The Beatles versus The Rolling Stones...

Flashback to February 1964 and The Beatles appeared on the Ed Sullivan Show. Later the same year, The Rolling Stones appeared on Ed's show as well as many other groups from England... The newspapers called it The British Invasion.

Long hair, VOX amplifiers and uniforms for some. It was soon after local radio stations were asking kids to vote. I was 12 years old and asked to vote. School mates were taking sides asking me to vote my favorite band: The Beatles or The Rolling Stones.

How can you compare? They were musically different and different in how they got packaged. I doubt Hells Angels attended a Beatles concert!

I did like Brian Jones and his influences on the Stones, but I was too young and distant to the politics surrounding his leaving the band.

McCartney still performs and so does Ringo Starr, their two other band mates are gone now. The Stones less a retired bassist remain intact and are still touring. 56 years later McCartney and Jagger are still trading barbs as to who was better... The Beatles or The Rolling Stones.

My vote?
Post Comment

Comments (22)

I read a book on Brian Jones not too long ago. I thought he was good for the group, could play a lot of different instruments. The recorder solo in Ruby Tuesday for example. Towards the end he was unreliable and they forced him out.
Chat, I’ve always enjoyed both groups but In 1964 it was “no contest” as far as Omaha goes. The Rolling Stones drew but 650 people in a 10,000 seat auditorium at $3.50 a ticket. If Nebraska was fortunate enough to have them back today - they would sell out Memorial Stadium 90,000+ in Lincoln where the Husker football team plays and for whatever the ticket asking price would be.
Tall, on a parallel of creativity in many ways to Syd Barrett who founded Pink Floyd, Brian Jones also succumbed to drugs, missed appearances and was kicked out of the Rolling Stones.

Nice, last year an associate went to see the stones at the Hard Rock stadium (Home of the Miami Dolphins) with a sold out venue and tickets were $200 and up.

Joking to me he asked "What do you think the opening song would be?"
My response was "Jumping Jack Flash"
"No way" he said...

Later that night, I received a text with the image and the comment "How did you know?"

Embedded image from another site


Judging by the location of the photo, he was in one of the cheap seats!

laugh
The Rolling Stones released a new single this month...

Living In A Ghost Town

Is your vote.....under your thumb, or in the strawberry fields.....forever ? laugh
Will wild wild horses....drag it out of you or is it buried under a long & winding road ? dunno
Not sure Jim. I've been fixing a hole on my Yellow Submarine. Angie and I decided to Paint It Black.
Just make sure that black paint is dry, or when you
Come Together you might get Something such as Sticky Fingers.
laugh thumbs up
I hear you knocking!
Help ! Don't let me down. It's been a hard day's night. Gimme Shelter ! laugh
The monkee's were America's failed answer the the Beatles


dancing rolling on the floor laughing
True, but they were partially successful with their own TV show.
This is funny;

58 episodes total. laugh
Pop versus Rock. The Stones win that one hands down.

Best period was when Mick Taylor joined the band, superb brilliant raw rock guitar from him and Richards. Get yer ya yas out, was and still is their best album.
beer

The Beatles did however open the door of the The Ed Sullivan Show for the Stones and others to follow.
I went to my older brothers house in West Hempstead LI and watched the Ed Sullivan show on TV with my nieces and nephew when the Beatles appeared on the show. It was wonderful and I'll never forget it. It was like a meeting of the ages, the old ages represented by Ed Sullivan and the new age represented by the Beatles. Ed seemed totally bewildered by it.
Not long after, I learned they had microphones in the audience.
That's a tough one. Although I was young, I do remember seeing the Beatles on Ed Sullivan. My grandmother bought me Beatles Bobbleheads. I probably wish I still had them. She also took me to a Beatles movie. Having said all that, I'd still pick the Stones. The Beatles have some songs that I'd still listen to but I think the Stones overall, would get my vote.
Brian Jones, and Mick Taylor after him, were probably the best two musicians in the Stones. Mick Taylor can straight from John Mayall's "Blues from Laurel Canyon" band - his work on that album was superb. But the reason I would have to vote for the Stones is because of how they brought to (a bit of) fame some of the last remaining old black blues masters, particularly Howlin' Wolf. And of course Robert Wilkins, whose "Prodigal Son" is (for me) a highlight of what is still my favourite Stones album ... "Beggar's Banquet"!
I remember watching the Beatles when they first appeared on the Ed Sullivan Show and the girls were screaming and some were even in tears I could hardly hear them sing.

The Rolling stones weren't exactly my favorite group I did often listen to a few of their songs.
Gimme Shelter I listened to alot.

Brian Jones, and Mick Taylor after him, were probably the best two musicians in the Stones. Mick Taylor came straight from John Mayall's "Blues from Laurel Canyon" band - his work on that album was superb. But the reason I would have to vote for the Stones is because of how they brought (a bit of) fame to some of the last remaining old black blues masters, particularly Howlin' Wolf. And of course Robert Wilkins, whose "Prodigal Son" is (for me) a highlight of what is still my favourite Stones album ... "Beggar's Banquet"!
The Stones were the bad boys of rock back in the day. Maybe that's why I liked them. That being said they should probably hang it up now before they have to wheel out the boys in wheelchairs to play. cool
Post Comment - Let others know what you think about this Blog.
Meet the Author of this Blog
chatilliononline today!

chatillion

Boca Raton, Florida, USA

I have an amazing ability to sniff-out bogus profiles...
If you're half my age... Don't expect a response! [read more]

About this Blog

created Apr 2020
532 Views
Last Viewed: 24 hrs ago
Last Commented: May 2020
Last Edited: Apr 2020
chatillion has 1,879 other Blogs

Like this Blog?

Do you like this Blog? Why not let the Author know. Click the button to like the Blog. And your like will be added. Likes are anonymous.

Feeling Creative?