Should Scotland become the worlds newest independent nation state? (149)

Sep 8, 2014 8:31 AM CST Should Scotland become the worlds newest independent nation state?
peachmelba
peachmelbapeachmelbawexford, Wexford Ireland72 Threads 9,779 Posts
kennyfromdublin: An opinion poll released last week has the YES side ahead for the 1st time although another poll has the NO side ahead by only 4 points.

I still think It will be a narrow NO vote.



Okay ill go with yes.
Sep 8, 2014 9:28 AM CST Should Scotland become the worlds newest independent nation state?
Phoenix
PhoenixPhoenixBelfast....., Antrim Ireland274 Threads 65 Polls 6,948 Posts
kennyfromdublin: An opinion poll released last week has the YES side ahead for the 1st time although another poll has the NO side ahead by only 4 points.

I still think It will be a narrow NO vote.


I want a yes vote for selfish reasons but it could quiet easily end up like the Quebec vote yrs ago.
Sep 8, 2014 11:52 AM CST Should Scotland become the worlds newest independent nation state?
if scotland vote yes... we have a great chance of a united ireland! some day......scotland wanting to break free from england is like the movie ''brave-heart''
Sep 9, 2014 11:03 AM CST Should Scotland become the worlds newest independent nation state?
peachmelba
peachmelbapeachmelbawexford, Wexford Ireland72 Threads 9,779 Posts
Scotland getting passionate about the yes vote.cheering ...good on you scots.
Sep 9, 2014 11:43 AM CST Should Scotland become the worlds newest independent nation state?
stanley8m
stanley8mstanley8mkildare, Kildare Ireland156 Threads 7 Polls 5,341 Posts




Go on Scotland, vote YES. applause
Sep 10, 2014 6:01 AM CST Should Scotland become the worlds newest independent nation state?
fifitheminx
fifitheminxfifitheminxDublin, Ireland35 Threads 4,039 Posts
can anyone tell me in laymans terms..cos im a bit thick like..

what changes if Scotland become independent?
Sep 10, 2014 6:24 AM CST Should Scotland become the worlds newest independent nation state?
peachmelba
peachmelbapeachmelbawexford, Wexford Ireland72 Threads 9,779 Posts
fifitheminx: can anyone tell me in laymans terms..cos im a bit thick like..

what changes if Scotland become independent?
.



I would say reduced taxes for a start,.. People in Scotland I think will show more innititive and have more incentive to do well for themselves by themselves choosing for themselves rather than west minister,,,Scotland will be independant , It's very Easey to throw in negatives bit at the end of the day it means Scottish people will be in charge of their own destiny come what may.
Sep 10, 2014 6:33 AM CST Should Scotland become the worlds newest independent nation state?
Phoenix
PhoenixPhoenixBelfast....., Antrim Ireland274 Threads 65 Polls 6,948 Posts
fifitheminx: can anyone tell me in laymans terms..cos im a bit thick like..

what changes if Scotland become independent?


Basically Scotland will once again be in total control of her destiny. With NATO looking on in the side...(they're worried about Trident among other things)

Look at it as a high stakes poker game with the billions of untapped oil & gas at stake (hence the three musketeers going to Scotland today to show a untied front)..


Britain is afraid incase it loses it's seat at the UN security council and it's standing in world affairs is down graded..And Britain is crapping itself incase Alex Salmond defaults on the UK national debt and it'll increase the debt on England, Wales & the o6c...

An if they do break away then there is a real chance of a vote on the position of the o6c...
Sep 10, 2014 6:36 AM CST Should Scotland become the worlds newest independent nation state?
fifitheminx
fifitheminxfifitheminxDublin, Ireland35 Threads 4,039 Posts
how are they selling it to the natives?
Sep 10, 2014 6:46 AM CST Should Scotland become the worlds newest independent nation state?
Phoenix
PhoenixPhoenixBelfast....., Antrim Ireland274 Threads 65 Polls 6,948 Posts
fifitheminx: how are they selling it to the natives?


