THE GREAT HARD- BOILED EGG CONTROVERSY : HOW LONG TO COOK THEM ? ( Archived) (37)

Nov 12, 2011 10:26 AM CSTTHE GREAT HARD- BOILED EGG CONTROVERSY : HOW LONG TO COOK THEM ?
wonderworker
wonderworkerwonderworkercosby, Tennessee, USA201 Threads 2 Polls 1,883 Posts

THE GREAT HARD- BOILED EGG CONTROVERSY : HOW LONG TO COOK THEM ?(Vote Below)

- (To Vote: select an option above, then press this button)
Less than 3 minutes
4
5%
4 minutes
14
18%
5 minutes
17
22%
6 minutes
3
4%
7 minutes
6
8%
8 1/2 minutes
6
8%
10 minutes
10
13%
15 minutes
6
8%
20 minutes
6
8%
Forever and a day
4
5%
Total Votes
76
This is an important issue.
TennesseeJudy overcooks eggs.
How can I be expected to live with such a culinary travesty ?

cool
------ This thread is Archived ------
Nov 12, 2011 10:27 AM CST THE GREAT HARD- BOILED EGG CONTROVERSY : HOW LONG TO COOK THEM ?
wonderworker: This is an important issue.
TennesseeJudy overcooks eggs.
How can I be expected to live with such a culinary travesty ?
Boil until SOFT!professor laugh
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 12, 2011 10:29 AM CST THE GREAT HARD- BOILED EGG CONTROVERSY : HOW LONG TO COOK THEM ?
montecito
montecitomontecitoLovely, New Jersey USA96 Threads 2 Polls 5,086 Posts
SLOW boil for 5 minutes. Then let sit in the water off the heat for 5 minutes. Then rinse and rinse and rinse in very cold water until the water doesn't retain heat from the egg. This will give you a shell that you can peel off easily.
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 12, 2011 10:35 AM CST THE GREAT HARD- BOILED EGG CONTROVERSY : HOW LONG TO COOK THEM ?
bestbefore
bestbeforebestbeforesomewhere, Dorset, England UK116 Threads 2 Polls 4,701 Posts
This is an important issue.
TennesseeJudy overcooks eggs.
How can IHow to boil an egg

The answer to this is carefully. Even the simplest of cooking demands a degree of care and attention. But in the end all it involves is first knowing the right way to proceed and then happily being able to boil perfect eggs for the rest of your life without even having to think about it. What we need to do first of all, though, is memorise a few very important rules.

1. Don't ever boil eggs that have come straight from the refrigerator, because very cold eggs plunged straight into hot water are likely to crack.
2. Always use a kitchen timer. Trying to guess the timing or even remembering to look at your watch can be hazardous.
3. Remember the air pocket? During the boiling, pressure can build up and cause cracking. A simple way to deal with this is to make a pinprick in the rounded end of the shell, as left, which will allow the steam to esape.
4. Always use a small saucepan. Eggs with too much space to career around in and crash into one another while they cook are, again, likely to crack.
5. Never have the water fast-boiling: a gentle simmer is all they need.
6. Never overboil eggs (you won't if you have a timer). This is the cardinal sin because the yolks will turn black and the texture will be like rubber.
7. If the eggs are very fresh (less than four days old), allow an extra 30 seconds on each timing.




Soft-boiled eggs - method 1
Obviously every single one of us has a personal preference as to precisely how we like our eggs cooked. Over the years I have found a method that is both simple and reliable, and the various timings set out here seem to accommodate all tastes. First of all have a small saucepan filled with enough simmering water to cover the eggs by about 1/2 inch (1cm). Then quickly but gently lower the eggs into the water, one at a time, using a tablespoon. Now switch the timer on and give the eggs exactly 1 minute's simmering time. Then remove the pan from the heat, put a lid on it and set the timer again, giving the following timings:
6 minutes will produce a soft, fairly liquid yolk and a white that is just set but still quite wobbly.
7 minutes will produce a firmer, more creamy yolk with a white that is completely set.


