What do you think of the theory of evolution by natural selection, do you think it's correct? (78)

Feb 21, 2013 4:23 AM CST What do you think of the theory of evolution by natural selection, do you think it's correct?
my view is all sentient beings (beings that have mind and fear death) like our selves there nature is moving energy, the physical form is impermanent, collection of constant changing fluid, cells etc, most of the cells are constantly being replaced, every second we shed skin, hair, moister etc until eventually the whole mass decays. The point i am trying to make is all sentient beings constantly migrate from life to life driving by cause and effect.
There are countless form bodies, (and formless beings and formless state as in after death in-between rebirth process) even the air is teaming with tiny sentient forms, and no doubt forms of evolution occur as like all matter in this universe are interdependent
Feb 21, 2013 4:36 AM CST What do you think of the theory of evolution by natural selection, do you think it's correct?
Merriweather
MerriweatherMerriweatherAdelaide, South Australia Australia51 Threads 11,403 Posts
Obsi.... you will not convince me... I look at the Orangatans in the zoo, and I observe ... with me little pea ping pong brain... these beautiful creatures are so like me..

Except that they have these beautiful natural red fur coats.. and whilst they are all kept behind bars, with naught else to do much.. except stare at us staring at them...

How are we going to allow evolution to occur for them??



anyway, I hope you dont mind... but this is in the theme..


Feb 21, 2013 4:38 AM CST What do you think of the theory of evolution by natural selection, do you think it's correct?
Merriweather
MerriweatherMerriweatherAdelaide, South Australia Australia51 Threads 11,403 Posts
robplum: my view is all sentient beings (beings that have mind and fear death) like our selves there nature is moving energy, the physical form is impermanent, collection of constant changing fluid, cells etc, most of the cells are constantly being replaced, every second we shed skin, hair, moister etc until eventually the whole mass decays. The point i am trying to make is all sentient beings constantly migrate from life to life driving by cause and effect.
There are countless form bodies, (and formless beings and formless state as in after death in-between rebirth process) even the air is teaming with tiny sentient forms, and no doubt forms of evolution occur as like all matter in this universe are interdependent


Robp... hi ah..

I know you believe in energy just bouncing around.. but what if your theory is wrong.??uh oh
Feb 21, 2013 4:44 AM CST What do you think of the theory of evolution by natural selection, do you think it's correct?
we are somewhat like the stock exchange most recent news heralds the appearance of more derivatives being let loose e.g
About $36 billion was wiped from the value of Australian shares on Thursday after the local market posted its largest one-day decline in nine months.

bound up in time
Feb 21, 2013 4:46 AM CST What do you think of the theory of evolution by natural selection, do you think it's correct?
Merriweather: Robp... hi ah..

I know you believe in energy just bouncing around.. but what if your theory is wrong.??

least i got one after spending many years study i have "a version" (that all i can describe it as) enough of a grip of it to be sent into debate by HHDL.
I'll be sticking to mine
Feb 21, 2013 4:52 AM CST What do you think of the theory of evolution by natural selection, do you think it's correct?
Obscuritan
ObscuritanObscuritanMelbourne, Victoria Australia37 Threads 3 Polls 1,284 Posts
Merriweather: Obsi.... you will not convince me... I look at the Orangatans in the zoo, and I observe ... with me little pea ping pong brain... these beautiful creatures are so like me..

Except that they have these beautiful natural red fur coats.. and whilst they are all kept behind bars, with naught else to do much.. except stare at us staring at them...

How are we going to allow evolution to occur for them??
anyway, I hope you dont mind... but this is in the theme..http://www.youtube.com/embed/nGeXdv-uPaw


Yes, they are very much like us. I know it's sad to have them in zoos. Evolution IS happening for them, they are dying out. That's the harsh reality, that's how evolution works. Unless we humans die out unexpectedly in the next 100 years or so then there will be no Orang Utans, Chimpanzees gorillas and many many others. Unless we miraculously figure out ways to conserve them.
Feb 21, 2013 5:04 AM CST What do you think of the theory of evolution by natural selection, do you think it's correct?
human hold scant regard for the welfare of even other humans and are clearly responsible for many problems inflicted upon other beings.

