How did Mary become pregnant? (427)

Feb 25, 2009 11:33 PM CST How did Mary become pregnant?
krimsa
krimsakrimsaMiddleton, New Hampshire USA6 Threads 2 Polls 1,345 Posts
galaxy15: Yes, I agree. But a problem remains - we should be developing an understanding, if not, an admission, that anthropomorphising a boundless and undefineable entity, which could be called - whatever you want! - is just another way of saying 'my god is better than your god - earlier than your god - mightier than your god'.
This 'entity' resides in 'non-time', and therefore -any- definition is acceptable, whenever this definition is made?!

cheers
chris


Oh no, you misunderstood I think. I’m not implying that the female creatrix is somehow more powerful or superior in any respect simply because it is older. You have to imagine first of all why the female would be associated with divinity at all and more than likely it’s the most obvious reason. Women are responsible for creating life and bringing it into the world. In fact all female animals are. What would have been the two most frightening and thought provoking mysteries expressed by early humans? More than likely birth and death. This is why the female would have this role for a long period of time preceding monotheism and the concept of a singular male deity. It’s not without social significance and explains a lot when you think about it in those terms.
Feb 26, 2009 6:27 AM CST How did Mary become pregnant?
krimsa
krimsakrimsaMiddleton, New Hampshire USA6 Threads 2 Polls 1,345 Posts
galaxy15: Yeah - which Mary?
Would a creator really care whether his envoys are immaculately conceived, or not? Why does this render the story of this event, either more mysterious or less mysterious? Someone called Mary, and someone called Joseph, did 'it', they had another son; the guy learned some pretty cool things (for his time), had an epiphany - whatever; this made him special enough to have been noticed by quite a few people - who wrote stories about him - Along the way, the stories became more and more embellished (we all do it! exaggerate - I mean), until a whole religion was written around him. Was he real?

If you look at the grain - you cannot see the beach;
and if you look at the beach - you cannot see the sand!


I also would agree that it does not matter how Jesus was conceived. That was a mistake anyway. The word "almah" was used to describe Mary (his mother) in the bible. In Hebrew, the word "almah" is a descriptive term and means "young woman." This would have been an accurate depiction of Mary at the time that she became pregnant because she was probably a teenager.

For whatever reason, later Christian theologians mistranslated the word almah to mean "virgin." The Hebrew word for virgin is "bethulah" and never once was used in connection with Mary.
Feb 28, 2009 7:16 PM CST How did Mary become pregnant?
galaxy15
galaxy15galaxy15melbourne, Victoria Australia3 Threads 480 Posts
krimsa: I also would agree that it does not matter how Jesus was conceived. That was a mistake anyway. The word "almah" was used to describe Mary (his mother) in the bible. In Hebrew, the word "almah" is a descriptive term and means "young woman." This would have been an accurate depiction of Mary at the time that she became pregnant because she was probably a teenager.

For whatever reason, later Christian theologians mistranslated the word almah to mean "virgin." The Hebrew word for virgin is "bethulah" and never once was used in connection with Mary.


Cheers krimsa
There is nothing better than debating with people who actually know thier subject. I liked this thread alot.
chris
Feb 28, 2009 7:18 PM CST How did Mary become pregnant?
mindfful
mindffulmindffulChicago, Illinois USA235 Threads 8 Polls 18,996 Posts
im glad someone enjoyed the thread

do you know any other song krisma?

just curious

yes a debate is good and enriching but how many times to discuss it?


dunno
Feb 28, 2009 8:30 PM CST How did Mary become pregnant?
mindfful
mindffulmindffulChicago, Illinois USA235 Threads 8 Polls 18,996 Posts
hopefloats: This is the most absurd poll I've seen yet!


now nowscold


i just thot to actually check the poll resultsdoh


cool
Mar 1, 2009 3:26 AM CST How did Mary become pregnant?
krimsa
krimsakrimsaMiddleton, New Hampshire USA6 Threads 2 Polls 1,345 Posts
mindfful: now now i just thot to actually check the poll results


I was shocked as to how close they were. I never expected to see that. thumbs up
Mar 1, 2009 3:30 AM CST How did Mary become pregnant?
krimsa
krimsakrimsaMiddleton, New Hampshire USA6 Threads 2 Polls 1,345 Posts
galaxy15: Cheers krimsa
There is nothing better than debating with people who actually know thier subject. I liked this thread alot.
chris


I don’t know everything. In school we read parts of the bible. Mainly I’m familiar with the OT. It was a course study in creation mythology of different peoples. Cultural anthropology.grin Thats the extent of it.
Mar 1, 2009 3:46 AM CST How did Mary become pregnant?
maybesoon
maybesoonmaybesoonthe moon, Queensland Australia16 Threads 1 Polls 951 Posts
hopefloats: This is the most absurd poll I've seen yet!


what do you expect coming from who started it, we cant help people that are just bored out of their mind, and want something to talk about, or maybe its another one of her fairy-tales...

sounds like it!!!tongue
Mar 1, 2009 3:48 AM CST How did Mary become pregnant?
turquoise
turquoiseturquoiseVienna, Austria1 Posts
whi is mary? which mary? where?
Mar 1, 2009 3:56 AM CST How did Mary become pregnant?
krimsa
krimsakrimsaMiddleton, New Hampshire USA6 Threads 2 Polls 1,345 Posts
turquoise: whi is mary? which mary? where?


