The Trail of Tears..... ( Archived) (130)

Feb 17, 2008 12:03 PM CST The Trail of Tears.....
EricKissesDeeply
EricKissesDeeplyEricKissesDeeplyThe Mountains, USA15 Threads 1 Polls 1,146 Posts
Cherokee words

gv-ge-yu-i a-da-ne-di ni-ga-da

pronounced...guh gay you ee ah dah nay dee knee gah dah


Translate... Love Gives Everything
------ This thread is Archived ------
Feb 17, 2008 1:06 PM CST The Trail of Tears.....
solitare
solitaresolitareBariloche, Rio Negro Argentina40 Threads 4,041 Posts
Several National Governments around the world have enacted "restitutional payments" as it were for all the damages, deaths and pains inflicted upon native groups/ tribes and various ethnic groups, be it in Australia, Canada, South Africa, South America...Have the tribes and or peoples of "the trail of tears" received any compensation at all from the US government over the injustices, deaths etc. that their anti-native peoples policies caused???
I remember many years ago that this was one of the sought after goals of the American Indian Movement , then under Russel Means and as usual a target of the FBI ....
------ This thread is Archived ------
Feb 17, 2008 1:09 PM CST The Trail of Tears.....
Hugz_n_Kissez
Hugz_n_KissezHugz_n_KissezSomeplace, Ontario Canada59 Threads 2 Polls 25,438 Posts
solitare: Several National Governments around the world have enacted "restitutional payments" as it were for all the damages, deaths and pains inflicted upon native groups/ tribes and various ethnic groups, be it in Australia, Canada, South Africa, South America...Have the tribes and or peoples of "the trail of tears" received any compensation at all from the US government over the injustices, deaths etc. that their anti-native peoples policies caused???
I remember many years ago that this was one of the sought after goals of the American Indian Movement , then under Russel Means and as usual a target of the FBI ....


I'm not sure...I don't think so though....Yes several groups have received payment...mostly far too little...BUT then there will never be enough money for all the pain...suffering and deaths....wine
------ This thread is Archived ------
Feb 17, 2008 5:13 PM CST The Trail of Tears.....
TTom50
TTom50TTom50Orlando, Florida USA21 Threads 10 Polls 1,301 Posts
When Andrew Jackson fought against the British in the war of 1812 at the Battle of New Orleans.....local Indians fought with him....so did many other ingenious groups local to LA. I am not saying what he did in ordering the Cherokee tribe to undertake in the Trail of Tears was honorable or decent thing. It was not.

But let us return to the Plains Indian war for a moment. The Plains Indians had three major problems with the movement white man in and thru thier terroritory. Each could have solved with negotiation and benefited all.

First, the Oregon trail wagon route crossed thier territory and 1000s of whites were using them. The Plains Tribes needed food, buffalo herds were beginning to dimish because over hunting by both sides. Wagon trains could have paid in food for thier crossing....as tariff to the Indian. If a man drives across my property, I don't go out kill him.

I might go out and talk with him to find out what his purpose for being there. If he is there for purposes that are legal or are reasonable, we negotiate for his access. Wagon train actually did this many times, paid for safe passage with cutting cattle out of thier herds. It could have been treatied into a common practice that benefited both.

Second, miners and mining operations. Almost the exact same answer here could be done. The mining operations were on Indian land, that had by treaty been agreed on. The minerial rights might have discussed in those treaties, I don't know. But assuming that they were the Indian's, then miners and Indian could have up some kind of sharing program. Where the minerial were shared. Would corruption of the wealth occurred?

Yes, likely it would have. But if men like your uncle L. Grant were hired to monitor the program and check the mining operations productions at turn in. Maybe not as bad as one thinks. It could have worked to the benefit of both. The Indians needed a revenue source. Precious minerials was an excellent means to achieve that.

Third, mentioned earlier was the decline in the Buffalo herds. Poor diet and lack of protiens caused them to develop many illness. Yes even white mans's minor diseases like like measles had deadly effect because they had no immunity. But they needed better medical attention than what they were getting from medicine men. Though even at the time white man's medicine was still in its infancy and with charlants. It was better than the Indian's traditional ways.

I am not talking alchol here sale here, a illness also that the white brought to the Indian. But the Whites had major medical improvements from the Civil War in the treatment of many illness and trauma injuries. They were becoming aware of the role invisible germs played and what sanitatary drinking water meant. None of these medical advances were passed on to the Plains Indian tribes until after the Indian wars were over. Had the wars not occurred they would have gotten them sooner. Medical programs and teaching could have been incorporated into these new treaties. Just as was done later when they were on the reservation. Only sooner without the wars.

