Republicans kill prison officer .. (201)

Nov 6, 2012 2:48 PM CST Republicans kill prison officer ..
sharmini: So Scrib., how do you square the circle when one section of the divide refuses to talk to those who marches directly affect..???And all the rest...

Well you dont murder people in cold blood!



Scriobs can (and I'm sure will) answer for himself but I know he doesn't support murdering anyone.
Nov 6, 2012 3:12 PM CST Republicans kill prison officer ..
Phoenix
PhoenixPhoenixBelfast....., Antrim Ireland274 Threads 65 Polls 6,948 Posts
snowlynx: Scriobs can (and I'm sure will) answer for himself but I know he doesn't support murdering anyone.


Scrib doesn't agree in murder from reading his posts. You on the other hand snowy have expressed a whish for me to be 'taken out' because of my views (then when I quoted you, YOU tried to change what you said and meant.. And anu time this emotive subject comes up YOU have said..'it's ok to kill republicans'<--I know I've paraphrased you. And be under no illusions I can go into the vortex of this place and requote you directly.

Sharmini all anyone one can do is try to keep talking to those who refuse to listen in the hope that you persuade them to think otherwise.
Nov 6, 2012 3:17 PM CST Republicans kill prison officer ..
sharmini
sharminisharminidublin, Dublin Ireland83 Threads 1 Polls 2,918 Posts
snowlynx: Scriobs can (and I'm sure will) answer for himself but I know he doesn't support murdering anyone.






So Scrib., how do you square the circle when one section of the divide refuses to talk to those who marches directly affect..???And all the rest...

Well you dont murder people in cold blood!”


The above is a comment made by Phoenix.....and my reply
Nov 6, 2012 3:27 PM CST Republicans kill prison officer ..
Phoenix: Scrib doesn't agree in murder from reading his posts. You on the other hand snowy have expressed a whish for me to be 'taken out' because of my views (then when I quoted you, YOU tried to change what you said and meant.. And anu time this emotive subject comes up YOU have said..'it's ok to kill republicans'<--I know I've paraphrased you. And be under no illusions I can go into the vortex of this place and requote you directly.

Sharmini all anyone one can do is try to keep talking to those who refuse to listen in the hope that you persuade them to think otherwise.


Please don't deliberately quote me out of context! You know quite well that I would want you taken out IF you came back and joined in the 'struggle'.

There's only one of the two of us here who supported murder in the North last week and it isn't me.
Nov 6, 2012 3:29 PM CST Republicans kill prison officer ..
sharmini: So Scrib., how do you square the circle when one section of the divide refuses to talk to those who marches directly affect..???And all the rest...

Well you dont murder people in cold blood!


Sorry for the mistake Shar but as you can see here it looks like you were quoting Scribs not Phoenix!
Nov 6, 2012 3:36 PM CST Republicans kill prison officer ..
Phoenix
PhoenixPhoenixBelfast....., Antrim Ireland274 Threads 65 Polls 6,948 Posts
sharmini: So Scrib., how do you square the circle when one section of the divide refuses to talk to those who marches directly affect..???And all the rest...

Well you dont murder people in cold blood!”

The above is a comment made by Phoenix.....and my reply


Sharmini..The question I posed to scrib was in relation to Loyal Orders. Not the killing of David Black.

I'll try again to answer you question in relation to last weeks killing. Last year ONH put a death threat on PO's because of what is going on within Brithish prisons in the North (inculdes beatings, forced strip searching, being locked up at least 23hrs a day..unlawful imprisonment of several anti agreement (not phyiscal force) republicans. There was an agreement accepted by all parties concerned and the puppet masters in the NIO and senior prison staff then refused to put the agreement into practise. The blame for the death of PO Black can be laid at many doors. But everyone (most) are saying it was simply due to PFR.

What I do know is certain sections within the o6c haven't learnt very much. The same threats were made during the dirty protest of the 70's & 80's and something in the region of 30 PO's were shot and killed. And they stopped once the 5 demands that 10 people died for were put into practise.

If the agreement in Roe Hse isn't put in place chances are there will be more PO's dead. Thats the nature of the beast in Ireland. Remember three people were arrested two from the North (released unconditionally) and one from Co. Letrim still being held by An Garda Siochana in relation to the killing.