The mother of Jesus from the NT.
Mar 1, 2009 4:11 AM CST How did Mary become pregnant?
maybesoon
maybesoonmaybesoonthe moon, Queensland Australia16 Threads 1 Polls 951 Posts
krimsa: The mother of Jesus from the NT.


tell me something, if Jesus had a offspring, why isn't anything written about it, even after Jesus was killed, and why wasn't anything written about this so called relationship Jesus had with MM...everything you say, you cant prove!!! its just what you think happen, I believe it didn't happen, or it would throw what Christ is, "out the window" and it would make people like what you believe in "all powerful" and "righteous"..

And where does the world go from there, do we then believe in what you believe in, do we then start Churches all over the world from what you believe in... then what... you become a religion of your own... then what...

what's ya point here...

so we throw the bible and its teaching out the window, and into the fire, we burn down all the Church's, destroy all crosses, then what.... we walk around the world with no meaning...no hope... then what...
Mar 1, 2009 4:15 AM CST How did Mary become pregnant?
Mercedes1
Mercedes1Mercedes1Sydney, New South Wales Australia101 Threads 1 Polls 3,764 Posts
maybesoon: tell me something, if Jesus had a offspring, why isn't anything written about it, even after Jesus was killed, and why wasn't anything written about this so called relationship Jesus had with MM...everything you say, you cant prove!!! its just what you think happen, I believe it didn't happen, or it would throw what Christ is, "out the window" and it would make people like what you believe in "all powerful" and "righteous"..

And where does the world go from there, do we then believe in what you believe in, do we then start Churches all over the world from what you believe in... then what... you become a religion of your own... then what...

what's ya point here...

so we throw the bible and its teaching out the window, and into the fire, we burn down all the Church's, destroy all crosses, then what.... we walk around the world with no meaning...no hope... then what...



We all become muslimssigh
Mar 1, 2009 4:23 AM CST How did Mary become pregnant?
maybesoon
maybesoonmaybesoonthe moon, Queensland Australia16 Threads 1 Polls 951 Posts
Mercedes1: We all become muslims


well isnt that great.. we change from one religion to another!!! just a different name!!!

so this whole forum is about, throw the bible out, and lets replace it with something else... sounds like someone jealous of what has exsited for thousands of years...
Mar 1, 2009 4:32 AM CST How did Mary become pregnant?
Dusty45
Dusty45Dusty45Louisville, Kentucky USA54 Threads 2,642 Posts
How did Mary become pregnant?
~~
One would surmise in some way or another. <grin>

The fact that we are still discussing the conception, birth
and the man, Jesus Christ, gives great relevance to what
his message means to those who have the ability to use the
goodness of His words and thoughts after so many, many years.
There are great numbers who perceived correctly and for the
greater good. Then, there are those who chose otherwise.
What can one say except it was their choice. For some, it
just takes longer.
The NT was a correction of OT ideas, thoughts and perceptions
from Jesus' Mindset. One has to have the willingness to 'see'
it correctly.
Namaste'
(keep trying)<smile>
Mar 1, 2009 4:35 AM CST How did Mary become pregnant?
mike1937
mike1937mike1937Broadstairs, Kent, England UK11 Threads 554 Posts
hopefloats: This is the most absurd poll I've seen yet!


Well said
Mar 1, 2009 4:36 AM CST How did Mary become pregnant?
maybesoon: tell me something, if Jesus had a offspring, why isn't anything written about it, even after Jesus was killed, and why wasn't anything written about this so called relationship Jesus had with MM...everything you say, you cant prove!!! its just what you think happen, I believe it didn't happen, or it would throw what Christ is, "out the window" and it would make people like what you believe in "all powerful" and "righteous"..

And where does the world go from there, do we then believe in what you believe in, do we then start Churches all over the world from what you believe in... then what... you become a religion of your own... then what...

what's ya point here...

so we throw the bible and its teaching out the window, and into the fire, we burn down all the Church's, destroy all crosses, then what.... we walk around the world with no meaning...no hope... then what...
Don't need to burn the Books,the Church was busy doing that through the centuries.
If you believe that you're reading what actually happened,or didn't happen back then,you need to radically revise your thinking.
Books have been omitted Stuff has been added,been rewritten to fit the needs of the ones in power.
Study some History,instead the Shadow of it.
Don't be like the People in Plato's Cave.conversing
Mar 1, 2009 4:39 AM CST How did Mary become pregnant?
jessejess47
jessejess47jessejess47ogdensburg, New York USA35 Threads 1 Polls 3,886 Posts
Mercedes1: Sounds like they may of had dating sites back then also
yes but no forums as it was hard to chip posts into the stone tabletsrolling on the floor laughing
Mar 1, 2009 4:42 AM CST How did Mary become pregnant?
nibblejc
nibblejcnibblejcMafikeng, North-West South Africa3 Threads 25 Posts
That Tommy story is brilliant and should be thought about.
Mar 1, 2009 4:45 AM CST How did Mary become pregnant?
Mercedes1
Mercedes1Mercedes1Sydney, New South Wales Australia101 Threads 1 Polls 3,764 Posts
nibblejc: That Tommy story is brilliant and should be thought about.