So for the defense of their territory, the Plains Indians lost a food source, lost a revenue source, and lost better medicines and medical
practices that the white man could have provided. Not a wise war to make, when it is going to cause the dicimation of your nation. This does not mean that heroism and foolishness on both sides did not occur during the Plains Indian wars. So did atrocities and indiscrimate killings, again on both sides. If one makes a case that one side or the other was totally in the right and the other was totally in the wrong, then it is biased position in my opinion.

As a former soldier, I don't honor men of any side of a conflict that commit atrocities. I have worked way to hard in this lifetime to keep atrocities of civilians from happening. Both in defending the country I love and honoring the people of all races that live here.
------ This thread is Archived ------
Feb 17, 2008 5:31 PM CST The Trail of Tears.....
EricKissesDeeply
EricKissesDeeplyEricKissesDeeplyThe Mountains, USA15 Threads 1 Polls 1,146 Posts
Cherokee words

gv-ge-yu-i a-da-ne-di ni-ga-da

pronounced...guh gay you ee ah dah nay dee knee gah dah


Translate... Love Gives Everything

Incase you missed it earlier ... i posted it againcheers
------ This thread is Archived ------
Feb 17, 2008 5:36 PM CST The Trail of Tears.....
Hugz_n_Kissez
Hugz_n_KissezHugz_n_KissezSomeplace, Ontario Canada59 Threads 2 Polls 25,438 Posts
EricKissesDeeply: Cherokee words

gv-ge-yu-i a-da-ne-di ni-ga-da

pronounced...guh gay you ee ah dah nay dee knee gah dahTranslate... Love Gives Everything

Incase you missed it earlier ... i posted it again


Thanks darlin...I probably did when I was in the middle of posting and correct...Love does give everthing....hug hug teddybear

We speak to all the nations
We speak to all the tribes.
We rode across America
We lived and then we died.

We were your forefathers
We honored this sacred land.
We fought for many years
To live in peace with man.

We arose with the morning sun
The Great Spirit as our guide.
At night we danced under the stars
As the embers of fire would fly.

The great medicine men, and healers
Would all gather in the night.
While the women birthed our children
Before the morning light.
In the distance wolves watched
As buffalo passed their way.
We dared not harm the creatures
For this was not our way.

The skies were not polluted
Mountain lakes ran pure and clear.
We honored earth and waters
With respect to all life here.

We harmed nothing and lived in peace
We taught our children too.
We knew the time was approaching
When our days on earth were through.

We now speak to all the nations
To all the descendents of our tribes.
You are our voices - now speak for us
For this land we loved and we died.

~author unknown~
------ This thread is Archived ------
Feb 17, 2008 6:01 PM CST The Trail of Tears.....
TTom50
TTom50TTom50Orlando, Florida USA21 Threads 10 Polls 1,301 Posts
solitare: Several National Governments around the world have enacted "restitutional payments" as it were for all the damages, deaths and pains inflicted upon native groups/ tribes and various ethnic groups, be it in Australia, Canada, South Africa, South America...Have the tribes and or peoples of "the trail of tears" received any compensation at all from the US government over the injustices, deaths etc. that their anti-native peoples policies caused???
I remember many years ago that this was one of the sought after goals of the American Indian Movement , then under Russel Means and as usual a target of the FBI ....


Solitare, what about modern day Indian tribe payments to ranchers that had thier deeded ranches burned out and cattle herds stolen?
Or to modern white families that had lost loved ones in Indian attacks of the day? Descentants (including Custers) of many of the 7th Calvary are still alive today. Maybe restitution from the Siuox and Cheyenne for what happened at Little Big Horn?

I think you see where this goes. We are talking of injustices that occurred 150 years ago. They are to hard (if not impossible) to document accurately.

I say let the spirits of our American forefathers that are both white and red rest. If we keep making them a battle ground in court, in
litigation, in legislation, we do them a grave disservice. They tried to protect thier families and thier nations to the best of their given abilities. They deserve that rest.

We show them little respect when we take court, things that they tried to settle on the battlefield. All we do is keep the reasons that they went to the battlefield in the first place in our society and country as open wounds. We don't achieve any honor for or direct restitution to these people that suffered then and hence passed on.