Only got to monitor news to gain some insight into the wide spread carnage constantly been played out. All sentient life on this planet entails suffering, just look at the food chain, bird eats worm, bigger bird eats bird, likewise in the oceans a sea of death, chimps in the wild kill other creatures to. Whales kill trillions of life forms even if only tiny creates they still have mind and fear death.
Every whee we look (if we look) suffering...
Feb 21, 2013 6:35 AM CST What do you think of the theory of evolution by natural selection, do you think it's correct?
Blizzard14u
Blizzard14uBlizzard14uGosnells, Western Australia Australia67 Threads 2 Polls 1,430 Posts
Obscuritan: Yes, they are very much like us. I know it's sad to have them in zoos. Evolution IS happening for them, they are dying out. That's the harsh reality, that's how evolution works. Unless we humans die out unexpectedly in the next 100 years or so then there will be no Orang Utans, Chimpanzees gorillas and many many others. Unless we miraculously figure out ways to conserve them.


That would be the zoo breading program? Where they exchange animals between zoos around the world in attempts to keep endangered animals from becoming extinct! Although some animals are becoming extinct because off greed! Like Tigers, Elephants, Rhinos, apparently they are worth more dead in the short term than what tourist will pay to see them living in the long term? Billions off dollars are spent each year just too watch whales?

What type of money do you think will be spent in the future just too see a tiger walking or stalking its prey?

People need to get the quick cash grab out off their minds and think about ways off making money the honest way? For eternity, so long as these animals still live people will want too see them,
professor
Feb 23, 2013 7:52 PM CST What do you think of the theory of evolution by natural selection, do you think it's correct?
revealer24
revealer24revealer24Arundel, Queensland Australia62 Threads 985 Posts
Blizzard14u: Evolution does not state that we evolved from monkeys! We evolved through a natural selection process over millions off years, we have all seen the docos off animals using tools to get food, so don’t expect a monkey to pop out a human baby anytime soon! In science things take a long time,

In religion it took six days then god took the seventh day off? But they don’t mention the dinosaurs?


The creation story is a song, it is symbolic, framed into a seven day block to give a reason for the seventh day rest.

Even science cannot fault the order of creation. What do you need for human life to occur? The story is given from the viewpoint of someone standing on earth. The first chapter is the global view, the second is local to a small area.

1. light
2. water cycle (water condensed, forms ground water and clouds)
3. vegetation (how else would animals survive - no mention of sea plants)
4. good temperature (so you can see the sun, moon and the stars). You need it for a rich animal world.
5. animal world
7. mankind

Dinosaurs? Not even cockroaches, spiders are mentioned. Argument from silence...

The problem is people take it literally that the days mean literal 24 hour days. All the waters cannot possibly precipitate and form oceans and dry land to appear in a single day.

Before you accuse me of pushing my own wheelbarrow, I don't care what anyone believes, what your religion, it is not my business. But let's be fair when dealing with the bible.
Feb 23, 2013 8:07 PM CST What do you think of the theory of evolution by natural selection, do you think it's correct?
AgentAjax
AgentAjaxAgentAjaxBrisbane, Queensland Australia81 Threads 1 Polls 3,965 Posts
revealer24: The creation story is a song, it is symbolic, framed into a seven day block to give a reason for the seventh day rest.

Even science cannot fault the order of creation. What do you need for human life to occur? The story is given from the viewpoint of someone standing on earth. The first chapter is the global view, the second is local to a small area.

1. light
2. water cycle (water condensed, forms ground water and clouds)
3. vegetation (how else would animals survive - no mention of sea plants)
4. good temperature (so you can see the sun, moon and the stars). You need it for a rich animal world.
5. animal world
7. mankind

Dinosaurs? Not even cockroaches, spiders are mentioned. Argument from silence...

The problem is people take it literally that the days mean literal 24 hour days. All the waters cannot possibly precipitate and form oceans and dry land to appear in a single day.

