Would you go out with someone who had a serious mental health problem? (103)

May 16, 2010 5:39 AM CST Would you go out with someone who had a serious mental health problem?
jeepers
jeepersjeepersCowpet Bay, Saint Thomas Virgin Islands (USA)57 Threads 10,968 Posts
Being crazy is way over rated ! violin crazy sheep
May 16, 2010 5:39 AM CST Would you go out with someone who had a serious mental health problem?
May 16, 2010 7:49 AM CST Would you go out with someone who had a serious mental health problem?
MrInteresting
MrInterestingMrInterestingedinburgh, Lothian, Scotland UK28 Threads 8 Polls 323 Posts
Well, I see that the bulk of people on here, wouldn't date someone with a serious mental health problem.

However, let's say that you were not aware, and it took a few months for you to notice, for sure. What would it then take for you to finish it, assuming, by this time, that you had strong feelings for them?
May 16, 2010 7:52 AM CST Would you go out with someone who had a serious mental health problem?
thewall2
thewall2thewall2montreal, Quebec Canada61 Threads 10,499 Posts
Some people are AWARE that they have mental health issues..some aren't.
The ones who aren't they're the one you gotta watch out for.

I'm crazy...if you wanna argue..








































pick another topic.tongue
May 16, 2010 3:10 PM CST Would you go out with someone who had a serious mental health problem?
MrInteresting
MrInterestingMrInterestingedinburgh, Lothian, Scotland UK28 Threads 8 Polls 323 Posts
So.

The people have spoken - people with an acute mental health problem, esp one which they will not address, as they should, should be avoided, at all costs, because, in the end it will prove to be a futile effort.

Yup. I would agree with that, sadly.
May 16, 2010 3:17 PM CST Would you go out with someone who had a serious mental health problem?
MovinFWD
MovinFWDMovinFWDDaytona Beach, Florida USA36 Threads 3,234 Posts
MrInteresting: So.

The people have spoken - people with an acute mental health problem, esp one which they will not address, as they should, should be avoided, at all costs, because, in the end it will prove to be a futile effort.

Yup. I would agree with that, sadly.
So should a dating site be created especially for them where they can meet other mental health problem people. I mean, they need lovin' too, right. help
May 16, 2010 6:15 PM CST Would you go out with someone who had a serious mental health problem?
MrInteresting
MrInterestingMrInterestingedinburgh, Lothian, Scotland UK28 Threads 8 Polls 323 Posts
MovinFWD: So should a dating site be created especially for them where they can meet other mental health problem people. I mean, they need lovin' too, right.


LOL. Not sure that would be a good idea. Can you imagine that havoc that two people, each with a serious mental health issue, might create?
May 16, 2010 6:18 PM CST Would you go out with someone who had a serious mental health problem?
nanners2863
nanners2863nanners2863Cayuga, Ontario Canada38 Threads 3,355 Posts
MrInteresting: LOL. Not sure that would be a good idea. Can you imagine that havoc that two people, each with a serious mental health issue, might create?
I used to volunteer in a half-way house. People fell in love all the time. Just because someone has a mental health issue doesn't mean they don't deserve compassion,love and tenderness..they're still human. What about the homeless..80% of homeless people are mentally ill..and they usually pair up..looking for comfort in their misery. Serious mental issues can be controlled and a person can function and love. very mad
May 16, 2010 7:24 PM CST Would you go out with someone who had a serious mental health problem?
MrInteresting
MrInterestingMrInterestingedinburgh, Lothian, Scotland UK28 Threads 8 Polls 323 Posts
nanners2863: Just because someone has a mental health issue doesn't mean they don't deserve compassion,love and tenderness..they're still human..


Of course!

However, that said, those that give them love, compassion and tenderness, they also deserve to be treated that way, right back in return, right? And there lies the problem. Many with a serious MHP cannot do those things, without it all imploding, or going really badly wrong, because of their condition.
May 16, 2010 8:06 PM CST Would you go out with someone who had a serious mental health problem?
mjames
mjamesmjamesnapa, California USA2 Threads 1 Polls 779 Posts
nanners2863: I used to volunteer in a half-way house. People fell in love all the time. Just because someone has a mental health issue doesn't mean they don't deserve compassion,love and tenderness..they're still human. What about the homeless..80% of homeless people are mentally ill..and they usually pair up..looking for comfort in their misery. Serious mental issues can be controlled and a person can function and love.


Of course everyone deserves passion and love but it's not the law that I have to date them.

I would never in a million years date anyone that is bipolar or have all this ridiculous anxiety and other emotional problems.