Sharmini go to Radio Ulster (or google The Nolan show) and listen to the first two interviews on yesterday mornings show. You may find them enlightening.
Nov 6, 2012 3:51 PM CST Republicans kill prison officer ..
Phoenix
PhoenixPhoenixBelfast....., Antrim Ireland274 Threads 65 Polls 6,948 Posts
snowlynx: Please don't deliberately quote me out of context! You know quite well that I would want you taken out IF you came back and joined in the 'struggle'.

There's only one of the two of us here who supported murder in the North last week and it isn't me.


Snowy again you not me or anyone else on this thread is advocating violence. I've kept what everyone has said very much in context.

Again snowy please feel free to contact the PSNI and let them read this thread. Or the British police force. I'll stand by what I said.

I'll quote what Rory Duggan said in a book called 'End Game in Ireland' by Emaon Mailie..he (Duggan) said it just before the PIRA broke their 1994 ceasefire in 1997.."There is a big angry dog out there..

What most people want to believe is it's all hunky dory when the reality is very much different. But people don't want to accept that.

And as I've said snowy..This 'civil war' that you keep harping on about will affect me quicker and more directly than you. I am at present living on the UK mainland. Most of my family live in a nationalist part of the patch work quilt of communties that make up North Belfast. Simple reasonings tells me the 'Civil war' will hit that part of the world a lot quicker than you living in Galway.
Nov 6, 2012 3:59 PM CST Republicans kill prison officer ..
Phoenix: Snowy again you not me or anyone else on this thread is advocating violence. I've kept what everyone has said very much in context.

Again snowy please feel free to contact the PSNI and let them read this thread. Or the British police force. I'll stand by what I said.

I'll quote what Rory Duggan said in a book called 'End Game in Ireland' by Emaon Mailie..he (Duggan) said it just before the PIRA broke their 1994 ceasefire in 1997.."There is a big angry dog out there..

What most people want to believe is it's all hunky dory when the reality is very much different. But people don't want to accept that.

And as I've said snowy..This 'civil war' that you keep harping on about will affect me quicker and more directly than you. I am at present living on the UK mainland. Most of my family live in a nationalist part of the patch work quilt of communties that make up North Belfast. Simple reasonings tells me the 'Civil war' will hit that part of the world a lot quicker than you living in Galway.


You're condoning violence, that's clear from your posts.

You should in all conscience tell the authorities where you live that you are a supporter of terrorists in NI, that would be important as the dissidents would love to bomb mainland Britain and the only reason they haven't up to now is they aren't strong enough. It's not up to anyone else to do it you have to decide that for yourself.

A civil war probably would effect you more than me...on balance I agree with you there, still don't know why you'd want to start one though.
Nov 6, 2012 4:53 PM CST Republicans kill prison officer ..
Phoenix
PhoenixPhoenixBelfast....., Antrim Ireland274 Threads 65 Polls 6,948 Posts
snowlynx: You haven't condemned the murder last week - that says it all.


And what good would that be? Has (condoning it or any murder in the North) stopped it before or now? If you or anyone thinks for a split second that by becoming a lemming like a lot of people and getting involved in a finger waving excerise or other is going to stop it you and them are (using your words) deluded.

snowlynx: I think you need to read again what I said about what you should do regarding telling the authorities...You're absolutely right in saying I've no idea what you've done or are likely to do...that's why I'm saying it's UP TO YOU to decide - in accordance with your own conscience - about who you tell. (Now I've made that clear I hope you can stop going on and on about flagging threads to whoever!)


Trust me snowy my conscience is very clear in what I believe in. I sleep very soundly every night. Again anyone who I have come into contact with know exactly my views concerning Ireland. And yes snowy that includes police forces of at least three different European countries..Would you like me to put it neon lights in Time Sq?? I PERSONALLY don't think Britian has any right in Ireland. What part of that don't you grasp.

snowlynx: You are supporting the people who would start civil war in Ireland, though of course you are so deluded you think that couldn't happen!!


