excerpt from John K. Roman on Costs of the Death Penalty Judiciary Committee Delaware Senate
Thank you for the opportunity to testify before you today on SB 19. The death penalty is one of the most polarizing social issues under debate today. Few debates, however, are undertaken with as little empirical evidence as is available in the debate about capital punishment. While there are substantial disagreements about most aspects of the death penalty, there is a consensus about one important data point: having a death penalty is more expensive for a state than not having the death penalty. In 2007 and 2008 I led a team at the Urban Institute that studied this question, and I would like to report the results of the study.
We find that the total costs of a typical murder case in Maryland are about $1 million, including post- trial incarceration. Capital eligible cases where prosecutors filed notice that they would seek the death penalty but where no death penalty was imposed cost almost $700,000 more than cases where prosecutors could have—but did not—seek the death penalty. When a death sentence was imposed, the total added costs were $1.8 million. We estimate that the total lifetime cost to Maryland taxpayers of murder cases where a death penalty is sought is $186 million. These numbers would be even higher, but few death sentences are imposed, and few of those result in an execution. While these data are particular to Maryland, all 14 prior studies of the death penalty have consistently shown that the death penalty increases costs. If the death penalty were abolished, those dollars could be used in a variety of positive ways—including returning them to Delaware taxpayers. However, hard- won experience suggests that the only way for those gains to be realized is to reallocate the public’s money now. When savings such as these can be anticipated, the best course of action is to take that money off the table. If we wait, the money will simply be spent for other purposes before there can be any public debate.
I have noticed that a lot of opponents to the death penalty are often pro-life defenders - life on one end yet not on the other?
Isn't is odd, we would sanction life of a person legally sentenced and then defend the right of a woman to end her pregnancy within a short window period of time - putting aside the debate about when do we consider an unborn child - a life.
Our country must come to grips when and how sanctioning the taking of another's life - through courts with due process, law and order, during war, during acts of self-defense - It is not a simple solution that fits.
This ethical question is a tough one. Except for Tru's solution!
DEBATE! (mob gathers around the soap boxes and intense silence befalls the growing crowd as in one corner approaching the microphone..... wearing a mischieveous crying but lovable granddaughter .....
Lethal Injection Drug Shortage By Jennifer Horne CSG Associate Director of Policy and Special Libraries Texas has 317 inmates on death row, but only enough of a key lethal injection drug to execute two of them. Ohio has just one dose of the drug left. A nationwide shortage of sodium thiopental, an anesthetic that is part of the three-drug cocktail used in lethal injections, has thrown capital punishment in the United States into disarray, delaying executions and forcing the change of execution protocols in several states. Last month, Hospira—the sole U.S. company approved to manufacture the drug—announced it will no longer produce sodium thiopental. This move followed a global campaign by death penalty opponents and pressure by Italian government officials after the company sought to shift production of the drug to an Italian plant. The shortage of sodium thiopental has forced the 35 states using lethal injection to scramble for any remaining stock and to explore alternatives. “Many states will have to change their method of execution, which means regulatory changes that have to be approved and lengthy court challenges,” says Richard Dieter, executive director of the Death Penalty Information Center. “In many states, this could take months, if not years, delaying executions.”
It is very expensive to do. Death row inmates require more supervision and more security to house.
The appeal process usually takes 10 to 12 years before execution. Now that Europe does not want to provide the drugs for the legal injection, it is a costly, long and painful process to put someone to death.
and is it really a deterrent to others?
Punishment that is just, swift and sure are said to be the answer to deterrent bad behavior.
It's a tough issue to address in a nation or state.
I recently read about a governor of an eastern united state pardoning all on death row and commuting their sentence to life in prison.
Sometimes the worry and rightly so, is that those that are condemned to die, get their sentence changed to life in prison and that does not mean their natural life, often shortened and then they get out of prison.
If a life in prison meant a life in prison - then that would be justice.
Just saw a great movie - "the Face of Love" - really addresses the issue of love. Its a story of a woman who's husband dies and she meets a man who is identical looking. Robin Williams plays the character of the next door neighbor and best friend.
dang, it's not what it says on the travel brochure?
Well, I am willing to take in the beautiful countryside and the warmth and friendship of the local folk - although not in winter...... nooooo, never in winter!
I'm trying to lure that Scottish gentleman to tropical Florida for the winter..... ---- IMAGE REMOVED because photobucket.com no longer allows embedded images ----
Do you think I should use this profile photo to lure him here?
I guess it depends on your flaws...... Leading a dating conversation with I have a bad credit rating, or red is not my real hair color might not find you any 2nd dates.....
My good friend has always preferred much younger men. She is very energetic and young at heart. It seems to work for her. When she was in her 50s she was dating a late 20 year old.
I myself have always preferred the same age, or older men than myself.
If space on a micro-cosmic level is seen on a cosmic level - our universe that hosts 100 billion galaxies, surely even if a bubble formed it would be doomed to disappear again in the blink of an eye. If all the galaxies are flying apart, they must have at one time been close together.
General relativity tells us that the space-time we live in could take 3 different forms. Flat as a table top, curve back on itself like a sphere or curve outward like a saddle. If the universe is flat - could we come from nothing. Quantum mechanics tell us that nothing is inherently unstable so the leap from nothing to something may be inevitable. Resulting in a tiny bible in space-time burst into a massive busy universe.
Linde thinks that the universes have always been springing into existence and that this process will continue forever.
RE: Death Penalty? Yes or No?
What about the other spectrum of the debate - is it Finland? Sweden? that allow the assisted killing of those with terminal illness?