Their trump card to cheating, stealing and doing whatever else they want and get away with it is their disease.

"I didn't take my meds!". lol;

Most people with issues like these are put on tons of meds instead of giving them good advice.

One friend who was "bipolar" always made stupid decisions in dating. It was never her fault; she always was a poor little victim, until we all said enough. Start taking responsibilities for your actions and stop the victim crap. Take control of your life.

3 years later she is in a stable relationship and takes no meds.

All of these mental "disorders" have been fed to us by the insurance companies, which right now are trying to pass U.S. laws to allow 2 year olds; YES TWO YEAR OLDS! to go on antidepressants!!!!

79% of mental drugs are taken by ONE COUNTRY!!! the U.S.

We're fed this crap that we are victims, go on meds, and if you do something wrong it's not your fault, it's the disease.

I think it's ridiculous. So no way would I date someone with emotional problems.
May 16, 2010 8:08 PM CST Would you go out with someone who had a serious mental health problem?
mjames
mjamesmjamesnapa, California USA2 Threads 1 Polls 779 Posts
MrInteresting: Would you date someone who had a serious mental health problem, such as Borderline Personality Disorder, or psychosis?

I ask this, because I have, and, despite my best efforts, it was always doomed to failure, and I think if faced with that choice again, I would shy away from it.


P.S. not by the insurance companies; I made a mistake; by the drug companies; they are also trying to make road rage a mental disorder so insurance companies can pay for mental meds for it.

I worked in a half way house too and to see doctors and nurses tell these people it was never their fault and to just take drugs was insanity.
May 16, 2010 8:12 PM CST Would you go out with someone who had a serious mental health problem?
nanners2863
nanners2863nanners2863Cayuga, Ontario Canada38 Threads 3,355 Posts
mjames: Of course everyone deserves passion and love but it's not the law that I have to date them.

I would never in a million years date anyone that is bipolar or have all this ridiculous anxiety and other emotional problems.

Their trump card to cheating, stealing and doing whatever else they want and get away with it is their disease.

"I didn't take my meds!". lol;

Most people with issues like these are put on tons of meds instead of giving them good advice.

One friend who was "bipolar" always made stupid decisions in dating. It was never her fault; she always was a poor little victim, until we all said enough. Start taking responsibilities for your actions and stop the victim crap. Take control of your life.

3 years later she is in a stable relationship and takes no meds.

All of these mental "disorders" have been fed to us by the insurance companies, which right now are trying to pass U.S. laws to allow 2 year olds; YES TWO YEAR OLDS! to go on antidepressants!!!!

79% of mental drugs are taken by ONE COUNTRY!!! the U.S.

We're fed this crap that we are victims, go on meds, and if you do something wrong it's not your fault, it's the disease.

I think it's ridiculous. So no way would I date someone with emotional problems.
I was responding to the statement of two people with mental health issues dating..not a healthy person dating someone with mental health issue..read carefully before you spout.doh
May 16, 2010 8:14 PM CST Would you go out with someone who had a serious mental health problem?
nanners2863
nanners2863nanners2863Cayuga, Ontario Canada38 Threads 3,355 Posts
MrInteresting: Of course!

However, that said, those that give them love, compassion and tenderness, they also deserve to be treated that way, right back in return, right? And there lies the problem. Many with a serious MHP cannot do those things, without it all imploding, or going really badly wrong, because of their condition.
AGAIN..my comment was directed to your statement about two people with mental health issues dating...geesh.
May 16, 2010 8:14 PM CST Would you go out with someone who had a serious mental health problem?
MrInteresting
MrInterestingMrInterestingedinburgh, Lothian, Scotland UK28 Threads 8 Polls 323 Posts
nanners2863: AGAIN..my comment was directed to your statement about two people with mental health issues dating...geesh.


Oh.

Well, in the case of that, I guess they would cancel one another out!!!

professor
May 16, 2010 8:29 PM CST Would you go out with someone who had a serious mental health problem?
Christmas1
Christmas1Christmas1Peterborough, Ontario Canada31 Threads 2,419 Posts
conjor: Yes 'with an IQ of about 70'That woulds be perfect;And oh can i have one who cant talk ????
I don't think that is funny. My sister is retarted. Her life has not been an easy one. She tried to hide her condition, but it became quite noticeable as she reached puberty. It was hard for her to talk. Going to high school was a shock to her. My God, she wasn't going to be ashamed anymore. She removed her breast binder, she no longer wore Oxford shoes, and now her face had more paint that the Mahattan Bridge. She could now celebrate the fact that she was a TART, (she had been for a while, but only in secret, sneaking out on Saturday night). So she was really celebrating her "RETART NIGHT". YES, MY SISTER IS RETARTED!!!!.
May 17, 2010 11:35 AM CST Would you go out with someone who had a serious mental health problem?
doberman3
doberman3doberman3Clarksville, Tennessee USA25 Threads 1 Polls 1,838 Posts
Yes everyone on their on merits.

