3 hostages killed by IDF (116)

Dec 18, 2023 3:41 PM CST 3 hostages killed by IDF
Youcannow
YoucannowYoucannowLondon, Essex, England UK96 Threads 3,523 Posts
Grandsiozzie: I think it can get worse for them than in the last 18 years, actually.
Unless if they wise up now. They can do it.

I understand you feel for the underdog John, with your background and personal experiences,
but I have one final question for you or anybody else here on this thread:

Do you seriously not see no need to demand something from the Palestinians here...
we as a world community should just continue to buy into this victim story
and never ask them to get a grip inside their own lines?
We can seriously not ask the adults there
to hold back their own youth with machine guns and rockets
in the name of building a better future for all
No?
I don’t think you understand.
I’m totally against Hamas , in every shape and form .
That’s not to say I agree with the tactics employed by the IDF .
A more controlled aggression, without so many civilian casualties & I would be right on board .
But the current tactics have raised suspicions on the motives employed & has isolated its support.
Dec 18, 2023 4:14 PM CST 3 hostages killed by IDF
Yes yes

But what I wonder about fundamentally is, what is best now-

to tell these folk
"listen damnint, now you talk within your group and bring forward your best and most reasonable people who in no shape or form will run Irans errand no more and we, Israel will help you build up your land again and make a nation that will be rigid too."
....
or
"you can go on like before poor you people, we will continue to send container after container with aid and no demands, you can keep your Iran support and holy wars and leaders in Doha too"

-
-
-

tip hat
Dec 19, 2023 6:17 AM CST 3 hostages killed by IDF
Youcannow
YoucannowYoucannowLondon, Essex, England UK96 Threads 3,523 Posts
Grandsiozzie: Yes yes

But what I wonder about fundamentally is, what is best now-

to tell these folk
"listen damnint, now you talk within your group and bring forward your best and most reasonable people who in no shape or form will run Irans errand no more and we, Israel will help you build up your land again and make a nation that will be rigid too."
....
or
"you can go on like before poor you people, we will continue to send container after container with aid and no demands, you can keep your Iran support and holy wars and leaders in Doha too"

-
-
-
First of all , the Jewish Zionists must lose the superiority complex they have over , not only the Muslims but non Jews in general.
They are not the chosen ones as they claim to be . That old saying “ the Egyptians are drowning & the Jews are cheering” . How do you think that would infuriate god ..the killing of his creation?
Palestinians who have lived for generations in their land have less right than a Jewish settler who arrived recently from another land .
Dec 21, 2023 3:59 PM CST 3 hostages killed by IDF
Youcannow
YoucannowYoucannowLondon, Essex, England UK96 Threads 3,523 Posts
The more I think about it , the more I’m beginning to realise this is a proxy war between the USA & Iran , judging by the language & rhetoric coming out of the White House .
Dec 21, 2023 4:00 PM CST 3 hostages killed by IDF
Aha. Who started it?
Dec 21, 2023 4:02 PM CST 3 hostages killed by IDF
Youcannow
YoucannowYoucannowLondon, Essex, England UK96 Threads 3,523 Posts
Grandsiozzie: Aha. Who started it?
How far are we going back ?
Dec 21, 2023 4:10 PM CST 3 hostages killed by IDF
Len05
Len05Len05Antwerp, Antwerpen Belgium33 Threads 11 Polls 972 Posts
in the close history,
I think the Turks colonised it first. Then the British conquered it during the great war.
The Zionists annoyed the British out, then they aimed for their local neighbours.

Then a lot if East European rich or elite used the country to flee their communist regime.
Israel then bombed their neighbouring countries and took a whole lot of land.

They gave most of that back.
Since then the zionists and the local neighbours have tried to outbreed each other.
One in a lot of land, one in refugee camps.
Dec 21, 2023 4:17 PM CST 3 hostages killed by IDF
Youcannow
YoucannowYoucannowLondon, Essex, England UK96 Threads 3,523 Posts
Len05: in the close history,
I think the Turks colonised it first. Then the British conquered it during the great war.
The Zionists annoyed the British out, then they aimed for their local neighbours.

Then a lot if East European rich or elite used the country to flee their communist regime.
Israel then bombed their neighbouring countries and took a whole lot of land.

They gave most of that back.
Since then the zionists and the local neighbours have tried to outbreed each other.
One in a lot of land, one in refugee camps.
The Israelis can’t keep up with their Palestinian counterparts in the breeding department, with the population nearly doubling since Hamas took over , whereas the Israeli population is dependent on foreign arrivals.
Dec 21, 2023 5:38 PM CST 3 hostages killed by IDF
Len05
Len05Len05Antwerp, Antwerpen Belgium33 Threads 11 Polls 972 Posts
Youcannow: The Israelis can’t keep up with their Palestinian counterparts in the breeding department, with the population nearly doubling since Hamas took over , whereas the Israeli population is dependent on foreign arrivals.
You have no idea what the Orthodox are doing.
No work for man, no army for man, and a lot of kids.

But yes Gaza and such is a productive area.

