When does a human being become a Person? ( Archived) (69)

Nov 2, 2011 9:25 AM CSTWhen does a human being become a Person?

When does a human being become a Person?(Vote Below)

- (To Vote: select an option above, then press this button)
At Birth?
30
32%
When it can live on it's own outside the womb?
13
14%
When it's heartbeat starts?
16
17%
When the fertilized egg attaches to the uterus?
3
3%
When the sperm fertilizes the egg?
25
27%
When it's old enough to vote?
7
7%
Total Votes
94
Nov 2, 2011 10:50 PM CST When does a human being become a Person?
Iuchi_Zien
Iuchi_ZienIuchi_ZienSheffield, South Yorkshire, England UK21 Threads 9 Polls 1,426 Posts
Fascinating nearly half the people voting believe life begins at conception yet not one of them has the courage to defend the MIS vote?

I wonder how many of them would be prepared to sit with am eight, nine or ten year old girl and explain that because of their own beliefs, not the childs, theyu are prepared to put that childs life at risk? How many of them would sit with a woman with an ectopic pregnancy and explain that their religious beliefs are more important than that womans health or ability to have children later in life. Me and my daughter are NOT Christians, how dare you try to force your religious beliefs upon me! If you are prepared to put your own or your childrens lives at risk for the 'potential' life then that is your choice, don't you dare try to impose your choices on my family!
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 3, 2011 5:08 PM CST When does a human being become a Person?
FreddyFudpucker
FreddyFudpuckerFreddyFudpuckerObamaville, Indiana USA10,179 Posts
Iuchi_Zien: Fascinating nearly half the people voting believe life begins at conception yet not one of them has the courage to defend the MIS vote?

I wonder how many of them would be prepared to sit with am eight, nine or ten year old girl and explain that because of their own beliefs, not the childs, theyu are prepared to put that childs life at risk? How many of them would sit with a woman with an ectopic pregnancy and explain that their religious beliefs are more important than that womans health or ability to have children later in life. Me and my daughter are NOT Christians, how dare you try to force your religious beliefs upon me! If you are prepared to put your own or your childrens lives at risk for the 'potential' life then that is your choice, don't you dare try to impose your choices on my family!


So, when are you moving to Mississippi? May I suggest Mayflower. Their prices are reasonable and they do a good job of packing fragile items.
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 3, 2011 5:22 PM CST When does a human being become a Person?
RayfromUSA
RayfromUSARayfromUSAvienne, Rhone-Alpes France86 Threads 29 Polls 6,611 Posts
Iuchi_Zien:
Me and my daughter are NOT Christians, how dare you try to force your religious beliefs upon me! If you are prepared to put your own or your childrens lives at risk for the 'potential' life then that is your choice, don't you dare try to impose your choices on my family!


Nobody's trying to "force religion" on you.
You are free to believe or not believe whatever you choose.

But society (whatever its views may be) always claims the right to set limits on human conduct. And even if people don't agree on those rules they are compelled to abide by them or face the consequences.

So get off your high horse. You are not Rambo, and you look silly trying to act like you are.

Learn to use reason and logic to try to support your views. Thumping your chest doesn't impress or frighten anybody.
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 3, 2011 5:39 PM CST When does a human being become a Person?
RayfromUSA
RayfromUSARayfromUSAvienne, Rhone-Alpes France86 Threads 29 Polls 6,611 Posts
Conrad73: Interesting that you Guys who are most vociferous about Rand rely nearly entirely on what other People think and wrote about her!


It's because people who have the intelligence to see through her blatant sociopathic insanity also have the intelligence to search the internet for quotes that demonstrate that insanity.

Why waste time composing from memory when the basic material for preparing a good exposé already exist within easy reach. Personally I don't see much point in wasting my own effort on Rand.

Both she and Jesus lived their lives, expounded their beliefs, collected disciples, and then passed on into the spirit world.

Time will tell which of them was right about things.

Jesus died about 2000 years ago, and his ideas are still going strong.

I wonder if any of you disciples of Ayn Rand will still be around even 10 years from now.
I sincerely doubt it.
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 3, 2011 5:46 PM CST When does a human being become a Person?
RayfromUSA: It's because people who have the intelligence to see through her blatant sociopathic insanity also have the intelligence to search the internet for quotes that demonstrate that insanity.

Why waste time composing from memory when the basic material for preparing a good exposé already exist within easy reach. Personally I don't see much point in wasting my own effort on Rand.

Both she and Jesus lived their lives, expounded their beliefs, collected disciples, and then passed on into the spirit world.

Time will tell which of them was right about things.

Jesus died about 2000 years ago, and his ideas are still going strong.