Before you accuse me of pushing my own wheelbarrow, I don't care what anyone believes, what your religion, it is not my business. But let's be fair when dealing with the bible.


Apart from life been created before food ( vegetation) and the sun created on the fourth day, everything else seems in order. doh rolling on the floor laughing
Feb 23, 2013 8:14 PM CST What do you think of the theory of evolution by natural selection, do you think it's correct?
revealer24
revealer24revealer24Arundel, Queensland Australia62 Threads 985 Posts
Obscuritan: Dr. Rev, I think Rob is referring to me actually. He says "The op of this thread asked the question..... OP stands for original poster."
The reason he says I have a closed mind is because I have often pulled him up for denigrating christians (even though I'm not one,) and I've probably had a go at his Buddhism, something I must stop doing.

Anyway I knew evolution was going to generate a lot of comment and different opinions.

So thanks everyone for expressing your opinions; very interesting.

Note by the way that the creationists made a late rally in the poll and have a surprisingly high percentage. However, I believe we get plenty of American visitors hhere.


I might have misunderstood that.

I don't consider myself a Christian. Christianity has deviated from the original teachings after the Bar Kochba revolt was crushed. It absorbed Pagan ideas and philosophy.
Feb 23, 2013 8:18 PM CST What do you think of the theory of evolution by natural selection, do you think it's correct?
revealer24
revealer24revealer24Arundel, Queensland Australia62 Threads 985 Posts
wash2u: From Old Testament point of view, it was "an eye for an eye, a tooth for a tooth" but usually interpreted as getting revenge.


The above means the punishment must be comparable to the harm done. You cannot chop the hand of someone who steals like in Islam.

wash2u: And from somewhere else in the Old Testament "What you sow you shall reap."

Jesus put it a bit different again (the Bible does love to repeat itself in so many different ways) "Give unto others what you would them give to you."


The above two shows the two sides of the same coin. The first is about the consequences of your actions. The second is what your attitude should be towards others. There is no contradiction.
Feb 23, 2013 8:22 PM CST What do you think of the theory of evolution by natural selection, do you think it's correct?
revealer24
revealer24revealer24Arundel, Queensland Australia62 Threads 985 Posts
wash2u: The Koran starts out something like "There is but one God." Something that is repeated throughout the Bible.

I (and probably Rob as well) have objections more towards the hierachial and political scheming of all religions and philosophies.

If more "practise what you preach" was adhered to, it would be a better place for all.


Agree. Original Christianity wasn't a creed religion, but about righteous living. The Greek Christian made it into a creed religion. Now what you believe is of paramount importance compared to how you live.
Feb 23, 2013 8:58 PM CST What do you think of the theory of evolution by natural selection, do you think it's correct?
revealer24
revealer24revealer24Arundel, Queensland Australia62 Threads 985 Posts
AgentAjax: Apart from life been created before food ( vegetation) and the sun created on the fourth day, everything else seems in order.


Have you actually checked it?

vs 9-10: waters and dry land
vs 11-13 vegetation

Light is there right from the beginning.

Here is my model.

Until vegetation appears there is a lot of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere - greenhouse effect -> thick clouds, so you cannot see the sun, moon and stars.

Once CO2 is consumed and absorbed by the waters the sky clears. The ancient man is not a rocket scientist to understand that these only became visible, the story is simply recorded in their language in their terms and understandings.

You don't have the animal world before these.
Feb 23, 2013 9:11 PM CST What do you think of the theory of evolution by natural selection, do you think it's correct?
AgentAjax
AgentAjaxAgentAjaxBrisbane, Queensland Australia81 Threads 1 Polls 3,965 Posts
revealer24: Have you actually checked it?

vs 9-10: waters and dry land
vs 11-13 vegetation

Light is there right from the beginning.

Here is my model.

Until vegetation appears there is a lot of carbon dioxide in the atmosphere - greenhouse effect -> thick clouds, so you cannot see the sun, moon and stars.