Soft-boiled eggs - method 2
I have found this alternative method also works extremely well. This time you place the eggs in the saucepan, cover them with cold water by about 1/2 inch (1cm), place them on a high heat and, as soon as they reach boiling point, reduce the heat to a gentle simmer and give the following timings:
3 minutes if you like a really soft-boiled egg
4 minutes for a white that is just set and a yolk that is creamy.
5 minutes for a white and yolk perfectly set, with only a little bit of squidgy in the centre.


Hard-boiled eggs
Some people hate soft-boiled eggs and like to eat them straight from the shell, hard-boiled. All well and good, but if you want to use hard-boiled eggs in a recipe and have to peel them, this can be extremely tricky if the eggs are too fresh. The number one rule, therefore, is to use eggs that are at least five days old from their packing date. The method is as follows: place the eggs in a saucepan and add enough cold water to cover them by about 1/2 inch (1cm). Bring the water up to simmering point, put a timer on for 6 minutes if you like a bit of squidgy in the centre, 7 minutes if you like them cooked through. Then, the most important part is to cool them rapidly under cold running water. Let the cold tap run over them for about 1 minute, then leave them in cold water till they're cool enough to handle - about 2 minutes. Once you've mastered the art of boiling eggs you can serve them in a variety of ways, and one of my favourites is in a curry.


Hope this helps with your dilemma or were you eggsagerating.



rolling on the floor laughing
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 12, 2011 10:47 AM CST THE GREAT HARD- BOILED EGG CONTROVERSY : HOW LONG TO COOK THEM ?
wonderworker
wonderworkerwonderworkercosby, Tennessee USA201 Threads 2 Polls 1,883 Posts
Slow Boil ?
As in Simmer ?
cool
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 12, 2011 10:49 AM CST THE GREAT HARD- BOILED EGG CONTROVERSY : HOW LONG TO COOK THEM ?
wonderworker
wonderworkerwonderworkercosby, Tennessee USA201 Threads 2 Polls 1,883 Posts
HARD-boiled eggs Conrad.....HARD !
cool
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 12, 2011 10:50 AM CST THE GREAT HARD- BOILED EGG CONTROVERSY : HOW LONG TO COOK THEM ?
montecito
montecitomontecitoLovely, New Jersey USA96 Threads 2 Polls 5,086 Posts
wonderworker: Slow Boil ?
As in Simmer ?


Right. If the water is in a fast boil it will crack the shell. Slow boil meaning the water tumbles just enough that it isn't standing still.
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 12, 2011 10:51 AM CST THE GREAT HARD- BOILED EGG CONTROVERSY : HOW LONG TO COOK THEM ?
lifeisadream
lifeisadreamlifeisadreamMexi Go, Mexico State Mexico156 Threads 20 Polls 16,713 Posts
bestbefore: This is an important issue.
TennesseeJudy overcooks eggs.
How can IHow to boil an egg

The answer to this is carefully. Even the simplest of cooking demands a degree of care and attention. But in the end all it involves is first knowing the right way to proceed and then happily being able to boil perfect eggs for the rest of your life without even having to think about it. What we need to do first of all, though, is memorise a few very important rules.

1. Don't ever boil eggs that have come straight from the refrigerator, because very cold eggs plunged straight into hot water are likely to crack.
2. Always use a kitchen timer. Trying to guess the timing or even remembering to look at your watch can be hazardous.
3. Remember the air pocket? During the boiling, pressure can build up and cause cracking. A simple way to deal with this is to make a pinprick in the rounded end of the shell, as left, which will allow the steam to esape.
4. Always use a small saucepan. Eggs with too much space to career around in and crash into one another while they cook are, again, likely to crack.
5. Never have the water fast-boiling: a gentle simmer is all they need.
6. Never overboil eggs (you won't if you have a timer). This is the cardinal sin because the yolks will turn black and the texture will be like rubber.
7. If the eggs are very fresh (less than four days old), allow an extra 30 seconds on each timing.




