”What are you doing for living?” (119)

May 16, 2009 11:05 AM CST ”What are you doing for living?”
Tulefel
TulefelTulefelGöteborg, Vastra Gotaland Sweden24 Threads 1 Polls 2,848 Posts
In response to: I think this is a normal question when you want to get to know someone. The question about your income, though, could sound quite rude


Well… I don’t know whether it’s normal or not (and who establishes norms in a private chat?), but for me it indeed is an indicator that there’ll be nothing to talk about.

To get to know someone takes its time, given the media we use, it takes at least an exchange of few letters before you’d feel if you would like to tell about yourself and your life. And when you’ve decided to trust the person, you’ll reveal a lot of information, and as we all have our routines, and there’re no many changes from a day to a day, you’ll tell about your work as well. (Wouldn’t that mean though that you’ve run out of subjects to discuss? Dunno…)

I’m reluctant to tell “what I do for a living” not because I’m ashamed of it or some such. I regard this question as an attempt to hang a price-tag on me (you can get some idea about people’s income of their occupation). And I don’t like it at all.

The other day I’ve talked about that with an acquaintance (he’s a GP), and he told that he hates to answer this question, because some people immediately start to ask his professional advice. Consider a party, folks in fine clothes, and a lady hitches up her long skirt and shows him her cellulites, never mind other guests, his wife among them… So he prefers to say that he’s unemployed, and people lose their interest… It clears space around him, but they who remain, well… they are interested in him (and he’s indeed a very interesting person to talk to), not in his occupation, income and his place on the social ladder that comes with it.

Sorry for a long post
May 16, 2009 11:07 AM CST ”What are you doing for living?”
Lagoona22
Lagoona22Lagoona22Bugibba, Majjistral Malta161 Threads 11 Polls 10,711 Posts
When people ask me what I do for a living, I usually answer..."As little as possible"...(smirk)laugh
May 16, 2009 11:10 AM CST ”What are you doing for living?”
venere08
venere08venere08Puglia and Autumn, South Australia Australia121 Threads 2 Polls 9,996 Posts
Lagoona22: When people ask me what I do for a living, I usually answer..."As little as possible"...(smirk)


In keeping with answering a question with a question, you can also try asking:

"And who wants to know?", or...

"Are you talkin' to me?"

laugh
May 16, 2009 12:05 PM CST ”What are you doing for living?”
Tulefel
TulefelTulefelGöteborg, Vastra Gotaland Sweden24 Threads 1 Polls 2,848 Posts
In response to: well if you don't like being asked what you do for a living ... maybe you can give guys some clues as to what they should be saying?

very often dates can seem like job interviews ....which is why I really don't enjoy them much .. hey, what you doing Friday? ..fancy an interview? .. not my idea of fun .. come on girls.. give us some tips ..



As I’ve noticed, you have no trouble to keep a conversation afloat, and the prettiest part of this forum likes you.

As to tips… people are different, and what one doesn’t like, the other to the contrary (a new word in my vocabulary, due to Mr Lagoona) would like to chat about.

In general, if you made her laugh at your jokes, then it’s a very good achievement, advance!

But if you keep asking questions that she already has answered fifty-eleven times… then you make yourself the fifty-twelfth, and she’ll lose interest at once.

And try not to ask “dangerous” questions: “How do you like my picture?”… oh, I luv that! “Is it YOUR picture? I thought it was Loch-Nessie…” (just an example of a very dangerous question)


tongue
May 16, 2009 12:39 PM CST ”What are you doing for living?”
Tulefel
TulefelTulefelGöteborg, Vastra Gotaland Sweden24 Threads 1 Polls 2,848 Posts
In response to: Gold Digger??!!..



Well… gold-miner then…

And in what direction the cavalry’s riding? (Never mind, the Earth is round anyway…)

grin
May 17, 2009 2:14 PM CST ”What are you doing for living?”
hathor
hathorhathorAltstetten/Stettbach, Zurich Switzerland10 Threads 3 Polls 214 Posts
Tulefel: Have got this question 3 times yesterday evening… Not that it was the first time… Actually it’s often the second question people ask, right after “How are you?”, 30 seconds into a first chat…

So I’m dying with curiosity: why do people want to know that? Are they employers looking for staff? Are they eager to offer a better opportunity straight away? Trying to figure out whether I’d be able to pay my meal in case they’d ask me out?..