But it is the right of the Cherokee Nation to press for those restitutions
from the Government of the United States. Just as it the right of the descendants of whites that lost lives and property to litigate Indians tribes. But what good would it do for those that actually cried those many tears on the trail or lost greatly in the those conflicts? Maybe some good for thier ancessors, yes. Does an honorable person wish to benefit on the tears of thier forefathers? It is best to let them rest, I think. jmo
------ This thread is Archived ------
Feb 17, 2008 7:00 PM CST The Trail of Tears.....
Hugz_n_Kissez
Hugz_n_KissezHugz_n_KissezSomeplace, Ontario Canada59 Threads 2 Polls 25,438 Posts
Love's Gentle Touch..........

Your gentle caress touches my soul as you look into my eyes and I see the love deep within them for me
The locks of your hair spread out over my chest as you lay your head gently upon my chest like a silken sea.....

When you run your hands softly across my chest rustling the hair softly in a tender caress as your breath moves them like a breeze
The soft sound of your voice as you tell me of your love reaches deep within me and I know happiness that puts my heart at ease....

As we sit side by side and you reach over to touch my leg softly with a gentle touch just to show me of your love
I know that I have truly been blessed with a love that reaches down deep within me because I have been blessed from above....

Driving down the road as you place your hand in mine or on my leg in a soft caress just to share your touch with me
These are the things that I have found are so very tender and caring to our love and I am so happy that all can see....

In the summer as we gently swing in the back yard on our bench just listening to the sound of nature and watching the hummingbirds feed
Working side by side in the garden as you flash me a soft smile I know that your love has filled me with a tenderness that I really need....

In the cool of the evening as the sun sets and the moon rises as we sit quietly down by the pond with the frogs croaking in the night
To hear your voice as I see you as a vague shadow as we share our time together watching the night sky which is a beautiful site....

Each of these moments are precious to me because I know that my love’s touch reaches out to me from deep within her heart
I have been truly blessed and I wanted to share this with you so that you would know that this kind of love can be yours from the start....

You must find someone who will care and share your life like I have to really understand how happiness can blossom into full love if you try
Yes I am blessed with such a love that touches me deeply and I am so happy that I wanted to share it with all who read these words perhaps with a tear in their eye....

For I know that so many have searched for this kind of love and yearn for it so that they can share it with the true love of their life
Finding that special person who can reach out to them tenderly with that touch that will end their loneliness and pain to end their strife....

So with my simple words I have tried to show you how your love’s tender touch can change your life as it has for me
I am so happy that I feel that I must tell others so that they will continue to search for this happiness you see....


-Hawkflying-










smitten
------ This thread is Archived ------
Feb 17, 2008 7:05 PM CST The Trail of Tears.....
trish123
trish123trish123Macclesfield, Cheshire, England UK177 Threads 4 Polls 13,724 Posts
Hugz_n_Kissez: Love's Gentle Touch..........

Your gentle caress touches my soul as you look into my eyes and I see the love deep within them for me
The locks of your hair spread out over my chest as you lay your head gently upon my chest like a silken sea.....

When you run your hands softly across my chest rustling the hair softly in a tender caress as your breath moves them like a breeze
The soft sound of your voice as you tell me of your love reaches deep within me and I know happiness that puts my heart at ease....

As we sit side by side and you reach over to touch my leg softly with a gentle touch just to show me of your love
I know that I have truly been blessed with a love that reaches down deep within me because I have been blessed from above....

Driving down the road as you place your hand in mine or on my leg in a soft caress just to share your touch with me
These are the things that I have found are so very tender and caring to our love and I am so happy that all can see....

In the summer as we gently swing in the back yard on our bench just listening to the sound of nature and watching the hummingbirds feed
Working side by side in the garden as you flash me a soft smile I know that your love has filled me with a tenderness that I really need....

In the cool of the evening as the sun sets and the moon rises as we sit quietly down by the pond with the frogs croaking in the night
To hear your voice as I see you as a vague shadow as we share our time together watching the night sky which is a beautiful site....

Each of these moments are precious to me because I know that my love’s touch reaches out to me from deep within her heart
I have been truly blessed and I wanted to share this with you so that you would know that this kind of love can be yours from the start....

You must find someone who will care and share your life like I have to really understand how happiness can blossom into full love if you try
Yes I am blessed with such a love that touches me deeply and I am so happy that I wanted to share it with all who read these words perhaps with a tear in their eye....

For I know that so many have searched for this kind of love and yearn for it so that they can share it with the true love of their life
Finding that special person who can reach out to them tenderly with that touch that will end their loneliness and pain to end their strife....

