Evolution Vs Creation (135)

Apr 30, 2009 11:39 AM CST Evolution Vs Creation
kawai
kawaikawaiPoint Cook, Victoria Australia3 Threads 354 Posts
kawai: Didn't you see monsters vs aliens? The link was very cleary explaind.


And my very bad spelling is even funnier. rolling on the floor laughing
Apr 30, 2009 2:28 PM CST Evolution Vs Creation
perfectdream2005
perfectdream2005perfectdream2005Hesperingen, Luxembourg Luxembourg15 Threads 10 Polls 64 Posts
I didn't vote because I would need a third option laugh
I think most likely God created humans by the means of evolution laugh yay
Apr 30, 2009 8:03 PM CST Evolution Vs Creation
thelovecats1
thelovecats1thelovecats1canberra, ACT Australia2 Threads 16 Posts
i'll give you one guess as to what i'd like to say in this thread.
Apr 30, 2009 8:14 PM CST Evolution Vs Creation
robplum
robplumrobplumEnsay, Victoria Australia107 Threads 1 Polls 12,031 Posts
thelovecats1: i'll give you one guess as to what i'd like to say in this thread.

Interdepenent Arising
Apr 30, 2009 10:19 PM CST Evolution Vs Creation
Ralf74
Ralf74Ralf74Bacchus Marsh, Victoria Australia44 Threads 2 Polls 4,241 Posts
bourbon: I'd say "Oh My God"... but I haven't got one.


I'll be your god, I bet i could get you yelling it!! wink laugh
Apr 30, 2009 11:23 PM CST Evolution Vs Creation
thelovecats1
thelovecats1thelovecats1canberra, ACT Australia2 Threads 16 Posts
i'd like to say something but i don't want to be seen inciting violence or hatred against religious nutters but i will say this much, ATHEISTS OF THE WORLD UNITE AND TAKE OVER. those who are into The Smiths will notice that i used the word ATHEIST and not SHOPLIFTERS. sorry Moz, hope you still love me!laugh
May 1, 2009 12:08 AM CST Evolution Vs Creation
lerald
leraldleraldCleveland, Ohio USA4 Threads 2 Polls 180 Posts
kizzy27: what if evolution was created by god


What if "God" was created by humans?
May 1, 2009 1:41 AM CST Evolution Vs Creation
kizzy27
kizzy27kizzy27a south coast beach, New South Wales Australia106 Threads 6 Polls 7,413 Posts
lerald: What if "God" was created by humans?

What if god was one of us ? Just a shuck Like one of us ? rolling on the floor laughing
May 1, 2009 1:43 AM CST Evolution Vs Creation
kizzy27
kizzy27kizzy27a south coast beach, New South Wales Australia106 Threads 6 Polls 7,413 Posts
kizzy27: What if god was one of us ? Just a shuck Like one of us ?


shmuck.....doh
May 1, 2009 6:49 AM CST Evolution Vs Creation
relaxin
relaxinrelaxinsomewhere, Queensland Australia33 Threads 3 Polls 1,371 Posts
Damianowen: No ! The more information we have the less we believe in the old man in the clouds. Monkeys didn't ponder their existence until they smartened up a bit.






wow uh oh thought there were some strange looking students around now sigh
May 1, 2009 7:17 AM CST Evolution Vs Creation
bourbon
bourbonbourbonSunshine Coast, Queensland Australia32 Threads 4 Polls 3,504 Posts
relaxin: thought there were some strange looking students around now


rolling on the floor laughing
May 1, 2009 7:19 AM CST Evolution Vs Creation
bubblesron
bubblesronbubblesronmaryborough, Queensland Australia442 Posts
kizzy27: what if evolution was created by god