???? What do you mean. You've lost me there (and several others at a guess)..
Sep 10, 2014 7:06 AM CST Should Scotland become the worlds newest independent nation state?
fifitheminx
fifitheminxfifitheminxDublin, Ireland35 Threads 4,039 Posts
well not everyone can grasp current affairs..or decipher political blurb..

For the lads down the gorbals and the sheep farmers with one tooth up north..which will indeed make up a lot of the voters..how are the pro independence people wording and selling independence to them...telling them how its all going to change the small man/woman/childs lives for the better.
Sep 10, 2014 7:31 AM CST Should Scotland become the worlds newest independent nation state?
peachmelba
peachmelbapeachmelbawexford, Wexford Ireland72 Threads 9,779 Posts
I think if Scotland goes with yes then why wouldn't they try make a good go of things,


I would have confidence in Scottish people doing it for themselves.thumbs up
Sep 10, 2014 8:09 AM CST Should Scotland become the worlds newest independent nation state?
Phoenix: Basically Scotland will once again be in total control of her destiny. With NATO looking on in the side...(they're worried about Trident among other things)

Look at it as a high stakes poker game with the billions of untapped oil & gas at stake (hence the three musketeers going to Scotland today to show a untied front)..Britain is afraid incase it loses it's seat at the UN security council and it's standing in world affairs is down graded..And Britain is crapping itself incase Alex Salmond defaults on the UK national debt and it'll increase the debt on England, Wales & the o6c...

An if they do break away then there is a real chance of a vote on the position of the o6c...



There is a chance of a vote on Northern Ireland's position in the UK, but the result would be a foregone conclusion, a massive majority in favour of remaining.
Sep 10, 2014 11:09 AM CST Should Scotland become the worlds newest independent nation state?
peachmelba
peachmelbapeachmelbawexford, Wexford Ireland72 Threads 9,779 Posts
I'm just watching the newse and the 3 musketeers as pheonix puts it,


I like David Cameran he convinces himself I think but I get the feeling in his heart he would like to say scots vote yes but think his passion for politics and looking good in Europe means he going with his head,


The no polition for Scotland is coming out with comments we will beat them just like we did the Germans,

That's pretty desperate bringing up Germany.will they ever be able to put it behind them.


laugh
Sep 10, 2014 5:33 PM CST Should Scotland become the worlds newest independent nation state?
Matisse_
Matisse_Matisse_Alte Brown District, Buenos Aires Argentina4 Threads 1 Polls 64 Posts
Ask Groundskeeper Willy.




laugh
Sep 10, 2014 5:40 PM CST Should Scotland become the worlds newest independent nation state?
peachmelba
peachmelbapeachmelbawexford, Wexford Ireland72 Threads 9,779 Posts
Matisse_: Ask Groundskeeper Willy.





Is that the queens keeper, I say they are quite taken with the highlands,the queen is a jolly good sportswoman.

She got stuck in the snow once on the highlands in her jeep,and a large stag came out of nowhere and just stayed with her till help arrived,. She gets upset when they are shot,

I watched it on tv her talking about it,,..she has a stiff upper lip but I do believe she is a great animal lover.
Sep 11, 2014 7:17 AM CST Should Scotland become the worlds newest independent nation state?
It will probably be a NO vote, an opinion poll released yesterday has the No side ahead by 53-47%. Saying that the Tories, Labour and the Lib Dems are quite desperate judging by Cameron's comments yesterday.
Sep 11, 2014 7:20 AM CST Should Scotland become the worlds newest independent nation state?
pedro27: if scotland vote yes... we have a great chance of a united ireland! some day......scotland wanting to break free from england is like the movie ''brave-heart''


We can't afford a United Ireland even in the good times, a UI would ultimately bankrupt Ireland again. NI has a bloated public sector, over 17% of the population are over 65 and a sizeable section of the population are on welfare benefits.
Sep 13, 2014 3:20 AM CST Should Scotland become the worlds newest independent nation state?
DazzleDaze
DazzleDazeDazzleDazea river bog hill road, Meath Ireland4 Threads 1 Polls 264 Posts
kennyfromdublin: W&e can't afford a United Ireland even in the good times, a UI would ultimately bankrupt Ireland again. NI has a bloated public sector, over 17% of the population are over 65 and a sizeable section of the population are on welfare benefits.