Still in my country, kids are seen as innocent, so i don't understand why these have to live/be raised in a prison.
Dec 28, 2023 1:31 AM CST 3 hostages killed by IDF
Bluefish22
Bluefish22Bluefish22Chooksville, Bay of Plenty New Zealand16 Threads 1 Polls 909 Posts
Youcannow:
Now under the Geneva convention, anyone who waves a white flag in surrender must be treated as a prisoner .,instead they were shot in cold blood , which begs the question.
Are the tactics to shoot anyone, fighter , or civilian?
Certainly seems than way, if they can't differentiate between a half naked Israeli waving a white flag, and a half naked Palestinian waving a white flag.
Dec 28, 2023 6:16 AM CST 3 hostages killed by IDF
Youcannow
YoucannowYoucannowLondon, Essex, England UK96 Threads 3,523 Posts
Bluefish22: Certainly seems than way, if they can't differentiate between a half naked Israeli waving a white flag, and a half naked Palestinian waving a white flag.
Nevertheless, it doesn’t matter who they are , it’s a war crime either way .
Dec 28, 2023 6:21 AM CST 3 hostages killed by IDF
Youcannow
YoucannowYoucannowLondon, Essex, England UK96 Threads 3,523 Posts
Len05: You have no idea what the Orthodox are doing.
No work for man, no army for man, and a lot of kids.

But yes Gaza and such is a productive area.

Still in my country, kids are seen as innocent, so i don't understand why these have to live/be raised in a prison.
Because Palestinians have less value than their Jewish counterparts.
If a Jewish civilian is killed , the whole world & his mother hears about it but when it comes to Palestinians, they are collateral damage.
Dec 28, 2023 6:29 AM CST 3 hostages killed by IDF
Youcannow
YoucannowYoucannowLondon, Essex, England UK96 Threads 3,523 Posts
Len05: in the close history,
I think the Turks colonised it first. Then the British conquered it during the great war.
The Zionists annoyed the British out, then they aimed for their local neighbours.

Then a lot if East European rich or elite used the country to flee their communist regime.
Israel then bombed their neighbouring countries and took a whole lot of land.

They gave most of that back.
Since then the zionists and the local neighbours have tried to outbreed each other.
One in a lot of land, one in refugee camps.
What people don’t realise is that before the 1948 Nakba , 8% of Palestine were Christian inhabitants who were part of the 700,000 driven out of their land by the Zionist movement .
Dec 28, 2023 6:47 AM CST 3 hostages killed by IDF
salamuna
salamunasalamunaDeventer, Overijssel Netherlands5 Threads 225 Posts
Youcannow: What people don’t realise is that before the 1948 Nakba , 8% of Palestine were Christian inhabitants who were part of the 700,000 driven out of their land by the Zionist movement .
Out greek hero loves to talk in slogans... he is not at all interested in facts and history. I love having fun reading your masterpieces, my lovedancing kiss
Dec 28, 2023 8:57 AM CST 3 hostages killed by IDF
Driven out. That is lieful to be honest. But you know what,
I don't think he knows any better.. cos youcannow don't check too deeply is my
experience. Just has decided "that's the bad guys over there" so let's go the other way.

Open prison, age old Arabic territory, blockade (dispite 500 trucks per day) etc.

Thouuu.. one thing I'll give cannon partially right about:

Until them Palestinans start properly behave like responsible adults who will from now on show some normal respect and validation to their counterpart on the other side of the border they will have to expect continued limitations still.
If they change (now is the chance soon) the gates to growth freedom and a better future for Gaza and W.B. opens up. And that is the key here.
But as long as the slogan is "kill them bad Jews" - no... you can't travel, trade or do as you wish freely. Sorry.
Dec 28, 2023 6:25 PM CST 3 hostages killed by IDF
Len05
Len05Len05Antwerp, Antwerpen Belgium33 Threads 11 Polls 972 Posts
Grandsiozzie: Driven out. That is lieful to be honest. But you know what,
I don't think he knows any better.. cos youcannow don't check too deeply is my
experience. Just has decided "that's the bad guys over there" so let's go the other way.

Open prison, age old Arabic territory, blockade (dispite 500 trucks per day) etc.

Thouuu.. one thing I'll give cannon partially right about:

Until them Palestinans start properly behave like responsible adults who will from now on show some normal respect and validation to their counterpart on the other side of the border they will have to expect continued limitations still.
If they change (now is the chance soon) the gates to growth freedom and a better future for Gaza and W.B. opens up. And that is the key here.
But as long as the slogan is "kill them bad Jews" - no... you can't travel, trade or do as you wish freely. Sorry.
Liqud is also about not recognising Palestinians. across the border or whatever.
For Liqud it is all jewish and only for the jews.
Can they bomb Israel flat for the Liqud statements?
Are newborns in Tel Aviv to blame for netanyahu?
When does the curse of a tribe or group start?

Yes there was a lot of violence when the Palestinians left their homes. Also a lot of Jewish people attacking Arabs.
Yes they should have been allowed to go home.
The peaceful people that left their houses due to violence.
nakba or whatever.
No matter their religion or heritage.
There seemed to be place enough for new people, so there was certainly place for old people. Old people that fled for violence.

The Israeli's didn't let them back in.
They are knocking on the door, or harder.

Let them back in.
Post Comment - Post a comment on this Forum Thread
We use cookies to ensure that you have the best experience possible on our website. Read Our Privacy Policy Here