I wonder if any of you disciples of Ayn Rand will still be around even 10 years from now.
I sincerely doubt it.
Ray,those Conspiracy-Theories are getting to you!
You see them around every corner now!
If anything,we are getting stronger!
Kind of exasperates you Guys,ain't it?laugh
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 3, 2011 5:57 PM CST When does a human being become a Person?
RayfromUSA
RayfromUSARayfromUSAvienne, Rhone-Alpes France86 Threads 29 Polls 6,611 Posts
Conrad73: Ray,those Conspiracy-Theories are getting to you!
You see them around every corner now!


I don't see any conspiracy here.

I just see you trying to promote a psychopath as some sort of guru.
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 3, 2011 6:01 PM CST When does a human being become a Person?
RayfromUSA
RayfromUSARayfromUSAvienne, Rhone-Alpes France86 Threads 29 Polls 6,611 Posts
Actually Conrad, I look forward to the day you and your fellow Randians try to set up your dystopian kingdom of selfishness. It will be the biggest failure in all history.
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 4, 2011 3:11 AM CST When does a human being become a Person?
RayfromUSA: Actually Conrad, I look forward to the day you and your fellow Randians try to set up your dystopian kingdom of selfishness. It will be the biggest failure in all history.
You know very well that Rand didn't propose Fullterm abortions!
rarely anyone does!
But implying that she did is just another way to demonize anything that does not fit in your rather narrow welt-anschauung!
BTW,have a look at the Austrian School of Economics!laugh
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 4, 2011 4:43 AM CST When does a human being become a Person?
joekickass
joekickassjoekickassHamilton, Waikato New Zealand1 Threads 1 Polls 20 Posts
when you develop a personality and can be independent.
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 4, 2011 4:52 AM CST When does a human being become a Person?
RayfromUSA: Actually Conrad, I look forward to the day you and your fellow Randians try to set up your dystopian kingdom of selfishness. It will be the biggest failure in all history.
laugh going on all around you,yet you can't see it!laugh
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 4, 2011 4:53 AM CST When does a human being become a Person?
joekickass: when you develop a personality and can be independent.
at 18?uh oh doh
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 4, 2011 6:41 AM CST When does a human being become a Person?
joekickass
joekickassjoekickassHamilton, Waikato New Zealand1 Threads 1 Polls 20 Posts
Conrad73: at 18?

no 25
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 4, 2011 7:16 AM CST When does a human being become a Person?
FreddyFudpucker
FreddyFudpuckerFreddyFudpuckerObamaville, Indiana USA10,179 Posts
Conrad73: at 18?


Under obamacare, that would be 26 years of age. The more I think about it, maybe abortions should be legal past post-birth. professor
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 4, 2011 7:48 AM CST When does a human being become a Person?
Witchaywoman
WitchaywomanWitchaywomanCarpentersville, Illinois USA97 Threads 13 Polls 4,344 Posts
ooby_dooby: http://www.npr.org/2011/11/02/141900772/miss-set-to-vote-on-measure-making-fetus-a-person


When do women become persons with indisputable rights like the right to choose our own course of medical treatment?
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 4, 2011 8:06 AM CST When does a human being become a Person?
FreddyFudpucker
FreddyFudpuckerFreddyFudpuckerObamaville, Indiana USA10,179 Posts
A legitmate argument could be made that even after birth of a child the mother should have right to terminate the life, it seems to me. dunno
If the fetus has no standing and is dependent on the mother prior to birth, it sure doesn't change much for the 1st few years of life. It's still dependent and serves no real purpose.
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 4, 2011 8:37 AM CST When does a human being become a Person?
joekickass
joekickassjoekickassHamilton, Waikato New Zealand1 Threads 1 Polls 20 Posts
for the religious there is a free film called 180 degrees turn. it has an interesting moral spin.
what if the baby is deformed and you have to quit work to look after an adult dependant? even then where do you draw the line?
is someone that is missing a chromosome 100% human?
are they a person if they do not have the intellectual ability to contemplate their own existence?
i believe you should have the freedom to do what you you believe in and not force your beliefs onto others. in nz when abortions were illegal and done on the dodgy there was no safety for woman getting it done illegally. think about that.
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 4, 2011 9:23 AM CST When does a human being become a Person?
stringman
stringmanstringmanwallaceburg, Ontario Canada649 Threads 1 Polls 7,049 Posts
i believe the topic was: when does a human being become a person.i believe i sated that, i'm not telling anyone what to do with there body or their unborn baby. that is up to them.
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 4, 2011 9:32 AM CST When does a human being become a Person?
montecito
montecitomontecitoLovely, New Jersey USA96 Threads 2 Polls 5,086 Posts
stringman: i believe the topic was: when does a human being become a person.i believe i sated that, i'm not telling anyone what to do with there body or their unborn baby. that is up to them.


