When you read someone's profile, and they are very specific in what they are looking for...do you find that a good thing or bad thing??
Let me outline a situation...
I had read someone's profile, he specifically said that he preferred slim/slender women...no problem but i would not be considered that by no stretch of the imagination...nor do i want to be....however I liked the rest of his profile and still contacted him...we became friends (which I said up front was all i wanted to be) we went out for drinks, and we've had a great time, he is as great a conversationalist as i thought he would be, he is a very attractive man and it was great to be in his company....here's the thing though...he would now like to have a relationship...and my answer has been...
He has changed his mind about the "body type"...I on the other hand am not willing to let him forget that by stating his preference so boldly on his profile he may have forfeited the company of many wonderful women....as well, I refuse to put myself in a position where I would be constantly questioning my "body"...even if it is only in my mind...
I don't think there is anything wrong with having a preference, but i'm not sure that such things as height and body type, eye colour, hair colour...things of that nature, need to be specified....
I don't think preferences are set in stone. There all always exceptions. He obviously was more open-minded than he appeared to be by talking to you in the first place. A lot of us (no not all of us) have an image in our mind of how we would ideally like her to look. When asked on a site like this sometimes we are honest. Hey...we are here looking for the person of our dreams; we might as well be honest on who we imagine that person is. That doesn't mean we aren't open to other ideas.
On the other foot....although my profile MAY be set up this way right now because I haven't yet revised it, I don't like when a guy has ANY all te way down the board.....so any woman will do as long as she is breathing? NOT....we are each different and initially attracted to certain things...doesn't mean personality won't persuade us into something else.
I specify certain things, such as height. For instance, I'm not attracted to very tall men. Never have been, never will be. If I put in my profile that I'm not looking for a guy over 6'2 (and that's stretching it; no pun intended), men 6'4 and over STILL contact me. What about "I don't like guys taller than 6'2" do they not understand? Do they think that they're otherwise so wonderful that I'm just going to fall at their feet?
Same with age. I'm not interested in dating men over 50...certainly no more than 55. It's just a preference. I've almost always dated men slightly younger than me. The fact I mention that in my profile doesn't do much good, however. I get contacted by men in their 70s, even!
So is it "wrong" to list specific preferences? I don't think so. He just better not be disappointed when I tell you that I'm not interested, and why, is all I can say.
I think prequisites makes sense. I mean dating isn't like Walmarts where you can just take it back if you find you don't like it later. There are people on the forums who have went through divorces. For some reason or another things just didn't go right or otherwise there wouldn't have been a divorce. Why not just think about like a car that would like to have with all the fancy gadgets, your personal choice of color, high or low mileage. Heck, kick the tires; take it out for a test drive and rev it up as fast as you can go then park it and see if has a leak or rattles or whatever. Take a look under the hood; check with the previous owner and look up the bluebook value on it. Do a FBI and police report on it. Put it under extremes form of tests and see if it will crack under high pressure. If it survives then ask it what it is hiding because it is probably too good to be true.
highplainsHighland Springs, Virginia USA4,288 posts
I think you should give the guy a chance. Perhaps he has seen the error of his ways...or just plain changed his mind. I personally think it would be petty to hold what he wrote as his preferences, before he knew you, against him or the chance that he could be good for you, and vice versa.
Top me, it is kinda like shopping online. I may have a preference as to someone I would date but not to whom I bacome friends with...Does that make any sense?
Mike1162Over the Rainbow, Pennsylvania USA1,694 posts
I would have to agree and disagree both.
First of all the man was honest with his prefferance, Second the man agreed to see you so he did have an attraction, Third the man adjusted his prefferance for you.
The rest is up to you. If you are going to hold this as ammunition for future battles then please let him go now.
I agree that prefferances need to be specified, I believe that adjustments can't be honestly made when there is an attraction.
Report threads that break rules, are offensive, or contain fighting. Staff may not be aware of the forum abuse, and cannot do anything about it unless you tell us about it. click to report forum abuse »
If one of the comments is offensive, please report the comment instead (there is a link in each comment to report it).
Let me outline a situation...
I had read someone's profile, he specifically said that he preferred slim/slender women...no problem but i would not be considered that by no stretch of the imagination...nor do i want to be....however I liked the rest of his profile and still contacted him...we became friends (which I said up front was all i wanted to be) we went out for drinks, and we've had a great time, he is as great a conversationalist as i thought he would be, he is a very attractive man and it was great to be in his company....here's the thing though...he would now like to have a relationship...and my answer has been...
He has changed his mind about the "body type"...I on the other hand am not willing to let him forget that by stating his preference so boldly on his profile he may have forfeited the company of many wonderful women....as well, I refuse to put myself in a position where I would be constantly questioning my "body"...even if it is only in my mind...
I don't think there is anything wrong with having a preference, but i'm not sure that such things as height and body type, eye colour, hair colour...things of that nature, need to be specified....
Agree or Disagree...