Again show me where I said violence is the answer? What you can do is show me lots of times where I explained why it's happening, I've also explained why it will continue. You snowy keep saying I want a civil war..When have I ever said that? I have asked for a flawed agreement that was democratically endorsed by the whole of Ireland to be implemented in FULL. I've also asked for the HET to investigate ALL UNSOLVED murders in the o6c and not cherry pick them.
Nov 6, 2012 5:03 PM CST Republicans kill prison officer ..
Phoenix: And what good would that be? Has (condoning it or any murder in the North) stopped it before or now? If you or anyone thinks for a split second that by becoming a lemming like a lot of people and getting involved in a finger waving excerise or other is going to stop it you and them are (using your words) deluded.
Trust me snowy my conscience is very clear in what I believe in. I sleep very soundly every night. Again anyone who I have come into contact with know exactly my views concerning Ireland. And yes snowy that includes police forces of at least three different European countries..Would you like me to put it neon lights in Time Sq?? I PERSONALLY don't think Britian has any right in Ireland. What part of that don't you grasp.
Again show me where I said violence is the answer? What you can do is show me lots of times where I explained why it's happening, I've also explained why it will continue. You snowy keep saying I want a civil war..When have I ever said that? I have asked for a flawed agreement that was democratically endorsed by the whole of Ireland to be implemented in FULL. I've also asked for the HET to investigate ALL UNSOLVED murders in the o6c and not cherry pick them.



It's very hard to argue with someone so evasive.......
I said you didn't condemn the murder, you've just admitted you haven't condemned it, people will make up their own minds about that....which is what I want them to do.

I understand how you feel Britain has no right to be 'in' Ireland (which it's not of course but anyway.......) all that concerns me is your support for terrorism, nothing else!

You're far too clever to explicitly say 'violence is the answer' of course you're never going to say that!! How foolish that would be! No, you just propagandise for the people who are carrying out the violence, that's all.
Nov 6, 2012 5:49 PM CST Republicans kill prison officer ..
Phoenix
PhoenixPhoenixBelfast....., Antrim Ireland274 Threads 65 Polls 6,948 Posts
snowlynx: It's very hard to argue with someone so evasive.......
I said you didn't condemn the murder, you've just admitted you haven't condemned it, people will make up their own minds about that....which is what I want them to do.


I was asked by various posters earlier in the thread to condone the killing and i said then as now..What good would that do? it didn't do any good in the past. It tells me it wont do any good today.

snowlynx: I understand how you feel Britain has no right to be 'in' Ireland (which it's not of course but anyway.......) all that concerns me is your support for terrorism, nothing else!


I've asked you before and i'll do it again..Please explain what a terrorist is? What do they look like?

snowlynx: You're far too clever to explicitly say 'violence is the answer' of course you're never going to say that!! How foolish that would be! No, you just propagandise for the people who are carrying out the violence, that's all.


Is this the same propaganda that the blogger Ardoyne Republican has on his blog about Loyal Order marches forced thorough nationalist areas that GARC has offered a viable and workable solution to ease tenisons in interface areas that the Loyal orders refuse to contemplate? Did you read it? Incase you missed it..Here's a small part of what he said and I agree with..

GARC accept that the Protestant, Unionist and Loyalist community have a legitimate right to express their religion, culture, heritage and allegiance to Britain. We do not wish to hinder those rights, however, parades should take place were they are welcome and this is clearly not the case on this stretch of Road. These contentious marches only serve to poison community relations and further alienate and polarise our peoples, and all just to pander to the will of a few bigots who use culture as an excuse to mask and impose their outdated and obsolete triumphalism upon our community..........

Tell me what wrong with that propsal? Where is the sectarianism in it? Or are GARC trying to diffuse a situation before it becomes volatile next year again?

When asked here directly on Sat. evening about the possiblies of a loyalist back lash..I said 'It aint going to happen'..They let the PSNI deal with it. Then on Sunday and Monday the PUP said the very same thing and a journalist in todays Newsletter said exactly what I said to 'ohnwiseone' a few days before (she has yet to reply).

You and others talk here about justice, rule of law etc..Why don't the PSNI simply go to Stormount and ask Peter Robinson about Ulster Resistance (he was the leader of UR at the time) and their 1988 South African arms shipment. That led directly to the deaths of scores of innocent people? And while the PSNI are questioning him maybe Petey could supply the names of Mi5 & 6 spies who set up the deal in the first place. Then the PSNI while in Stormount talking to Petey could walk down a corridor and question Martyboy about the 30 odd PO's killed while he was on PIRA army council..What I don't do snowy is cherry pick.