Life begins when the fetus is severed from the umblicial cord... when it can survive on it's own without nourishment from the cord.
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 4, 2011 12:06 PM CST When does a human being become a Person?
FreddyFudpucker
FreddyFudpuckerFreddyFudpuckerObamaville, Indiana USA10,179 Posts
Conrad73: In legal standing,it becomes a person at Birth!


But therein lies the issue. Why should it even have legal standing? It's just as dependent on the mother after birth as it was 10 minutes before the birth. Common sense logic would tell me that it could be destroyed after leaving the birth canal.

Where's my flaw of logic? dunno
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 4, 2011 12:23 PM CST When does a human being become a Person?
FreddyFudpucker
FreddyFudpuckerFreddyFudpuckerObamaville, Indiana USA10,179 Posts
Conrad73: Common sense tells me to not destroy one of my own,and that IMO goes back a few months before Birth,when the potential Life is advanced enough,that it would be unethical to destroy that life,except in a dire medical emergency!


But therein is the flaw, what common sense tells one person, it may not tell the other. A female could make a very legitimate claim after the fact that the child is her property (as it was before birth), therefore she has the right to make a decision on it's "future" or lack thereof.

dunno
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 4, 2011 12:36 PM CST When does a human being become a Person?
stringman
stringmanstringmanwallaceburg, Ontario Canada649 Threads 1 Polls 7,049 Posts
Conrad73: Common sense tells me to not destroy one of my own,and that IMO goes back a few months before Birth,when the potential Life is advanced enough,that it would be unethical to destroy that life,except in a dire medical emergency!
http://youtu.be/c82WUgjIUng here is what is happening
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 4, 2011 12:37 PM CST When does a human being become a Person?
stringman
stringmanstringmanwallaceburg, Ontario Canada649 Threads 1 Polls 7,049 Posts
stringman: http://youtu.be/c82WUgjIUng here is what is happening
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 4, 2011 12:38 PM CST When does a human being become a Person?
stringman
stringmanstringmanwallaceburg, Ontario Canada649 Threads 1 Polls 7,049 Posts
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 4, 2011 1:17 PM CST When does a human being become a Person?
FreddyFudpucker
FreddyFudpuckerFreddyFudpuckerObamaville, Indiana USA10,179 Posts
Conrad73: I know that's what you were doing!



thumbs up laugh
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 4, 2011 2:01 PM CST When does a human being become a Person?
FreddyFudpucker
FreddyFudpuckerFreddyFudpuckerObamaville, Indiana USA10,179 Posts
amahlala: But it makes as much sense as the bill trying to be passed....



Now where we may part company. No one is required to live in that particular state. laugh
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 4, 2011 2:17 PM CST When does a human being become a Person?
FreddyFudpucker
FreddyFudpuckerFreddyFudpuckerObamaville, Indiana USA10,179 Posts
amahlala: It would be kind of cool to watch people leave in droves.....


And some probably will...they get to pick from 49 others. (Or if you live in Obama's world 56 others). laugh
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 4, 2011 4:18 PM CST When does a human being become a Person?
Class5
Class5Class5Skankytown, Queensland Australia4 Threads 1,010 Posts
It's sad that the most vociferous anti-abortionists are usually men. roll eyes
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 4, 2011 4:22 PM CST When does a human being become a Person?
amahlala
amahlalaamahlalaAberdeen, South Dakota USA21 Threads 8,314 Posts
Class5: It's sad that the most vociferous anti-abortionists are usually men.


Yup.
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 4, 2011 4:38 PM CST When does a human being become a Person?
lifeisadream
lifeisadreamlifeisadreamMexi Go, Mexico State Mexico156 Threads 20 Polls 16,713 Posts
ooby_dooby: When does a human being become a Person?


When does a person become a human being?

typing
------ This poll is Archived ------
Nov 4, 2011 5:30 PM CST When does a human being become a Person?
FreddyFudpucker
FreddyFudpuckerFreddyFudpuckerObamaville, Indiana USA10,179 Posts
Class5: It's sad that the most vociferous anti-abortionists are usually men.


Dunno about that. Was watching the news a few minutes ago. The black female being interviewed was on a pretty big roll about it. (A resident of the state)
dunno
------ This poll is Archived ------

This Poll is Archived

This Poll is archived, so you will no longer be able to post to it. Poll get archived automatically when they are older than 3 months.
Message #318

Stats for this Poll

94 Votes
3,295 Views
69 Comments
Created: Nov 2011
Last Viewed: Apr 25
Last Commented: Nov 2011
Last Voted: Jul 2017

Share this Poll

We use cookies to ensure that you have the best experience possible on our website. Read Our Privacy Policy Here