So with my simple words I have tried to show you how your love’s tender touch can change your life as it has for me
I am so happy that I feel that I must tell others so that they will continue to search for this happiness you see....-Hawkflying-



Phewwww - lovely and thank you sigh
------ This thread is Archived ------
Feb 17, 2008 7:06 PM CST The Trail of Tears.....
Hugz_n_Kissez
Hugz_n_KissezHugz_n_KissezSomeplace, Ontario Canada59 Threads 2 Polls 25,438 Posts
trish123: Phewwww - lovely and thank you


Yes it is and would certainly be nice to have....blues sigh hug
------ This thread is Archived ------
Feb 17, 2008 7:08 PM CST The Trail of Tears.....
trish123
trish123trish123Macclesfield, Cheshire, England UK177 Threads 4 Polls 13,724 Posts
Hugz_n_Kissez: Yes it is and would certainly be nice to have....


It reminds me of what I was hoping my first love would be like and why I was so heartbroken when it wasnt sigh blues hug
------ This thread is Archived ------
Feb 17, 2008 7:12 PM CST The Trail of Tears.....
Hugz_n_Kissez
Hugz_n_KissezHugz_n_KissezSomeplace, Ontario Canada59 Threads 2 Polls 25,438 Posts
trish123: It reminds me of what I was hoping my first love would be like and why I was so heartbroken when it wasnt


I think that's the kind of love we all want...I know I do and I know I won't settle for less...It also shows how simplistic love can be and we try to make it sooooooo complicated...Yet it doesn't have to be....hug hug teddybear
------ This thread is Archived ------
Feb 17, 2008 7:23 PM CST The Trail of Tears.....
trish123
trish123trish123Macclesfield, Cheshire, England UK177 Threads 4 Polls 13,724 Posts
Hugz_n_Kissez: I think that's the kind of love we all want...I know I do and I know I won't settle for less...It also shows how simplistic love can be and we try to make it sooooooo complicated...Yet it doesn't have to be....


I sure do too and theres no way I will settle for less than Im looking for - theres no way I ever want bad feelings and negativity in my life ever again - Its really simple, just keep it simple laugh
------ This thread is Archived ------
Feb 17, 2008 7:43 PM CST The Trail of Tears.....
trish123
trish123trish123Macclesfield, Cheshire, England UK177 Threads 4 Polls 13,724 Posts
trish123: I sure do too and theres no way I will settle for less than Im looking for - theres no way I ever want bad feelings and negativity in my life ever again - Its really simple, just keep it simple


sorry, got disturbed there that should have ended with; hug teddybear hug
------ This thread is Archived ------
Feb 17, 2008 8:19 PM CST The Trail of Tears.....
trish123
trish123trish123Macclesfield, Cheshire, England UK177 Threads 4 Polls 13,724 Posts
TTom50: Many of the items coming to the Indians of the post Civil War period were items that had been stock piled from the war. Even during war the Union forces got bad food, equipment and clothes......substandard
manufacturing and lack of quality controls was the causes.

I am not going to say that corruption and a general lack of concern for the Indian did not cause thier gov't supplied foods, blankets and such
to be of poor quality. But for example, most of the 7th Calvary troopers
had no dental care. They were suffering from Gov't inaquancies as well.

As far as supplying supplying contaminated blankets. I need to see some proof that contamination occurred prior to being dispensed.
If it did, then gov't parties of the time should be held accountable.
But reservation often had poor sanitation standards. Could not the
contamination have come after being despense?

You are putting alot of words out.....alot of words of accusations and speculation...unless you have evidence and proof. Where does that take us? Systemic across the board evidence of the Federal Gov't of the time to commit genocide or ethnic cleansing of the American Indian
has never been proven, to my knowledge. I asked earlier if you had orders or other documentation to such, yes?

Did bad things happen to American Indians that were on reservation or in child home of the day? Yes. But I can also show you child homes for white children of the day, where similar things and conditions existed.

The south was rebuilding from the Civil War and was barely feeding
the southern population. The north was trying to convert from a military economy to a peace time. A warring Indian nation got caught in the middle of a country trying to rebuild and change. The US simply did not have a lot to give.

My great-great grand parents were southern. They lived in a cover wagon (not a house) for nearly 35 years after the Civil War ended. That is how bad things were during the soutern reconstruction of post Civil War. Now put that into context and in trying to feed and care for the Plain Indian nations as the Indian wars ended and they made their way to reservation.

This is my last post here, unless you supply some evidence.