What I wont do eiter is get involved in a futile finger waving excercise becasue the masses do. I think for me and I don't need any one to help me with my thought process. I make my decisons based on scratching the surface to get at the truth and from personal experience.
Nov 8, 2012 10:14 AM CST Republicans kill prison officer ..
Phoenix
PhoenixPhoenixBelfast....., Antrim Ireland274 Threads 65 Polls 6,948 Posts
Snowy you sill haven't answered my question on what a terrorist looks like..

snowlynx: “I understand how you feel Britain has no right to be 'in' Ireland (which it's not of course but anyway.......) all that concerns me is your support for terrorism, nothing else!


"This is an all too familiar pattern. Here we have several homes ransacked and a number of people arrested and taken from their familes. Unsurprisingly, those arrested were later released without charge within hours and nothing untoward found during the searches.
The PSNI's strong arm tactics left a number of children terrified and families were left to pick up the pieces. These raids were particularly frightening for young children"




What do you call TERRORISM snowny..? Men with guns frightening children or men with guns killing PO's..?

As I said several times..Why doesn't the HET go and ask questions to the 'Folks on the Hill'..?



Ulster Resistance (UR)
A Loyalist paramilitary style organisation which was formed on 10 November 1986 by Ian Paisley, then leader of the Democratic Unionist Party (DUP), Peter Robinson of the DUP, and Ivan Foster. The initial aim of Ulster Resistance was to bring an end to the Anglo-Irish Agreement. Following a rally in the Ulster Hall in Belfast, other rallies were held in towns across Northern Ireland. The group was organised in nine 'battalions' and members wore a red beret. In November 1988 there was an arms find in County Armagh and the subsequent arrest of a former DUP election candidate brought accusations of links between DUP politicians and armed paramilitary groups. The DUP claimed that party links with the organisation had ended in 1987. Two members of Ulster Resistance were arrested in April 1987 in Paris along with a South African diplomat. It was claimed that there had been an attempt to exchange information on Shorts' missile technology for weapons. In the late 1980s some former members of Ulster Resistance joined another grouping called Resistance.





Martin McGuinness In an unambiguous message to his fellow nationalists and republicans, he said: "I would say, and I am standing up to be counted, give the information to the police, give it to the Garda in the south if you have it, give it to the PSNI [Police Service of Northern Ireland] in the north.



Why doesn't Martboy do his own dirty work..?
Nov 8, 2012 11:51 AM CST Republicans kill prison officer ..
Phoenix
PhoenixPhoenixBelfast....., Antrim Ireland274 Threads 65 Polls 6,948 Posts
Snowy, I'll answer the question that you either can't or refuse to answer.

A terrorist is someone who terrorises (be it state sponsered or other).
Nov 8, 2012 12:18 PM CST Republicans kill prison officer ..
Phoenix
PhoenixPhoenixBelfast....., Antrim Ireland274 Threads 65 Polls 6,948 Posts
Some of you have used the words justice, rule of law and democracy. Have any of you ever asked yourselves why haven't the HET examined the files concerning the Stalker, Sampson, Stevens inquiries in to 'Shoot to kill/Collusion'? Instead they go to America and ask for the tapes in Boston College to be released. Why don't they clean up their own back yard first. Maybe it's because it's too close to home for some of them.

Try this for size.Why don't the HET have a look at the Savile inquiry into Bloody Sunday and charge those responsible for shooting dead 14 innocent people dead with murder?

Could it be becasue all their available resources are tied up looking at who was behind the Dublin and Monaghan bombings of 1974?

If this flawed document (GFA) was implemented in full anyone involved in the above who committed murder (and it was proved in court) goes to prison for two years.

But instead the HET simply cherry pick what they want to investigate. Doesn't sound like the rule of law is very just.

But I'm told I'm a deluded phyisical force republican who doesn't know what I'm talking about....
Nov 8, 2012 2:44 PM CST Republicans kill prison officer ..
facetowardsfront
facetowardsfrontfacetowardsfrontCork, Ireland42 Threads 1 Polls 2,921 Posts
Phoenix: A terrorist is someone who terrorises (be it state sponsered or other)


