Should there be a one Universal language ? (42)

Jul 2, 2008 5:23 AM CST Should there be a one Universal language ?
popcorn
Jul 2, 2008 5:48 AM CST Should there be a one Universal language ?
wedward
wedwardwedwardlinz, Upper Austria Austria680 Threads 7,252 Posts
: dunno
Jul 2, 2008 7:11 AM CST Should there be a one Universal language ?
FlowerOfTheSun
FlowerOfTheSunFlowerOfTheSunMalaga, Andalusia Spain7 Threads 1,017 Posts
wedward: -- and here are but a few sir francis bacon- bertrand russell - david store-js mill sir thomas more - adam smith --and the list goes on-please research before u make false statments on the the english and their language then u will get it right ----remember to put brain in gear before opening mouth or writing words --


Weddy!! Don't so harsh!!! How do you know this statement was not an "informed" statement?

Although I agree with you about the many amazing English writers and phylosophers, when I meet up with my friend who also peaks 3 languages totally fluently, we find ourselves using words in either French or Spanish because those words ARE more expressive and accurate to convey feeling or thought than the words that are available in English. Yes, the English language does have words that convey subtle differences sometimes BUT at times there is just NOT a word that exists that conveys something specific that DOES exist in an other language. JMHO
Jul 2, 2008 7:50 AM CST Should there be a one Universal language ?
patrickthomas
patrickthomaspatrickthomasMullingar, Westmeath Ireland33 Threads 4 Polls 1,911 Posts
wedward: --- the worlds people commuicate with each other very well, if its not broken why try to fix it , it works as it is leave it alone---


Yes! Wedward. This is quite true. The spread of a language is organic and English seems to be the common language within a large part of the World. It is also a language that is evolving day by day with new words being added at an extremely fast pace.

To the other comments that say that any one language is better or worse for expressing oneself is nonsense, language is merely the medium of expression. This is purely a subjective aesthetic judgement.
Jul 2, 2008 8:11 AM CST Should there be a one Universal language ?
wedward
wedwardwedwardlinz, Upper Austria Austria680 Threads 7,252 Posts
FlowerOfTheSun: Weddy!! Don't so harsh!!! How do you know this statement was not an "informed" statement?

Although I agree with you about the many amazing English writers and phylosophers, when I meet up with my friend who also peaks 3 languages totally fluently, we find ourselves using words in either French or Spanish because those words ARE more expressive and accurate to convey feeling or thought than the words that are available in English. Yes, the English language does have words that convey subtle differences sometimes BUT at times there is just NOT a word that exists that conveys something specific that DOES exist in an other language. JMHO
--sorry flower i was just making a point not being harsh but i have a great love of the english language for instance did u know will shakspear gave it over 1500 new words and english is a most romantic language to read wordsworth ,s host of daffiodilsenglish is just great its the country thats going to the dogs
Jul 2, 2008 8:20 AM CST Should there be a one Universal language ?
gongman
gongmangongmanCarcassone, Occitanie France28 Threads 2 Polls 515 Posts
wedward: -- its the country thats going to the dogs


That´s an insult to dogs!

When did you last see a dog stab another dog for his mobile phone?

Drunk as a skunk at 7 in the evening because it´s friday.

Smash up a public place because his football team (Rovers laugh) lost

Etc etc

Greetings from Spain!
Jul 2, 2008 1:29 PM CST Should there be a one Universal language ?
sellacurulis
sellacurulissellacurulisSofiya, Sofia City Bulgaria1 Threads 27 Posts
Manolito: What's wrong with it???

I guess it's an ok language for global simple communication, but that's it. The english language is too poor in it's grammar and expressional context to accomodate a lot of people's need of expression. Ever thought why not one great philosopher was english?


Well, it's not related with philosophy..... the functionality and simplicity of the language is more important.
This is what makes one language more flexible for communication....
By the way, the english language is reach enough for expressions and expalnations.
I will not mention one of the famoust writers, poets and philosophers....
Don't forget- there are lots of words coming from french , german or old lathin language, and nowadays more and more words from other languages being used for expresions of different situations or weird things... such as: monochrome, rug, lamp...etc.
Jul 2, 2008 5:10 PM CST Should there be a one Universal language ?
antcus
antcusantcusSt Paul's Bay, Majjistral Malta17 Threads 948 Posts
Manolito: What's wrong with it???

I guess it's an ok language for global simple communication, but that's it. The english language is too poor in it's grammar and expressional context to accomodate a lot of people's need of expression. Ever thought why not one great philosopher was english?



BALLS BALLS BALLS !!!
What has expression got to do with thinking.....Philosophy is a way of conceiving reality.
Why don't you tell Shakespeare that the English language is too poor in its grammar. BALLS!!
Jul 2, 2008 5:14 PM CST Should there be a one Universal language ?
antcus
antcusantcusSt Paul's Bay, Majjistral Malta17 Threads 948 Posts
wedward: -- and here are but a few sir francis bacon- bertrand russell - david store-js mill sir thomas more - adam smith --and the list goes on-please research before u make false statments on the the english and their language then u will get it right ----remember to put brain in gear before opening mouth or writing words --


Well said Sir Wedward.
Empty barrels make the most sound. And who needs emptier barrels after hearing such heresies from a guy who describes the English language as poor in its grammar??
Jul 2, 2008 5:26 PM CST Should there be a one Universal language ?
antcus
antcusantcusSt Paul's Bay, Majjistral Malta17 Threads 948 Posts
FlowerOfTheSun: Weddy!! Don't so harsh!!! How do you know this statement was not an "informed" statement?