Have you ever asked someone what they are doing for living? If yes, why?


I don't know about other, but I can tell you why I am asking the ppl I meet here about their jobs.

First, when you are together with someone, you are not only together with her but also her family, friends and job.
Some ppl bring there problems into their relationship.
And then it is good to know in advanced what she is doing.

Then asking for a job, gives a topic what the conversation could be about.

I would not like the idea of falling in love with someone who works as politican, movie star or model. So I have an eye on her job, too.
May 17, 2009 2:47 PM CST ”What are you doing for living?”
symbolistartist
symbolistartistsymbolistartistHanko, Southern Finland Finland10 Threads 761 Posts
hathor: I don't know about other, but I can tell you why I am asking the ppl I meet here about their jobs.

First, when you are together with someone, you are not only together with her but also her family, friends and job.
Some ppl bring there problems into their relationship.
And then it is good to know in advanced what she is doing.

Then asking for a job, gives a topic what the conversation could be about.

I would not like the idea of falling in love with someone who works as politican, movie star or model. So I have an eye on her job, too.

Good points. However...
I wonder why you are lynching the poor politicians, movie stars and models... don't they deserve your love too? banana
May 18, 2009 4:08 PM CST ”What are you doing for living?”
Tulefel
TulefelTulefelGöteborg, Vastra Gotaland Sweden24 Threads 1 Polls 2,848 Posts
In response to: I don't know about other, but I can tell you why I am asking the ppl I meet here about their jobs.

First, when you are together with someone, you are not only together with her but also her family, friends and job.
Some ppl bring there problems into their relationship.
And then it is good to know in advanced what she is doing.

Then asking for a job, gives a topic what the conversation could be about.

I would not like the idea of falling in love with someone who works as politican, movie star or model. So I have an eye on her job, too.


Well… of course, when you’ve decided to settle down with someone you have to consider their entire environment as well (or a large part of it).

And, as I’ve noticed, people usually write about their education/occupation in their profile. Those who don’t, they have their reason not to, and I doubt they’d reveal it in the first chat. Especially when it feels that there’s nothing to talk about.

As to liking the idea of falling or not falling in love with someone with a certain job…

I’d prefer that my partner wouldn’t bring his job home. But if I love him, and he works at home… Shall I cancel the relationship, and choose someone I don’t love, only on the ground of his occupation?

dunno
May 18, 2009 4:10 PM CST ”What are you doing for living?”
Tulefel
TulefelTulefelGöteborg, Vastra Gotaland Sweden24 Threads 1 Polls 2,848 Posts
In response to: Cool! I do it the easy modern way though, I chase millionaires! Wouldn't believe how many sites there are out there for that... more than there are millionaires I'm sure...



thumbs up
May 18, 2009 4:22 PM CST ”What are you doing for living?”
guiriman
guirimanguirimansouth of milan, Lombardy Italy53 Threads 6 Polls 2,128 Posts
Tulefel: As
..

But if you keep asking questions that she already has answered fifty-eleven times… then you make yourself the fifty-twelfth, and she’ll lose interest at once.

And try not to ask “dangerous” questions: “How do you like my picture?”… oh, I luv that! “Is it YOUR picture? I thought it was Loch-Nessie…” (just an example of a very dangerous question)


yeah ... I can see why that might be annoying ..
May 19, 2009 5:24 AM CST ”What are you doing for living?”
guiriman
guirimanguirimansouth of milan, Lombardy Italy53 Threads 6 Polls 2,128 Posts
Hi Tul, forgot to ask ... what do you do for a living? ..laugh
May 19, 2009 6:12 AM CST ”What are you doing for living?”
sasseez
sasseezsasseezlakes entrance, Victoria Australia1 Threads 3,150 Posts
laugh laugh naughty boi but funny laugh
May 19, 2009 4:55 PM CST ”What are you doing for living?”
Tulefel
TulefelTulefelGöteborg, Vastra Gotaland Sweden24 Threads 1 Polls 2,848 Posts
guiriman: Hi Tul, forgot to ask ... what do you do for a living? ..