If person was on theirs med's and acted like a adult, why not? Look at all the normal people with problems that act like children and are on this site.

Don't label all that have the a mental disorder as someone bad to date, you might just have met one of the greatest people around.

True, if they are not one their meds and are not trying, that is a different story.

Even if they are on their meds, and they are not working, maybe the most simple thing that can be done, to to change their doctor, to get a second opinion.

But of all things considered, try to treat these people as human beings and with dignity. This seems to be the illness to shame people for and people say run. You may not want to date people with a condition like this, but respect them like you want to be respected yourself. It goes both ways.

The Doberman
May 17, 2010 1:19 PM CST Would you go out with someone who had a serious mental health problem?
doberman3
doberman3doberman3Clarksville, Tennessee USA25 Threads 1 Polls 1,838 Posts
mjames: Of course everyone deserves passion and love but it's not the law that I have to date them.

I would never in a million years date anyone that is bipolar or have all this ridiculous anxiety and other emotional problems.

Their trump card to cheating, stealing and doing whatever else they want and get away with it is their disease.

"I didn't take my meds!". lol;

Most people with issues like these are put on tons of meds instead of giving them good advice.

One friend who was "bipolar" always made stupid decisions in dating. It was never her fault; she always was a poor little victim, until we all said enough. Start taking responsibilities for your actions and stop the victim crap. Take control of your life.

3 years later she is in a stable relationship and takes no meds.

All of these mental "disorders" have been fed to us by the insurance companies, which right now are trying to pass U.S. laws to allow 2 year olds; YES TWO YEAR OLDS! to go on antidepressants!!!!

79% of mental drugs are taken by ONE COUNTRY!!! the U.S.

We're fed this crap that we are victims, go on meds, and if you do something wrong it's not your fault, it's the disease.

I think it's ridiculous. So no way would I date someone with emotional problems.


My your remarks are long and draining. This is why I reply, my last note to you in the matter.

Mr. James, thanks for the last letter. It was one I will forget. Alot of it was titling me as you are this and you are that, I feel you are biased in your opinions.

I do not like being judged by such a perfect man as yourself.

If I am more sensitive and open than you, don't worry about it.
But you did not get into the plain ugliness of someone's reply to me,
but I doubt if you have the heart to understand the impact made.

Futhermore, to try to reason with you, who already has made up his mind is draining to me.

Not one answer on the brillance of so called depressed people in the past like Lincoln and Churchill who just did their jobs even though they had a illness. Enough said between you and me. You have won.

The doberman
May 17, 2010 2:02 PM CST Would you go out with someone who had a serious mental health problem?
bodleing
bodleingbodleingGreater Manchester, England UK238 Threads 8 Polls 13,810 Posts
My wife had a serious mental health problem.

Well she must have...she married me!!!


laugh
May 17, 2010 2:15 PM CST Would you go out with someone who had a serious mental health problem?
doberman3
doberman3doberman3Clarksville, Tennessee USA25 Threads 1 Polls 1,838 Posts
My wife had a serious mental health problem.

Well she must have...she married me!!![/quote


I accept that answer, good one!handshake


So are you a notapolar?


You see, you have bipolar: manic depressive
unipolar: depressive
notapolar: ones that are normal -
but who is normal, these days?


The Doberman
ALso, notapolar, made up by me, not a scientific term.
May 17, 2010 5:40 PM CST Would you go out with someone who had a serious mental health problem?
MrInteresting
MrInterestingMrInterestingedinburgh, Lothian, Scotland UK28 Threads 8 Polls 323 Posts
doberman3: Yes everyone on their on merits.

If person was on theirs med's and acted like a adult, why not? Look at all the normal people with problems that act like children and are on this site.

Don't label all that have the a mental disorder as someone bad to date, you might just have met one of the greatest people around.

True, if they are not one their meds and are not trying, that is a different story.

Even if they are on their meds, and they are not working, maybe the most simple thing that can be done, to to change their doctor, to get a second opinion.