Although I agree with you about the many amazing English writers and phylosophers, when I meet up with my friend who also peaks 3 languages totally fluently, we find ourselves using words in either French or Spanish because those words ARE more expressive and accurate to convey feeling or thought than the words that are available in English. Yes, the English language does have words that convey subtle differences sometimes BUT at times there is just NOT a word that exists that conveys something specific that DOES exist in an other language. JMHO


No, Flower, IMHO, which is not so H after all, I think that when a person talks like me and you, fluently in three languages, they become "language non specific", and tend to borrow words that suit their ways of expression, from the other languages. Each language has its idiomatic expressions, but those of us who study more than one language often do away with these idiomatic expressions, because they don't come to mind as easily as our word substitution in our colloquil expressions.
I believe that every language has more than one way of expressing the equivalent of another language's idiomatic expressions.

There are some expressions that the world has adopted as international expressions like Raison d' etre, or Laissez faire, (excuse my French spelling, it is not one of the languages I talk fluently). These will always be used to make special emphasis when talking in any language.
Jul 3, 2008 1:24 AM CST Should there be a one Universal language ?
wedward
wedwardwedwardlinz, Upper Austria Austria680 Threads 7,252 Posts
gongman: That´s an insult to dogs!

When did you last see a dog stab another dog for his mobile phone?

Drunk as a skunk at 7 in the evening because it´s friday.

Smash up a public place because his football team (Rovers ) lost

Etc etc

Greetings from Spain!
---- oh how true but how sad, im glad i live where i live
Jul 3, 2008 1:27 AM CST Should there be a one Universal language ?
wedward
wedwardwedwardlinz, Upper Austria Austria680 Threads 7,252 Posts
antcus: Well said Sir Wedward.
Empty barrels make the most sound. And who needs emptier barrels after hearing such heresies from a guy who describes the English language as poor in its grammar??
- thank you anntcus
Jul 3, 2008 12:07 PM CST Should there be a one Universal language ?
smoky
smokysmokyUnterland, Zurich Switzerland266 Threads 6 Polls 9,412 Posts
Then we should all be speaking Latin. In that way we could understand Everything!... and there`d be no need to have "common" names for anything ... just the original Latin name!

So, yes, Latin it is. Then no-one would speak in a Foreign Tongue, and we wouldnt have to learn so many different languages. And just think how easy that would make life for doctors and lawyers .... they would not be able to hood-wink us with all their gobbly gook speak!
Jul 3, 2008 12:22 PM CST Should there be a one Universal language ?
smoky: Then we should all be speaking Latin. In that way we could understand Everything!... and there`d be no need to have "common" names for anything ... just the original Latin name!

So, yes, Latin it is. Then no-one would speak in a Foreign Tongue, and we wouldnt have to learn so many different languages. And just think how easy that would make life for doctors and lawyers .... they would not be able to hood-wink us with all their gobbly gook speak!
Don't worry they'd have their Own Pork-Latin in a jiffy!grin
Jul 6, 2008 8:39 AM CST Should there be a one Universal language ?
Roomi
RoomiRoomiParis, Ile-de-France France17 Threads 38 Posts
smoky: Then we should all be speaking Latin. In that way we could understand Everything!... and there`d be no need to have "common" names for anything ... just the original Latin name!

So, yes, Latin it is. Then no-one would speak in a Foreign Tongue, and we wouldnt have to learn so many different languages. And just think how easy that would make life for doctors and lawyers .... they would not be able to hood-wink us with all their gobbly gook speak!


How you can recommend that Latin can be a universal language, I mean by what criteria. How about the Chinese ? More than one billion population learn it as a mother language and probably this is the biggest language in this regard ?
Jul 6, 2008 12:53 PM CST Should there be a one Universal language ?
Roomi: How you can recommend that Latin can be a universal language, I mean by what criteria. How about the Chinese ? More than one billion population learn it as a mother language and probably this is the biggest language in this regard ?
Heard of "Tongue In Cheek" ?rolling on the floor laughing wave
Jul 6, 2008 3:22 PM CST Should there be a one Universal language ?
smoky
smokysmokyUnterland, Zurich Switzerland266 Threads 6 Polls 9,412 Posts
Roomi: How you can recommend that Latin can be a universal language, I mean by what criteria. How about the Chinese ? More than one billion population learn it as a mother language and probably this is the biggest language in this regard ?


Well, Scrap the Latin, make it Chinese! That will make it easier for the doctors, lawyers and horticulturists with their Latin - then they can continue to charge extra for "interpretations".
Aug 29, 2008 6:13 AM CST Should there be a one Universal language ?
professor dunno confused popcorn popcorn hole
Aug 29, 2008 6:13 AM CST Should there be a one Universal language ?
And the Beat goes on!!!rolling on the floor laughing
Aug 29, 2008 12:35 PM CST Should there be a one Universal language ?
common_me
common_mecommon_meSutton, Greater London, England UK49 Posts
antcus: No Conrad. The Nokia slogan is "connecting people". But it becomes useless if after connecting these people, they cannot speak to each other because of the language barrier. My motto "one people (the whole world population) one language!!


Hmmm.... maybe better solution would be to learn more languages dunno

I am quite fluent in 5 ( + ability to communicate with other Slavs as well ) and still find it amusing if I can learn some more .... every nation thinks different way and this shows in their language....

Don't forget eastern half of EU speaks Russian as second language (was taught in school) - why English than?? Half of Africa speaks French.... Brasilians Portugese....

Who is to define which language should be "the chosen one"??
Post Comment - Post a comment on this Forum Thread

Share this Thread

We use cookies to ensure that you have the best experience possible on our website. Read Our Privacy Policy Here