From now on I’m a lumberjack!

dancing
May 19, 2009 4:56 PM CST ”What are you doing for living?”
guiriman
guirimanguirimansouth of milan, Lombardy Italy53 Threads 6 Polls 2,128 Posts
Tulefel: From now on I’m a lumberjack!


laugh thumbs up
May 19, 2009 5:50 PM CST ”What are you doing for living?”
symbolistartist
symbolistartistsymbolistartistHanko, Southern Finland Finland10 Threads 761 Posts
Tulefel: From now on I’m a lumberjack!

You're more likely to make a fortune on seeking gold in the streams of Lapland... I would seriously advice you to reconsider... unless you like hugging trees of course! But that won't help you find a date I'm afraid...

rolling on the floor laughing
Aug 12, 2009 4:19 PM CST ”What are you doing for living?”
leonjs48
leonjs48leonjs48michigan, Michigan USA1 Threads 299 Posts
Tulefel: Have got this question 3 times yesterday evening… Not that it was the first time… Actually it’s often the second question people ask, right after “How are you?”, 30 seconds into a first chat…

So I’m dying with curiosity: why do people want to know that? Are they employers looking for staff? Are they eager to offer a better opportunity straight away? Trying to figure out whether I’d be able to pay my meal in case they’d ask me out?..

Have you ever asked someone what they are doing for living? If yes, why?


thats a question people ask here in the states as well, i don't care for it. i think most people that do this are trying to find out if you are on their level, career,intellect,ect,ect. i'm sure some don't mean any offense, but i find it offensive when they hear "what you do for a living" they find a reason to cut-off whatever conversation you were having and get away from you.
this has happened to me on several occasions, the crazy thing is, before "they found out what you do" you got along great. and possibly besting them on whatever the topic was, maybe thats why they beat a hasty retreat, imagine that.dunno
Aug 12, 2009 4:27 PM CST ”What are you doing for living?”
RobertC2
RobertC2RobertC2Xaghra, Gozo, Gozo Malta91 Threads 8 Polls 8,344 Posts
Tulefel: Have got this question 3 times yesterday evening… Not that it was the first time… Actually it’s often the second question people ask, right after “How are you?”, 30 seconds into a first chat…

So I’m dying with curiosity: why do people want to know that? Are they employers looking for staff? Are they eager to offer a better opportunity straight away? Trying to figure out whether I’d be able to pay my meal in case they’d ask me out?..

Have you ever asked someone what they are doing for living? If yes, why?


Most people work eight hours most days and have 'recreation' eight hours per day and sleep about eight hours per day........... what you do most days for 50% of your waking life has to be important!

Ok - so I'm a lazy bum and have recreation 20 hours per day and sleep just 4 hours....... wtf? dunno grin
Aug 12, 2009 4:28 PM CST ”What are you doing for living?”
RobertC2
RobertC2RobertC2Xaghra, Gozo, Gozo Malta91 Threads 8 Polls 8,344 Posts
leonjs48: thats a question people ask here in the states as well, i don't care for it. i think most people that do this are trying to find out if you are on their level, career,intellect,ect,ect. i'm sure some don't mean any offense, but i find it offensive when they hear "what you do for a living" they find a reason to cut-off whatever conversation you were having and get away from you.
this has happened to me on several occasions, the crazy thing is, before "they found out what you do" you got along great. and possibly besting them on whatever the topic was, maybe thats why they beat a hasty retreat, imagine that.


Well, people are free to make choices - right? cool
Aug 12, 2009 10:49 PM CST ”What are you doing for living?”
CuspofMagic
CuspofMagicCuspofMagiclight, South Australia Australia278 Threads 7,904 Posts
--- Wine (Australian)own business, own brands --- laugh

Yes - I am conducive to a loving business arrangement

--- ah! summer and spring in Europe and Australia alternating would be wonderful
Aug 13, 2009 1:53 AM CST ”What are you doing for living?”
wolyrra
wolyrrawolyrraRiga, Latvia470 Posts
Now I've started to like this question, cos I am unemployed now and it is isteresting to watch how people do react rolling on the floor laughing
Post Comment - Post a comment on this Forum Thread
We use cookies to ensure that you have the best experience possible on our website. Read Our Privacy Policy Here