MH17 Shoot Down over Eastern Ukriane ( Archived) (6)

Jul 18, 2014 8:59 AM CST MH17 Shoot Down over Eastern Ukriane
TTom50
TTom50TTom50Orlando, Florida USA21 Threads 10 Polls 1,301 Posts
Flying at 33,000 a Malayasia Boeing 777 (FL # MH 17) was shoot down by a anti aircraft missile. At this point all sides are pointing fingers at the other.

The Ukraine government denied involvement and quickly showed a radar image of a empty sky taken shortly after the incident.

The Russian gov't denied giving the Russian Separatist any anti aircraft missile with that range. President Putin did call the incident a 'crime'. The Russian gov't says that this event is the cause of conflict in the area.

Russian Separatist said intially that they had shot down a Ukraine military aircraft on social network site. Then those posts were quickly pulled. Now the Russian Separatist have secure many of the black boxes. Rumor is that they are for sale to the highest bidder.

President Obama contacted President Putin immediately after learning of the shoot down. The phone conversation was made public by the American and Russian government. Yesterday, President Obama offered to provide American technical assistance in a investigation of the event.
American radar satellites have the traks of both the MH17 and a ground to air missile.....likely a Buk anti aircraft missile....making a intercept.

The head of the NTSB (National Transportation Safety Board) that heads the US aircraft accident investigation. Says that she will not send her investigation teams into a war zone. President Obama is asking for a cease fire for the investigation.

The gov't of Malayasia is asking for a complete and through indepedent investigation into the tragedy.

But what is the culpability of a government and its officials that gives advanced anti aircraft missiles to a group of separatist that have no legal or formal government in place? Can President Putin be held responsible in aiding and abetting the death (either murder or accidental)of 298 individuals that were on MH 17? Can and should charges be brought against the the Separatist in a international court?
This of course assumes that the separatist fired the missile. If the missile was fired by the Ukraine, should the same charges be made here?

Only the day prior, a high flying Ukraine military jet was shot down by the Russian separtists. So the Kremlin statement that they have not provided them with advanced anti missile doe snot hold much water. Nor are the separatist strongly denying thier involvement in the shoot downs.

The shoot down caused the international air community to reroute many of their flights away from conflict areas. This will likely lead to increase fuel use. What are your thoughts on the MH 17 shoot down and tragedy of lost of human life. 80 of the victims were children.
------ This thread is Archived ------
Jul 18, 2014 9:12 AM CST MH17 Shoot Down over Eastern Ukriane
A thread was already started on this subject. You may want to copy & paste this timely update into the other thread and let this one expire.dunno
------ This thread is Archived ------
Jul 18, 2014 3:54 PM CST MH17 Shoot Down over Eastern Ukriane
reb56
reb56reb56carthage, Missouri USA55 Polls 8,629 Posts
ooby_dooby: A thread was already started on this subject. You may want to copy & paste this timely update into the other thread and let this one expire.
american killed 1 so far/act of war.
------ This thread is Archived ------
Jul 19, 2014 2:28 PM CST MH17 Shoot Down over Eastern Ukriane
Kattte
KattteKattteVancouver, British Columbia Canada759 Posts
I have found it very strange that since the Malaysian 747 was shot down with the deaths of all passengers and the virtual 24/7 news coverage dredging up other passenger jets that were similarly shot down either by the Soviets or others, all these comparisons failed to even mention in passing the 2 Air Rhodesia Viscount passenger planes shot down by Soviet Stela 2 surface to air missiles on Sept.3, 1978 and February 1979 killing all aboard.
The first, Air Rhodesia Flight 825 was on route from Victoria Falls to Salisbury via Kariba when 2 missiles hit the plane. The jet tries to belly land in a field but cartwheeled, broke up and exploded. The terrorist group known as ZIPRA claimed responsibility for both downings. Flight 825 had 54 passengers with 4 crew. 38 died on impact. 10 survived but were bayoneted, chopped up by pangs and shot by machine-gun firkin a virtual bloodbath of a massacre. 3 had crawled away and hid in the bush to later testify to the events.
Air Rhodesia flight 827 was shot down in Feb. 1979, again by ZIPRA terrorists under the command of Joshua Nkomo. All were killed. England called it a tragedy and never referred to these again.The ever sanctomonious English later turned Rhodesia over to these new and enlightened rulers of the terrorists, Robert Mugabe and his then partner, Joshua Nkomo. No govt. around the world referred to this act of terrorism and savagery. Perhaps it was because of racial issues…. as everyone outside of Rhodesia and South Africa kept calling the war a racial war and to be white in southern Africa was regarded as 'a crime against humanity'…In the memory of all those passengers…RIP. I haven't forgotten.The hypocrisy is still very much alive.barf barf
------ This thread is Archived ------
Jul 19, 2014 7:14 PM CST MH17 Shoot Down over Eastern Ukriane
Looks like the other thread expired. dunno RIP other thread.

Anyway, I have a theory about how and why the Boeing 777 got shot down.
The plane was brought down on Putin's orders. The reason was to make the Ukrainians look like they are a wild undisciplined dangerous people who must be the bad guys in the conflict and are unstable. He wanted to plant the idea that he is the good guy and should take control of the whole country like in the Soviet days.
The way he did it was to give a BUK missile launcher to the separatists with instructions to fire the missile from Ukrainian territory and then hightail it back over the border into the Russian zone leaving the launcher behind. He knew that the Intel would show the the launch track originated in the Ukrainian zone so they would get the blame and have egg on their face. He probably even figured or was advised that the wreckage would land in the Russian zone based on the direction of flight and the Russians would have unfettered access to the black boxes and all the forensic evidence. that's exactly what happened isn't it?
Putin is devious and ambitious and clever enough to come up with such a plan. Also his history with the KGB makes it likely that he looked at the 295 civilians on the plane as the cost of doing business. If a bunch of people get killed and he gets control of a whole country to him that's a pretty good deal.
------ This thread is Archived ------
Jul 22, 2014 6:09 PM CST MH17 Shoot Down over Eastern Ukriane
Echo_17
Echo_17Echo_17Saint Vicent, Buenos Aires Argentina40 Posts
It was a BUK they say.
------ This thread is Archived ------
Post Comment - Post a comment on this Forum Thread

This Thread is Archived

This Thread is archived, so you will no longer be able to post to it. Threads get archived automatically when they are older than 3 months.

« Go back to All Threads
Message #318

Stats for this Thread

742 Views
5 Comments
by TTom50 (21 Threads)
Created: Jul 2014
Last Viewed: Apr 7
Last Commented: Jul 2014

Share this Thread

We use cookies to ensure that you have the best experience possible on our website. Read Our Privacy Policy Here