But of all things considered, try to treat these people as human beings and with dignity. This seems to be the illness to shame people for and people say run. You may not want to date people with a condition like this, but respect them like you want to be respected yourself. It goes both ways.

The Doberman


I would agree.

However, the problem with many who have, for example, Borderline Personality disorder, is that meds or no meds, they still need to work hard, themselves, to take the edge of some of their behaviours.

Sometimes I feel that they can pull this or that, and get away with it, kinda hide behind their mental health problem.
May 17, 2010 6:18 PM CST Would you go out with someone who had a serious mental health problem?
doberman3
doberman3doberman3Clarksville, Tennessee USA25 Threads 1 Polls 1,838 Posts
MrInteresting: I would agree.

However, the problem with many who have, for example, Borderline Personality disorder, is that meds or no meds, they still need to work hard, themselves, to take the edge of some of their behaviours.

Sometimes I feel that they can pull this or that, and get away with it, kinda hide behind their mental health problem.


Yes, I have know those types, you are completely correct, anyone with a mental illness can not take advanage of people because of their disease. Because soon, people around them will be calling wolf. They need to constantly be doing team work with their doctors-talk therapy and their meds. The sad thing is, the other can do only so much. Then it is between the person and their doctors.

There are support groups for the loved ones dealing with the person, so they can get the support from others going through the same or similiar problem. Because one thing that is not mentioned, is heredity has alot to do with mental illness. Then when the mentally ill person marries, the disease is often passed to their children.

The person, should also attend support groups for the mentally ill.
They can hear others talk about their particular illness. In the end,
the mentally ill person is in charge for their own life. Not someone else taking care of them constantly, but times do arise when they do need a hug or some understanding. It is not a easy disease to cope with and really hard when such a stigma goes along with it. Look at how many here would not date a mentally ill person.

I think the old saying is very true here, talk a walk in my shoes. Maybe you would get a new outlook.

The Dobermanhandshake
May 17, 2010 7:08 PM CST Would you go out with someone who had a serious mental health problem?
MrInteresting: Would you date someone who had a serious mental health problem, such as Borderline Personality Disorder, or psychosis?

I ask this, because I have, and, despite my best efforts, it was always doomed to failure, and I think if faced with that choice again, I would shy away from it.


No, I would feel that I am walking on egg shells all the time. You can't fix the person, and if they
forget to take their meds, you are in dire strait!
May 17, 2010 7:21 PM CST Would you go out with someone who had a serious mental health problem?
MrInteresting
MrInterestingMrInterestingedinburgh, Lothian, Scotland UK28 Threads 8 Polls 323 Posts
mychelle: No, I would feel that I am walking on egg shells all the time. You can't fix the person, and if they
forget to take their meds, you are in dire strait!


Well, how about this one. When I was with this lass, in question, I went all the way to the other end of the country, to live with her. It cost me a lot to do that, and, of course, the upheavel of it. The day that I got there, she proudly announced that she was coming off ALL her meds, at once. Obviously, I was concerned, suggested that if she did not like them, perhaps she should go to the GP, and be guided. But no, she did not take them for two weeks, began coming apart at the seams, being really nasty to me. Which was really hard, given that I was in her flat, in her town.

After two weeks, she went back on them (not a good idea to flip flop), and, later that same day, she went out drinking, and got v ill.

Guess who the mug was who was running back and forth, with a bucket..?

That would have been bad enough. However, she then proceeded to tell anyone who would listen, that I was trying to convince her she had a MHP, and that I wanted her on the meds 'as it is easier to control her'.

That really hurt, because I had only ever tried to do my best, when it came to her care, and meds, so for her to turn around, say such things, well, to me, that is really evil.
May 17, 2010 7:34 PM CST Would you go out with someone who had a serious mental health problem?
MrInteresting: Well, how about this one. When I was with this lass, in question, I went all the way to the other end of the country, to live with her. It cost me a lot to do that, and, of course, the upheavel of it. The day that I got there, she proudly announced that she was coming off ALL her meds, at once. Obviously, I was concerned, suggested that if she did not like them, perhaps she should go to the GP, and be guided. But no, she did not take them for two weeks, began coming apart at the seams, being really nasty to me. Which was really hard, given that I was in her flat, in her town.

After two weeks, she went back on them (not a good idea to flip flop), and, later that same day, she went out drinking, and got v ill.

Guess who the mug was who was running back and forth, with a bucket..?

That would have been bad enough. However, she then proceeded to tell anyone who would listen, that I was trying to convince her she had a MHP, and that I wanted her on the meds 'as it is easier to control her'.