People refuse to see governments as the terrorists and thieves they are. It must be Stockholm Syndrome. Governments use force and intimidation to coerce people to comply with their demands. Terrorism is defined as the use of violence and intimidation in the pursuit of political aims. Bells ringing anyone?
Nov 8, 2012 2:47 PM CST Republicans kill prison officer ..
Phoenix
PhoenixPhoenixBelfast....., Antrim Ireland274 Threads 65 Polls 6,948 Posts
facetowardsfront: People refuse to see governments as the terrorists and thieves they are. It must be Stockholm Syndrome. Governments use force and intimidation to coerce people to comply with their demands. Terrorism is defined as the use of violence and intimidation in the pursuit of political aims. Bells ringing anyone?


thumbs up
Nov 8, 2012 3:31 PM CST Republicans kill prison officer ..
sharmini
sharminisharminidublin, Dublin Ireland83 Threads 1 Polls 2,918 Posts
You may have explained this already..but who or what is the HET?

I honestly think that this discussion would fair better if started on a new thread....



Phoenix: Some of you have used the words justice, rule of law and democracy. Have any of you ever asked yourselves why haven't the HET examined the files concerning the Stalker, Sampson, Stevens inquiries in to 'Shoot to kill/Collusion'? Instead they go to America and ask for the tapes in Boston College to be released. Why don't they clean up their own back yard first. Maybe it's because it's too close to home for some of them.

Try this for size.Why don't the HET have a look at the Savile inquiry into Bloody Sunday and charge those responsible for shooting dead 14 innocent people dead with murder?

Could it be becasue all their available resources are tied up looking at who was behind the Dublin and Monaghan bombings of 1974?

If this flawed document (GFA) was implemented in full anyone involved in the above who committed murder (and it was proved in court) goes to prison for two years.

But instead the HET simply cherry pick what they want to investigate. Doesn't sound like the rule of law is very just.

But I'm told I'm a deluded phyisical force republican who doesn't know what I'm talking about....
Nov 8, 2012 4:03 PM CST Republicans kill prison officer ..
Phoenix
PhoenixPhoenixBelfast....., Antrim Ireland274 Threads 65 Polls 6,948 Posts
sharmini: You may have explained this already..but who or what is the HET?

I honestly think that this discussion would fair better if started on a new thread....



HET= Historical Enquiry Team.
The HET have ex members of the RUC and RUC Special Branch working along side serving memebers of the PSNI and they are meant to re examine all unsolved murders of the troubles.

And the RUC had officers who were either directly or indirectly involved in the killing of innocent people. And the HMSU(Headquarter Mobile Support Unit) headed by Ronnie Flanagan (who went on to become Chief Constable of the RUC) have been implicated in the shoot to kill enquiry that John Stalker, Colin Sampspn and John Stevens investigated (All three were Cheif Constables in the UK for different forces). But the findings have never been released.

But the PSNI want to go to America by using the MLAT (Mutual legal assistance treaty) and are asking for tapes held in Boston College to be released because they believe somewhere inside the tapes they'll have proof that Gerry Adams ordered the abduction and burial of Jean McConville. MLAT wasn't set up so police forces can have a fishing excercise.

The Boston College tapes if handed over to the PSNI will open a can of worms....And will (this is very important), allow 'people' to not only 'airbrush' certain events and figures from crimes they committed. But allow 'people' to revision history. THe BC tapes were set up for ex paramilitaries to tell there version of events and only to released when they die of natural causes or other.

The MLAT treaty was set up to help countires enforce public and criminal laws, tax matters etc..Not as a fishing exercise for a political police force.

If the HET are really interested in solving murders committed during the troubles..Why don't they clean up their own back yard first..?

Why can't Petey and Martyboy lead by example and tell the PSNI's HET team all they know about the paramilitary groups they were once involved in?

I hope that goes some way to explaining things..
Nov 8, 2012 5:06 PM CST Republicans kill prison officer ..
Phoenix
PhoenixPhoenixBelfast....., Antrim Ireland274 Threads 65 Polls 6,948 Posts
Here's something else to ponder on.

Should 10 prisoners have been allowed to starve themselves to death in 1981. No. Did six of the ten die to further the agenda of SF. Yes.

What are a lot of repubicans pissed of with SF and why have I said earlier in this thread that SF have done 180° about face..

Listen to this speech by martyboy..and look at what eventually happened.


Nov 8, 2012 7:20 PM CST Republicans kill prison officer ..
Post Comment - Post a comment on this Forum Thread

Share this Thread

We use cookies to ensure that you have the best experience possible on our website. Read Our Privacy Policy Here