Once CO2 is consumed and absorbed by the waters the sky clears. The ancient man is not a rocket scientist to understand that these only became visible, the story is simply recorded in their language in their terms and understandings.

You don't have the animal world before these.


The bible says what it says the sun was created on the fourth day and life before vegetation. Earlier your comment to blizzard was that the bible was not intended as a science book, but here you are trying to use science to create some sort of illusion that the bible is a scientific book. Yeah whatever keep beating that drum.
Feb 24, 2013 5:56 AM CST What do you think of the theory of evolution by natural selection, do you think it's correct?
revealer24
revealer24revealer24Arundel, Queensland Australia62 Threads 985 Posts
AgentAjax: The bible says what it says the sun was created on the fourth day and life before vegetation. Earlier your comment to blizzard was that the bible was not intended as a science book, but here you are trying to use science to create some sort of illusion that the bible is a scientific book. Yeah whatever keep beating that drum.


It is not intended as a science book, therefore it gives you an account of how the ancient man would have understood.

The bible says what we read into it. It is often difficult to interpret, particularly that we read translations not the original language. The first verse is simply a summary of the whole story. It is about fashioning a home for mankind. Here are two videos I like:


Feb 25, 2013 4:24 AM CST What do you think of the theory of evolution by natural selection, do you think it's correct?
AgentAjax
AgentAjaxAgentAjaxBrisbane, Queensland Australia81 Threads 1 Polls 3,965 Posts
Where are these original NT texts that were written in Hebrew?
Feb 25, 2013 5:51 AM CST What do you think of the theory of evolution by natural selection, do you think it's correct?
revealer24
revealer24revealer24Arundel, Queensland Australia62 Threads 985 Posts
AgentAjax: Where are these original NT texts that were written in Hebrew?


Did I say the original NT text was written in Hebrew? The guy does, but I don't think there is enough evidence. I rather think they were written to the leaders of the early churches that were initially Jews for obvious reason, who might have spoken a mixed kind of language like we do :)

Migrants in Australia often use their own idioms and translate it into English.

But whatever language it was written in, we don't have ANY of the original stuff, only copies of copies of copies, only fragments before the fourth century, with the first more complete manuscripts and translations appearing later.

But I think this is becoming way off-topic...
Feb 26, 2013 4:10 AM CST What do you think of the theory of evolution by natural selection, do you think it's correct?
AgentAjax
AgentAjaxAgentAjaxBrisbane, Queensland Australia81 Threads 1 Polls 3,965 Posts
revealer24: Did I say the original NT text was written in Hebrew? The guy does, but I don't think there is enough evidence. I rather think they were written to the leaders of the early churches that were initially Jews for obvious reason, who might have spoken a mixed kind of language like we do :)

Migrants in Australia often use their own idioms and translate it into English.

But whatever language it was written in, we don't have ANY of the original stuff, only copies of copies of copies, only fragments before the fourth century, with the first more complete manuscripts and translations appearing later.

But I think this is becoming way off-topic...
No you didn’t say it but you did post a clip that said it for you. I’ve seen most of Banners writings long time ago and now that you have reminded me of him, I do like the way he presents his arguments.
Feb 27, 2013 6:08 AM CST What do you think of the theory of evolution by natural selection, do you think it's correct?
revealer24
revealer24revealer24Arundel, Queensland Australia62 Threads 985 Posts
I think he makes a good argument, but I doubt we will ever know the truth.
Feb 27, 2013 11:13 PM CST What do you think of the theory of evolution by natural selection, do you think it's correct?
Martia
MartiaMartiabenalla, Victoria Australia141 Threads 1 Polls 2,888 Posts
I like these threads as you can always sort out the men from the boys so to speak.
As for my opinion oh dear 'cannot answer I am agnostic and saying that it comes down to its a bloody cruel world out there'and how can we start as there is no beginning and I would guess no end its just there' which our minds cannot fathom as nature did not give us the ability to infinity.
Feb 28, 2013 3:31 AM CST What do you think of the theory of evolution by natural selection, do you think it's correct?
wash2u
wash2uwash2uMelbourne, Victoria Australia79 Threads 1 Polls 3,768 Posts
AgentAjax: Yes we understand that. What Banner is saying the original texts might have been written in Hebrew and then translated later into Greek, assuming the apostils were bilinguistic jews.