Have always felt that the two theories are not mutually exclusive. We were taught that the 7 days was not 7 of our days, it could have been over millions of years, and the first homo sapiens could have been adam and eve?
The question of creation defies logic, as does the existance of a god in any form. Belief requires a "leap of faith" to put it in philosophical terms. So unless one is prepared to put aside science and logic to make that leap, evolution must win out.
As far as I am concerned, the jury is still out. I have not found a satisfactory answer in nearly 61 years so i doubt if I will find one before I leave this life.
May 1, 2009 7:27 AM CST Evolution Vs Creation
relaxin
relaxinrelaxinsomewhere, Queensland Australia33 Threads 3 Polls 1,371 Posts
bubblesron: Have always felt that the two theories are not mutually exclusive. We were taught that the 7 days was not 7 of our days, it could have been over millions of years, and the first homo sapiens could have been adam and eve?
The question of creation defies logic, as does the existance of a god in any form. Belief requires a "leap of faith" to put it in philosophical terms. So unless one is prepared to put aside science and logic to make that leap, evolution must win out.
As far as I am concerned, the jury is still out. I have not found a satisfactory answer in nearly 61 years so i doubt if I will find one before I leave this life.


do you know of any 2 ppl who can describe a colour exactly the same way and agree on what they were discribing when they see it??

i think that even the definations of evolution and creation may differ in various ways ..... hug
May 1, 2009 10:14 AM CST Evolution Vs Creation
No1knows1
No1knows1No1knows1Rockhampton, Queensland Australia182 Posts
Damianowen: I'm interested to know the state of the debate here on CS. I would start a thread but I'm sure it's been done to death. The poll probably has been to but I missed it so if you will...... If you think it warrants a new thread, feel free to start it but please notify me !!


Created by living origins! Whilst looking at this through
a microscope would look like art in the making it is was
not done by an actual artist!! IMOAprofessor
May 1, 2009 5:37 PM CST Evolution Vs Creation
truladee
truladeetruladeeWorcester, Massachusetts USA19 Posts
bubblesron: Have always felt that the two theories are not mutually exclusive. We were taught that the 7 days was not 7 of our days, it could have been over millions of years, and the first homo sapiens could have been adam and eve?
The question of creation defies logic, as does the existance of a god in any form. Belief requires a "leap of faith" to put it in philosophical terms. So unless one is prepared to put aside science and logic to make that leap, evolution must win out.
As far as I am concerned, the jury is still out. I have not found a satisfactory answer in nearly 61 years so i doubt if I will find one before I leave this life.



Well, I think it's true-and maybe some evolution believers may not be aware- but there are many views of creation...there's the 7 days is 7 days belief....and there are others as well... At the end of the day, science believe it or not can support either belief. Each persons view of God will play the main role in thier belief about creation or evolution. I encourage you to be open about creation....
May 1, 2009 10:34 PM CST Evolution Vs Creation
blondeaozichick
blondeaozichickblondeaozichickMelbourne, Victoria Australia60 Threads 1 Polls 4,392 Posts
I am waiting for someone to invent the first ever time machine so we can settle this age old argument for good laugh

personally I think all religions and their associated story books like the bible are just that... stories/myths/legends that have been passed on down through the ages ... and it first they were passed down verbally .. ever played the game of chinese whispers?.. how different is the story by the time the 10 or 20th person repeats it dunno

thousands of years ago they didn't have the benefit of science and knowledge to explain a lot of the things that were seen back then as 'miracles' .. we do now

yes I believe we have divine helpers who share a collective knowledge and help us on our journey through each lifetime.. I do not believe that one all knowing, all powerful entity created life as we know it

however.. I guess none of us will know for sure until we pass over from this life into the afterlife
May 1, 2009 11:26 PM CST Evolution Vs Creation
Ralf74
Ralf74Ralf74Bacchus Marsh, Victoria Australia44 Threads 2 Polls 4,241 Posts
thelovecats1: i'd like to say something but i don't want to be seen inciting violence or hatred against religious nutters but i will say this much, ATHEISTS OF THE WORLD UNITE AND TAKE OVER. those who are into The Smiths will notice that i used the word ATHEIST and not SHOPLIFTERS. sorry Moz, hope you still love me!