Soft-boiled eggs - method 1
Obviously every single one of us has a personal preference as to precisely how we like our eggs cooked. Over the years I have found a method that is both simple and reliable, and the various timings set out here seem to accommodate all tastes. First of all have a small ....

6 minutes will produce a soft, fairly liquid yolk and a white that is just set but still quite wobbly.
7 minutes will produce a firmer, more creamy yolk with a white that is completely set.


Soft-boiled eggs - method 2
I have found this alternative method also works extremely well. This time you place the eggs in the saucepan, cover them with cold water by about 1/2 inch (1cm), place them on a high heat and, as soon as they reach boiling point, reduce the heat to a gentle simmer and give the following timings:
3 minutes if you like a really soft-boiled egg
4 minutes for a white that is just set and a yolk that is creamy.
5 minutes for a white and yolk perfectly set, with only a little bit of squidgy in the centre.


Hard-boiled eggs
Some people hate soft-boiled eggs and like to eat them straight from the shell, hard-boiled. All well and good, but if you want to use hard-boiled eggs in a recipe and have to peel them, this can be extremely tricky if the eggs are too fresh. The number one rule, therefore, is to use eggs that are at least five days old from their packing date. The method is as follows: place the eggs in a saucepan and add enough cold water to cover them by about 1/2 inch (1cm). Bring the water up to simmering point, put a timer on for 6 minutes if you like a bit of squidgy in the centre, 7 minutes if you like them cooked through. Then, the most important part is to cool them rapidly under cold running water. Let the cold tap run over them for about 1 minute, then leave them in cold water till they're cool enough to handle - about 2 minutes. Once you've mastered the art of boiling eggs you can serve them in a variety of ways, and one of my favourites is in a curry. Hope this helps with your dilemma or were you eggsagerating.


wave


What types of eggs are you talking about?

From hens or from ostrich birds?


dunno

rolling on the floor laughing
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 12, 2011 10:51 AM CST THE GREAT HARD- BOILED EGG CONTROVERSY : HOW LONG TO COOK THEM ?
wonderworker
wonderworkerwonderworkercosby, Tennessee USA201 Threads 2 Polls 1,883 Posts
Wow !
Jesus H. Christ.
Thank you very much.

.....maybe I'll just give up eggs now....
cool
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 12, 2011 10:57 AM CST THE GREAT HARD- BOILED EGG CONTROVERSY : HOW LONG TO COOK THEM ?
montecito
montecitomontecitoLovely, New Jersey USA96 Threads 2 Polls 5,086 Posts
wonderworker: Wow !
Jesus H. Christ.
Thank you very much.

.....maybe I'll just give up eggs now....


Don't give them up, the yolk is good for your hair and it has iron. But be careful cause the yolk is where the fat and cholesterol is. When I make scrambled eggs I use two yolks and 3 whites. You can do the same thing with hard boiled eggs.
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 12, 2011 11:10 AM CST THE GREAT HARD- BOILED EGG CONTROVERSY : HOW LONG TO COOK THEM ?
mustbnutz
mustbnutzmustbnutzKingman, Arizona USA33 Threads 5 Polls 3,730 Posts
Monti nailed it.......this is the best way....cheers
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 12, 2011 11:11 AM CST THE GREAT HARD- BOILED EGG CONTROVERSY : HOW LONG TO COOK THEM ?
Good advice about letting the eggs come up to room temp. Also very true about using older eggs, my eggs make lousy hard boiled eggs because they are too fresh. White eggs also are better hard boiled than brown eggs from my exp.
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 12, 2011 11:14 AM CST THE GREAT HARD- BOILED EGG CONTROVERSY : HOW LONG TO COOK THEM ?
FreddyFudpucker
FreddyFudpuckerFreddyFudpuckerObamaville, Indiana USA10,179 Posts
Put them in the microwave on a plate for 3 minutes!

