the 'learn by your mistakes' age and it's up to them to learn on their own.
I hope this helps. If at all possible, don't force your children to grow up too fast. Ages 13-18 are a very rough time for them, even though it seems that WE'RE the ones getting the rough time.
Take care.
-Kyuzo
"Live as you train, and train as you live."
------ This thread is Archived ------
Apr 19, 2006 10:16 AM CST Ok...I need some advice.....PLEASE!!!!
patientlywating
patientlywatingpatientlywatingNew Salisbury, USA14 Threads 254 Posts
I deal with my son as if he were a young adult....to a certain point.
I let him know that he has choices to make...I always let him make his own choice...this will teach him not only that he has a right to choose what happens in his life...but that with every choice there comes a consequence. That will help him thru out life...

Anyway...I am very involved with my kids' school life...I am not the smartest person...but if I dont know the answer when it comes to homework I get online and find the answer so I can help him.

I will sit down with him and give him the option of summer school or 7th grade again. Once again giving him the power to choose.

He does doodle and draw all day....I know he is a very creative kid. He is very artistic...He has a lot of wonderful Ideas in his head...I know he is not gonna be the best kid acedmically but He does need to finish high school. So as a parent it is my responsibility to help him get thru. I don't expect A's and B's from him...Just that he do his best...And failing 4 of 7 classes is not his best. I know that!!
Anyway thank you all so much for your advice....it was all good and was definately taken in by me!!
Thanks again!!! Tonya
------ This thread is Archived ------
Apr 19, 2006 10:39 AM CST Ok...I need some advice.....PLEASE!!!!
jamesl39scuba
jamesl39scubajamesl39scubaTempe, Arizona USA1 Threads 2 Posts
If I were you I'd let your son be held back.Children today need most of all to learn that there are consequences for their actions.If you pay for his summer school he will not learn anything except that if he gets himself in trouble,his mother will be there to bail him out.Tough love has to be just that,tough.James
------ This thread is Archived ------
Apr 19, 2006 12:46 PM CST Ok...I need some advice.....PLEASE!!!!
Alexis
AlexisAlexisWilmington, Delaware USA3 Posts
Perhaps he's too young to learn by himself. He is not an adult. Perhaps he needs someone in authority to give him direction. He has no basis for such decision making.
------ This thread is Archived ------
Apr 19, 2006 12:49 PM CST Ok...I need some advice.....PLEASE!!!!
deborah12
deborah12deborah12wolverhampton, UK89 Threads 11,243 Posts
could he have private tutoring at home to help him
------ This thread is Archived ------
Apr 19, 2006 1:10 PM CST Ok...I need some advice.....PLEASE!!!!
soleil
soleilsoleiledinburgh, UK4 Threads 52 Posts
Hi,
I think that summer school could really be a good thing.
For one thing I suppose he would be in a smaller group and get the attention he needs.
And if he achieves well, that may encourage him to keep doing better. You know, more praises from the people helping him and from you when he tries hard.
A small bribery wouldn't come amiss. Like what he can get for a good day work.
Maybe your son needs to have very short term targets. Something which seems easily achievable for him.
Repeating a year is no garanty that he will do better.
He might just need a chance to see that learning can be fun and really interesting and that you can even get goodies for it!
Until they are old enough to understand that education is important, and that it's their own responsibility, you just have to keep pushing and praising.
Punishment and threats won't do the trick.
My personal and practical experience is, after the first year at uni, you kind of start realizing it.
So, keep tryingxx
------ This thread is Archived ------
Post Comment - Post a comment on this Forum Thread

This Thread is Archived

This Thread is archived, so you will no longer be able to post to it. Threads get archived automatically when they are older than 3 months.

« Go back to All Threads
Message #318

Stats for this Thread

2,819 Views
36 Comments
by patientlywating (14 Threads)
Created: Apr 2006
Last Viewed: 10 hrs ago
Last Commented: Sep 2006

Share this Thread

We use cookies to ensure that you have the best experience possible on our website. Read Our Privacy Policy Here