Why do we as Athiests need to unite and take over? Why can't we just accept that others are free to believe whatever they wish? Why do we feel the need to force our beliefs upon others? I just dont know why we need to find other religions outside of our own beliefs so offensive. I personally think that they all have something to offer and if their faith is what helps people get through the day, then good luck to them.
May 1, 2009 11:51 PM CST Evolution Vs Creation
goldiloxgirl
goldiloxgirlgoldiloxgirlSydney North West, New South Wales Australia4 Posts
[there is too many unanswered questions!/quote]


Humans have always struggled with the concept of something coming out of nothing. Our minds are finite and simply cannot grasp what is an infinite reality. Evolution explains how matter changes form and relies on the 'big bang' theory where all matter was 'created' out of dense energy, but does not explain how this energy came into existence. The creationist's position however, ascribes this creation to an infinite being.

The belief in an infinite God merely recognises that existence is beyond humans comprehension and requires a default to a infinitely higher being. We can learn about the building blocks of life as much as we like but as we are finite beings we will never comprehend infinity or how something comes out of nothing.

I believe the rejection of an infinite being, has to do with not accepting the perceived moral implications of the existence of God, rather than a lack of evidence of His existence. In the end it is our own existence along with the natural realms that declares there is a God. Without God we cannot answer the questions of how we came into being and what is our purpose.

If mud slinging follows an in depth discussion on this topic, it is because proponents for and against creation are both afraid...afraid that they are wrong. The person who knows 100% that their belief is right does not fear but rests peacefully in their position.
May 1, 2009 11:52 PM CST Evolution Vs Creation
blondeaozichick
blondeaozichickblondeaozichickMelbourne, Victoria Australia60 Threads 1 Polls 4,392 Posts
melty1: I think in all countries and cultures around the world worship the same god, but in diferent ways!



thumbs up yep.. same god ... different names for it


and some cultures/religions have lots of gods


I found an interestng website if you wanna know about lots of different gods

May 1, 2009 11:53 PM CST Evolution Vs Creation
blondeaozichick
blondeaozichickblondeaozichickMelbourne, Victoria Australia60 Threads 1 Polls 4,392 Posts
Ralf74: Why do we as Athiests need to unite and take over? Why can't we just accept that others are free to believe whatever they wish? Why do we feel the need to force our beliefs upon others? I just dont know why we need to find other religions outside of our own beliefs so offensive. I personally think that they all have something to offer and if their faith is what helps people get through the day, then good luck to them.


thumbs up right on Ralfy
May 2, 2009 5:52 AM CST Evolution Vs Creation
truladee
truladeetruladeeWorcester, Massachusetts USA19 Posts
goldiloxgirl: [there is too many unanswered questions!/quote]Humans have always struggled with the concept of something coming out of nothing. Our minds are finite and simply cannot grasp what is an infinite reality. Evolution explains how matter changes form and relies on the 'big bang' theory where all matter was 'created' out of dense energy, but does not explain how this energy came into existence. The creationist's position however, ascribes this creation to an infinite being.

The belief in an infinite God merely recognises that existence is beyond humans comprehension and requires a default to a infinitely higher being. We can learn about the building blocks of life as much as we like but as we are finite beings we will never comprehend infinity or how something comes out of nothing.

I believe the rejection of an infinite being, has to do with not accepting the perceived moral implications of the existence of God, rather than a lack of evidence of His existence. In the end it is our own existence along with the natural realms that declares there is a God. Without God we cannot answer the questions of how we came into being and what is our purpose.

If mud slinging follows an in depth discussion on this topic, it is because proponents for and against creation are both afraid...afraid that they are wrong. The person who knows 100% that their belief is right does not fear but rests peacefully in their position.