I guarantee you won't have any runny yolk!
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 12, 2011 11:29 AM CST THE GREAT HARD- BOILED EGG CONTROVERSY : HOW LONG TO COOK THEM ?
Frankinstien
FrankinstienFrankinstienSan Juan, Puerto Rico1 Threads 1,521 Posts
montecito: Don't give them up, the yolk is good for your hair and it has iron. But be careful cause the yolk is where the fat and cholesterol is. When I make scrambled eggs I use two yolks and 3 whites. You can do the same thing with hard boiled eggs.
Yes the yoke has the cholesterol but it isn't that much compared to a lot of other common foods . They also are high in protien . Don't over do them and you will be all right, They also can be turned into deviled eggs ( the best ). .
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 12, 2011 11:37 AM CST THE GREAT HARD- BOILED EGG CONTROVERSY : HOW LONG TO COOK THEM ?
montecito
montecitomontecitoLovely, New Jersey USA96 Threads 2 Polls 5,086 Posts
Frankinstien: Yes the yoke has the cholesterol but it isn't that much compared to a lot of other common foods . They also are high in protien . Don't over do them and you will be all right, They also can be turned into deviled eggs ( the best ). .


It depends on how many eggs someone eats. If they like a western breakfast everyday, which is steak, eggs, buttered toast and fried potatoes, that's a lot of fat and cholesterol. Even if it's not a western breakfast and a city guy eats eggs every morning, each egg has 235 mg of cholesterol. Two eggs every day is a whopping amount of cholesterol in addition to other foods one eats. It's a personal choice. I love eggs but I don't eat them more then twice a week and like I said, I cut back on the yolk.
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 12, 2011 11:41 AM CST THE GREAT HARD- BOILED EGG CONTROVERSY : HOW LONG TO COOK THEM ?
wolfenfun
wolfenfunwolfenfunriddle, Oregon USA16 Threads 5 Polls 302 Posts
montecito: It depends on how many eggs someone eats. If they like a western breakfast everyday, which is steak, eggs, buttered toast and fried potatoes, that's a lot of fat and cholesterol. Even if it's not a western breakfast and a city guy eats eggs every morning, each egg has 235 mg of cholesterol. Two eggs every day is a whopping amount of cholesterol in addition to other foods one eats. It's a personal choice. I love eggs but I don't eat them more then twice a week and like I said, I cut back on the yolk.
cook until done how you like them, if you cannot do that, stay out of the kitchen, or hire some one who knows what the heck ther're doing.
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 12, 2011 11:44 AM CST THE GREAT HARD- BOILED EGG CONTROVERSY : HOW LONG TO COOK THEM ?
montecito: He will have pieces of egg all over the microwave....Bad Freddy ..
That may depend on how long ya nuke 'em! That reminds me of the very first time I nuked an egg. Everything came out right, the shell peeled off nicely and here I was holding a perfect hard-boiled nuked egg!
So I lightly salted it and took a bite...
The thing exploded and went everywhere!

I felt like Wile E Coyote after having a cigar bomb go off in my face! mumbling

rolling on the floor laughing
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 12, 2011 11:46 AM CST THE GREAT HARD- BOILED EGG CONTROVERSY : HOW LONG TO COOK THEM ?
montecito
montecitomontecitoLovely, New Jersey USA96 Threads 2 Polls 5,086 Posts
wolfenfun: cook until done how you like them, if you cannot do that, stay out of the kitchen, or hire some one who knows what the heck ther're doing.


wow
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 12, 2011 12:01 PM CST THE GREAT HARD- BOILED EGG CONTROVERSY : HOW LONG TO COOK THEM ?
FreddyFudpucker
FreddyFudpuckerFreddyFudpuckerObamaville, Indiana USA10,179 Posts
YouMeUs: That may depend on how long ya nuke 'em! That reminds me of the very first time I nuked an egg. Everything came out right, the shell peeled off nicely and here I was holding a perfect hard-boiled nuked egg!
So I lightly salted it and took a bite...
The thing exploded and went everywhere!