Jews have been multi-lingual for the last 3 millenium at least. They often had different "masters." Much as England had for many centuries when there were so many different conquerers. Fresians, Angles, Saxons, Romans, Danes, Normans.

The original Hebrew text was translated into Latin, not Greek. When the Christian religion and all its in-fighting was taking place, the Greeks were a non-entity in the power games. So Latin was the only place where the "recorded history" was taking place as they made a decision to destroy any records of cults or opposing religions when they found them.

And much of the New Testament was set in its final form some 400 years after Christ. Relying on collective (often vague) hand-me-down stories, it is the "recalled" truth from those stories that did survive. And also what the "Church" wanted to put out to the common and uncommon (lords) man for its own benefit.

It was in 1450 that Gutenberg's press (an adaption of earlier invented technologies) that we had mass produced Bibles saying the exact same thing every time it was printed. It wasn't until Martin Luther (a very good copy-writer) actually read what he was copying that things began to change. "Hang on, I am copying something that Father Long-time-ago wrote and it says in Samuel 13.4 'you' not 'me' and it doesn't agree with the new printed version." They cost a lot to print in those days and priests were paid nothing to do the work. And they could colour in bits as well.

So the Bible is not the end-all of recorded history, just one version that has survived. There a documented facts to support the events recorded in the Bible. But all the knockers have to realise that it is an "abridged version" of history.
Feb 28, 2013 3:46 AM CST What do you think of the theory of evolution by natural selection, do you think it's correct?
Obscuritan
ObscuritanObscuritanMelbourne, Victoria Australia37 Threads 3 Polls 1,284 Posts
wash2u: NT was written in Latin. OT was written in Hebrew, "translated" into Latin as the priests saw fit, and often misinterpreted. The St James version of the Bible was translated from the Latin version and the New Age Bible actually had the courage to consult the early Hebrew texts and discuss with approriate theologian people the merits of the orginal meanigs of some/many words.



Nope, it is generally believed that the NT was written in Greek.
Feb 28, 2013 7:10 AM CST What do you think of the theory of evolution by natural selection, do you think it's correct?
Blizzard14u
Blizzard14uBlizzard14uGosnells, Western Australia Australia67 Threads 2 Polls 1,430 Posts
revealer24: Since you apparently don't know how to quote and comment I need to dig out what you wrote from the body of the text.
Perhaps you should state if you are talking about the bible or its interpretation. Not the same. Heaps of people make such claims like the bible says this or that. The bible is not intended as a science book. And argument from silence is worthless.
Maybe if you actually had read what I wrote you would have spared yourself the time to write this. I repeat it for you: the sun is the SUSTAINER of life. What proof do we have that it is its creator?
What does this have to do with real scientists getting Nobel Prize for their achievements? You seem to have a very high opinion of yourself.
It is obvious they don't know who is behind that door. If they knew they wouldn't.

Why do you open the door?
An ex-CIA agent testified a few years ago that the US was either directly or indirectly responsible for the death of 6 million people since WWII.

What proof do you have of murder in such a high scale due to religious wars any time in history?
Totally unintelligent and disrespectful. You have absolutely no idea what you are talking about and your post proves it.


You’re an idiot!
I refuse to lower myself to argue with an idiot as you will just bring me down to your level and beat me with experience!