deutsche bank's opinion is 'an aye would be the worst economic /political mistake'
mmmm me wonders why confused
Sep 13, 2014 11:05 AM CST Should Scotland become the worlds newest independent nation state?
DazzleDaze: deutsche bank's opinion is 'an aye would be the worst economic /political mistake'
mmmm me wonders why


Are you suggesting a UI is affordable?
Sep 13, 2014 11:14 AM CST Should Scotland become the worlds newest independent nation state?
Phoenix
PhoenixPhoenixBelfast....., Antrim Ireland274 Threads 65 Polls 6,948 Posts
kennyfromdublin: Are you suggesting a UI is affordable?


I am...I don't have time to explain how but it is. As for the debt of the 26counties, thats simply been grandfathered off for your grandkids.
Sep 13, 2014 11:19 AM CST Should Scotland become the worlds newest independent nation state?
Phoenix: I am...I don't have time to explain how but it is. As for the debt of the 26counties, thats simply been grandfathered off for your grandkids.



on the beer boss?
Sep 13, 2014 11:22 AM CST Should Scotland become the worlds newest independent nation state?
Phoenix
PhoenixPhoenixBelfast....., Antrim Ireland274 Threads 65 Polls 6,948 Posts
pedro27: on the beer boss?


Nope not even smoking. I need a clear head for a few things. Keep the faith, I'll make up for lost time later...
Sep 13, 2014 11:24 AM CST Should Scotland become the worlds newest independent nation state?
Phoenix: Nope not even smoking. I need a clear head for a few things. Keep the faith, I'll make up for lost time later...



i have a party after few beers and a chat
Sep 13, 2014 5:24 PM CST Should Scotland become the worlds newest independent nation state?
DazzleDaze
DazzleDazeDazzleDazea river bog hill road, Meath Ireland4 Threads 1 Polls 264 Posts
DazzleDaze: deutsche bank's opinion is 'an aye would be the worst economic /political mistake'
mmmm me wonders why

mmmm ...seems some of the financial sector tend ti agree ? Yet there's a strong opposite argumemt -perhaps economics have outdated ideals / morals / democracy in the choice for self determined destiny ?dunno
Sep 15, 2014 10:28 PM CST Should Scotland become the worlds newest independent nation state?
jondoe1916
jondoe1916jondoe1916Tallaght, Dublin Ireland3 Threads 1 Polls 46 Posts
Absolutely Yes, if Ireland had a referendum on Irish independence we would jump at the chance to be free of the chains of British rule in part of Ireland, Any Scottish man who does not take the opportunity to vote Yes is wasting his right to vote for freedom and independence, currency wise I think Scotland needs to form a new currency that`s not under Brit rule or European rule, Go on Scotland, Ireland watches eagerly. Yes all the way.
Sep 16, 2014 6:17 PM CST Should Scotland become the worlds newest independent nation state?
jondoe1916: Absolutely Yes, if Ireland had a referendum on Irish independence we would jump at the chance to be free of the chains of British rule in part of Ireland, Any Scottish man who does not take the opportunity to vote Yes is wasting his right to vote for freedom and independence, currency wise I think Scotland needs to form a new currency that`s not under Brit rule or European rule, Go on Scotland, Ireland watches eagerly. Yes all the way.


out of curiosity are you a shinner
asking scotland to follow our example is open to interpetation
Sep 19, 2014 5:23 AM CST Should Scotland become the worlds newest independent nation state?
stanley8m
stanley8mstanley8mkildare, Kildare Ireland156 Threads 7 Polls 5,341 Posts



Scotland voted Nay. crying
Sep 19, 2014 7:24 PM CST Should Scotland become the worlds newest independent nation state?
DazzleDaze
DazzleDazeDazzleDazea river bog hill road, Meath Ireland4 Threads 1 Polls 264 Posts
stanley8m: Scotland voted Nay.

which makes this thread irrelevant now so it's officially now closed
wave
We use cookies to ensure that you have the best experience possible on our website. Read Our Privacy Policy Here