I felt like Wile E Coyote after having a cigar bomb go off in my face!
rolling on the floor laughing

Mine blew up in the microwave. It took an hour to get all the egg/shells cleaned up. It was a freakin' mess! laugh
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 12, 2011 12:04 PM CST THE GREAT HARD- BOILED EGG CONTROVERSY : HOW LONG TO COOK THEM ?
FreddyFudpucker
FreddyFudpuckerFreddyFudpuckerObamaville, Indiana USA10,179 Posts
TheresMyFriend: Morning Freddy:

Odd that you should mention the Microwave! TRUE STORY:

Many moons ago, during my 2nd marriage, when my intelligence was not that high on the scale, and any good ideas, (in my mind), would be the worlds answer to another problem. Yea, right!

I had some boiled eggs left over from Easter, and I had a craving to eat a hard boiled egg...just as a quick snack....

Sooooo, my idea was to place one in the Microwave, and watch it very, very close... to where it was "JUST" (operative word here) at the point of cracking (finger set to push "stop") at that very crucial point.

My idea was that, if it was starting to swell from the inside, enough to pressure the shell to crack, then it would be warm enough to eat! Now, I'm a fairly intelligent person...with what I thought to be plenty of common sense as well.

OK, carefully peeling the shell from the now, warmed up boiled egg, being very proud of myself...prancing around like the "rooster that laid the prettiest hen"!

I placed the egg up to my lips, proud of my accomplishment, and gently and slowly biting into the egg!!!!!! POWWWWWWW, was all I heard!

Did you know that a boiled egg with that much built-up internal pressure, WILL sound like shotgun or M80 when you pierce the egg while halfway in your mouth? Well, let tell you...IT DOES!!! My ears rang for a good 20 minutes, my 1st thought was to go look in the mirror, to see if my upper lip was still there, and that I had not blown it off. Keep in mind, as I'm examining the lips, I also noticed that my mustache was now sort of a whitish/yellowish color (ears still ringing, lips burning)! The wife laughing so hard, she fell of the stool! After explaining to her, MY great adea, and what had happened...I returned to the kitchen to look and clean up the mess...and the rest of the egg! Guess what...the egg WAS GONE! I finally concluded that the egg that did not get caught in my mustache, had descentagrated !!!

This is my story, and I'm sticking to it!
Have a great weekend....

-John-



I'm trying to think of who I could invite over for a few hard boiled eggs??? rolling on the floor laughing


That was rolling on the floor laughing
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 12, 2011 12:35 PM CST THE GREAT HARD- BOILED EGG CONTROVERSY : HOW LONG TO COOK THEM ?
lifeisadream: I use the microwave only to heat or reheat some food mostly in the morning –like the soy milk for my coffee and a few other things- and I am not a fan of the boiling eggs in either way.

But trying to find a solution for the eggs being cooked in the microwave, would it be better if you set the eggs in water then in the microwave?

If not using water to cook an egg in the microwave would it help to make a tiny little hole with a needle for the pressure to escape, would that be enough?

Not that would try either of those but I was wondering if you could.


Not sure the water idea would work on an egg, that was already hard boiled. Being that the Microwave is going to heat "from the inside"! dunno

-John-wave
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 12, 2011 12:46 PM CST THE GREAT HARD- BOILED EGG CONTROVERSY : HOW LONG TO COOK THEM ?
lifeisadream
lifeisadreamlifeisadreamMexi Go, Mexico State Mexico156 Threads 20 Polls 16,713 Posts
TheresMyFriend: Not sure the water idea would work on an egg, that was already hard boiled. Being that the Microwave is going to heat "from the inside"!