That really hurt, because I had only ever tried to do my best, when it came to her care, and meds, so for her to turn around, say such things, well, to me, that is really evil.


Looking at it, it appears evil, but that is exactly how people with bipolar and other mental illness feels. The psychoses or grandiosity, tell them that you did it, he made me do it, she did it, she made me do it sort of thing. Now that you have had a chance to step back and look at what was, you can now see that there was nothing in Hell(pardon the expression) that you could do to change that situation, except get You out of there safely. Do not be bitter, but let your real feelings come out. Allow yourself to feel that emotion again, say out loud I couldn't help it, but may she be at peace wherever she is at this moment. She was there in your life to teach you a lesson, to be in touch with yourself, to protect yourself, and not let people walk all over you !
May 17, 2010 7:38 PM CST Would you go out with someone who had a serious mental health problem?
Barrellofart
BarrellofartBarrellofartGrand Rapids, Michigan USA16 Threads 9 Polls 761 Posts
mjames: Of course everyone deserves passion and love but it's not the law that I have to date them.

I would never in a million years date anyone that is bipolar or have all this ridiculous anxiety and other emotional problems.

Their trump card to cheating, stealing and doing whatever else they want and get away with it is their disease.

"I didn't take my meds!". lol;

Most people with issues like these are put on tons of meds instead of giving them good advice.

One friend who was "bipolar" always made stupid decisions in dating. It was never her fault; she always was a poor little victim, until we all said enough. Start taking responsibilities for your actions and stop the victim crap. Take control of your life.

3 years later she is in a stable relationship and takes no meds.

All of these mental "disorders" have been fed to us by the insurance companies, which right now are trying to pass U.S. laws to allow 2 year olds; YES TWO YEAR OLDS! to go on antidepressants!!!!

79% of mental drugs are taken by ONE COUNTRY!!! the U.S.

We're fed this crap that we are victims, go on meds, and if you do something wrong it's not your fault, it's the disease.

I think it's ridiculous. So no way would I date someone with emotional problems.


barf

If you want to get preachy about who does-or-does-not have a mental disorder, start your own thread.

The question is: Would you date a person who DOES have a mental disorder.

I know people who do have social anxiety, and it is not even remotely a matter of just needing 'good advice', or a 'reality check'.
May 17, 2010 7:46 PM CST Would you go out with someone who had a serious mental health problem?
tatami
tatamitatamiInuyama City, Aichi Ken, Chubu Japan1 Threads 51 Posts
conjor: I would if she was retarted,and non violent...
confused
May 17, 2010 7:51 PM CST Would you go out with someone who had a serious mental health problem?
MrInteresting
MrInterestingMrInterestingedinburgh, Lothian, Scotland UK28 Threads 8 Polls 323 Posts
mychelle: She was there in your life to teach you a lesson, to be in touch with yourself, to protect yourself, and not let people walk all over you !


Not sure if the lesson I learned was of any merit, tbh, other than that it showed me;

A) If someone exhibits obvious signs of a MHP, or you know they have one, do not risk being hurt, by helping them, or going out with them.

dunno
May 17, 2010 8:33 PM CST Would you go out with someone who had a serious mental health problem?
MrInteresting: Not sure if the lesson I learned was of any merit, tbh, other than that it showed me;

A) If someone exhibits obvious signs of a MHP, or you know they have one, do not risk being hurt, by helping them, or going out with them.

If in the future you should come across someone in similar situation, do not feel afraid. If they are in danger to you, others or themselves, call for help, and get away to a safe distance. .
May 17, 2010 9:35 PM CST Would you go out with someone who had a serious mental health problem?
mindfful
mindffulmindffulChicago, Illinois USA235 Threads 8 Polls 18,996 Posts
Desertguy49: I have no tolerance for women with psychotic behavior....
so this is your coming out party then desert guy?

banana
May 17, 2010 9:53 PM CST Would you go out with someone who had a serious mental health problem?
Witchaywoman
WitchaywomanWitchaywomanCarpentersville, Illinois USA97 Threads 13 Polls 4,344 Posts
MrInteresting: Would you date someone who had a serious mental health problem, such as Borderline Personality Disorder, or psychosis?

I ask this, because I have, and, despite my best efforts, it was always doomed to failure, and I think if faced with that choice again, I would shy away from it.


I had a boyfriend who claimed he was diagnosed schizo. He was on meds when I met him and he was ok to me. We broke up because of the usual stuff.

Share this Poll

We use cookies to ensure that you have the best experience possible on our website. Read Our Privacy Policy Here