The white man may well have suffered as you say but I think the important fact that you are overlooking is that the white man was there by choice, broke and dishonoured many treaties and basically it was the indiginous peoples country in the first place - if somebody invaded anywhere that way today they would never get away with it - and I am fully aware that that was then this is now so I am not having a go at anybody personally.
------ This thread is Archived ------
Feb 17, 2008 8:36 PM CST The Trail of Tears.....
HJFinAZ
HJFinAZHJFinAZSun CIty, Arizona USA870 Threads 1 Polls 17,068 Posts
Hugz_n_Kissez: I think that's the kind of love we all want...I know I do and I know I won't settle for less...It also shows how simplistic love can be and we try to make it sooooooo complicated...Yet it doesn't have to be....


Love is simplistic, it is humans that complicate it..wink


hug
------ This thread is Archived ------
Mar 19, 2008 3:29 AM CST The Trail of Tears.....
wanderinggnome
wanderinggnomewanderinggnomeBelle Fourche, South Dakota USA5 Threads 688 Posts
trish123: Is beautiful Hugz, very in touch with all sorts of important aspects of existence. Based on the Lakotah/Dakotah and relates the tale of a few generations as the demise is approaching - it really touched me, this was 25 or 30 yrs since and it has helped me to find who I am - somehow

scold
Tut tut Trish
"Hanto Yo is NOT well recieved By The Lakota. It is a fictional imagining a band that has no factual evidence of having existed. The ogallala ( the band of which Crazy Horse was for a time a 'shirt wearer") are most indignant about the translation of thier bands name.
The problems and culture of the Native Americans are real, and cannot be explained in a mass market paperback. The current infatuation of Europeans with the "Hollywood Indian" does nothing to help create a solution for these people.
------ This thread is Archived ------
Mar 19, 2008 6:16 AM CST The Trail of Tears.....
HerenNow
HerenNowHerenNowLondon, Greater London, England UK2 Posts
TTom50: I have walked the Oregon Trail and imagined the settlers who wagons fell behind main body. Then were easy prey for the Indian hunting parties....just like the mule driver in Dancing with Wolves. I hold no
anger for the red man. And I have told you the truth the best I know it.



Just an observation TTom50... I don't wish to sound juvenile.... but if someone drove some mules through your kitchen , every day at dinner time, what right would the mule driver have to be "angry" ?
------ This thread is Archived ------
Mar 19, 2008 7:00 AM CST The Trail of Tears.....
wanderinggnome
wanderinggnomewanderinggnomeBelle Fourche, South Dakota USA5 Threads 688 Posts
HerenNow: Just an observation TTom50... I don't wish to sound juvenile.... but if someone drove some mules through your kitchen , every day at dinner time, what right would the mule driver have to be "angry" ?


In the same vein- if you are on your way to an outing with your family and are accosted by a dozen or so street people, demanding you surrender your property for the privilage of passing thru thier territory, would you feel they were justified?

Hindsight is 20/20. To even come close to understanding the actions that took place you have to accept the perception of right and wrong of the peoples involved at that place and time.
------ This thread is Archived ------
Mar 19, 2008 7:56 AM CST The Trail of Tears.....
Hugz_n_Kissez
Hugz_n_KissezHugz_n_KissezSomeplace, Ontario Canada59 Threads 2 Polls 25,438 Posts
wanderinggnome: In the same vein- if you are on your way to an outing with your family and are accosted by a dozen or so street people, demanding you surrender your property for the privilage of passing thru thier territory, would you feel they were justified?

Hindsight is 20/20. To even come close to understanding the actions that took place you have to accept the perception of right and wrong of the peoples involved at that place and time.


I'm sorry but I have no sympathy....and I don't have to accept anyone's version of right and wrong at the time...because right and wrong doesn't change with history...If nobody tried to force the Native people from their land in the first place and just left them alone...then none of this would have come about...It's not about one battle and the Trail of Tears is not about someone crossing someone elses property...It's about genocide....and it was wrong then and it still is today!!!!!!!


Taking land for nothing more than greed is NOT an exscuse to attempt to wipe out another cultures entire existence....NOT to mention...Don't you think the Native people had a right to defend the only places they called home and were fighting not only for their lives...BUT for their very existence...Hardly comparable!!!!!!!!


wine
------ This thread is Archived ------
Post Comment - Post a comment on this Forum Thread

This Thread is Archived

This Thread is archived, so you will no longer be able to post to it. Threads get archived automatically when they are older than 3 months.

« Go back to All Threads
Message #318

Share this Thread

We use cookies to ensure that you have the best experience possible on our website. Read Our Privacy Policy Here