-John-


Keep us informed of the findings with the microwave and the eggs, please.

grin


And thank you for the info.

wave
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 12, 2011 1:23 PM CST THE GREAT HARD- BOILED EGG CONTROVERSY : HOW LONG TO COOK THEM ?
FreddyFudpucker
FreddyFudpuckerFreddyFudpuckerObamaville, Indiana USA10,179 Posts
This is an eggciting thread! grin














doh
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 12, 2011 1:31 PM CST THE GREAT HARD- BOILED EGG CONTROVERSY : HOW LONG TO COOK THEM ?
FreddyFudpucker
FreddyFudpuckerFreddyFudpuckerObamaville, Indiana USA10,179 Posts
TheresMyFriend: Yea...and don't forget "EGGPLOSIVE" too!



And the yolk was on you! rolling on the floor laughing
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 12, 2011 1:44 PM CST THE GREAT HARD- BOILED EGG CONTROVERSY : HOW LONG TO COOK THEM ?
FreddyFudpucker
FreddyFudpuckerFreddyFudpuckerObamaville, Indiana USA10,179 Posts
lifeisadream: What are you smoking?

I want the same, but I do not smoke!!



I get my stuff south of the border. rolling on the floor laughing


(an attempt at a yoke) help
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 12, 2011 1:58 PM CST THE GREAT HARD- BOILED EGG CONTROVERSY : HOW LONG TO COOK THEM ?
FreddyFudpucker
FreddyFudpuckerFreddyFudpuckerObamaville, Indiana USA10,179 Posts
Sorry Life... bouquet






















laugh
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 12, 2011 3:07 PM CST THE GREAT HARD- BOILED EGG CONTROVERSY : HOW LONG TO COOK THEM ?
tennesseejudy
tennesseejudytennesseejudyNew Holland, Pennsylvania USA54 Threads 2 Polls 1,540 Posts
wonderworker: This is an important issue.
TennesseeJudy overcooks eggs.
How can I be expected to live with such a culinary travesty ?


How funny! Now the age old question....does the size matter "eggxactly"?
These were small eggs.
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 12, 2011 4:02 PM CST THE GREAT HARD- BOILED EGG CONTROVERSY : HOW LONG TO COOK THEM ?
bestbefore
bestbeforebestbeforesomewhere, Dorset, England UK116 Threads 2 Polls 4,701 Posts
lifeisadream: What types of eggs are you talking about?

From hens or from ostrich birds?


Hens eggs of course.My egg cups wont hold an ostrich egg,and probably not my saucepan.rolling on the floor laughing
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 12, 2011 4:08 PM CST THE GREAT HARD- BOILED EGG CONTROVERSY : HOW LONG TO COOK THEM ?
bestbefore
bestbeforebestbeforesomewhere, Dorset, England UK116 Threads 2 Polls 4,701 Posts
tennesseejudy: How funny! Now the age old question....does the size matter "eggxactly"?
These were small eggs.



I'd do what most women would do,make him cook his own.

Can't be doing with all this eggcentricity .yay
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 12, 2011 4:39 PM CST THE GREAT HARD- BOILED EGG CONTROVERSY : HOW LONG TO COOK THEM ?
Lonely1
Lonely1Lonely1Ottawa, Ontario Canada76 Threads 21 Polls 1,858 Posts
bestbefore: I'd do what most women would do,make him cook his own.

Can't be doing with all this eggcentricity .


Well, you do have great eggspectation.easter egg snooty
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 12, 2011 4:43 PM CST THE GREAT HARD- BOILED EGG CONTROVERSY : HOW LONG TO COOK THEM ?
bestbefore
bestbeforebestbeforesomewhere, Dorset, England UK116 Threads 2 Polls 4,701 Posts
Lonely1: Well, you do have great eggspectation.



Eggsactly! giggle
------ This poll is Archived ------

This Poll is Archived

This Poll is archived, so you will no longer be able to post to it. Poll get archived automatically when they are older than 3 months.
Message #318

Stats for this Poll

76 Votes
2,021 Views
37 Comments
by wonderworker (2 Polls)
Created: Nov 2011
Last Viewed: Apr 24
Last Commented: Dec 2011
Last Voted: Jul 2017

Share this Poll

We use cookies to ensure that you have the best experience possible on our website. Read Our Privacy Policy Here