Whose Tommy?grin
Mar 1, 2009 4:45 AM CST How did Mary become pregnant?
jessejess47: yes but no forums as it was hard to chip posts into the stone tablets
They had Wax-tablets and Styli then!professor rolling on the floor laughing
Mar 1, 2009 4:47 AM CST How did Mary become pregnant?
jessejess47
jessejess47jessejess47ogdensburg, New York USA35 Threads 1 Polls 3,886 Posts
Mercedes1: Whose Tommy?
he was a blind kid that played pinball really wellprofessor
Mar 1, 2009 4:48 AM CST How did Mary become pregnant?
nibblejc
nibblejcnibblejcMafikeng, North-West South Africa3 Threads 25 Posts
Read page 2
Mercedes1: Whose Tommy?
Mar 1, 2009 4:49 AM CST How did Mary become pregnant?
jessejess47
jessejess47jessejess47ogdensburg, New York USA35 Threads 1 Polls 3,886 Posts
jessejess47: he was a blind kid that played pinball really well
ok so I am a 70's child rolling on the floor laughing
Mar 1, 2009 4:51 AM CST How did Mary become pregnant?
Mercedes1
Mercedes1Mercedes1Sydney, New South Wales Australia101 Threads 1 Polls 3,764 Posts
nibblejc: Read page 2


rolling on the floor laughing rolling on the floor laughing rolling on the floor laughing
I read itrolling on the floor laughing
Mar 1, 2009 4:51 AM CST How did Mary become pregnant?
Mercedes1
Mercedes1Mercedes1Sydney, New South Wales Australia101 Threads 1 Polls 3,764 Posts
jessejess47: ok so I am a 70's child


Yeah their was a song for that movieboogie
Mar 1, 2009 4:52 AM CST How did Mary become pregnant?
Mercedes1
Mercedes1Mercedes1Sydney, New South Wales Australia101 Threads 1 Polls 3,764 Posts
nibblejc: Read page 2


I found it sooo funny but was it spose to be funny?grin
Mar 1, 2009 4:52 AM CST How did Mary become pregnant?
nibblejc
nibblejcnibblejcMafikeng, North-West South Africa3 Threads 25 Posts
Definitely not Joseph's Tommy.
Mercedes1: Whose Tommy?
. Maybe you meant Who's Tommy!laugh
Mar 1, 2009 4:53 AM CST How did Mary become pregnant?
trish123
trish123trish123Macclesfield, Cheshire, England UK177 Threads 4 Polls 13,724 Posts
maybesoon: tell me something, if Jesus had a offspring, why isn't anything written about it, even after Jesus was killed, and why wasn't anything written about this so called relationship Jesus had with MM...everything you say, you cant prove!!! its just what you think happen, I believe it didn't happen, or it would throw what Christ is, "out the window" and it would make people like what you believe in "all powerful" and "righteous"..

And where does the world go from there, do we then believe in what you believe in, do we then start Churches all over the world from what you believe in... then what... you become a religion of your own... then what...

what's ya point here...

so we throw the bible and its teaching out the window, and into the fire, we burn down all the Church's, destroy all crosses, then what.... we walk around the world with no meaning...no hope... then what...


Its basically all dictates from either the Council of Nicea or the Council of Trent at which meetings, official policy and guidelines were decided by important churchmen. They decreed church laws which were then given from the pulpits as fact.

Those people were as powerful in their day as various politicians and world leaders are today. Personally, I find little meaning in their dictates, especially as modern methods are exposing things such as a virgin birth to be a scientific impossibility.
Mar 1, 2009 4:58 AM CST How did Mary become pregnant?
trish123: Its basically all dictates from either the Council of Nicea or the Council of Trent at which meetings, official policy and guidelines were decided by important churchmen. They decreed church laws which were then given from the pulpits as fact.

Those people were as powerful in their day as various politicians and world leaders are today. Personally, I find little meaning in their dictates, especially as modern methods are exposing things such as a virgin birth to be a scientific impossibility.
Unless they are those Stick-Insects!
Some of them are definitely Insects.laugh
Mar 1, 2009 5:02 AM CST How did Mary become pregnant?
trish123
trish123trish123Macclesfield, Cheshire, England UK177 Threads 4 Polls 13,724 Posts
Conrad73: Unless they are those Stick-Insects!
Some of them are definitely Insects.


Or a plant rolling on the floor laughing
We use cookies to ensure that you have the best experience possible on our website. Read Our Privacy Policy Here