Should dogs live in apartments? (71)

I know there are many variables around this, according to the breed, size and temperament of the dog, the owner's lifestyle etc. but I'm interested in people's views

Dogs can be a deterrent and much safer than a gun.

Hi lovely

Not looking for protection here, it's more about the welfare of the dog

PS. Good to see you again

Hi Gal

I agree that dog owners need to take responsibility regarding their pets and be respectful of their neighbours

Also in the community in general.

I'm just wondering about people's views in terms of having a dog enclosed in an apartment for hours on end while they are at work or out socialising

Sorry, I probably should have provided a little more clarification around my question

So let's cut to the chase.. My thoughts are that it's not right for a dog to be shut in an apartment for eight, ten or twelve hours a day with no company or access to the outdoors during that time

It's not right for a dog to be shut in ANYWHERE for prolonged periods. It would be the same in any home not just an apartment. So many dogs are now being abandoned due to lack of care by owners . A dog is for life .

Unless you have a neighbour or trusted friend who can take the dog out at regular intervals don't get one.

Why do you cage a dog when you are out ? Have you considered how the dog feels about being shut in , what harm can she come to ?

As for all the vaccines etc that's the norm for any pet not just a pedigree.

Thanks Tiger, I completely agree.

I also feel for doggos that are enclosed in a backyard for hours on end, no walks or interaction with other dogs or people.

Some people should not be allowed pets Serene. They haven't a clue .You should have a relationship with your pet and yes dogs should know boundaries but not have a "boss" .

I have a large dog and live in a two bedroom home with a large fenced in back yard. I also work part time (3 days a week). It was not my intent to keep this sweetie, I rescued her from a bad situation, she was eight months old. But something about her she is laying by me as I type. The excuse the people used to why they treated her so badly was she was a horrible dog and they couldn't help it they hated her What I did because I worked full time then I instantly taught her what a pee pad was and how to use it. That way she was not forced to hold it in if she had to go. I still put them out for the three days a week I do work and in May she will be 3. She rarely uses them now. But they are there if she needs them. The stinker if weather is really bad will use them. She has full roam of our home when I am at work. That was a trip when she was young. She was a chewer, thank goodness my pillows are safe now. I use to wonder if I did right taking her and keeping her and not putting her in a home with children to run and play with her. I know longer wonder that. I know she is right where she should be. I work a early shift and when I get home I swing the back door open to let her out to roam and play. When we are out in public people comment on what a good girl she is and how happy she is. She is also easily trainable. She does it with love. She wants to make me happy. I don't know why the people before me did not like her keeping her was one of the best decisions I have ever made. She is a good friend and a well behaved baby. So I believe yes there are some cases an animal can be happy even being in a home with working parents. I also believe it is my responsibility to make her life as happy and healthy as I can. She is the only dog I have ever had that will wear shoes in the summer if we are going somewhere. Florida side walks and roads are really hot in the summer. Just how I see things. If there are not people willing to do this then sadly many dogs in my area would be euthanized. I believe you can work things out if you are willing to try. I made the decision to go part time at work because I did not want her to be alone all the time. I could afford to do it and should of done it before getting her. Some dogs would be really sad all by themselfs for long periods. That is a fact. I would not know what to do if you end up with a pet like that. Most people I know have to work for a living. I checked into doggie care at first and then reaized May is a homebody. Maybe that would work for those in apartments. And once again not all can afford the luxry of day care. In my area they are always in supply of homeless dogs. But we do have a place that will euthanize. And that breaks my heart. They call is humane euthanization. Wonder what they would call it if they were the ones fixing to get the needle. A pet is a commitment. Just like children.

Most of the dogs in my apartment are for mental support