At being an idiot!
professor rolling on the floor laughing rolling on the floor laughing
Feb 28, 2013 1:02 PM CST What do you think of the theory of evolution by natural selection, do you think it's correct?
Good on you Blizzard i agree, for revealer to make a statement "I don't care what anyone believes"!, just show how completely ignorant a person can be, revealer goes on to promote a whole lot of gibberish that defies logic and reason, promotes the notion people engaged in starting and playing out wars are not doing so based on there thought process e.g religion, a complete ignorant stupid assertion.
Blizzard even if you disagree that's ok but I think you'll find a lot more sinse in the thread well until revealer has finished talking crap
Feb 28, 2013 1:30 PM CST What do you think of the theory of evolution by natural selection, do you think it's correct?
Lookin4missright
Lookin4missrightLookin4missrightmelbourne, Victoria Australia400 Threads 24,032 Posts
i'm going to the bottleshop, anyone need anything?
Feb 28, 2013 1:40 PM CST What do you think of the theory of evolution by natural selection, do you think it's correct?
AgentAjax
AgentAjaxAgentAjaxBrisbane, Queensland Australia81 Threads 1 Polls 3,965 Posts
robplum: Good on you Blizzard i agree, for revealer to make a statement "I don't care what anyone believes"!, just show how completely ignorant a person can be, revealer goes on to promote a whole lot of gibberish that defies logic and reason, promotes the notion people engaged in starting and playing out wars are not doing so based on there thought process e.g religion, a complete ignorant stupid assertion.
Blizzard even if you disagree that's ok but I think you'll find a lot more sinse in the thread well until revealer has finished talking crap
This is relatively a new belief, around 50 years young and is lived today amongst some villages in Jerusalem. They have gone away from all faiths including spirituality. Main stream religions are selfish, spirituality says love is an answer, but we know love and hate is the same emotion. So what they do is honour, give thanks to the beauty in the world, nature and people. The crime rate and violence is almost non existent. As far as I know the belief has no name, it is just an attitude you live by.
Feb 28, 2013 1:55 PM CST What do you think of the theory of evolution by natural selection, do you think it's correct?
yeah but i study suffering, and do so for a reason being the nature of experience is actually suffering and unless we understand the dependent arising of our sufferings we cannot apply the correct antidotes.

I don't mind revealer holding his own views or expressing them in an open forum such as this, however being rude to everyone who other other views (i'm not saying anyone has to agree with others) but it isn't constructive.
There are new versions or faith based beliefs turning up all the time, none seem willing to debate so one can only conclude is just another form of harmful out of control ego
Mar 1, 2013 3:17 AM CST What do you think of the theory of evolution by natural selection, do you think it's correct?
wash2u
wash2uwash2uMelbourne, Victoria Australia79 Threads 1 Polls 3,768 Posts
AgentAjax: This is relatively a new belief, around 50 years young and is lived today amongst some villages in Jerusalem. They have gone away from all faiths including spirituality. Main stream religions are selfish, spirituality says love is an answer, but we know love and hate is the same emotion. So what they do is honour, give thanks to the beauty in the world, nature and people. The crime rate and violence is almost non existent. As far as I know the belief has no name, it is just an attitude you live by.


Ummm, that has been around in many parts of the world for a long time. 50 years ago they were called "Hippies" and didn't the 'organised' world hate all this love and peace they were preaching. In the 50s, they were called Bomenians or Beatniks.

The USA was started by those who went for all this peaceful stuff and religious freedom (as long as you were a Quaker).
Mar 5, 2013 1:22 AM CST What do you think of the theory of evolution by natural selection, do you think it's correct?
gold71
gold71gold71Cairns, Queensland Australia25 Threads 339 Posts
Blizzard14u: The bible is a lie! Evolution is the only explanation that fits in!

I have watched those idiots from the USA, on you tube! Saying where is the crockaduck?

Felt like sending the idiot a picture off a platypus or a 20 cent Australian coin.

The truth is the Sun is god! the giver off all life, But the religious people have too have something else so you can pay them money! The Earth is mother Mary the shelter off all life as we know it! The twelve disciples are the 12 signs off the zodiac!

The thing that gets me is that all religions follow these three basic rules and none off them have got it right as yet? That all religions putdown science until it is beyond doubt! The advancement off mankind can only be achieved if we get rid off religion!

I am sick off people dieing because off who they believe in? or more off what they are told to believe in?

One day we will all have freedom! From greed and corruption!
We use cookies to ensure that you have the best experience possible on our website. Read Our Privacy Policy Here