Wow---Well said!!!
May 2, 2009 7:19 AM CST Evolution Vs Creation
viper3310
viper3310viper3310Gladstone, Queensland Australia13 Threads 199 Posts
Hiya all,

I couldn't help but add to this topic and say my opinion :)

I personally belive that there is a higher being or beings not just one specific person.

I do have one thought on the whole heaven and hell theroy though, If the both exist and they were created by god, then the way i see it is that this is hell and we all keep getting sent back here until we get it right. If thats wrong the explain to me why some of the most wonderful and undeserving people I know constantly have the worst that life can throw at you thrown at them????


Just my 2 cents worth :) Hope everyone is well..

teddybear
May 2, 2009 7:28 AM CST Evolution Vs Creation
Ralf74
Ralf74Ralf74Bacchus Marsh, Victoria Australia44 Threads 2 Polls 4,241 Posts
viper3310: Hiya all,

I couldn't help but add to this topic and say my opinion :)

I personally belive that there is a higher being or beings not just one specific person.

I do have one thought on the whole heaven and hell theroy though, If the both exist and they were created by god, then the way i see it is that this is hell and we all keep getting sent back here until we get it right. If thats wrong the explain to me why some of the most wonderful and undeserving people I know constantly have the worst that life can throw at you thrown at them????Just my 2 cents worth :) Hope everyone is well..


Hey Viper, good to see your smiley face again! grin wave
May 2, 2009 7:33 AM CST Evolution Vs Creation
viper3310
viper3310viper3310Gladstone, Queensland Australia13 Threads 199 Posts
Ralf74: Hey Viper, good to see your smiley face again!


Hey there honey,

good to see you too, i just said hi to you in bar.

talk soon ok

teddybear
May 2, 2009 9:09 PM CST Evolution Vs Creation
Damianowen
DamianowenDamianowenDubbo, New South Wales Australia14 Threads 4 Polls 718 Posts
zztopbanana: How do you know monkeys ponder their existence ?


Actually I can't say for sure either way whether or not monkeys ever ponder their existance but I do seriously doubt it. What I meant was, there was no god until intelligence evolved.
May 2, 2009 9:12 PM CST Evolution Vs Creation
Damianowen
DamianowenDamianowenDubbo, New South Wales Australia14 Threads 4 Polls 718 Posts
kawai: Isn't that what I just said? Maybe I misunderstood you in the first place, but the way I see it, the more intelligent we get, the less we believe in religion.


There's a big difference between intelligence and information.
May 2, 2009 9:18 PM CST Evolution Vs Creation
Damianowen
DamianowenDamianowenDubbo, New South Wales Australia14 Threads 4 Polls 718 Posts
Ralf74: Why do we as Athiests need to unite and take over? Why can't we just accept that others are free to believe whatever they wish? Why do we feel the need to force our beliefs upon others? I just dont know why we need to find other religions outside of our own beliefs so offensive. I personally think that they all have something to offer and if their faith is what helps people get through the day, then good luck to them.


But so many people have died in the name of their religion. It's a matter of the nonprolferation of that mentality.
May 2, 2009 11:39 PM CST Evolution Vs Creation
goldiloxgirl
goldiloxgirlgoldiloxgirlSydney North West, New South Wales Australia4 Posts
truladee: Wow---Well said!!!


To follow on from the premise outlined earlier regarding being at peace with your belief, the reason for that serenity is simple. If I want to know the truth regarding anything then I first must be willing to accept the implications of knowing that truth. If I am willing to do so, then the moral impediment to knowing it is gone and I have no inner conflict. It is that lack of inner conflict that gives rise to being peaceful in what I believe.

If I were not willing to accept the implications of there being a creator then I would raise all manner of objections to His existence. If I am willing to accept the implications then the evidence of His being becomes obvious. If the fact that something has come out of nothing is insufficient then the very order of all creation cries volumes to declare God's existence. However, we see in that order something insidious , for there is a decay that works against creation and brings with it pain and suffering.

