When you read someone's profile, and they are very specific in what they are looking for...do you find that a good thing or bad thing??
Let me outline a situation...
I had read someone's profile, he specifically said that he preferred slim/slender women...no problem but i would not be considered that by no stretch of the imagination...nor do i want to be....however I liked the rest of his profile and still contacted him...we became friends (which I said up front was all i wanted to be) we went out for drinks, and we've had a great time, he is as great a conversationalist as i thought he would be, he is a very attractive man and it was great to be in his company....here's the thing though...he would now like to have a relationship...and my answer has been "nope"
He has changed his mind about the "body type"...I on the other hand am not willing to let him forget that by stating his preference so boldly on his profile he may have forfeited the company of many wonderful women....as well, I refuse to put myself in a position where I would be constantly questioning my "body"...even if it is only in my mind...
I don't think there is anything wrong with having a preference, but i'm not sure that such things as height and body type, eye colour, hair colour...things of that nature, need to be specified....
Agree or Disagree...
(I had actually started this thread back in Dec '06...it was a good debate back then so i thought i'd raise it again....)
I personally don't want to date an 'obese' man for the sake of loving what's on the inside because it doesn't necessarily mean he's ok in there. I also appreciate a man who may not want a woman with my type of body. It's all preference i guess.
I respect those who don't consider body types when finding partners 'AT ALL' too!
Oh yep I DO... but I also think that when you do *Fall* for someone .. things about them that you may not have noticed at first.. become more and more attractive to you..
Like.. the (maybe) quirky little way their mouths move when they speak.. Or they way they squint their eyes when they laugh.. or walk.. talk.. etc.
I always insist that the man for me has to bond with me intellectually, spriritually, emotionally and physically.
That's the package for me and none can function without the other.
I can't be with a man who has an attractive mind yet with nothing in the 'chemistry' department. Einstein comes to mind with this broken equation. Lol...He may have been good in chemistry but would do nothing for me in the other 'chemistry' department.
Wikked
I think you should give this guy a chance because he has obviously connected with you on a good level to ask you to date. It doesn't matter what he may have had in his profile because he's human and bound to change preferences.
None of the woman who fitted my perception of what I wanted ever managed to captivate me. Both the ladies I came to love deeply were physically complete opposites of what I thought would attract me. It is the woman inside who captivates. I hope I remember that the next time I get to meet someone who do not fit the picture that I even now still faithfully - stupidly - carry in my mind.
Wikked I understand your reasons for not wanting to get involved with this guy. I pretty much did the same to the first woman I loved and she never quite recovered from this insecurity that I placed in her mind - even though I came to love her so much that I would never have left her for someone fitting my mental description. I was more than happy with who the woman was that I loved and totally committed to her - but I could never convince her.
"He has changed his mind about the "body type"...I on the other hand am not willing to let him forget that by stating his preference so boldly on his profile he may have forfeited the company of many wonderful women....as well, I refuse to put myself in a position where I would be constantly questioning my "body"...even if it is only in my mind..."
This phrase is a red flag for me: "I WILL NOT LET HIM FORGET"
I lived with a woman for 5 years who was like that. Make one mistake and never hear the end of it no matter how many times you appologize and never make the same mistake again. Sooner or later the next time you have a tiff she throws it up in your face again. If I'm man enough to appoligize, you should be woman enough to accept my appology and not drag out the old garbage everytime you need to "vent". Needless to say I'm not with this woman anymore and that was a major contributing factor.
Urs, if you had met this man on the street without ever knowing of his "preference", you might have been able to begin a relationship.
I read an article a while back written by someone that runs a dating site. He is a liberal, Jewish democrat and he was looking for a woman with the same qualities according to his profile. While at a party, he met a conservative, Catholic republican. They have been together for 8 months now.
mbcaseyNorth Myrtle Beach, South Carolina USA16,449 posts
Some people (myself included) hardly pay attention to "what I am seeking" and just check the first box they see.
I hope the mods will understand, but I think trying to sum up "what you seek" with a few boxes to check is kind of rediculous. I understand their reasons behind this, but we are so complex and the boxes are so general.
So Ursula, I wouldn't hold what is checked in a box as a standard to accept or reject anyone.
have you heard the term, sabotaging your own happiness? you appear in all your words to want someone who loves you for who you are not your body. Now this man may have put something in his profile that pertains to body, his perrogative indeed, however after he spends time with you he finds something he did not know that changes his mind (something that happens with us all, life is everchanging). In fact what he has found is what 'you say you want', something that goes beyond body only, something far deeper, and with your chance at love, your pride comes up and sabotages you? you're now saying you dont want the love you want... makes sense? Face it if we have insecurities about our body we'll have them with or without anyone else.
I agree! When women state in their profile 10 things they are looking for in a guy, and I meet 9 of those pre-requisites, I never contact them. I won't have someone settle on me, because they couldn't find that perfect 10 they were looking for.
I could rant about this all day! I have very few pre-requisites. Love music, animals, and be politically left wing. And I still can't find a date. Could be because I could never date a woman whose standards are so low, that she would date me!!
I am not going to say whether i agree or disagree with anyone's opinion on here...they all have valid points...
What i would like to point out...it that is was almost the majority of votes that "I" should not hold this against him...and give him another chance...as well that it is a "crippling" habit have of "holding things against their partner for future ammunition"....
If i missed it I apologize now...however i don't recall seeing it stated that he was in any way wrong for having a preconception of what is the "perfect" woman...those are the types of comments and "descriptions" that make the average everyday woman feel like she does not "measure up"....
I will concede that on this site you are almost "forced" to detail what you are looking for...some of us feel the need to give an answer...some of us don't....all i know is that i was not willing to "get over it" to please someone else..."I" like myself...and at the end of the day that's all that really counts...
Report threads that break rules, are offensive, or contain fighting. Staff may not be aware of the forum abuse, and cannot do anything about it unless you tell us about it. click to report forum abuse »
If one of the comments is offensive, please report the comment instead (there is a link in each comment to report it).
Let me outline a situation...
I had read someone's profile, he specifically said that he preferred slim/slender women...no problem but i would not be considered that by no stretch of the imagination...nor do i want to be....however I liked the rest of his profile and still contacted him...we became friends (which I said up front was all i wanted to be) we went out for drinks, and we've had a great time, he is as great a conversationalist as i thought he would be, he is a very attractive man and it was great to be in his company....here's the thing though...he would now like to have a relationship...and my answer has been "nope"
He has changed his mind about the "body type"...I on the other hand am not willing to let him forget that by stating his preference so boldly on his profile he may have forfeited the company of many wonderful women....as well, I refuse to put myself in a position where I would be constantly questioning my "body"...even if it is only in my mind...
I don't think there is anything wrong with having a preference, but i'm not sure that such things as height and body type, eye colour, hair colour...things of that nature, need to be specified....
Agree or Disagree...
(I had actually started this thread back in Dec '06...it was a good debate back then so i thought i'd raise it again....)