And what are the implications of the existence of an infinite creator? If I was created by someone then I am their property and if I am their property then likely there is a purpose for my life and with that purpose a responsibility. If I do something that harms His property-whether to myself or another person- then I have harmed His order and created a debt to Him in so doing.

Rather than being responsible to the creator for my life, it would be so much easier to deny His existence and live my life on my own account. To do that I would then need to obfuscate all the obvious pointers to God's existence and seek out new objections to the cries of my God given conscience.

To deny God I would say "If there is a God then why do babies die?" or "if God is so loving then why are there wars?" or "why are religious people such hypocrites?" or many other similarly veined objections. The answer to those questions goes right back to the implications of not accepting God and the incumbent responsibility to Him. It is in the rejection of God's claim on our lives that decay of His order takes place.

No, this is not a question of evidence (which is essentially what science is about) but is a question of acceptance of moral implications of that evidence.
May 3, 2009 5:10 AM CST Evolution Vs Creation
bourbon
bourbonbourbonSunshine Coast, Queensland Australia32 Threads 4 Polls 3,504 Posts
goldiloxgirl: To follow on from the premise outlined earlier regarding being at peace with your belief, the reason for that serenity is simple. If I want to know the truth regarding anything then I first must be willing to accept the implications of knowing that truth. If I am willing to do so, then the moral impediment to knowing it is gone and I have no inner conflict. It is that lack of inner conflict that gives rise to being peaceful in what I believe.

If I were not willing to accept the implications of there being a creator then I would raise all manner of objections to His existence. If I am willing to accept the implications then the evidence of His being becomes obvious. If the fact that something has come out of nothing is insufficient then the very order of all creation cries volumes to declare God's existence. However, we see in that order something insidious , for there is a decay that works against creation and brings with it pain and suffering.

And what are the implications of the existence of an infinite creator? If I was created by someone then I am their property and if I am their property then likely there is a purpose for my life and with that purpose a responsibility. If I do something that harms His property-whether to myself or another person- then I have harmed His order and created a debt to Him in so doing.

Rather than being responsible to the creator for my life, it would be so much easier to deny His existence and live my life on my own account. To do that I would then need to obfuscate all the obvious pointers to God's existence and seek out new objections to the cries of my God given conscience.

To deny God I would say "If there is a God then why do babies die?" or "if God is so loving then why are there wars?" or "why are religious people such hypocrites?" or many other similarly veined objections. The answer to those questions goes right back to the implications of not accepting God and the incumbent responsibility to Him. It is in the rejection of God's claim on our lives that decay of His order takes place.

No, this is not a question of evidence (which is essentially what science is about) but is a question of acceptance of moral implications of that evidence.


Can I draw your attention to the only TRUE religion, the Church of the Flying Spaghetti Monster.



On this website you will find much testament to the Flying Spaghetti Monster. As YOUR religion is based solely on testament, surely you cannot deny the testament presented in this website is irrefutable proof that the Flying Spaghetti Monster IS the one, only and true god. drinking
May 3, 2009 7:06 AM CST Evolution Vs Creation
Ralf74
Ralf74Ralf74Bacchus Marsh, Victoria Australia44 Threads 2 Polls 4,241 Posts
Damianowen: But so many people have died in the name of their religion. It's a matter of the nonprolferation of that mentality.


yes, that is true but i refer to religion on a personal level not as a sect, cult, church, gathering, whatever the fark you want to call them, the institutions which coerce their members to commit such acts. That is my point, people do not need to belong to any of these to believe anything they want nor should they be judged for doing so. Many people observe their own forms of faith be it a higher being, a combination of beliefs, no faith at all, worshipping idols or demons, witchcraft. Whatever is your choice should be your choice and not be forced upon others in any way from violent acts to preaching to others. Your religious beliefs are yours and are nobody elses business.

Share this Poll

We use cookies to ensure that you have the best experience possible on our website. Read Our Privacy Policy Here